New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

Posts

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#26

Re: chisel wear hypothesis

Rob Lee

Hi Bill -

Once we're done with our testing, we'll get to publishing some results. We're just now hiring a Mech Eng student for the summer to complete some of our tribology work.

This is being supplemented with the possible acquisition of an electron microscope (show me another woodworking firm that has one!), to add a bit more capability to our $40K digital microscope we purchased to support our steel testing for chisels.

Primary private research is an intellectual property asset, so we do have to be selective about how much/what we reveal. The investment we make is staggering...

Then too - publishing means committing to answering the zillion questions and arguing in a dozen forums about interpretation.... :)

Cheers -

Rob

(on vacation for three weeks!!)

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#27

Re: A steel question....Thanks Wilbur

George in mosquito filled Lowell, Mich.

I have for years read about these "classifications" and wondered about quality and consistantcy. Thanks for the info. It sounded like it was up to the craftsman to make his alloy in the shop as he needed it.

George Allchin

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#28

Inappropriate chisel

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I hadn't bought a chisel for more than twenty years, but this morning I took a pleasant 3.6 mile drive to a flea market. After 48 minutes I was back home and the proud owner of an inappropriate, unavailable chisel. The cost was $15. I could have been home a lot sooner but I got sidetracked talking to a few interesting guys.

I could have bought an appropriate chisel. On the same table was a Stanley socket chisel with a maroon handle, but that cost $25. Or I could have driven to Woodcraft for a truly available chisel, but that was 45 minutes away.

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#29

Publishing means......

Bill Tindall

making data and methods available to a greater community for critique, confirmation and inspiration for improvement. This is how science has best worked since the Renaissance. If people didn't publish we would still be in the stone age.

The risk is aiding the competition. The benefit is fresh ideas from others, and the intangible benefit of enhancing reputation which helps marketing and recruiting.

The depth of field provided by a scanning electron microscope will make the pictures of edges we have today look like doodles. If the work is published in a technical journal I hope you will provide the citation on this Forum.

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#30

the second ref. answered the question, thanks

Bill Tindall

As far as you know, will a $20 Japanese chisel advertised as being fabricated from "white steel" indeed be the Hitachi "white paper grade" of steel, or has white and blue become generic terms like Kleenex?

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#31

Re: the second ref. answered the question, thanks

wilbur

As far as I know, yes. "White steel" or "blue steel" implies that the steel is sourced from Hitachi's Yasugi Works.

There are different varieties of these steels. There is white steel #1 and white steel #2. There is blue steel #1, blue steel #2, and super blue steel. There may be additional variations that I don't know about. White steel #1 has additional carbon compared to white steel #2, and blue steel #1 has additional carbon, tungsten, and chromium compared to blue steel #2. The really inexpensive Japanese chisels almost always are using white steel #2, as that seems to be the cheapest steel out of these varieties.

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#32

Re: the second ref. answered the question, thanks

Bruce, a MN Galoot

So how are we supposed to know what we have or what we're getting, Wilbur? Is a white steel chisel from Japan Tools the same as a white steel chisel from Hida Tools the same as a white steel chisel from Schtoo? Are they white steel 1 or white steel 2?

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#33

Re: the second ref. answered the question, thanks

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Of course not, there are all sorts of variations in manufacture. Maybe one maker lets the forged steel sit for a month whereas another might use a kiln to speed up the process. Maybe one does heat treating one way, another another.

My rule of thumb is to buy based on maker and more or less disregard the steel used. That means a bit of experimentation to determine which maker you like best, most of which can be avoided by finding a good vendor or three.

Pam

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#34

Re: the second ref. answered the question, thanks

wilbur

I completely agree with Pam.

Bottom line: there's a lot more going into a Japanese chisel than just the raw material. I bet the same holds for western chisels as well. Not all A2 chisels will be equal. It's sort of like choosing between a chair made from cherry by Mike Dunbar and a chair made from walnut by me, and being most concerned about the choice between walnut and cherry. ;)

Or I could pull out the Jacques Pepin chicken dish analogy again. ;)

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#35

It is more than 3.6 miles for me ....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

... Warren, probably closer to 10000 (or 16000 km), and the cost of this chisel, pleasant though the drive may be, would be around $2000. :)

We do plan a pleasant drive today, about 50 minutes into the Hills, meandering along farms and forests with the ragtop down, at the end of which will be a pleasant lunch with friends in a vineyard. I doubt that we will be thinking about, never mind find, any 19 century chisels. ;)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#37

Dang chickens! 

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#38

Amen to that

Bill Tindall

I have some experience with M2. The knife material from Wisconsin Tool works is awesome. I got some Chinese M2 and it is brittle as untempered carbon steel, with resulting chipping failures in tools.

That said, it is useful to know that material one is dealing with. The Hitachi data shows what the material is capable of, how it can be heat treated for this or that performance, etc.

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#39

Re: A visit to the Hitachi web site

Sam Takeuchi

Hi Bill. White and Blue steel are actually Hitachi brand of steels, not mumbo jumbo or mythical steels. There is nothing ambiguous or mythical about these steels as they are modern production steels made to set specifications just like any other tool steels. If a plane blade or chisels say White or Blue steel, I would think that would possibly be illegal or fraudulent as these terms don't have generic meaning, but mean very specific products.

The data you are looking for is available on the Hitachi site, however so far I could only find it one in Japanese, but I can provide you with info on what to look for.

Take a look at a file here: http://www.hitachi-metals.co.jp/pdf/cat/hy-b10-d.pdf

Go to page 4, there you will find a list. Steels are in this order:

White Steel No.1

White Steel No.2

White Steel No.3

White Steel Saw steel

Yellow Steel No.2

Blue Steel No.1

Blue Steel No.2

Blue Steel Super

KK (I have no idea what it is)

Below KK are stainless:

Silver 1

Silver 3

Silver 5

ATS34

ZDP189

Composition should be obvious. Data sheet includes annealing temperature, hardening temperature (water, oil or both specified also) and tempering temperature (air) and so on, plus what each steel is suitable for.

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#40

*correction*

Sam Takeuchi

Just correction to my previous post.

"If a plane blade or chisels say White or Blue steel, I would think that would possibly be illegal or fraudulent *to use anything other than Hitachi white or blue steel* as these terms don't have generic meaning"

I must've blown that chunk of sentence while backspacing something else.

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#41

thank you

Bill Tindall

After being chastised by Wilbur for being lazy in looking for these data on the sites he first provided I redoubled(actually more like 10X) my efforts and dead ended at this same site. It may be that if I contact one of the American distributors that I can obtain the English version but I was unable to find an English version of these data anywhere on the Hitashi site/catalog.

What remains unclear is the point you raised. Is the term "white steel" trade marked or can this name be used for generic version of Hitashi "white paper steel".

As best I can tell the Hitashi steel is priced substantially higher than something like 0-1. Hence it would be tempting for a company making $20 chisels to advertise white steel for a generic product if they could get away with it (or at least that would be the case in America!). On the other hand, if "white steel" is equivalent to a US trademark then Hitashi will defend this trademark with vengeance and no company would risk labeling a product white steel if it was not a Hitashi material.

BTW, I find Hitashi spelled with either an "s" or a "c'. Which is most correct?

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#42

Re: thank you

Sam Takeuchi

In Japan, the term White Paper, Blue Paper, Yellow Paper etc, are indeed registered trademarks of Hitachi, and I would believe Hitachi would rigorously defend their trademark if any other steel producers try to name their product the same or similar enough to be confused with Hitachi's. I don't think any self respecting blacksmith in Japan would use cheaper steel to save a few yens while advertising to use White or Blue steel. Besides legally and ethically no go, cheaper steels don't have the kind of characteristics associated with those higher quality steels (mass produced chisels and plane blades available at local home centers throughout Japan come with those mysterious steel. They are not bad, usable, but definitely don't sharpen nor wear like good steels, and I'm sure they behave differently in the forge as well. No one cares what kind of steel they are anyway). Other than those Hitachi steels and vintage steels, I've never seen any other producers' steel mentioned in woodworking tools. Maybe there are something else that are well known or famous, but at least I haven't seen it. On the other hand, Japanese knife makers (minus traditional kitchen/chef knife makers) are pretty open about variety of steels like knife makers elsewhere.

I have no idea what the tool steel pricing is like within Japan. As far as woodworking tools go, laminated construction is still the main stay of the WW tools, so compare to similarly sized O1 stock, those Hitachi steels may be more expensive, but the amount used in a similarly sized chisel is fraction of solid O1 chisel, that might offset the cost difference somewhat. I'm not a blacksmith, so I don't know exactly how that work out. Since there is only one source for those ~ paper steels, quality consistency of original stock should be very good. However as many people attest, there are quite quite a bit of variation in end products. That really depends on the smiths' skills and judgment. I have a feeling some smiths literally slapped those Blue and White steels onto so-so quality grade tools to piggy back on the reputation of these steels just to sell, and retailers across the Pacific went free-for-all by adding ambiguity and mysticism to these steels. I think those tools are the ones that earned ever so lasting impression that the Japanese tools are for softwood and prone to chipping, which is really unfortunate.

White and Blue steels are definitely not wonder edge steels, and they don't magically perform X times better than O1 or whatever other steels overseas. Nonetheless, when properly worked, these are very high quality and robust steels that sharpen, take and hold edge extremely well, and these have become the tried and tested trusty brand of steels people can safely rely on without too many surprises. Also I think fundamental difference between O1 and those Hitachi steels is that those White and Blue (and partially Yellow since only half of Yellow is iron sand) are made from iron sand, originally the same iron sand that was used to make tamagagane for centuries in Yasugi. I don't know if they are still using the same iron sand from the region though. I don't know how much difference that makes compare to a steel made from ore, but apparently it is a significant part of these steels' character. Parts of production of White and Blue steels (also Yellow) include modernized processes developed from tamahagane production that worked or was beneficial in modern steel production. So in short, these steels are indeed successor to the famous tamahagane that can be mass produced, controlled, consistent, and are extremely refined. In the end, they are designed and produced solely as high end cutting edge steels and not as general purpose cutting steels or anything else. For non cutting purposes, probably better and cheaper alternatives are available.

I don't know where I heard it from. Someone said some Japanese blacksmiths intentionally make their tools a bit softer for whatever reason. I don't know how true or why, it seems like there is some trend like that going on, but don't quote me on that.

Lastly Hitachi is spelled with "c".

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#44

Re: thank you

Schtoo

Hi Sam, and everyone else.

What Sam has written here is very true and accurate, and I can't improve on it myself, so I won't. What I can do is fill in some of the gaps and correct a few details.

White, blue and yellow 'steel' are trademarks of Hitachi steel, but they're also just designations of steel composition. I know of at least 2 other steel companies who have made steel designated and white steel, although they are no longer in existence and may have paid Hitachi for the rights to use the naming conventions. This is from over 30 years ago, and there's been a lot of absorbing of companies over this time, and it's not something I've looked into deeply as there's really no need.

The cost of white and blue steel? I'll be honest, it's cheap! Seriously "are you kidding me?" cheap. About US$4000 per metric ton. But that's a telling price, since the minimum order from Hitachi directly is one metric ton. Anyone can buy it (I've asked), but you then need to be able to process that much steel AND get it off the truck, and I've seen what a metric ton of cutlery steel looks like up close and personal. It's a LOT of steel. The other point is that you then need to process that much steel, and considering how much steel is actually in a simple chisel, you're looking at maybe $0.20 worth of hard steel in it, and a ton will make about 20,000 chisels.

You'll find that the makers are centralized in particular areas, now limited to Sanjyo in Niigata prefecture and Miki in Hyogo. One of the reasons is that they pool resources and buy up the minimum order and split it amongst themselves. Some of the bigger operations will order up a batch of steel for their own use and meter it out to the smaller makers as they need it, with a small mark up.

No other maker's steel in tools? Google 'Tsunesaburo plane'. Third listing. #1 and #2 and #3 are my own site. #3 explains the different steels Tsunesaburo offers, 7 of them not made by Hitachi. All offer something different in a blade, and the differences are generally described there. The information is translated from the Japanese only, not my own experience. Some makers are offering different steels than the traditional white and blue, typically high speed steels but Swedish carbon steel is quite popular as well.

The 'brittle' thing. Darned annoying, and hard to erase. Simple explanation is as Sam said, who and how they made the tool. Poorly made, white steel is like glass. Well made, it's tough and durable. Backing off the hardness a little will return some of the toughness to the finished tool but at the expense of a long lasting edge and a 'proper' tool needs no such help to be tough and durable.

I was of the same thinking myself (brittle, fragile), until I got some good tools of my own, and good gad they're tough. I've actually been chastised by Mr. Koyama(ichi) for not having enough faith in his chisels...

(But he still fed me lunch anyway. :) )

There's pretty much 4 different ways Japanese tools are made.

#1, properly and traditionally. Example; Koyamaichi.

#2, properly using modern technology. Example; Tsunesaburo.

#3, a nodding acknowledgement of 'properly' but something is missing. I refuse to offer an example here, although there are many.

#4, simple and quick, just a tool. Example; the VERY cheap laminated Japanese chisels.

#1 and #2 are 'the good stuff'.

#3 resembles the good stuff, and very often does a good impersonation of it. When pushed too hard, that 'lacking' shows up in one form or another.

#4 are tools made to a price. Occasionally you'll get lucky, sometimes not.

And again, Sam is right. White and blue steel are not magical, but they are highly refined. Back to tamahagane (sword steel) that was refined by hand in a fire where all the impurities were burned out, white steel is a modern, mass produced interpretation of it. In O1, different things were added to the steel to improve durability, toughness and edge taking/holding. In white steel, instead of adding elements to improve the qualities, those elements present that detracted from the steel were removed. Blue steel has chrome and tungsten to make it a little tougher, but mostly to improve edge life due to it's improved abrasion resistance. Consider A2 to O1 for a similar difference, where A2 has improved abrasion resistance, but is otherwise not too dissimilar to O1.

One last thing, the makers themselves are on the whole, very nice, friendly people. Some are very much wrapped up in themselves, but the overwhelming majority are genuine and warm, and will go to great lengths to help you understand what's going on. There are few secrets, it's just that the language barrier gets in the way and sometimes, some of the traditional thoughts make information flow difficult at best. I find being up front breaks down the barriers VERY quickly most of the time, and the fact that I do poke my head in, shake hands and say hello is surprising to many here because it's simply 'not the done thing'.

Because I do know several makers and have talked with them at length about these steels (and many other things of course), I know there's nothing magical about them, but also know that if corners are cut, the tools won't be of good quality.

Which reminds me. I need to talk with someone on the weekend and see if I can't work out what's going on with their chisels. That's going to be painful, because like I said, most of them are really nice folk and me telling him his chisels are not up to snuff, I'm not looking forward to it at all. Being diplomatic is not my strong point...

I hope that all makes sense, and if not, I'll try and clear it up if I can. I don't know everything, but I'm lucky in that I can ask the source if I need to. Usually over lunch. ;)

All I can really ask is that folks open their mind a little to Japanese tools, and understand what they are and how they work. Myself, I don't see them as a cure all, but merely another arrow in my quiver to get the job done.

And they do get the job done, more often than most think. :)

Stu.

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#45

Re: thank you

Sam Takeuchi

Ah you are absolutely right. I've forgotten about those non Hitachi steel tools. Shame shame...

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#46

This has been a great discussion

Bill Tindall

What a treat to have such knowledgeable people available to share their knowledge to the "curious minds". Thanks to all.........

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#47

Re: Publishing means......

Rob Lee

Hi Bill,

In principle, I agree with you.

But when you pay the bill for the work .... Your perspective changes a tad....

Public sector R&D is one thing....the private sector needs some sort of return on the work, or it would never happen in the first place - especially in the market of today, where outsourcing is rampant. Virtually every manufacturer faces global, not local, competition...and the IP is critical for competition.

When we're done, we'll publish some of it for sure..we've been very free with this type of information in the past. Not all of it is academic type work though....much it could be called " decision support" activity...

Cheers -

Rob

(in Harrisonburg VA)