New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Hey, Marv (et al)

Posts

Hey, Marv (et al)

#1

Hey, Marv (et al)

Joe Shelton

I'm still dissatisfied with my lack of skill in sharpening saws, and have decided to buy a couple of the Lee Valley backsaws, then use them until they need sharpening. Of course, I'll have to use the correct file, right?

Before I asked this here, I stopped in at Highland Hardware (or Woodworking) to pick up the saws and files, but was told that TPI and PPI are the same. Also, the files on display did not list the number of teeth for the particular saws I want.

Since I felt their information was wrong, I left empty-handed and appear now before this appellate body:

1) TPI differ from PPI, in that there is one less tooth per inch than points per inch. Yea or nay?

2) What sizes of files will I need for 12 TPI? For 14 TPI?

3) Is this hopeless enough that I should start sending you my saws?

Joe, who should probably go back to electric saws...

Re: Hey, Marv (et al)

#2

I can handle your first question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

even though I have yet to tackle saw sharpening.

Teeth per inch counts the entire tooth, and starts at the root of the tooth (in the gullet), measuring until it reaches the gullet on the far side (from the starting point) of the last tooth.

Points per inch measures the very tip of the tooth, going until you reach the inch mark.

So, yes, you should (at least generally speaking) get more points per inch than teeth per inch, because with PPI, you're not including the slopes of the teeth outside the inch, while with TPI, you are.

I will now sit back, waiting for a more knowledgeable person to correct my poor statement of the difference and answer your other questions.

Re: Hey, Marv (et al)

#3

Re: Hey, Marv (et al)

John Pappas

Joe, 1) I am not an expert in saw sharpening. 2)I learned most of what I know from Leonard Lee's book, 'The Complete Guide to Sharpening'. I have successfully sharpened several saws that cut fast and straight. What I have found to be the single most important point that has helped me is to have the proper lighting. I think it is essential to be able to clearly see the flats on the points after the saw teeth have been jointed. If you can't see the flats, I believe you have no chance of success, but if you can see them, the odds are good that you will be successful.

Hang in there. Good luck on you next attempt.

Re: Hey, Marv (et al)

#4

Re: Hey, Marv (et al)

Bill Tindall

One of those magnifying lights is mighty handy for this operation.

Re: Hey, Marv (et al)

#5

Re: Hey, Marv (et al)

David Weaver

I'd like to ad that I think it's important for you to learn to sharpen your saws to a level you can tolerate for two reasons:

1) sending them off is a huge waste of time and money

2) it's not that hard and you will not tolerate using a saw that is "sort of sharp" when you can sharpen your own

Keep at it. Your other questions have already been answered, but to one point, files in a range for each tooth size are not critical. Just don't try to use a 6 slim on either of the saws you're talking about.

Re: Hey, Marv (et al)

#6

Oh yeah...

David Weaver

... even if you do have good eyesight and don't need magnification, dykem - red or blue, whatever you see better, and good raking light to see the tips of the teeth.

Re: Hey, Marv (et al)

#7

Re: Hey, Marv (et al)

Warren in Lancaster, PA

In the old system, you line up the end of a ruler with the tip of a tooth and called this tooth number one. Then if tooth number 8 matched up with the one inch mark you had an 8 point saw. I taught this system to many people; it usually took about half a minute to learn. We did not use the term ppi, we just said a 10 point saw.

In the late 20th century some people thought it would be easier to count the tooth at the end of the ruler as the zero tooth and the next tooth as tooth 1. They called this system tpi. This results in a 10 point saw being said to have 9 tpi (always one less than point number). The problem is that old saws are marked with the old system and old literature uses the old system, so you end up having to teach people two systems, a pain in the neck and not easier at all. Some current literature uses the old system, some uses the tpi system.

I would say for the 12 point a 5X slim or a 6XX slim, for a 14 5XX slim. There is some leeway here. As to whether to file your own, filing is an art, but I think there is more of an art to sawing than filing, so if your going to saw by hand it is a small thing to learn sharpening. And it is much better to stop and sharpen when you need to than to wait for a convenient time to send the saw away. As others have said, make sure you can see well.

Re: Hey, Marv (et al)

#8

Good Point

David Weaver

Sawing accurately and with good result is harder than filing a saw.

Re: Hey, Marv (et al)

#9

Joe, look at this link, if you haven't seen it *LINK*

patrick gibbons

A good primer on saw sharpening and answers your questions I think.


http://www.vintagesaws.com/cgi-bin/frameset.cgi?left=saws&right=/library/primer/sharp.html

Re: Hey, Marv (et al)

#10

for some reason a bad link

patrick gibbons

Go to www.vinatagesaws.com and look in their library for the primer on saw sharpening.

Re: Hey, Marv (et al)

#12

I repaired the link

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Ellis puts an "http://" in the link box, as a clue to what's supposed to be there. You have to delete it, or mark it and paste your link over it (that is, replace it).

Previewing messages is always a good idea, including checking on your links.