Re: Adhesive Wear
Larry Williams
All this newer stuff about wear is coming from surface engineering and research into things that have significant commercial applications. Woodworkers traditionally sharpen tools that would take tooling for woodworkers out of the realm of surface engineers. So I have never found anything that deals directly with woodworking edge tools.
In fact, I'm surprised at how much things have changed since I searched all this out a few years ago. A couple of my book marks are no longer valid and there isn't that much out there in the public domain.
Here's a quote from one of the remaining things:
Adhesive wear is generally the most important type of wear at all non-lubricated moving parts, or moving parts which operate at partly lubricated conditions. Coldwelding describes the formation of small connections whereby tiny disruptions arise during translation. These disruptions leave small malformations at the surface, called adhesive wear.
This is from a .pdf file at http://www.wmv.nl/4%20ADHESIVE%20WEAR.pdf
The web page that describes this is no longer at the book mark I had. I haven't had time to search for it. It was poorly translated but it did explain adhesive wear between tool steel and some plastics. You can see in this chart that both surfaces lose volume in adhesive wear but only one is measured.
One other that's still valid is very basic and is at:
http://www.gordonengland.co.uk/wear.htm
If you scroll down to the links at the bottom there are links to some information on different coatings but not much that's relevant.
Just the basic definitions, though, offer a lot:
Abrasive Wear -- Wear due to hard particles or hard protuberances forced against and moving along a solid surface.
Adhesive Wear -- Wear due to localised bonding between contacting solid surfaces leading to material transfer between the two surfaces or the loss from either surface.
If you dig into the nitride coatings used on metal working tooling, you'll find they're designed to resist adhesive wear. You can quickly verify this by sharpening a carbide insert. The coating will abrade away in a hurry.
Lubricants don't do a lot to inhibit abrasive wear, that's why oil stones cut just as well with oil as without. With abrasives one surface suffers all the volume loss. If you look at tooling coatings and the claims about how they work, it becomes pretty obvious that resisting abrasion isn't what they're about.
I hope this is somewhat coherent. I wrote part of it last night and finished this morning. It's still a little foggy between the ears here yet but I need to get back to work.