New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

Posts

Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

#1

Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

roger lance

RUST. Well we are at the beginning of our annual heat wave in Michigan and the humidity is going up with the temperatures. So I thought this might be a good time to ask about opinions, strategies, products, and approaches to combating rust especially on hand tools. My shop is in the basement and I run a de-humidifer which definitely helps and I use Johnson's Paste Wax (silicone free) on the CI surfaces and this is generally effective. Also, I place one of those silica gel metal cased dehumidifiers from Lee Valley in each drawer that houses metal tools....these have the little window that shows a color change when it has absorbed its capacity of moisture and you then heat it in the oven to recycle it. I've also heard of a product called "Dry Right" which is suppose to be calcium chloride in bulk form....does anyone know about this, is it readily available, etc ?? Lie-Nielsen sells a couple of oils to wipe your tools...Camellia & Jojoba oils...except their shipping charges basically equal the cost of these products and I am not expecting a period of free shipping from them....again, does anyone have an opinion about these products or have other sources for them or other oils that they would recommend (or not) ?? Appreciate your insights....stay cool.

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

#2

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against.... *LINK*

anotherBob

I've heard GoldenRod recommended by quite a few people... never tried them myself... yet.


GoldenRod website

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

#3

I feel your pain

Bill Tindall

I bought a set of nice box handled chisels for son-in-law. They were in wonderful condition with mirror polished backs......but....there was a tiny bit of rust on the backs right at the edge of several. This tiny bit of rust had pitted, not a lot, but it took hours to grind the pits out and re-polish the backs. I had forgot how fast 30 micron diamond paste on cast iron grinds. You can hear it milling shavings of metal. It got employed for the last three and things went quicker.

Rust requires water. So preventing a film of water absorbing is essential to rust prevention. This can be accomplished by lowering the humidity or repelling water absorption by coating the steel with a film of "water repellent" such as oil, wax, Boshield T9, etc.

"Also, I place one of those silica gel metal cased dehumidifiers from Lee Valley in each drawer that houses metal tools".... There are gallons of water as water vapor in your shop air. I can't imagine the tiny capacity of these things does any good unless the container is sealed from air exchange.

"I've also heard of a product called "Dry Right" which is suppose to be calcium chloride in bulk form" Dry Right is anhydrous calcium sulfate, not chloride. The chloride salt would hydrate and likely release small amounts of hydrochloric acid which would promote corrosion. Not a good solution- too small capacity for the gallons of water in the air.

Boshield T-9 is amazing. I use it on the bed of a large thickness planer that lives out in a lumber shed. At some times of year water condenses on any metal surface (cold metal, damp humid spring air). If there is a layer of T-9 on the bed I get no rust. But, it is sticky messy stuff. In the shop area I dehumidify. If I keep under 65% I get no rust problems. Dehumidifying is the most effective solution in my situation.

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

#4

Silica Gel

Kenneth Martin Sacramento

My brother did did some checking and found that �FRESH STEP� cat litter is SILICA GEL crystals which will soak up any moisture in a closed container. He has started using it in his gun case.

Ken

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

#5

Camellia oil - no direct experience, but info

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

One of the magazines did a test of various rust-preventives a few years back (for some reason, they failed to include paste wax, which I find quite effective). Camellia oil did NOT do well.

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

#6

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

Jesper, Denmark

Dehumidifying is the only safe solution. If you can keep the RH lower than about 50%, you are safe.

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

#7

My experience

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

The Ottawa area where I live gets pretty humid on a regular basis. My shop is in the basement, and if I keep RH at 60% or below I don't get rust on my tools. When the temperature is on the low side my dehumidifier takes care of things, when it's hot the AC does the work of taking the moisture out of the air.

Been doing this for over 15 years without trouble.

DC

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

#8

Re: My experience

TomD

I find camellia oil is excellent. My tools never rust with it on them, and I don't find I need much for them to be prottected. I never have to clean them before using them. I have also blued certain things, like plane bodies, and table saw tops. I have also blued chisels. I use Birchwood Cassey cold chemical blue. Bluing is not a rip roaring rustproofing, but it ads a little resistence, by essentially pre-rusting it, and it seems to hold oil and wax a little better. And some tools just look better for it.

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

#9

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I've found wooden cabinets and drawers to be perfectly adequate, the wood seems to attenuate the ability of water to move onto stored tools.

Pam

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

#10

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

Rob Lee

Hi Roger -

Couple of quick observations....

1) it's not as much humidity, as temperature change (and Condensation) that will cause issues. Keeping your tools warmer than the surrounding environment can go a long way to preventing rust... even a low wattage bulb in a cabinet will heat it enough to prevent rust

2) Some rust can be a good thing.... some oxides make an effective barriers to ongoing corrosion...think "patina"...

3) While dessicants work well, adding something like a VCI (Vapour Corrosion Inhibitor) emitter to a cabinet or toolbox is an effective passive method of rust prevention. Those bags our planes (and I assume L-N's) come in are VCI bags....even putting the bags in a toolbox could help!

Cheers -

Rob

(headed to Vegas, where at 40C, ain't nothin' rusting....)

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

#11

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

Vegas? I bet you'll have fun there :-)

DC

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

#12

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

roger lance

Rob....thanks for your period of free shipping....I did participate in that and purchased a couple of your planes which are beautiful and I want to keep them that way !!....and I'm saving my nickels and dimes for the next time....I've also used those rubber mats that fit into the bottom of the tool drawers and claim that they also inhibit rust....I'm assuming they are vapor emitters as well....take care in Vegas....stay out of the news....and don't bet against the house.

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

#13

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Keeping in the spirit of LV (was that Las Vegas?), how much you want to bet? :)

Pam

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

#14

LV... Cute   

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

#15

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

Charles

A very thin coat of Vaseline works great.

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

#16

Cheap help in this fight

Bill Tindall

Recently I tested the water corrosion resistance of a titanium nitride coated plane iron. The uncoated control rusted severely while the coated blade suffered no corrosion. The coating process is cheap, amounting to less than a dollar on a typical milling machine tool bit.

Wear improvement aside(see recent post on main Forum), the corrosion benefits of coating are not insignificant. Had the chisels referred to in an earlier post been coated there would have been no pits to grind away.

The problem is that the typical TiN coating process will soften carbon steel as the coating is applied at 750 F. The tools steels (for example M2) will not be adversely affected at this temperature. There are other coatings that are applied at lower temperature. We are currently investigating one that is applied at a safe 400 F. An additional problem is that the coated part can not be further abraded after coating or the coating will come off. Hence, things like plane irons and chisels would have to be flattened sufficiently before coating, but then I think this operation should be done in any case by the manufacturer as it can be done cheaply in bulk.

I would cheerfully pay a premium for a tool coated with something that resisted or eliminated rust.

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

#17

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

Jim Boynton

I also live in Michigan. I also use Johnsons Paste Wax on my castiron surfaces and it works well. Been using it for years!

I throw those silica-gel pouches into my tool boxes, have never encountered any rust problems.

Cary on, Jim.

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

#18

Re: Hand tools, humidity, & the fight against....

George in sticky Lowell, Mich.

Johnson's wax as well. I coat everything 2-3 times a year whether they need it or not.

Work safe,

George