New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Handles, Corners and Straps for Military Chests.

Posts

Handles, Corners and Straps for Military Chests.

#1

Handles, Corners and Straps for Military Chests.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Although it will likely be several weeks before I need to fit the hardware on the Military Chests, I need to order the parts now. I have been considering what to use.

Picture from early in the build ..


The two banks of small drawers (in the centre) will have one handle each, and the single set of three long drawers (on the left) will have two handles. The far right are three shelves (although I am building drawers to match that can be used here if we later decide to stop using this as an entertainment centre - Lynndy is already trying to talk me into the latter option, and build something separate for the audio equipment!).

There are several options for the hardware.

Here are a sample of cabinets and their hardware ...


This cabinet uses the handles like these:


Corners:


Straps:


On light wood the brass looks good. However on a dark wood, such as Jarrah, I fear it will end up rather gaudy. Our choice is to either just go with handles only, or handles and corners (no straps). What are your thoughts?

Here is a dark cabinet with all the fruit:


There are other handles to consider. I particularly liked this profile. Unfortunately the smallest has a width of 3 1/2" and this is too large for the drawers I have.



The third choice was perhaps too modern? My wife likes it. I think that they might end up too small. But they do have a "neat" look ..



Here is a military chest by Philip Marcou. He specialised in military furniture before turning to plane making. Philip seems to favour these handles ...


Opinions, ideas?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Handles, Corners and Straps for Military Chests.

#2

Re: Handles, Corners and Straps for Military Chest

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Immediate response: I don't care for the brass corners, nor probably any other type of metal corner.

Pam

Re: Handles, Corners and Straps for Military Chests.

#3

Re: Handles, Corners and Straps for Military Chest

John in NM

Personally, I'd antique the brass. Probably give it a light sand blast followed by scotch brite or similar (I'd definitely experiment first, easy to over do it) to get rid of the hugely polished look. Then go with a blacking compound or fuming weak ammonia or a salt solution. If you're near the sea, there's a ready made fuming compound right there.

I like those second pulls too, they really have the right look. The little ring pulls are nice, but I find the ring too small for my fingers, and so not very comfortable to use (and my hands are not especially meaty). Buffing the inside corner of the hole might be the ticket, never thought of that for some reason (and the offending pull is in my last house, sold 6 years ago). If I couldn't find the perfect pull, I might opt to make some out of heavy brass wire let into a recess.

Re: Handles, Corners and Straps for Military Chests.

#4

Ellis Walentine

Some thoughts

Ellis Walentine

You might want to review your reason for choosing this type of chest to build. I'm no expert on this genre, but it would seem that the corners and straps and flush pulls are the main aesthetic ingredient, presumably harking to the colonial days of the British empire or some such provenance. If those details are what attracted you to this furniture form, I'd stick with the real thing and not try to second-guess a classic design.

If you're prepared to take some liberties, though, and you feel the metal bits are necessary or desirable, go ahead and add a surface treatment that looks better with your jarrah. If you preserve the basic simplicity of the design, the chests will still retain a lot of the original character. This isn't a crime. I have often taken liberties with such recognizable forms as Craftsman and Greene & Greene styles, changing proportions, detailing, visual weight (especially this, as I feel that much early 20th Century A&C stuff was visually ponderous), and even motifs, trying to stay within the bounds of tastefulness while preserving as much of the essence as seemed necessary.

Ellis

Re: Handles, Corners and Straps for Military Chests.

#5

A book

Phil Joines

If you can find a copy of "British Campaign Furniture, Elegance under Canvas, 1740-1914" by Nicholas A. Brawer ISBN 0-8109-5711-6 published in 2001it's worth a look. It has about 200 pages with 275 illustrations including closeups of hardware and a bunch of pieces most people wouldn't think of as "campaign".

Re: Handles, Corners and Straps for Military Chests.

#6

Re: A book

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Phil

Philip Marcou recommended this book to me, which is a serious recommendation as he specialised in military furniture. When I last looked at its price it was close to $600!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Handles, Corners and Straps for Military Chests.

#7

You're a wise man, Ellis.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

You might want to review your reason for choosing this type of chest to build. I'm no expert on this genre, but it would seem that the corners and straps and flush pulls are the main aesthetic ingredient, presumably harking to the colonial days of the British empire or some such provenance. If those details are what attracted you to this furniture form, I'd stick with the real thing and not try to second-guess a classic design.

It is very relevant to understand how I got to this point. This does make the decision easier.

I was visiting my brother- and sister-in-law in January, which was when I decided to change the design of the entertainment centre to a pair of military cabinet (the previous attempt ended up as an end table with coopered legs). They had a military cabinet that I had admired for 30 years. This really was a modern translation ... clean lines and restful ...


On our return home I began researching military chests for ideas. My thoughts (head) moved to a more traditional design ... but my heart has kept telling me to keep the design clean and uncomplicated.

So I shall return to the roots and build them without brass corners or straps.

Not sure of the handles yet.

I have 18 to buy. This is an extra 6 to go with the three extra drawers I will built for "one day" when the shelves become drawers.

Thanks for the reminder ..

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Handles, Corners and Straps for Military Chests.

#8

Re: A book

Phil Joines

I didn't realize it had gotten so high. I got mine at the used book store for $12. :b

Re: Handles, Corners and Straps for Military Chests.

#9

Re: Handles, Corners and Straps for Military Chest

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I am not overly fond of highly polished brass hardware. I like the flush pulls and the whole asthetic of the simple utilitarian chest with flush pulls, just not the gleaming shiny new hardware.

I have run into this problem with my own work and I usually opt to strip the protective lacquer and add a patina. Some times just heating with a smal propane torch and spraying with tap water is enough to add a bit of a tarnished look and take the glare off.

For yellow brass my favorite patina is: 1 pint warm water, 1 teaspoon feric nitrate, a pinch of sodium thiosulfate. this will give a nice rich brown when applied to hot brass and sealed with paste wax. One of the keys to a successfull patina is that you add chemical and let the work cool and then rub off as much as you can with 0000 steel wool and then re-patina this will add depth similar to finishing a piece of furniture with several coats of glaze stain. If you mess up just soak in sudsy ammonia for a 1/2 hour and you will be back to bare brass.

Robin

Re: Handles, Corners and Straps for Military Chests.

#10

Re: Handles, Corners and Straps for Military Chest

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I forgot to add that I think the most handsome examples you posted pics of are the vintage pieces that have a nice patina to them, even you brothers chest has a nice patina to it.

Robin

Re: Handles, Corners and Straps for Military Chests.

#11

Re: Handles, Corners and Straps for Military Chest

Leon

Here's a campaign furniture antiques sight

http://www.campaignfurniture.com/

Leon

Re: Handles, Corners and Straps for Military Chests.

#12

Re: Handles, Corners and Straps for Military Chest

James Watriss

I think one of the things to bear in mind is that the hardware basically provides a shift in emphasis, especially on a dark wood. Instead of the wood, the wood grain, etc, the emphasis shifts to the hardware, and the geometric regularity it provides.

Is it gaudy? Eh, maybe. I think the conflict arises when you have too many design elements that you consider to be important. If it's the wood, skip the fruit. If it's the design of the overall piece, finish the wood with a nice, dark finish that doesn't highlight the grain, and bring on the brass.

When I was making my tool chest at school, we were all informed that there was to be no figured woods, period. I hemmed and hawed about what kind of wood to use, and how I was going to show it off, and I really wanted something that would be flashy. And then I simply flipped the mental switch, and decided to make something that looked simple and good, and not focus so heavily on the wood.

I went with plain, straight grain mahogany for the carcase. Drawer fronts and dividers were hard maple, ebonized with a black dye, and a black tinted garnet shellac, with bright and shiny brass ring pulls. Ultimately, it looks very clean. The mahogany is a pleasing shade, the ring pulls stand out nicely. And the end result is about displaying good design and workmanship, which doesn't necessarily have to be about the wood.


Re: Handles, Corners and Straps for Military Chests.

#13

a good lesson in design....thanks

Bill Tindall

Re: Handles, Corners and Straps for Military Chests.

#14

Good post James...

John in NM

It's too easy to forget that good furniture can be made of poplar and painted (with milk paint in Bill's case :D :D :D )

A couple of my favorite old pieces are painted.