Mortise Chisel Bevel Angles
Steve Elliott
The recent post by Derek Cohen motivated me to try a quick test of my own comparing the performance of different tool steels used for chopping end grain. My first question was what bevel angle to use and so far that's as far as I've gotten. Instead of waiting to post the complete test, I'd like to start with what I've found out about bevel angles.
The image below shows the cutting edges of plane blades used to take a slice off a piece of hard maple 1" thick and 1-11/16" wide. Cutting was done across the width of the maple so that only 1� of the blade edge was being used. All slices were just over 1/64" thick. My original attempt at taking slices 3/64" thick made me whack so hard that I'd never make such a cut in practice.
The two blades used were a William Marples laminated blade, high carbon steel forge welded to a soft steel back like a Japanese blade, and a CPM 3V blade hardened to Rc 61. The Marples blade is typical of the older plane blades I've used and has shown good edge retention in planing. The 3V blade has shown better edge retention than any carbon steel blade I've used for planing.
Both blades performed better with a microbevel in the range of 34-35 degrees. The mode of edge failure was deformation and a "cresting wave" shape at the edge was typical. The main bevel on both blades was 25 degrees. The narrowest microbevel was about .008" and in this test of just one slice the amount of edge degradation never exceeded .001".
In an upcoming test I will be comparing more types of steel and doing more of an endurance test to see how long the edges remain useful for actual woodworking. For now I think what I�ve learned about bevel angles might be interesting. It�s not a surprising result considering the traditional recommendation for mortise chisel sharpening, but the microscope images convinced me not to try more acute angles even in exotic alloys.




