New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Lee Valley metals insights

Posts

Lee Valley metals insights

#1

Lee Valley metals insights

Bill Tindall

The latest Lee Valley supplement catalog arrived and therein was information on ceramic water stones and a statement that they would abrade M2, as well as less recalcitrant stuff. Previously in a Newsletter were quantitative data on abrasion rates of M2 on various stones.

The only M2 in my shop are lathe tools and jointer knives. So, why would I care about how these stones abraded M2, or why would Lee Valley even be spending time studying abrasion of M2.....unless there was some reason that in the future I might be expected to have something in the shop made of M2 that would be appropriate for water stone abrasion.

Essential to the introduction of any more abrasion resistant woodworking tool steel will be providing some consumer acceptable means of sharpening it. At $43 + 47 +62 + 59 + $74 to get from "quickly grinding the primary bevel" to "mirror finish" that is one steep entry fee to more abrasion resistant tools, and that is for the "cheap" stones. It would be interesting to know why LeeValley is pursuing these stones for sharpening rather than would would appear to be vastly cheaper diamond. Which is yet another example of why a career in marketing was not in my future........

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

#2

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

Schtoo

Hi Bill,

Just quickly. LV has M2 plane blades for sale now.

The Sigma Power Select II stones they're mentioning (I don't have the catalog, but I know what they sell because I sell them too) are brutally effective with any steel. Arguably faster and easier to live with than diamond paste. The cheaper Bester stones, much less effective.

I don't think diamond pastes are the be all and end all. I've got lines in the water and partway through examination, but there are potentially excellent reasons why diamonds are not such a hot idea for sharpening acute angle blades. For polishing, great. For less acute angles, wonderful. For the acute angles such as knives and tools that will see some hard use, maybe not. And yet, the lightly loaded edges as in a razor, they're a good idea.

Like I said, I've got things in the works, but am not willing to say any more than that, even with aggressive provocation. When I'm sure, then I'll say why.

The more expensive stones? The company who makes them also manufactures diamond plates, diamond stones both under the own name (Sigma Power) and under license/rebranded for other companies.

Makes you wonder why they'd do that...

Stu.

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

#3

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

David Weaver

<---.. o O *Applies provocation aggressively twice*...

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

#4

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

Schtoo

Dang mosquitoes are big this year...

Will have more answers come Monday. Get to bend the ear of some of the best in the business on Sunday.

And none of them use diamonds.

Stu.

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

#5

Moses Yoder

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

Moses Yoder

I have not used diamonds yet because the stones I have are there ready to go and they work. My dad didn't use diamond to sharpen, why should I? A stone is easy; you buy it, then you use it. With diamond past you have to buy a substrate, then apply the diamond, and hope you did it right because there is not much detailed information out there on how to actually apply the diamond to the substrate, and then there is the question of whether I will like the way it works. I like diamonds on rings, but the thought of using diamond to sharpen doesn't appeal to me as much for some reason. From reading this board, diamond sharpening sounds almost like a religion to me.

We are just finishing up cabinetry for a 15,000 square foot house, and that's just one of our jobs. We have 3 salespeople who are constantly busy drawing up plans for cabinetry. In a supposedly soft economy, we have more work than we can do. The thought occurs to me that money does not matter all that much to most of the people who are woodworking as a hobby. They already spent $50,000 on their shop, what's a couple thousand more for some nice ceramic sharpening stones?

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

#6

Re: Lee Valley metals insights *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Moses,

While I haven't tried diamond sharpening myself yet, it's on my round tuit list; and I'm fairly conservative when it comes to adopting technologies. I'll really be sad if I find diamonds so much better that all my carefully accumulated oilstones (mainly from years of hunting and gathering expeditions, aka garage sale trolling) become useless.

The article by Bill Tindall and Phil Smith, linked below, seems pretty clear and straightforward on the selection and preparation of diamond paste on a substrate. Not sure how much more might be needed.

I haven't ever attempted to calculate what I've spent on my shop, but I seriously doubt it's $50,000; I doubt that it's even a tenth of that. But then, I am a cheapskate.


Bill Tindall's article

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

#7

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

Rob Lee

Hi Bill -

Just publishing some findings is all.... :)

As mentioned above - we've had M2 blades since last fall, but didn't want to promote them without an effective array of stones that would handle them.

Cheers -

Rob

(spending the day walking around Savannah)

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

#8

Why!?

Bill Tindall

I just checked the weather there and it's 98 degrees. Gasp. Natives escape to the mountains this time of year where it is cool(er). There are some very good woodworkers in that area.

Anyway , thanks for the information. What is the Rockwell hardness of your M2 blades?

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

#9

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

Brian Greene

I've been using the Bester stones for quite a while now. I've probably sharpened 200+ edges with them. In terms of speed and durability they blow Nortons and Kings out of the water. 3x faster than Nortons; 6x faster than Kings; give or take. I have a set of 1000-4000-8000 at work, which replaced Norton's. I was sufficiently impressed that I purchased a set for home, replacing Kings, but opted for 700-2000-8000 which is a more aggressive combination (the 700 compares roughly to a King 1200 and the 2000 to a 4000; the 8000 would compare to a King 10,000 if there was one.) I have been very impressed and I'm a huge skeptic of "new" tools.

I haven't tried the Power Select yet nor have I experienced M2 steel.

By the way, I work for Lee Valley in Ottawa and Robin didn't make me write this!!

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

#10

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

Warren in Lancaster, PA

How long would it take you to sharpen a chisel full bevel using the Bester stones?

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

#11

A question

Bill Tindall

This is an honest question....no hidden agendas, just something I haven't seen an answer to ......

This question is focused on the coarser stones where there is equivalence in scratch size between what ever these stones deliver and some fixed diamond plate equivalent-medium, fine or extra fine. What is the advantage of these, or any water stone, over a fixed diamond plate? (fixed diamond plate is defined as diamond material permanently embedded in some metal matrix on a flat steel plate. Not loose diamond on cast iron)

I have never used any sort of water stone, so I have not experienced what ever advantage they must have to make them preferred over a fixed diamond plate for material removal.

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

#12

Re: A question

wilbur

Hi Bill,

This is my take on the waterstone/diamond plate thing. It depends on which diamond plates and which waterstones you're talking about. In my shop, I have a DMT diamond plate, an Atoma diamond plate, a Sigma Power waterstone, and a Shapton pro waterstone. All more or less give the same scratch size. Most of the chisels and plane blades that I use are Japanese chisels and planes.

What I find is that the DMT cuts the slowest, then it's a close race between the remaining three. Certainly you have to do more management with the waterstones in terms of managing flatness than the diamond plates. And I find it trivial to manage the flatness of a waterstone.

So if you were to compare a Shapton with a DMT plate, I would say that the waterstone has an advantage in terms of speed by a fair amount. In terms of the Shapton, Sigma Power, and Atoma, the speed issue is close, but the edge probably goes to the Atoma since you don't have to worry about maintaining flatness.

Subjectively, I much prefer the feel of the waterstones in use than either diamond plates in use. It's a smoother feel, whereas the diamond stones give me a "fingernails on the blackboard" type of feeling, and that's a big enough priority for me to usually pick up the waterstones first when sharpening.

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

#13

Fixed diamond plates v. coarse waterstones

Steve Elliott

What is the advantage of these [coarse waterstones], or any water stone, over a fixed diamond plate?

I found that extra-coarse diamond plates removed metal very well when new but lost their speed too quickly to justify their cost. I have several well-broken-in plates that are just too slow to be of much use to me now and I'm back to using a coarse waterstone (240x I think) despite how quickly it dishes out.

For exotic alloys I like 60 micron diamond paste on cast iron, but for carbon steel blades I'd probably use the waterstone.

I'd like to try the newer stones like the Sigma Power series but until I actually need a new stone I'll stick with what I have.

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

#14

Re: A question

David Weaver

There is some commonality with what wilbur is saying here. I'll attest to the waterstones that I have and the diamond stones.

waterstones

* glasstone 1k

* shapton pro 1k

* bester 1200

diamonds

* atoma 400 (which has worn to the point that it cuts at the speed of more like an 800)

* two DMTs - a bench stone, and a duosharp

* two chinese knock-offs of the koyama double sided diamond (electroplated diamonds on a milled steel plate)

I wore the DMT out on steel. I don't think I ripped too many of the diamonds loose from the plating substrate, but wore them out. Same with the atoma 400, but it has settled a little more nicely than the DMT, maybe because I knew better how to use it.

The stones don't feel as nice as the diamond hones, they cut a more uniform scratch pattern, and through their life, their performance is consistent. think of the diamond plates as a slower wearing sandpaper. they lose their initial smartness pretty quickly, then settle in for a long time gradually wearing out until they cut very very slowly for their grit size.

I use the chinese diamond plates for a lot of stuff where total flatness doesn't matter. It cuts HSS very well, as you'd expect, but it's also good for laziness with a lot of other things and good for touching up carbide or HSS tooling bits where you want a hard surface and a light cut.

I wore out one of the chinese hones and eventually broke a small patch of plating off of it, and the other one I've near worn out.

I have not worn out any stone, though I did run a fair amount off of the glasstone before I pitched up the dollars to get shapton's *real* stones.

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

#15

Re: Fixed diamond plates v. coarse waterstones

David Weaver

I agree with this exactly. The coarsest stone I can get along with, though, is the chosera 400. The shapton 220 I had loaded too quickly and you had to clean it up as often as you'd have to flatten a softer stone. The norton 220 was near useless for any purpose it needed to be flat - it never stayed flat long enough for me to assess how fast it cut.

the chosera 400 is hard enough that it still loads, and you have to condition the surface with a diamond plate to bring its aggressiveness back when you're flattening something. A knife or the bevel of a tool might be aggressive enough to keep it shedding its surface grit on its own and negate that, but it reminds me a lot of a medium india the way it loses it's snap and can be refreshed with a diamond plate.

I choose loose diamonds for the level below that, because when an expensive 60 or 240 grit diamond plate wears out, you are stuck but with loose diamonds, a tiny pinch of dust and you're in business again for a while. I can't stand the coarse silicon carbide oil stone that I have - it doesn't stay flat that well, nor is it that easy to flatten.

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

#16

follow up

Bill Tindall

The consensus is that experience has shown that water stones cut faster than an unspecified size diamond plate. However, no one specified what grit diamond plate they were comparing. Note, in the question I purposely excluded coarse diamond from the comparison. I found the "coarse " plates short lived but I have yet to see any loss of speed on the "fine" plate I use after initial grinding. So, does anyone have comparative data of water stones vs diamond in the medium to extra fine diamond range.

DMT plates are single crystal diamond, according to my sources not the best choice for the task at hand.

Whooohooo, masive lightening bolt....I'm out of here.............

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

#17

Re: follow up

David Weaver

I'll answer from my experience.

The 400 grit atoma as worn if there is any lubricant (including water) cuts about as fast as the shapton 1k, which is apparently more akin to anyone else's 800 grit stone.

The 600 grit side of my duosharp is a good bit slower than that, and the 350 side is probably similar to where the atoma is.

The same thing goes for the scratch size of the cheap chinese planes (cheap is relative, they're two sided and $45 each), it is smaller as they get older, but i'm guessing they are polycrystalline diamond because the retain the sharpness feeling even as the grit gets smaller. The DMT leaves large scratches still, but the diamonds just feel duller on it.

I have never touched metal to my 220 grit DMT bench stone since it is for oilstones, and while I'll use the worn duosharp to scuff the surface of an oilstone, especially a fine one where I don't want to use the 220 grit, it won't remove much material and isn't suitable for flattening anything that is more than the tiniest bit out of flat.

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

#18

Re: follow up

wilbur

I do have a DMT diamond hone in their "extra fine" range. I hate using it because of the "fingernails on the blackboard" issue that I mentioned before. It doesn't seem to be any faster than my equivalent waterstones for sure, and I think the waterstones are a little quicker, to be honest.

But any increase in speed either way is going to be of minimal benefit. At this stage in sharpening, I'm spending only about 30 seconds on the higher grits. So there's only so much time you can save. Over the course of a weekend afternoon in my shop, I'll save way more time by not taking a bathroom break.

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

#19

Re: Fixed diamond plates v. coarse waterstones

TomD

I prefer to power grind it. One can power grind any steel without drawing the temper, that's how they make the tools.

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

#20

Clarification

Bill Tindall

that bolt of lightening earlier triggered my routine thunderstorm computer shut down . Friend and fellow woodworker has several thousand $ in lightening strike damage earlier.

I "remove metal" on a powered grinding wheel which would be equivalent to the coarsest sharpening water stone or diamond "grinding in function. It is the next step in edge refinement that I am exploring. I spend the most time on this step for it is this step I return to during typical work to "touch up". It is at this stage that I use a $60 "fine" or "extra fine" polycrystalline diamond plate, 12 x 3" made by Ez-lap in Nevada.(I think retail for these plates is more but they do "show specials" and that is where I have bought from them. I very much like the longer 12" surface, the plate seems to be staying sharp for a long time (unlike coarse diamond I once used) and it cuts quick. The fine or extra fine, I can't tell much difference between them, removes 80 grit grinder scratches in a few strokes. Am I likely to see any benefit to exploring water stones for this step?

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

#22

Re: Clarification

wilbur

For me, yes, waterstones have an advantage in doing what you describe in terms of avoiding the "fingernails on a blackboard" issue. That may or may not be important to you.

In terms of speed of obliterating scratches as you describe, waterstones probably don't offer any advantage over diamond plates. On the other hand, diamond plates don't offer any advantage over waterstones for this task, either.

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

#23

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

Brian Greene

I don't know because I would use a grinder. I can say that I can turn a burr on a freshly ground blade with the 700 stone in two strokes.

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

#24

Re: A question

Brian Greene

Except for diamond paste, I have no experience with diamonds.

Re: Lee Valley metals insights

#25

Bester stones

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Brian, you stated yesterday that the Bester stones were six times as fast as the King stones. I am wondering about this. How long does it take you, start to finish, to sharpen a chisel using the grinder and the Bester stones?

I sharpen a chisel with King stones in 70 seconds. I never bother with a grinder. Am I to believe that the Bester stones would do this in 12 seconds?