New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Stark Contrast

Posts

Stark Contrast

#1

Stark Contrast

Jay Samuels

We were up in western New York over the weekend. Saturday we went out to Elma (outside Buffalo) to the Made in America store. They carry only items certified to be made 100% in the US. Interesting place. Apparently tour busses actually stop there. Hand-tool wise, they carry what looked to be a pretty complete line of Channellock pliers. Plus various specialty items by small makers. Certainly worth a stop if you are in the area. It is right off "the 400" as they say up there. As I own more pliers than all rational humans (you readers not included), I did not buy any.

Sunday, and only because I had time to kill, I went to the retail store of a large tool importer that uses the names of northeastern and midwestern cities as brand names for some of its tool lines. They had pretty much everything you can think of. I spent some time looking at boxes and packaging. Everything is made in China, except for boxes of latex gloves that were made in Malaysia. Prices for "comparable" pliers were less than half of the Made in America store cost. Since I don't own Chinese pliers, I can't comment on quality.

Obviously, this is not a new phenomenom, but I am still not sure what to make of the experience.

By the way, if any of you are snickering at a trip to western New York, I quote the woman we were talking to while waiting to get into a place featured on "Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives" - "If you are not having a good time in Western New York in the summer, you are not trying."

Re: Stark Contrast

#2

Re: Stark Contrast

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

An aside, read in the NYTimes early this week: only 2.7% of the goods we buy are made in China. For example, those iPhones only cost Apple about $6 for the hardware. It's a bit more noticeable because so many of our durable goods are made there, such as washers, dryers, furniture, etc.

Pam

Re: Stark Contrast

#3

But are you comparing apples to applesauce?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Are you comparing tools of like quality? Back when Porter-Cable, Milwaukee, and such brands were U.S. made, their prices were similar to the prices for the same kind of tool from Makita and Bosch - with similar quality.

I assume you were referring to Harbor Freight (aka Horrible Fright), whose tools are not, generally, speaking at the same quality level - although, in some cases, it appears to be an issue of minimal quality control as much as anything.

Re: Stark Contrast

#4

Re: Stark Contrast

Alex Grigoriev

According to iSupply, iPhone BOM (bill of materials) is $172, and manufacturing expenses $6.50. But it's just because Foxconn workers are paid peanuts.

Re: Stark Contrast

#5

Re: Stark Contrast

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Thanks for the BOM correction. We agree about Foxconn.

Pam

Re: Stark Contrast

#6

Re: Stark Contrast

Phil Joines

It might have been in the NY times but I don't believe it. I think it's more like 70%.

they have their own reasons for distorting the figures.

Re: Stark Contrast

#7

Re: Stark Contrast

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

OMG, my brother-in-law is now posting in WC!

Phil, I know there's a lot of room for data manipulation in an article like this one; but the numbers are fairly straightforward in economic terms, so maybe it's twice that, 5.4%, but that's still low. The Chinese say that for US products they contribute mostly labor, with high tech content coming from elsewhere, like Japan; so I suspect there's a lot of non-Chinese content in those products labeled "Made in China."

Pam

Re: Stark Contrast

#8

How many worms in that can?

Bob Hackett

Here I just got back after a rather long forced hiatus due to computer failure and you already are trying to get me thrown off the board by blatantly trotting out the whole China/quality control vs USA made card?

You guys are tough on an old hand I tell ya (will not rise to the bait,will NOT rise to that bait,keep sayin` it buddy).

Re: Stark Contrast

#9

Moses Yoder

Re: How many worms in that can?

Moses Yoder

Yea, I thought political discussions were banned. Since I have already had my quota of posts removed this week, I'll keep my mouth shut as well. Although it is very tempting, seeing as how Channellock is being compared to a Chinese made plier. I think there is a Latin phrase for that, something about a sucker born every minute.

Re: Stark Contrast

#10

Re: How many worms in that can?

Jay Samuels

Actually, the main point I wanted to make was that tools wholly made in the USA are few and far between, while tools made in China fill a store in a place that was once a hub of tool manufacturing. I wasn't trying to make anyone fall off the wagon.

Re: Stark Contrast

#11

Come clean Jay.

Bob Hackett

How much did our gem working southern friend pay you to start this post? ;^)

As for you Dave, I know you`re lurking and I hope you aren`t too disappointed that I didn`t take the bait,even though I was sorely tempted. :D

Re: Stark Contrast

#12

Re: How many worms in that can?

Alex Grigoriev

I've heard a couple years ago that ChannelLock is moving their manufacturing overseas, too.

Re: Stark Contrast

#13

Re: Stark Contrast

Alex Grigoriev

Don't forget that the major semiconductor fab companies (TSMC, USMC) are also chinese/taiwanese. Much of the chips inside iPhone are fabricated by them.

Re: Stark Contrast

#14

Re: Come clean Jay.

Todd O. Cronkhite

Beep breaths Bob, deep breaths, besides I thought you gave up eating the bait years ago. ;)

Re: Stark Contrast

#15

Re: Come clean Jay.

Bob Hackett

Lets just say not all the scars from the hooks have healed completely. Most just think I`m an old dude who`s finally taken the piercings out.

Luckily it`s been catch and release so far. :)

Re: Stark Contrast

#16

Moses Yoder

Re: How many worms in that can?

Moses Yoder

That ZZZZZZZZZZZIIIIPPPP you hear is me shutting my mouth.

Re: Stark Contrast

#17

Re: Stark Contrast

TomD

"suspect there's a lot of non-Chinese content in those products labeled "Made in China.""

An example of that is fish. recently bought some Atlantic Haddock, said made in china on it. Raises fears that the fish comes out of some sea size sump that is full pof dioxin and gian jellyfish. Or on the other hand, fish is now sent from the Atlantice to China for processing, which isn't ideal either...

Of course if your concerns are eithical rather than economic, any portion of Chinese content may be unacceptable. That can be awkward in the modern world.

Re: Stark Contrast

#18

Re: How many worms in that can?

TomD

The real interesting bit will be when Chinese products are seen as being of superior quality. They are buying CNC, and our old tooling at an astounding rate. They don't have to make junk, it is a choice.

Re: Stark Contrast

#19

Re: How to put old factories back into use

TomD

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ShbC5yVqOdI&feature=player_embedded#!

Re: Stark Contrast

#20

Re: Stark Contrast

Pam Niedermayer

Yeah, those pesky ethical concerns. I'm more of an economist, way to hard to attribute motivation and the like.

Pam

Re: Stark Contrast

#21

Re: How many worms in that can?

Pam Niedermayer

And to a great extent, that's our corporate choice, not Chinese. Who else really wants the cheapest products? The rich can buy whatever they want.

Pam

Re: Stark Contrast

#22

It's the poor who have to shop at Walmart.


Re: Stark Contrast

#23

Devil's advocate

North of the Border

Three points to share:

a) I would not make a statement like NYT distorts the % of goods Made in China, unless there`s proof or other statistics that I can quote. Of course, we all know about lies and statistics but saying NYT is not giving the truth without any supporting data is not a fair act.

b At another forum, most of the users who responded to a question about the products seemed to be happy about what they had bought from Harbor Freight. I really think it all depends on what products we are looking for there. I bought some 12`or (16") bar clamps there and they are just as good as any other bar clamps I have that I paid 30% or 40% more.

c) In a recent review by WOOD, the top choice and top value air compressors were all made in China and Taiwan. The two US made compressors (one of them the most pricey in the review) didn`t come out ahead of the imported products whether in price or performance. The lesson I learned from this (and many other tools reviews by FW, etc.) is that origin is less important when it comes to determining quality, performance and price. I have tools in my shop made in this part of the world as well as in Asia and I think they all do the functions they are designed for -- well.

Re: Stark Contrast

#24

Pam, You hit the nail on the head!

North of the Border

Many people have pointed out here or elsewhere that Chinese or for that matter, Taiwanese or Indian, etc. suppliers make and supply goods according to what WE (American or Canadian firms) tell them to. We often blame the suppliers for poor quality, taking away our jobs, paying mean wages etc. but we turn a blind eye on who make the corporate decisions to close our plants, move jobs overseas, and import sub-quality goods. We don't look into the mirror.

Shareholders want higher returns from their investments, companies want lower costs and high profits, AND we consumers want better products at lower costs. So, where does all that lead us to?

So let's stop making iPhones in China...the outcome may be no one - except few - can afford any of them. Welcome to the world of capitalism.

Re: Stark Contrast

#25

Re: Devil's advocate

TomD

"Of course, we all know about lies and statistics but saying NYT is not giving the truth without any supporting data is not a fair act. "

It might be a fair guess though. Virtually no statistics in popular press are accurate for many reasons:

1) Where do they come from. I know I don't hire a guy just to prepare stats on Chinese trade, I wonder what kind of person does do that, and what kind of spin they put on it.

2) Complexity problem. Basically everything in one's favorite newspaper seems accurate until one reads and aritcle in one's area of competence, and then most articles appear 100% incorrect. Doesn't seem unreasonable that if one could real all the articles through the eye's of experts the whole paper would be complete nonsense. And I say that with some considerable respect for the people who's job it is to prepare these articles on various subjects each day.

3) In dicussion with my sister the Doctor of stats, it normally comes out that all stats are improperly prepared. Normally any stats person will look at any project and see gapping holes in it and yet they don't really pay you for saying no. Indeed she is currently engaged in a job search, and it is rare to find organizations who retain statisticians for statistical puporses, they prefer to retain various comunications types, etc...