New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Cigar Spokeshave

Posts

Cigar Spokeshave

#1

Cigar Spokeshave

Les Winter

I own a reproduction cigar spokeshave (looks like a Millers Falls #1). I bought it a dozen years ago and only today tried to make it work. Didn't go so well. So I've looked on the web and all of the links to instructions that I have found are dead. Wayback didn't help either.

Can anyone can point me in the right direction?

thanks

Les

Re: Cigar Spokeshave

#2

Re: Cigar Spokeshave

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Search on something like "mf cigar spokeshave sharpen" and you'll get several pointers to the Old Tools archive, in which is a lot of useful information about the MF; however, that may not do much for your reproduction.

Worth a try.

Pam

Re: Cigar Spokeshave

#3

Re: Cigar Spokeshave

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I believe I recall Joel Moskowitz writing a little article on the subject of sharpening cigar shaves a while back. I just looked on the Tools for Working Wood site, and couldn't find it. Of course, that could well be because my memory's just about worthless and that it was by someone else altogether. Maybe the author of the article (Joel or whomever) will come visit and enlighten you (and me).

I have learned with round-bottomed shaves in general, and definitely with my limited use of the cigar shave, that they're best used as pull tools. My theory is that our wrists are better-designed to curl in* than out, so you can better control the cutting edge by pulling the shave, standing in front of the piece being worked with the curve you're working facing you.

*By "in," I mean: if you hold your forearm out straight, with your palm vertical - as if you're about to shake hands with someone - curling your wrist so that your palm faces toward your body is "in."

Re: Cigar Spokeshave

#4

Re: Cigar Spokeshave

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I'm probably violating all kinds of copyright laws here; but Ralph Brendler's pages on spokeshaves have disappeared. Here's his text:

Author's Note:

This was originally posted to the OldTools list, at the request of Tom Bruce and others. It's pretty much a brain dump of my experience with the Miller's Falls #1 spokeshave. I don't know if anyone will find this useful, but this is what works for me...

Catalog photo of the Miller's Falls #1, courtesy of Chuck Zitur

The M-F #1 shave is apparently a very difficult tool to adjust and use.

I say "apparently", because it seems like everyone but me who has ever tried to use one has had a tough time with it. Personally, I never had a problem learning to use it. I don't know why everyone says it's so tricky... ;-)

First off, what is this thing?

The #1 is basically a metal cylinder 4" in length and 5/8" in diameter, with 3" turned handles sticking out either side. The general size and shape is about the same as a large stogie, hence the #1's common nickname-- the "cigar".

The center section holds the blade, which is an unusual semi-cylindrical affair which wraps around the body. The blade is held in place by two short screws at the sides, and can be rotated around the center section to open and close the mouth.

This cylindrical blade poses one other interesting problem-- sharpening! Simply stated, these things are not easy to sharpen (and you can forget using your Veritas jig). The outer bevel can be sharpened on a typical stone or SS plate, but the inside must be done with a slipstone of some sort.

Another sharpening "gotcha" (courtesy of David Pozar's hard-earned experience) is that you cannot use a secondary bevel on the blade. Due to the extremely small clearance angle of the bevel in use, use of a secondary bevel may cause the sharpened edge to not contact the wood!

Grinding the curved blade is another real challenge. Luckily, Ray Smith has figured out a nice way to do this-- Check out Ray's hints for grinding a #1's iron.

So now the real question-- how does one adjust one of these?

The key to adjusting the cigar is to get the mouth opening right. Since the bevel of the blade on this tool acts as the "heel" of the shave, the mouth width adjusts the rankness of the cut. If the mouth is too wide the shave will dig in and tear out large chunks, while if it is too small the throat will jam with shavings.

Perhaps the first hurdle in adjustment is figuring out which way the blade goes. This is surprisingly tricky, since the blade can easily be put in facing either direction. Based on the number of these I've seen with the blade in backwards, I think the old-timers may have had their problems with this as well.

The correct orientation of the blade is with the bevel facing the side of the mouth closest to the retaining screws. If you look carefully at this side of the mouth, you will see a shallow depression machined into the surface of the cylinder-- this will be the actual mouth of the shave when the blade is installed.

Once the blade is in place and facing the proper direction, you can easily see how the mouth opens and closes by rotating the blade fore and aft. As a starting position, I like to set it so that the tip of the bevel just barely covers the rear edge of the mouth depression. This is a good general-purpose setting-- not too fine, not too rank. For final smoothing, moving the blade forward 1/16" will close up the mouth and allow you to take the nice gossamer shavings.

Re: Cigar Spokeshave

#5

Re: Cigar Spokeshave

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

And here's Ray Smith's page on grinding the cigar blade, also originally shown on Ralph Brendler's site:

Author's Note:

This was originally posted to the OldTools list by Ray Smith (RayTSmith@aol.com).

Grinding them MF #1 Blades

By Ray T. Smith

Having 2 MF #1's, one with a big nick in the blade(but only 5 bucks), I was disappointed when Ralph said he hadn't come up with a good way to grind them.

The blade with the nick was way out of square and was going to take forever to hone down by hand. It had been laying on the assembly table for months, between the tool chest and my sharpening supplies, waiting to be sharpened before being stored away in the chest. I have a norm grinder with a Veritas tool rest and a sliding tool holder rig that works great on plane blades, but it seemed too dangerous to use for the MF #1 blade.

Last night, after smoothing a Shaker oval carrier with one of them IT scrapers, I was in a laid back mood, just right for sharpening or trying something new. I clamped the MF blade in the Veritas tool holder. It fit well, the curved blade clamped between two flat surfaces had a self-jigging action, squaring the blade up on its own. The holder held the blade solidly when the screws were clamped down, so I went to the grinder to see if it would work.

The only way to present the bevel to the stone was to point the rest down toward the wheel. Looked dangerous to me, but I fiddled with it and made a few dry runs with the grinder unplugged and it didn't seem so bad after all. I adjusted the rest so that it could not grab too much of the blade and tightened the clamps down good. Then I donned my leather turning apron and face helmet to help deflect flying objects.

It went extremely well. I had to stop often and readjust the rest a smidgen closer to the wheel when it quit making contact, but never set it so close that it could get a really good bite on the steel. Some paraffin on the rest, a light touch, and lots of readjusting were used.

I ended up with a dead straight, hollow ground bevel that honed up beautifully on a stone. That hollow grind is great for keeping these little blades flat on the stone's surface. I was so encouraged by the first blade, that I gave the other blade the same treatment. The other blade was in decent shape, but the bevel was getting just a tad rounded, making it more difficult to hone. Now I got two MF #1 blades, hollow ground, nice and sharp, with dead straight edges. Having a straight edge makes shaving a lot easier, since it will take a consistent shaving no matter which side of the shave is in contact with the wood. At least it works a whole lot better for me. I figure I can re-hone them for the next 10 years or so before regrinding.

I can't say that I recommend this procedure, so if you get killed trying it, don't come crying to me. But if you are really careful, it can get them blades in great shape.

* Keep the clamps TIGHT.

* Keep your touch light at all times, lube the rest with wax or something.

* Keep the rest backed off so the wheel cuts lightly, even if you are pressing against it.

* The Veritas rest can flex toward the wheel if you press, take this into account when adjusting closer to the wheel.

* Don't get greedy and try to take too much metal off at once.

* Take your time. (I spent maybe 30 minutes per blade)

* Wear your safety stuff !

Ray T.

Re: Cigar Spokeshave

#6

Re: Cigar Spokeshave

Les Winter

Thanks Pam and Bill. I have some studying and practice ahead of me.

Re: Cigar Spokeshave

#7

Honing a M-F cigar shave

Michael Brady

Actually, you can put the cutter from a MF #1 shave into an Eclipse jig, but you need to make a simple fixture to do it. This is my original design: I used a scrap of oak 1/2" thick and 3"x4", with the 3" wide end grain rounded over so that it is similar to the metal section of the shave in profile. I placed two flat head screws in the rounded section of the wood at the same spacing as the screws that hold the cutter in the shave. What you have now is a way to hold the cutter on the rounded-over end of the wood block much the way it is held in the shave. This wood block is then inserted into the upper jaws of the Elipse jig. You can adjust the block or the cutter until the flat of the bevel aligns with the sharpening stone. Go through your regular schedule of grits. I went all the way through 8000 grit on mine. As said in this thread, you have to sharpen the whole bevel...no microbevel...or the shave will not stay in the cut due to its very small radius.

I would say that my #1 shave is as easy to use as any small radiused shave I have used. The steel in that cutter is very nice quality.

Re: Cigar Spokeshave

#8

Re: Cigar Spokeshave

David Charlesworth

I could have written exactly the same post as Les, about three weeks ago, also having a rather nice reproduction shave languishing in a drawer.

Decided to have a go. Got stuck very quickly. Some enquiries on UK Workshop forum soon revealed that mine was missing the small flat which forms the front sole. Some people suggested no inner bevel, so I made a jig for the Tormek and removed the existing one. Big mistake, the edge is now infinitely thin and fragile..........

Having corrected this it now works well, but adjustment does not seem to match Brendeler's description. When the edge is near the flat (and the mouth fine) the shaving is coarse. It gets finer as the mouth is opened a little.

Can anyone confirm this please?

David Charlesworth

Re: Cigar Spokeshave

#9

Re: Cigar Spokeshave

Les Winter

Hi David.

That is my experience exactly. I had the thing working for a bit with a wide mouth. I then decided if it worked wide open, it must be even better closed up. Nope. Not even close. And then I couldn't find my original setting again.

thanks

Les