New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

Posts

Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#1

Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

Steve Elliott

The recent post by Derek Cohen motivated me to try a quick test of my own comparing the performance of different tool steels used for chopping end grain. My first question was what bevel angle to use and so far that's as far as I've gotten. Instead of waiting to post the complete test, I'd like to start with what I've found out about bevel angles.

The image below shows the cutting edges of plane blades used to take a slice off a piece of hard maple 1" thick and 1-11/16" wide. Cutting was done across the width of the maple so that only 1� of the blade edge was being used. All slices were just over 1/64" thick. My original attempt at taking slices 3/64" thick made me whack so hard that I'd never make such a cut in practice.

The two blades used were a William Marples laminated blade, high carbon steel forge welded to a soft steel back like a Japanese blade, and a CPM 3V blade hardened to Rc 61. The Marples blade is typical of the older plane blades I've used and has shown good edge retention in planing. The 3V blade has shown better edge retention than any carbon steel blade I've used for planing.

Both blades performed better with a microbevel in the range of 34-35 degrees. The mode of edge failure was deformation and a "cresting wave" shape at the edge was typical. The main bevel on both blades was 25 degrees. The narrowest microbevel was about .008" and in this test of just one slice the amount of edge degradation never exceeded .001".

In an upcoming test I will be comparing more types of steel and doing more of an endurance test to see how long the edges remain useful for actual woodworking. For now I think what I�ve learned about bevel angles might be interesting. It�s not a surprising result considering the traditional recommendation for mortise chisel sharpening, but the microscope images convinced me not to try more acute angles even in exotic alloys.


Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#2

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Steve,

My impression from the pictures is that both steels failed at parallel rates and in parallel ways - is that a correct impression?

As an amateur user working mainly friendly woods, I've been watching these discussions with interest. The recent tests leave me feeling more comfortable with my instinct, which was to hold on to the kit of tools I've developed over the years; it seems they'll work adequately, unless Derek Cohen starts sending me some of the sandpaper and iron compounds referred to as wood in Oz.

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#3

Hold on to your chisels

Steve Elliott

Bill,

While this preliminary test wasn't closely enough controlled to answer your question for sure, my impression is that traditional carbon steel is a very good choice for mortising chisels. Since the edge degradation was due to deformation rather than wear or chipping I'd like to try some harder carbon steel (and maybe harder blades of other alloys) to see if they hold up better, but there's every reason for you to hold on to your current tools.

In this first test the 3V did seem to work somewhat better at the more acute angles. I was hoping an increased bevel angle would eliminate deformation but so far I�ve gone to 36 degrees and the deformation hasn�t gone away.

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#4

suggestion, question

Bill Tindall

One of the valuable responses measured by Derek was the paring test. Your stunning pictures (if you haven't tried to get pictures of an edge you may not appreciate how stunning they are) quantitatively compare results, but the comparison- microns of deformation- is an abstract metric to most folks. While a deformation of 0.00X" may look alarming at 500X, perhaps the edge still will pare end grain, a common standard of sharpness among us.

From my experience, these edges are still very sharp in the context of chopping to the scribe line of a dovetail. My edges are clearly deformed at 10X magnification and one can feel the rolled edge before it is necessary to resharpen for this task. However, this point is well past sharpness for successful paring. Since dovetail preparation is a combination of "chopping" and paring, something most do with the same chisel, it is desirable for the edge to hold up and perform both tasks well.

To put your results in context many can relate to, can you try paring after chopping in some of these experiments?

Can you detect an obvious difference in force to penetrate in going from a micro-bevel of 30 to 34 degrees, or among any bevel angle changes?

Good work.....carry on.

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#5

Good points, Bill

Steve Elliott

I have some soft pine and will include paring pine endgrain in my further tests. I forgot to mention that the edges at 35 degrees would still pare maple endgrain quite well (a less stringent test, but useful for dovetailing) and that I was just barely able to detect a "wire edge" with my fingernail after chopping one slice at 35 degrees, on both blades tested.

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#6

Excellent Steve!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Steve, those images are simply amazing! What camera/machine/resolution are you using? I am sure that mine could be improved a whole lot with better lighting, but still would not get close to the detail you have achieved. Amazing.

So far your results are paralleling mine, which is a relief (although it should be anticipated).

There are inconsistencies in my results that I am trying to resolve. Such as my longstanding experience of Japanese chisels holding an edge well beyond that of Western O1 steel. In the chopping/impact test the Koyamaichi held up so well, really well. Yet in the paring/abrasion test it started well then faded badly. Of course, not all Japanese steels are the same. However it raises the question whether there is a difference in constructon/treatment for paring versus bench chisels?

The same may be said of the PM steels. Perhaps they could get sharper than I managed in the paring test. What this suggests is that they actually were more durable than the results indicate. That is, they held a almost-sharp edge all the way through and could have continued this way a while longer (while the other steels had reached the end of the road).

It is good to get as many testing along these lines as possible since it is not reasonable for one person to do extensive testing (I do not have the time and it is not the priority in the time I have in the workshop), plus there are many variations within one steel such that it is also not reasonable to generalise too much from one set of results.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#7

chisel wear hypothesis

Bill Tindall

The results to date are consistent with this hypothesis: because of the way chisels are used chisels don't get dull by abrasive wear. Rather they get dull by micro deformations and/or chipping at the edge.

Supporting data: It has been found in both Steve and Derek's work that it takes hundreds of feet of planing for an edge to get dull by abrasion. We know from experience that chisels get dull long before they experience even tens of feet of penetration into wood.

In the planing tests the results correlated with the know abrasion resistance of the metals tested.

In the chopping tests, the results correlated with the hardness of the metals. (all the test metals were tough enough to not chip)

The performance of the Japanese chisel is easily explained by this hypothesis. It did best in chopping and in practice using it because it is both hard and tough, attributes that would predict chisel performance. It did worst in planing because it is the worst for wear (didn't really anticipate that pun!).

I wish a glimmer of light would shine into the dark corners of Lee Valley research and we could see what they think about these results. It is hard to see why their results are not shared. I can't imagine that anyone doing research in these matters hasn't benefited greatly from the pioneering work of Beech, Elliot and now Cohen who have published their results, at least on Forums. Science progresses best when results and methods are shared by all.

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#9

Re: chisel wear hypothesis

Schtoo

The performance of the Japanese chisel is easily explained by this hypothesis. It did best in chopping and in practice using it because it is both hard and tough, attributes that would predict chisel performance. It did worst in planing because it is the worst for wear (didn't really anticipate that pun!).

Yep, no doubt.

When the abrasive wear is lower, then white steel does respectably in a plane. There are other factors involved that I won't go into though.

However, one of the plane makers whose wares I sell (I sell Japanese tools, and am the 'Stu' in Derek's testing write ups), and are one of, if not the most prolific plane makers in Japan, do not make a white steel plane. They're all either blue steel or other specialist steels specific to the planer's desires.

(Blue steel is, functionally speaking, O1 cranked to 11, maybe more. Then cleaned to be a better steel rather than adding stuff to improve it.)

Already mentioned to Derek that you cannot cover every eventuality. I'm just glad Derek is using GOOD white steel rather than some chisel made with 'white steel'. How it's treated when made into a tool makes a huge difference. It can be good, ok or terrible and all three extremes come from the exact same raw ingredients.

At least with something like a solid chunk of O1, you can't easily and completely make a hash of it. I know, I've tried and have enough annealed O1 left to try many more times.

Stu.

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#10

Re: chisel wear hypothesis

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I'm just glad Derek is using GOOD white steel rather than some chisel made with 'white steel'. How it's treated when made into a tool makes a huge difference. It can be good, ok or terrible and all three extremes come from the exact same raw ingredients.

It is interesting that you say this, Schtoo, because my reaction to the Stanley 750 chisel was that it was a rather junky choice for comparison. In the dark ages of handtool use, in the 1953 Stanley catalog, the 750 chisel had the lowest price of seven models. I always thought it was marketed to the handyman. Derek called it W-1 last week, now O-1; I wonder where this information comes from. Even if it is O-1 that does not imply an exact composition. And who knows what the heat treating was?

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#11

hypotheses are for challenging

Bill Tindall

Hypotheses are something to be challenged with data. We keep them around so long as they stand up to the challenges. Folklore, is what we accommodate and live with.

I am really impressed with the progress that has been made by you and others in getting at the fundamentals of hand tool performance. It was not long ago that the very notion of investigating the variables affecting hand tool performance was scorned.

There is not a single M4 knife available in the Smoky Mountain Knife Store (huge knife distributor and retailer near here). On the other hand there aren't many carbon steel knives either. Through the efforts of persons willing to try new stuff, and share the results, various grades of stainless steel have become the preferred practical knife steel. Boutique knife makers make M4 knives for high performance applications. Traditionalists pound them out of Chevy leaf springs. Research into steel and fabrication has led to this diversity and made available knives best suited for various tasks and personalities. I predict steel for hand tools will eventually follow this same path, however slower than I would hope, mainly due to the difficulty of reliably measuring performance. It is not surprising that knife makers like John are among the pioneers.

Knife makers may have benefited from contests. Contests revealed the best steel and fabrication for whatever was being tested in the contest. Maybe we need a dovetail contest. Participants would be timed chopping some number of dovetail joints using only two chisels and a saw. We would soon learn what chisel was best for this task.

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#12

interesting......

Bill Tindall

In your hands what have you found to be better of the traditional chisels?

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#13

Re: chisel wear hypothesis

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

my reaction to the Stanley 750 chisel was that it was a rather junky choice for comparison

Warren

I have owned and used a number of the high-rep American chisels. These include two sets of Witherbys, the first sold because the steel kept folding on me. I have had a set of near-original condition Bergs, which were collected over a period of years.

None of these chisels were as good as the Stanley set I have put together. The 3/4" Stanley 750 I included in the test is an excellent chisel.

In my admittedly limited experience steel is variable. Sometimes you are lucky and sometimes not. I imagine that not much has changed over the past few hundred years.

W1 or O1? I called the 750 W1 because I assumed it to be water hardening. A few corrected on the forum me, stating it was O1. Do you have an opinon?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#14

Re: interesting......

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I would think any of the 19th century English tools would be worth a look. Cam and Butcher are two that were widely sold in the United States. They sharpen like a dream and have a nice edge. If you look at Stanley advertisements from the 1950's you see guys chiseling construction lumber, not drawer fronts. Many guys back then thought chisels were for removing putty from old windows.

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#15

Microscope used to make edge images

Steve Elliott

The edge images were made using a small digital inspection microscope (the View Solutions GE-5) which gives a 60x image. I'm using a 9x Barlow lens that increases the magnification to 540x. My original images were 1280 x 1024 pixels and were cropped, then reduced to half size to make the composite image I posted. The larger resolution doesn't have much additional detail�the digital resolution is greater than the optical resolution.

For lighting I have two white LEDs shining in from the sides which provide most of the light on the microbevel, plus another white LED that shines in from the back and helps light the main 25 degree bevel. Opposite the worn edge is an amber LED that brings out flaws in a freshly honed edge and helps to light the wear surface or wire edge on a used edge.

I thought I had a picture of the whole setup but I haven't been able to find it.

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#16

Re: chisel wear hypothesis

David Weaver

I don't have that many chisels either, but I do have new, japanese, old domestic, really old domestic and really old english.

I have found the stanley 750s to be on par with the 19th century chisels for the edge they take and the retention of the edge. None of my 750s are from the 1950s, as far as I know, but it is difficult to tell - maybe some are later ones and I don't know it (i'm including the longer chisels that probably are referred to as 720s).

I am not sharpening with oil stones, but with ceramics, and that might be why I don't notice any difference in the edge with either stone. with a 1 micron shapton, the wire edge is pretty well long gone without any stropping for anything that is O1 or less wear resistant.

I have also seen chisels, as derek is referring to, that we tested to be in the low 50s hardness (also a witherby, but a later one), and they could not hold an edge below 30-35 degrees, and even at that, it wasn't a durable edge, it was just blunt enough to avoid rolling over immediately. I have an earlier witherby and it's similar in feel and durability to the stanley chisels.

If I had to guess, I would assume chisels of that time were oil hardening steel, but that's just a guess. I've blunted a few to a 90 degree edge and hardened them without tempering to use as bed scrapers for making planes and for bedding irons in japanese planes. They are difficult to sharpen without power sharpening tools or diamonds (so they are very hard). I would assume if they were water hardening, they wouldn't get to that level of hardness with a torch and a quench. I have not specifically done stanleys, but a dunlap and a rockford forge come out like that. I targeted them because both were a little soft and weren't going to be used otherwise.

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#17

Well now......

Bill Tindall

You are being a bit unkind to the carpenters of that day. My uncle was a finish carpenter in the 50's. One of my fond memories was watching him chisel out hinge and lock mortises with his Stanley chisels, as well as planing a door to fit. He hung doors, installed molding, and even built cabinetry in place on the jobs. I was occasionally his goofer.

I never knew him to own a router; they may not have been invented yet. No idea what happened to his tool chest, but I wish I had it.

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#18

Re: chisel wear hypothesis

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

So that's why Koyamaichi uses only blue steel in his thin/ultrathin chisels?

Pam

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#19

Re: interesting......

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I would think any of the 19th century English tools would be worth a look.

Warren

I do not consider this appropriate in the context of the current research. In contrast to the steels used in these tests, the chisels you select are not freely/easily available in an original state condition that would allow results to be generalisable. Yes, the steel may be good (I believe you and others who rave about them), but I doubt that they will be made again. Consequently they are of esoteric interest only.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#20

Re: A steel question....

George in mosquito filled Lowell, Mich.

Being a "metal head" and a machinist for atleast 35 years, the question that comes to my mind is .....

What is white and blue steel? I have grown up with O1, S7, A2, O2 D2 W1 and now the compressed powdered metals etc. Is there a comparable alloy to this "white & blue" steel. Having been through Bethleham Steel in fun filled Gary Ind. I watched steel be made from pellets to be the white hot slabs 1 1/2' X 8' X 20'. Is Japanese steel made in the laboratory conditions that we in the US do? If not how can they even be in the competition?

I guess I got into a "rant", but the question still needs an answer.

George

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#21

Re: A steel question.... *LINK*

wilbur

Both white and blue steels are made by Hitachi (http://www.hitachi-metals.co.jp), so that should satisfy the concerns about whether the people making these steels know what they are doing. White steel is a high carbon steel, and blue steel is white steel with some added chromium and tungsten.

The "white" and "blue" labels just comes from the packaging. White steel is wrapped in white paper, and blue steel is wrapped in blue paper, sort of like how the cold rolled angle iron at the borg is painted a certain color on the end to distinguish it from hot rolled steel, which is painted a different color.

I have a more detailed write up on my blog, linked below.


White steel and blue steel

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#22

Re: Microscope used to make edge images

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks Steve

I tried again with mine using more light. A little better but not a real significant difference. I think that the set up,itself, needs redesigning. I will try one based on yours. I am using the QX5 (up from a QX3).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#24

A visit to the Hitachi web site

Bill Tindall

It looks just like a typical metals supplier web site, at least once one finds the English version. Products have names created from a few letters and numbers (like CPM 3V), and there are data on composition, performance characteristics, heat treat data, etc. It is a great web site, with comprehensive information. And if a Japanese tool maker revealed what material they were in fact using one could compare the properties of this metal to that used in western tools.

No where to be found is "white" or "blue". One is left to wonder if this white and blue stuff is another part of the mumbo-jumbo of Japanese tool making. One could suspect that "white steel" is the generic name Japanese woodworking tool makers use for carbon steel of some variety and blue the generic name for what we would call tool steel. Of course white and blue is no less useless than the larger western tool makers that don't reveal anything about the steel product they use. (I was told by a US steel supplier that S7 was used in chisels but I have never seen this alloy name come up in any discussion). As consumers have become more knowledgeable knife makers are revealing the metal they use by stamping it on the blade, and personally I use this information to make my knife purchases. One could hope woodworking tool supplies arrive at this state.

The bottom line seems to be that we really don't know what product, or even if it is a Hitachi product, in the tool.

Re: Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles

#25

Re: A visit to the Hitachi web site

wilbur

"One is left to wonder if this white and blue stuff is another part of the mumbo-jumbo of Japanese tool making."

Oh, come on, Bill. Why is it that whenever information is difficult to find, it's automatically Japanese mumbo-jumbo, as opposed to just not being posted on the internet? Just to add to the mumbo-jumbo, there's also yellow steel that's used in Japanese saws, that comes from the factory wrapped in -- you guessed it -- yellow paper.

There's really no mumbo-jumbo here. These are the common terms used to describe this particular set of tool steels. The production of white and blue steels is only a small part of Hitachi's output. As a supplier of tool steel, Hitachi's customer base includes major manufacturers, including the auto industry. All the Japanese woodworking tool makers put together would be a very small fraction of the rest of their customer base.

There is a special manufacturing section of Hitachi that makes the white and blue steel used in Japanese tools, called the Yasugi Works. http://www.hitachi-metals.co.jp/e/corp/corp07/s_yasu.html

There's some more technical information about these steels at the DICK GmbH website, which is a German woodworking tool retailer that carries Japanese tools. http://www.mehr-als-werkzeug.de/medias/sys_master/124_01_M_WE_D_en.pdf

Hope that clears up some of the mumbo-jumbo.