New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

An idea for improved plane iron durability

Posts

An idea for improved plane iron durability

#1

An idea for improved plane iron durability

Bill Tindall

Steve Elliot has shown that abrasion resistance of the back of the iron is important in the life of the plane edge for a bevel down plane iron. This observation has some ramifications and offers a means of improving plane iron durability.

First, for the home made plane irons it means that one must be sure to grind away any metal on the back that is damaged from heat treating. I have been told that several thousandths of an inch must be removed, but a poor job of heat treating may require more removal.

Second, would a coating of Titanium nitride or other abrasion resistant material coated on the back of the plane iron improve its edge life? Steve's data suggest that it could. As I understand the process, doing this coating is simple if one has the facilities to do it. see follow up post....

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#2

calling all metal workers.....

Bill Tindall

Does anyone work in a shop that could get a plane iron coated with TiN or similar abrasion resistant coating? I suspect Steve could be persuaded or even bribed into testing the coated iron to determine if the coating improved life.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#3

Stephen Shepherd

Another idea for improved plane iron durability

Stephen Shepherd

I have an idea for improving plane iron durability. Start out with a thin slip of good steel, really doesn't matter what kind, then forge weld it onto a softer substrate like wrought iron.

It takes three heats, but the forge welding and shaping would work harden the steel changing its characteristics considerably.

Then after it is shaped and ground, heat it up and quench it in brine. The steel will be brittle hard and the wrought iron will of course remain ductile. I think this might be an improvement whose time has come.

Stephen

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#4

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

Larry Williams

Bill,

The nitride coatings are designed to increase lubricity and limit adhesive wear. These coatings are for tooling that won't be sharpened because sharpening or abrasion removes them. If you look at what surface engineers are doing with nitride coatings to tooling, it's all about adhesive wear.

That's kind of a big issue around here because all these magic bullet steels are all about abrasive wear. Abrasive wear is what happens when one sharpens but most dulling wear from use comes from adhesive wear. Abrasive wear and adhesive wear are very different and heat is a major catalyst to adhesive wear but has little effect on abrasive wear. There's a lot of heat generated in the process of taking a plane shaving. Chasing abrasive wear is pretty misleading if you're talking about most dulling wear to woodworking tool edges. Generally, increasing hardness does increase adhesive wear resistance but harder tools usually have other issues for woodworking.

Unfortunately most US manufacturers like to group adhesive wear and abrasive wear together. If they can increase the resistance to abrasive wear it makes their specs look pretty good but it changes only the specs, not the actual resistance to most dulling wear.

Here's a chart from Uddeholm where adhesive and abrasive wear are shown separately:


img

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#5

likely won't work to improve abrasion resistance

Bill Tindall

Derek tested this concept in his recent post where he turned chisels into a bevel up plane iron. Abrasion resistance has little to do with the hardness of the steel. It is primarily determined by what carbides are present. Vanadium makes the most abrasion resistant carbide. Hence, it is not surprising that alloys like M4 and 3V have better wear resistance than carbon steel.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#6

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

Bill Tindall

Once polished and coated there would be no need to further abrade the back of a plane iron. So it sounds like this may be worth trying.

Steve pointed out another advantage. It would be obvious how much bevel to grind to renew an edge. Grind back to the yellow.

Steve's data and Derek's data and lathe turners experience all correlate nicely with the published abrasion resistance of tool steels. More vanadium, better abrasion resistance, longer edge life.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#7

Adhesive Wear

Steve Elliott

Larry,

I've been interested in the distinction between adhesive and abrasive wear for some years now and have never found any source that has studied the type of wear that happens when steel blades are used to cut wood. Do you know of any work that has been done to research this? Most wear studies seem to focus on wear between metal surfaces.

As for titanium nitride coatings, they certainly would do nothing on surfaces that the end user (woodworker) honed. Considering the flatness of the backs of Lee Valley plane blades these days it seems to me that a TiN coating on the back might be useful in a bevel-up plane. It could reduce wear on the back side of the blade and then be a good visual guide to show how much needs to be ground off the bevel to get back to the original edge geometry. When the bevel side is finely honed it becomes unnecessary to hone the blade back to remove a wire edge, so the TiN surface would remain untouched.

That said, I still prefer bevel-down planes. They put the greater wear on the bevel which is routinely ground off. But these days there are lots of woodworkers who use bevel-up planes and like them.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#8

Re: Adhesive Wear

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

You guys must be some good sharpeners if you can grind to a specific line, no more, no less, whether by hand or machine, even color coded.

And, Steve, did you intend to say you still preferred bevel-up planes?

Pam

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#9

Bevel-down planes

Steve Elliott

As soon as I start thinking I'm a really good sharpener, reality has a way of showing me I'm not as good as I thought. But if there's a line showing how far I need to go to grind something off, I'm able to continue until I reach the line.

As for bevel-down planes, yes I do prefer them. My favorites are old infill smoothers I've tuned up but for rapid stock removal I like wood-bodied planes for their lighter weight and slick soles. When it comes to stock prep I'm pretty much a power tool guy, though.

I like block planes, which of course are bevel-up. For end grain I like the low angle one, otherwise just whichever one is sharper.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#10

Hitting lines

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I don't see how that could be done with any edge-formation consistancy, except a consistancy of a small non-edge. Really. How do you grind to a line that produces a sharp edge and no burr? And that's a real question, because I don't necessarily doubt that you can do that.

Pam

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#11

Re: Hitting lines

Steve Elliott

The grinding doesn't remove the burr, it just removes the previous edge. When the bevel is honed to a high polish the wire edge finally drops off when the honing is complete. This has been my experience on almost all blades, the exception being a Stanley V-logo blade that formed the most tenacious wire edge I've ever seen.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#12

Re: Adhesive Wear

Larry Williams

Steve,

Are you suggesting I grind the edge back at each sharpening? OMG, do you have any idea how many hours that would add to my work week? I sharpen a lot but I might grind the edge back on any given tool every year or three. Yes, I do get wear on the flat face but it's very shallow and can be removed by a pass or two on a well maintained medium or fine India. Just make sure the abrasive signatures go all the way to the edge.

I almost always only grind to keep the honed bevel at the edge to less than about 3/32". That way it's only a couple passes on the bevel to raise a wire edge medium then three or four passes of the back on a dressed translucent Arkansas to remove the medium abrasive signatures and the wire edge. A couple passes of the bevel on the translucent to raise a second wire edge then a pass or two to remove that wire edge. One or two short light passes on a strop to remove any remnants of the wire edge and I'm done.

I grind an edge back only in the case of something that causes significant damage or after maybe 50 or 60 sharpenings (nothing more than a guess here) because I freehand hone and tend to put slightly more pressure on the right side when honing which will, over time, cause the edge to be a little out of square.

I probably spend more time dressing the stones with a few passes each and checking them for flat than actual honing. Sharpening the tools I work with is not a problem and involves very little time. In the grand scheme it's simply insignificant.

That wouldn't be the case if I ground the edge back at each sharpening. For that to make sense you'll have to give me an edge that lasts about 3 years in daily use. I don't think these magic-bullet steels are even close to that.

On the topic of nitride coatings for wood, I've looked for information and haven't found anything. With indexable tooling becoming popular for some machines I'm sure they're working on it. It's proprietary information but will become known in time. I've experimented a little with different coatings on metal working tooling we machine wood with. I haven't made a real study of it but I'm always looking to see how things are doing. Increasing lubricity with nitride coatings when machining wood does seem to reduce wear and buildup in the flutes so I assume it helps. Normal TiN seems to be as effective as anything.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#13

Re: Adhesive Wear

Steve Elliott

I'm not suggesting that you change your sharpening technique. Since you prefer bevel-down planes (as I also do) then the use of TiN on the flat side of a bevel-up blade is a non-issue for you. When I sharpen bevel-up blades (block planes mostly) I do start by grinding because I've found the amount of steel that needs to be removed makes this a more effective technique for me.

I'm still interested in a source for the statement that the wear on a blade used in cutting wood is adhesive rather than abrasive. The descriptions I've found of adhesive wear refer to things like cold welding and galling, which are not present when a blade cuts wood.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#14

Re: Adhesive Wear

joel moskowitz

"When the bevel side is finely honed it becomes unnecessary to hone the blade back to remove a wire edge, so the TiN surface would remain untouched. "

I have never ever seen a case where this is true. Any abrasive no matter how fine removes material and creates a wire edge. With super fine abrasives you cannot even explicitly feel the burr but stropping with a non-abrasive like untreated horsebutt (which is sort of an abrasive) will remove a burr you cannot feel and the edge will be sharper and last longer. (this is a simple test to do).

the effect is far more pronounced on less crumbly steels like oh one and I am convinced that one appeal of the higher tech alloys is that the the wire edge falls off easier.

If you do not feel a burr when you sharpen you are not sharp and if you do not approach the burr from both sides you don't remove it so a strop can do the final clean up. You get a false edge which seems sharp but doesn't last. If you mechanically remove the burr you get a rough edge which isn't that sharp as can be and won't last.

When I teach I routinely demonstrate this - and hone a blade on both sides until none of the students can feel a burr, we do a test cut with it, then I strop and test cut again. Folks are amazed how much sharper the tool is.

note: I repeat just to be sure this effect only happens on an untreated strop. If the strop is treated with compound it acts like any other abrasive surface, just a softer one.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#15

Wire Edges

Steve Elliott

My statement was based on looking at finely honed edges under increasing magnification, to the point that I'd gone past the commonsense, practical kind of sharpening I'm really interested in.

To be very clear, honing both faces will give a slightly sharper edge, as seen under a microscope and measured doing thread-cutting tests. The sharpest edges are produced when a narrow back bevel is used. But for any result that survives the first stroke of the blade through wood fine honing of the bevel only, when well done, is sufficient for a producing a good sharp working edge, in my experience.

I've tried an untreated strop (horsebutt--one I bought from you, thanks) and was unable to see any improvement in the edges I was producing using fine diamond on cast iron.

When sharpening bevel-up blades I�ve found the more important issue to be complete removal of the worn edge. On a very worn blade a burr can be felt even before the entire worn edge is gone. One advantage of the TiN coating would be to make it easier to see when the worn edge had been removed.

I hone chisels freehand on a waterstone and work the back of the chisel for a few seconds when I�m done with the bevel. I�m not suggesting that honing one side only is better, only that on a blade with a TiN coating on the back a sharp edge can be produced by working the bevel and not touching the back.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#17

Re: Hitting lines

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

The grinding doesn't remove the burr, it just removes the previous edge. When the bevel is honed to a high polish the wire edge finally drops off when the honing is complete.

Of course it doesn't remove the burr; but usually there's a new burr formed. I think Bill's first posit was that with a (yellow?) titanium coating on the blade back, the sharpener would know where to stop grinding so that: 1) there would be a sharp edge formed and 2) there would be no new burr produced....

Tell you what, we're most likely talking at cross purposes, there's something basic one of us isn't making clear; so I'm going to drop out now.

Pam

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#18

On sharpening TiN ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill wrote: When the bevel side is finely honed it becomes unnecessary to hone the blade back to remove a wire edge, so the TiN surface would remain untouched.

Joel replied: I have never ever seen a case where this is true. Any abrasive no matter how fine removes material and creates a wire edge. With super fine abrasives you cannot even explicitly feel the burr but stropping with ..will remove a burr you cannot feel and the edge will be sharper and last longer. .. I am convinced that one appeal of the higher tech alloys is that the the wire edge falls off easier.

If you do not feel a burr when you sharpen you are not sharp ...

I have a very limited experience of sharpening and using TiN blades. The first thing that I discovered is that they do not create a wire edge in the expected sense. It is so small that you will not feel it. The steel does not fold - insteads it snaps off. When using a blade like this, the steel wears but the TiN coating remains and leaves a jagged edge. The edge can steel feel sharp, but it is not what you would want for planing. Chopping would still work.

As I said, my experience is limited. It no doubt required a new learning curve to extract the potential.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#19

Slight clarification

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I wrote, "The steel does not fold - insteads it snaps off".

What I meant to say was that the Titanium coating does not fold - instead it staps off.

You knew that, didn't you :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#20

there must be more to this story......

Bill Tindall

Nothing like data to end speculation and it appears you have come to the rescue.....

So, someone makes, or has made, a TiN coated plane iron and you have tried it?

Is the coating typically of a thickness where it "breaking off" would leave an edge too dull for practical planing? I thought these coatings were submicron in thickness, in which case how could one tell if it broke or ground or whether it made any difference.

I wonder if the bevel was sharpened with something that would cut the TiN if it would still break, or would it sharpen. If you still have this blade around try diamond.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#21

Re: there must be more to this story......

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

This was a while ago. It was pre-diamond paste and so used my Shaptons to 12000. These did the job - the blade was sharp enough to pare end grain pine cleanly.

I cannot say more at this time. The topic was opened, there was speculation about the wire edge, and I had something to offer to answer the question marks.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#22

Re: calling all metal workers.....

Charlie

Bill - I have in my imagination when I consider your post that you are a cross between Arnold Schwarzenegger in his prime and a 22 year old Kenyan marathoner. You can plane and plane all day with nary a break and can't find edge tools that can keep up.

Do you guys ever get tired? Using honing breaks as a break from woodworking? Fear honing that much?

With due respect, and I mean that sincerely, I don't get the obsession.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#23

Re: Adhesive Wear

Larry Williams

All this newer stuff about wear is coming from surface engineering and research into things that have significant commercial applications. Woodworkers traditionally sharpen tools that would take tooling for woodworkers out of the realm of surface engineers. So I have never found anything that deals directly with woodworking edge tools.

In fact, I'm surprised at how much things have changed since I searched all this out a few years ago. A couple of my book marks are no longer valid and there isn't that much out there in the public domain.

Here's a quote from one of the remaining things:

Adhesive wear is generally the most important type of wear at all non-lubricated moving parts, or moving parts which operate at partly lubricated conditions. Coldwelding describes the formation of small connections whereby tiny disruptions arise during translation. These disruptions leave small malformations at the surface, called adhesive wear.

This is from a .pdf file at http://www.wmv.nl/4%20ADHESIVE%20WEAR.pdf

The web page that describes this is no longer at the book mark I had. I haven't had time to search for it. It was poorly translated but it did explain adhesive wear between tool steel and some plastics. You can see in this chart that both surfaces lose volume in adhesive wear but only one is measured.

One other that's still valid is very basic and is at:

http://www.gordonengland.co.uk/wear.htm

If you scroll down to the links at the bottom there are links to some information on different coatings but not much that's relevant.

Just the basic definitions, though, offer a lot:

Abrasive Wear -- Wear due to hard particles or hard protuberances forced against and moving along a solid surface.

Adhesive Wear -- Wear due to localised bonding between contacting solid surfaces leading to material transfer between the two surfaces or the loss from either surface.

If you dig into the nitride coatings used on metal working tooling, you'll find they're designed to resist adhesive wear. You can quickly verify this by sharpening a carbide insert. The coating will abrade away in a hurry.

Lubricants don't do a lot to inhibit abrasive wear, that's why oil stones cut just as well with oil as without. With abrasives one surface suffers all the volume loss. If you look at tooling coatings and the claims about how they work, it becomes pretty obvious that resisting abrasion isn't what they're about.

I hope this is somewhat coherent. I wrote part of it last night and finished this morning. It's still a little foggy between the ears here yet but I need to get back to work.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#24

the explanation is straightforward

Bill Tindall

I never met a material or process I didn't want to try to improve. I travel through life shedding ideas about anything that captures my curiosity. Most are flawed, some are useful(3V and diamonds), still others lead to patents. Given all the experimentation with knives, I wonder why it took so long to get a similar effort going with woodworking tools.

Re: An idea for improved plane iron durability

#25

How to decide which is valid in wood

Bill Tindall

We now have in hand , thanks to the efforts of people like Steve Elliot and Derek Cohen, dulling data on a number of steels at hand tool velocities. Furthermore, there is a huge body of practical data on wear while turning wood on a lathe. It is a straightforward matter to then correlate these data with the adhesive and abrasive wear properties of the steels they tested.

In the case of adhesive wear I gather that molecular forces yank material from one surface to the other? Is it likely that low strength wood would pull metal from high strength metal? We know wood has a mineral content. Is it not possible that this mineral content results in abrasive wear.