New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

An idea for improved plane iron durability

Posts

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#26

referencing the data in your table

Bill Tindall

The data in your table suggest abrasive wear is more significant than adhesive wear in the case of plane irons.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#27

Re: the explanation is straightforward

Charles Stanford

Have you applied that same zeal to, say, joinery? It's a process too.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#28

Yes indeed....to a fault

Bill Tindall

"Improve" in the realm of making furniture can mean improvement of what is known or accepted or, what I have been able to do or have done in the past.

Various times I have tried my hand at reproduction work and along the way I can't resist changing this or that, for better or worse. I have a friend that does reproduction work and he faithfully copies every detail. I don't see how he can stand it. The French Footed thing started out a typical Federal Period piece and then the whimsical skirt got added in mid flight. Now I have to figure out a different top to go with the whimsical skirt. I have made several dozen case pieces and the joinery in every one is different, and gotten better(more robust) over time. And, the details of how the joinery is made has changed. I still haven't settled on the "best" way to lay out and make M&T or dovetails, even after making hundreds of them. Probably never will.

Just finished making NY Pizza and tried a different water to flour ratio...was not better. But tomorrow I am getting some new yeast to try. The buttermilk pancakes are settled. There is no chance for improvement.......that I can see yet.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#29

care to explain how you came up with that? n/m

Larry Williams

n/m

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#30

Re: Wire Edges

David Weaver

I agree with this. When I've sharpened sub-micron as a final step, I haven't paid any attention to the wire edge.

I can bend the edge one way or another with a bare strop to get it to feel sharper on one side of the bevel than the other, but at super fine grits, it's either already broken off or too small to create the same damage it would if you don't strop off of a hard black arkansas stone or a 5k shapton or something.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#31

Re: care to explain how you came up with that? n/m

Bill Tindall

I began the task but soon discovered that a picture(in this case a Table)is worth a 1000 words, or at least more than I care to type.

Look for comparisons between metals that we know something about. Then see if what we know of plane iron performance correlates with the adhesive wear column or the abrasive wear column. For example, the most striking example is D2 vs O1. D2 has poor adhesive wear but we know it to be more durable in plane irons. The vanadium steel is another case where the abrasive wear data best correlates with durability as a plane iron. A2 is more durable than O1 in plane irons but this fact would not be predicted by the adhesive wear column. I found numerous cases in the Table where abrasive wear correlated better than adhesive wear with performance as a plane iron.

Summary, the data in the Table as well as Derek and Steve's data makes a convincing case that it is abrasive wear that is most important.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#32

Re: Wire Edges

Steve Elliott

At the risk of continuing to focus attention on a subject of marginal practical use, I'm going to add a little more.

The fact that a well-trained and knowledgeable person like Joel, someone whose opinion I respect, is reporting results different from what I've found intrigues me. I looked at the sharpening section of Joel's website again and from what I can tell he's using oilstones. When I was using a black Arkansas for final honing I can remember having to chase the wire edge, in the sense of chasing it from one side of the edge to the other until it was finally gone. I wasn't stropping but it probably would have helped.

When I switched to waterstones I still had to chase the wire edge at first but as I bought finer stones it became unnecessary, though I do still flip the blade over for a few seconds on the back when I'm done with the bevel.

I've been reading Double Bevel Sharpening by Brian Burns and he notes that "At this point [after the 8000 grit stone] there should be no burr left on the cutting edge. Pick with your fingernail on the back side to check. The 8000 grit stone is so fine that it leaves none; or at any rate I can't find one with a 200 power microscope."

There are different ways of sharpening tools well. Oilstones and strops are certainly one method with a lot of tradition and knowledge behind it. The same can be said of Japanese waterstones. When it comes to wire edges the two methods seem to produce different results.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#33

Re: Wire Edges

David Weaver

A light touch on the shapton 15k usually leaves me with nothing to do. I do alternate briefly between the back and the front when I feel like i'm done, literally one or two strokes.

The first time I used oil stones, I was shocked by how large of a wire edge I got on a surgical black, hard black, (whatever you call it). Unfortunately, the stone that I bought is not that close to flat, and i'm choosing to get it there by lapping it fairly hard every couple of uses. The corners drop of significantly and I'll probably leave them as they are, and I have a large flat now much larger than an 8x2 stone (it's a 12x3 surgical black). I am reasonably pleased with how it behaves once the smarts are knocked off the surface and it hasn't been lapped in a while. If I didn't have steel with hard carbides, I can get a very fine edge with it and a bare strop, as long as it isn't freshly honed.

Coming off of a hard arkansas (i saw warren's comments last week about really liking the hard arkansas, and I think it's an interesting stone, too), I wish I would've gotten HTA instead of the surgical black. When the surgical black has a chance to settle in for a while, though, I don't know if there will be much difference.

But there is no great reason for me to use any arkansas stones other than curiosity (which is good enough for me).

I got one of joels choseras, too, not that long ago - someone was selling a NIB stone (same part #, etc) for what was a pretty good deal (still expensive, though). Same thing as shapton's 15k - no wire edge. Totally different stone, but same result. Nicer stone, too - than the shapton - totally different polish, more muddy by a little and more shiny, less concern for the swarf (which can cause problems on the surface of a shapton if allowed to accumulate, making it behave like a more coarse stone.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#34

3V wire edges

Bill Tindall

Because of its exceptional toughness the wire edge on 3V is exceptionally tenacious. (great for lathe scrapers I might add, but this fact remains undiscovered by most turners. That's a long story!). When I first stated sharpening 3V I often found it to be "dull" because that pesky wire edge was still clinging.

What I find is that with 1 micron diamond on cast iron the wire edge from the previous grit just "dissolves away. You can see it happen. It may be replaced by a nanometer wire edge from the 1 micron abrasive but that is no concern at my level of planing needs.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#35

Re: Wire Edges

joel moskowitz

Actually I use both. I remember at our connect to the craft event when I sharpened a chisel on IIRC norton waterstones to 8000 and then passed it around. None of the dozen or so viewers could feel a burr (I couldn't either) and we all agreed it was sharp. Then i stropped it on a plain leather strop. about 10 a side 4 or 5 rounds.

then I passed it around again. The same folks were amazed that it both felt sharper and more importantly cut far far better.

On more brittle steels the effect is less obvious but I don't know a single case where it isn't true even on far finer abrasives. Japanese knive sharpeners routinely strop too.

The theory is that long after we can feel a burr remains of it are still there and removing it with a plain strop fatigues the metal and removes it cleanly and doesn't create more burr at the same time. this give a smooth, sharper, longer lasting edge.

This is a simple test to duplicate take a chisel - just follow the instructions and compare. The only caveate is that you have to test sharpness by using the tool and of course a plain strop. It took me a couple of years after I started before I could feel the difference between a tool honed until I could not feel a burr on either side and one that was stropped. In use it was easier to see. Also you had mentioned previous sharpening from one side only this will leave a burr on the other side no matter how fine an abrasive you use. again with brittle steels the burr is far smaller and more fragile.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#36

Question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

David,

You said, "I am reasonably pleased with how it behaves once the smarts are knocked off the surface..."

The smarts got knocked off my surface years ago; I don't understand what you mean here. What is a "smart" in this context?

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#37

Re: Wire Edges

David Weaver

I saw the same effect with the 8k stones as the oilstones, too. It was the finer abrasives where I lost track of whether I could tell if a wire edge exists. Continuing to hone on the shapton 15k made me feel like I was doing the same thing to the edge as I would be doing with a strop, to some extent - working whatever the edge may be and orienting it (albeit only a degree or two maybe?) with some pressure.

I have not viewed an edge more coarse than the shapton 15k under high magnification that I can recall, and only have viewed edges to try to figure out what stones that were claimed to be finer than that were doing. I wasn't really looking for a wire edge, so I could've missed it, but I didn't see it.

With an 8k stone, white steel may behave like it has no wire edge, but A2's wire edge is easy to notice. You can see some of it let go sometimes.

Joel, I don't want to run you around, but I know (or I think) you have a 10k chosera floating around there. Can you see if you can duplicate the effect on it, intentionally polishing both sides of the bevel with the chosera?

I'm curious, though I will admit that sometimes I will take an edge off of the 15k stone and give it a very light strop to orient it the way I want it to be oriented (i.e., on a smoothing iron, I want the shaving effect to be most effortless bevel down, and a single pass of the back of the iron across bare leather and little pressure can do that quite well).

This is a curiosity to me because I went straight to the shapton 15k as my second finishing stone and never did really think about stropping until either I started shaving with a straight razor or I put power to leather (i can't remember which).

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#38

Re: Question

David Weaver

Bill, by that, I mean that after a pass of a diamond hone to freshen up the surface, or in my case to continue flattening it, the stone is very aggressive. It cuts aggressively and behaves like a coarser stone than you'd think to finish with.

However, the abrasive is so soft (compared to synthetic abrasives) that i'm assuming that it dulls and the surface gets plugged very quickly, it's easy to notice just by lapping the back of something on the stone. It gets finer as you use it in subsequent sharpenings to the point that it feels like it is almost not cutting. Unfortunately, my stone is not flat, so when I lap it i lose that fineness. At some point, it'll be good enough and I'll stop doing that - i'm probably there right now.

With the aggressive freshly lapped feel and no strop, you can *just* shave with an (what was yesterday a 26 degree bevel) edge off of it. Once it is finer, it shaves quite easily and though it cuts slow, it's fast enough as long as it's not following something that makes deep grooves (i.e., it works well following a hard arkansas or a soft arkansas).

Those are just my opinions, there are a lot of folks who are oil stone fanatics. I have them only as a curiosity, and because they do have a nice feel. I wish they cut tougher steels well, I like their feel.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#39

Re: Wire Edges

joel moskowitz

David,

Sure, I've done it before I can do it again - no sweat with a 10K. I'm not sure if you can photograph the burr at this stage because (I've never tried to photograph it) if it is straight it will look like part of the blade. You get a sharp edge that doesn't last. Stropping as I describe fatiques and removes the last but of wire. one or two strokes doesn't do it.

Just for jollies why don't you try it yourself - after get and edge as perfect as you can give it 10 x 5 strokes on a side on some clean leather. 10 strokes, flip over 10 strokes, flip etc. Be careful on the back side as it is easy to round over the edge. If you feel carefully the edge will change feel but the real test is if it seems sharper.

joel

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#40

Stropping Technique

Steve Elliott

I've never used anywhere near 50 strokes per side on a strop so that may account for not seeing the effect you describe. I have enough projects underway already that I'm not sure I want to get back into sharpest-edge-possible stuff again, but my curiosity is piqued.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#41

Re: Stropping Technique

joel moskowitz

you will see the effect with less but if you are trying to see if the effect exists going whole hog makes sense. it only takes a couple of minutes.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#42

Re: Stropping Technique

David Weaver

i haven't tried this since last night, shop time is a bit scarce.

However, I know what this much stropping does for a razor edge, so I have no doubt that it will make a sharper feeling edge, and like you said, whatever is going on at the very edge is too small to see so I've got no interest in looking at it under a digital microscope.

Who wants to do a durability test? I don't, but I'd be curious to find the answer as to whether this adds any durability.

A real durability test, not "planing in MDF" or some such thing. Last time I did one, I ran two irons against each other in hard maple - one went 750 swipes and the other one just short of 1100. It took a LONG time.

Sample of ten durability tests under each sharpening method would be nice! Who is up for it?

When I strop generally, I pull the bevel and the back across bare leather under little more than the weight of the tool, it's just a few seconds. I think 50 passes is a lot more than removing the wire edge, and is more akin to removing the wire edge and then moving the rest of the steel at the edge some with the additional stropping, no matter how light the pressure (actually, I have better results with very light pressure in absolute sharpness, just like a razor).

This is way above and beyond what I'd go for working, and I guess i'm looking for something that's quick for while I'm working. The only real measure I have of "good enough" then is surface quality and no lines or visible imperfections on whatever a smoother touches, and 1 micron edges are about where I see a level of shine that I can't improve on with medium hardwoods (a buddy blew his wad on the 30k shapton stone, and we couldn't see a difference in surface finish between it and a 15k stone).

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#43

Re: Wire Edges ... comments *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

All the good discussion takes place when I am asleep! So late to the discussion I offer a few thoughts and comments ...

I remember at our connect to the craft event when I sharpened a chisel on IIRC norton waterstones to 8000 and then passed it around. None of the dozen or so viewers could feel a burr (I couldn't either) and we all agreed it was sharp. Then i stropped it on a plain leather strop. about 10 a side 4 or 5 rounds. then I passed it around again. The same folks were amazed that it both felt sharper and more importantly cut far far better.

Hi Joel

I agree with David, 50 strokes takes this out of the realm of wire removal and into the world of honing. Used this way, the leather strop is just another sharpening medium.

My idea of a strop is that it is used to remove vestiges of the wire edge, not the whole wire edge (which should be removed on the polishing stone). It is also used to re-new an edge - although I am having second thoughts about this now.

How does one remove a wire edge? What direction do you move the steel?

In videos, we see David Charlesworth moving the blade fore-and-aft. And we see Harrelson Stanley moving it sideways. When moved fore-and-aft the wire comes off as a single thread. I can't help but wonder if the remaining edge is smooth or, as I suspect, ragged from breaking off. When moving sideways (my preferred method), the wire appears to be ground off, judging from the black smear that remains on a waterstone. The edges feel smoother to my touch (Note to self - must test this out and take a few images).

I really like the Horse Butt strops you sell. Over the past year or so I have used them less and less. They work well, but that is half the problem. To work, I believe a strop has to dub an edge ... very slightly, but still there will be some dubbing as the leather does have some give (even the Horse Butt leather). For re-newing an edge I simpy return to my Shaptons. I have the luxury of a dedicated sharpening bench with runing water, and this is alongside my work bench. The wire edge is removed on a 12000 stone, and for good measure I run it across 0.5� Chromium Oxide Micro Abrasive paper from Lee Valley (This is glued to glass on MDF to assure flatness).

A couple of years ago I completed a comparison of Veritas green compound and 0.5� diamond paste using the Horse Butt strops as a substratum. I preferred the green crayon. It seemed to leave a smoother finish. (link below)

Lastly, can one feel the wire edge off an 8000 Shapton? I can feel the wire edge off a 12000 Shapton. How do I know it is the 12000 and not the 5000 that precedes this? Simply because I always remove the wire edge before moving onto the next grit. (The wire edge communicates that one has honed across the bevel).

Regards from Perth

Derek


Stropping with green rouge versus diamond paste

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#44

Re: Wire Edges ... comments

joel moskowitz

"agree with David, 50 strokes takes this out of the realm of wire removal and into the world of honing. Used this way, the leather strop is just another sharpening medium."

Sorry I don't agree. On any sharpening medium even down to .3 micron it is pretty easy to see steel roll off the edge. with good plain leather not so easy. I can for a wire with just about any abrasive, not with leather. As I said previously the process works for a lot less than 50 strokes, but the reason I suggested 50 strokes is that for a test purpose you want to ensure the effect.

"My idea of a strop is that it is used to remove vestiges of the wire edge, not the whole wire edge (which should be removed on the polishing stone)."

this i agree with. As I said I only go to leather AFTER I have removed the wire edge by honing until I cannot feel it.

This is a simple test to do. Sharpen something until you think it's sharp and you cannot feel the wire edge. (if you remove the wire mechanically all bets are off and you will get a I think a slightly duller edge.) test the cutting, then strop.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#45

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

bugbear

That's kind of a big issue around here because all these magic bullet steels are all about abrasive wear. Abrasive wear is what happens when one sharpens but most dulling wear from use comes from adhesive wear.

If I'm understanding you correctly, that could mean that it's possible to have a material with low resistance to abrasion wear (easy to sharpen), but high resistance to adhesive wear (keeps an edge for a long time).

That's the goal!

(unless, of course, there are metallurgical reasons that the two types of wear resistance stem from common factors)

BugBear

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#46

Chris Scholz

Good old scratch test to test toughness!

Chris Scholz

There is a professor at MIT, Dr. Franz-Josef Ulm, who together with his co-professor and graduate student Ange-Therese Akono, just figured out that the good old scratch test, is actually quite a good test to assess the toughness of (some/many?) materials.

Looks like this research was sponsored by the Portland Cement Association and the Ready Mixed Concrete corporation, so it might be advised to transfer these results directly to the problem at hand.

For details, check it out at in Phys. Rev. Lett. V. 106, N. 20 p. 204302ff

Here is more information on the model they use.

Enjoy!

Chris

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#47

Oh my....there is some "light" reading

Bill Tindall

Sharpening is equivalent to scratching, but that was more materials science than I was up to attempting to understand to glean addition insight. To think that while I was "studying" the latest Lee Valley supplement others were nobly plowing through the integrals of Equations 16.

Rockwell hardness is a penetration test, while Mohs hardness is a scratch test. The paper, what little I understood of it, states that these two measures are fundamentally different. I gathered the scratch test measures some combination of toughness and hardness but I was lost shortly thereafter.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#48

Re: One of the things that I loved .....

George in mosquito filled Lowell, Mich.

about college was studying Calculus. Not because I understood it, but that the equations were so beautiful and mysterious!!!!!

Thanks for sharing that!

Work safe,

George