thanks, that was helpful
Bill Tindall
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
thanks, that was helpful
Bill Tindall
meaningless times
Bill Tindall
By the time I declare a chisel dull you would not sharpen it in 70 seconds. On the other hand a carver friend "sharpens" in a few seconds by frequent stroking the tool on a strop. In each case there is a huge difference in the amount of metal being removed as well as differences in working and sharpening strategy, rendering times a meaningless metric.
I believe the figures initially quoted were from quantitative tests where the amount of metal removed per unit of time was measured. The data are in an a recent article on the LV web site. It is an interesting article that would convince many that IF they were buying a new water stone these new stones are worthy of consideration. Absent were comparative data on a fixed diamond plate, an alternative that "on paper" would seem to be advantageous in several respects.
Re: Bester stones
Brian Greene
Yes. When I did my own test, to get a feel for the results the company was reporting, I counted the strokes required to turn the burr. I didn't time it but your extrapolation is obviously logical and valid. Bear in mind that just turning a burr doesn't give you much of a micro-bevel. It's actually difficult to see. In practice, therefore, I do a few extra strokes than what is actually required to achieve sharpness in order to have a serviceable micro-bevel.
Re: meaningless times
Brian Greene
You are correct. I noted the time difference between Bester, Norton and King to offer a relative order of magnitude comparison of the differences.
Re: I, too, will grind anything I can, but..
David Weaver
... that's not an option on a nice white steel chisel or a $500+ japanese plane iron that you've intentionally gotten produced with an extremely hard but temperature sensitive tempering.
I also have yet to see a device that does a good job flattening the back of tools like a good stone or lapping surface (with diamonds or whatever) does by hand. Every powered solution leaves me underwhelmed, from the WS 3000, to the side of a tormek wheel to a makita sharpener.
So sometimes those coarse stones have to come out.
But as you, my grinder gets used 20 to 1 at least for each time any of those coarse stones come out. The hope is once a japanese tool has settled in (past the initial edge), the lapping of the back can be done on a polishing stone, and the edge will be tough enough to avoid nicking, and the same thing about the back with western steels - just the polish stone.
Re: Bester stones
David Weaver
King stones, warren?
I thought you used oil stones.
Bester stones are harder than kings and cut faster. Because a lot of your time will be spent looking at the edge and cleaning swarf off the chisel, they aren't a lot faster than the kings in the overall scheme, but they have a nicer feel in the cut (aggressive and hard, but without stiction) and when you do need to run off a nick or something, they're a good bit faster.
The swarf is very little slop, and mostly water and metal - less flattening.
But, in the long discussion of what's really necessary, kings are fine, and probably the cheapest. Bester's are better, though, so for anyone who doesn't already have stones or mind a soak for their stones, they soak faster, they can be had fairly cheaply, flattened a lot less, and they cut a lot faster.
$500 plane iron !?!
Bill Tindall
I'm stunned. Anyone that owns a $500 plane iron, or a $500 plane for that matter, is in a different woodworking universe than I. I suspect experiences in these separate universes are not readily translatable between them.
Re: $500 plane iron !?!
David Weaver
Well, they work just like cheaper irons, except they're nicer - and harder without being brittle.
....and the iron is the focus of the plane.
I only have two of them, and i got them used. I must say that they are a really spectacular demonstration of hand-done tool work, though, both in appearance as well as in excellent performance.
A total extravagance, of course, but they are nice. The one of them that is white steel is monstrously hard without being chippy.
I might be interested...
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
After all, I have to plan for my first "smoke-free anniversary" (less than three months from now)...
Actually, not sure if I could appreciate the difference these days (not doing that much woodworking of late, getting back to it though) between a $500 blade and a $500 complete plane (other than edge retention, maybe), but I do want to discover Japanese planes, good ones at that. Suggestions welcome...
DC
Re: I might be interested...
wilbur
If you are interested in trying out Japanese planes, I have two suggestions.
First would be Hida Tool, and try one of the 45� Ishihisa smoothing planes. I find that the 45� bed angle is more forgiving on North American hardwoods than the standard angle planes, which are bedded at about 40�. The standard angle planes can be used on North American hardwoods, but there is a bit of a learning curve. My understanding is that the Ishihisa planes that Hida carries are the same as the Meimon planes that Kayoko used to sell, but with a different brand name. At the very least, they are made by the same maker.
The second option would be Stuart Tierney's Tools From Japan. He has a really complete line of Tsunesaburo planes, ranging from reasonable prices to the nosebleed range.
I have another option, if you want to shoot me an email.
Re: I might be interested...
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
Wilbur, any blade can be fit in a 45� bedded dai, so spend away. I've recently gotten some more very good plane deals on ebay, one an Ishido Hideo 70mm. Also, Alex Gilmore is selling a couple of beautiful NOS planes. It's all I can do to resist buying one of them.
Pam
Re: I, too, will grind anything I can, but..
TomD
"... that's not an option on a nice white steel chisel or a $500+ japanese plane iron that you've intentionally gotten produced with an extremely hard but temperature sensitive tempering."
Temper wise one can easily dry grind that, it doesn't do anything to it at 200 degrees, which is an easy temp range to also get some production going. I would often prefer to have a slower means of stock removal when working with expensive tools, but there is the occasional chip to remove. An example was my personal notorious case when some visiting workman grabbed a Oucci chisel worth hundreds and used it to cold chisel a bolt...
"I also have yet to see a device that does a good job flattening the back of tools like a good stone or lapping surface (with diamonds or whatever) does by hand. Every powered solution leaves me underwhelmed, from the WS 3000, to the side of a tormek wheel to a makita sharpener."
One can't beat hand work here, but I wouldn't use stones either. I have a surface grinder, and must give it a try someday. But it presumably will never offer a polish. Anyone know what the japanese makers are using? Hard to believe it is hand work.
Re: I might be interested...
wilbur
You got that Ishido Hideo? Nice.
Re: I, too, will grind anything I can, but..
David Weaver
I don't know what the maker's use, it may vary by maker.
I have seen videos of older blacksmiths using an iron holder and a very long waterstone and flattening plane irons by hand.
you can definitely dry grind white steel, but I don't do it with really expensive white steel, because I just don't want to have a mental lapse and warm up a spot.
I have put irons in the tormek several times when they're new and "nicky", but once they settle in, I don't find the need to put them back there.
Re: I might be interested...
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
I think so; but even better, I got it for less than one of your billable hours.
Hmmm, on second thought, that would be way more than I paid for it, showing my age.
Pam
Re: I might be interested...
wilbur
You have no idea how low on the payscale pediatricians are, even in the subspecialties.
Given that our interventions arguably lead to many more years of health for the kid than the equivalent interventions on the adult side, we are the one real bargain in healthcare.
Re: I might be interested...
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
Sorry about that; but it's quite obvious how Americans feel about the value of children. Look at all the money we spend on education, NOT. Hope it's the same fee structure for geriatrics, now that we're going to eliminate Medicare.
However, from an evolutionary/survival standpoint, children are of lesser value than adults.
Pam
Especially if you`re sellin them by the pound. :^)
Bob Hackett
LOL!
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
Re: I might be interested...
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
I don't see your e-mail address...
Mine should be visible to you, please try sending me an email...
DC
Re: $500 plane iron !?!
TomD
Bill you are wrong about one thing. It isn't a different "woodworking" environment. It is a different tool addict environment. 
I have a hundred or more Japanese blades in a pretty much the whole quality range, and I have $10.50 Japanese plane blades that are 95% there. I believe that the more expensive tools I have bought have always been better, but the law of diminishing returns is heavily in play. I regret that one of the things missing in the current enviro is that the bottom end of the market has not expended. As I see it it has nearly disappeared. It is great we have the upper end to play in moreso than ever before, but the lower end is in some respects more useful, particularly to the users, should there be any. I think the structure of the market for Japanese tools today says a lot about it. It is a tourist/collector market not a user one. Like waterfront condos compared to the working waterfront. But with a nautical theme.