Re: thank you
Schtoo
Hi Sam, and everyone else.
What Sam has written here is very true and accurate, and I can't improve on it myself, so I won't. What I can do is fill in some of the gaps and correct a few details.
White, blue and yellow 'steel' are trademarks of Hitachi steel, but they're also just designations of steel composition. I know of at least 2 other steel companies who have made steel designated and white steel, although they are no longer in existence and may have paid Hitachi for the rights to use the naming conventions. This is from over 30 years ago, and there's been a lot of absorbing of companies over this time, and it's not something I've looked into deeply as there's really no need.
The cost of white and blue steel? I'll be honest, it's cheap! Seriously "are you kidding me?" cheap. About US$4000 per metric ton. But that's a telling price, since the minimum order from Hitachi directly is one metric ton. Anyone can buy it (I've asked), but you then need to be able to process that much steel AND get it off the truck, and I've seen what a metric ton of cutlery steel looks like up close and personal. It's a LOT of steel. The other point is that you then need to process that much steel, and considering how much steel is actually in a simple chisel, you're looking at maybe $0.20 worth of hard steel in it, and a ton will make about 20,000 chisels.
You'll find that the makers are centralized in particular areas, now limited to Sanjyo in Niigata prefecture and Miki in Hyogo. One of the reasons is that they pool resources and buy up the minimum order and split it amongst themselves. Some of the bigger operations will order up a batch of steel for their own use and meter it out to the smaller makers as they need it, with a small mark up.
No other maker's steel in tools? Google 'Tsunesaburo plane'. Third listing. #1 and #2 and #3 are my own site. #3 explains the different steels Tsunesaburo offers, 7 of them not made by Hitachi. All offer something different in a blade, and the differences are generally described there. The information is translated from the Japanese only, not my own experience. Some makers are offering different steels than the traditional white and blue, typically high speed steels but Swedish carbon steel is quite popular as well.
The 'brittle' thing. Darned annoying, and hard to erase. Simple explanation is as Sam said, who and how they made the tool. Poorly made, white steel is like glass. Well made, it's tough and durable. Backing off the hardness a little will return some of the toughness to the finished tool but at the expense of a long lasting edge and a 'proper' tool needs no such help to be tough and durable.
I was of the same thinking myself (brittle, fragile), until I got some good tools of my own, and good gad they're tough. I've actually been chastised by Mr. Koyama(ichi) for not having enough faith in his chisels...
(But he still fed me lunch anyway.
)
There's pretty much 4 different ways Japanese tools are made.
#1, properly and traditionally. Example; Koyamaichi.
#2, properly using modern technology. Example; Tsunesaburo.
#3, a nodding acknowledgement of 'properly' but something is missing. I refuse to offer an example here, although there are many.
#4, simple and quick, just a tool. Example; the VERY cheap laminated Japanese chisels.
#1 and #2 are 'the good stuff'.
#3 resembles the good stuff, and very often does a good impersonation of it. When pushed too hard, that 'lacking' shows up in one form or another.
#4 are tools made to a price. Occasionally you'll get lucky, sometimes not.
And again, Sam is right. White and blue steel are not magical, but they are highly refined. Back to tamahagane (sword steel) that was refined by hand in a fire where all the impurities were burned out, white steel is a modern, mass produced interpretation of it. In O1, different things were added to the steel to improve durability, toughness and edge taking/holding. In white steel, instead of adding elements to improve the qualities, those elements present that detracted from the steel were removed. Blue steel has chrome and tungsten to make it a little tougher, but mostly to improve edge life due to it's improved abrasion resistance. Consider A2 to O1 for a similar difference, where A2 has improved abrasion resistance, but is otherwise not too dissimilar to O1.
One last thing, the makers themselves are on the whole, very nice, friendly people. Some are very much wrapped up in themselves, but the overwhelming majority are genuine and warm, and will go to great lengths to help you understand what's going on. There are few secrets, it's just that the language barrier gets in the way and sometimes, some of the traditional thoughts make information flow difficult at best. I find being up front breaks down the barriers VERY quickly most of the time, and the fact that I do poke my head in, shake hands and say hello is surprising to many here because it's simply 'not the done thing'.
Because I do know several makers and have talked with them at length about these steels (and many other things of course), I know there's nothing magical about them, but also know that if corners are cut, the tools won't be of good quality.
Which reminds me. I need to talk with someone on the weekend and see if I can't work out what's going on with their chisels. That's going to be painful, because like I said, most of them are really nice folk and me telling him his chisels are not up to snuff, I'm not looking forward to it at all. Being diplomatic is not my strong point...
I hope that all makes sense, and if not, I'll try and clear it up if I can. I don't know everything, but I'm lucky in that I can ask the source if I need to. Usually over lunch. 
All I can really ask is that folks open their mind a little to Japanese tools, and understand what they are and how they work. Myself, I don't see them as a cure all, but merely another arrow in my quiver to get the job done.
And they do get the job done, more often than most think. 
Stu.