Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels
John Payne
Will try to answer several questions here. First, why did I do this. Probably the same reasons you did. Curiosity and I am also cheap. As for background on me. Grew up working with metal. My father owned a body shop and I grew up working in it. So grinding, shaping, welding, sanding. etc was something I did since I can remeber. Woodworking was not a part of that, my father hated it, although he did when he had to. I'll never forget what he said about woodworking, "I hate this stuff, if you cut off too much you can't weld it back on". Amazing how some things stick in your mind. Anyway, with this back ground I've been comfortable with metal for a long time. Started making knives out of leaf springs and grinding them on a bench grinder and I was hooked, that was 39 years ago.Since then I've been making and selling knives at various times depending on what was going on in my life. There are some big gaps there as when I was in the military and moving and building houses. Right now I'm kind of out of the knife stuff, but still make a few for people.
Woodworking - Got into it when my new wife told me she was into riding horses and I saw what a tack trunk cost. I was shocked and told her that I could build a much better one for less and did. That started a business that lasted many years with me building them for a large tack supply company here. All of that work was powered stuff. It ended with the birth of my daughter and us builind a new home, everything went into storage for a couple years and I never got back into it. Getting into the handtool stuff was kind of an odd thing. My daughter wanted a certain toy that was made of wood and I was too cheap to buy it. Was having a hard time figuring out how to make it when my father(who hated working with wood) just said, "come one, glue up several pieces of wood and shape just like we did with with fenders and such, wood is soft, will be a piece of cake." That got me into using chisels, rasps, etc. and I've been using them since. There are just some things that you can do better by hand, some you can't.
New steels - as Derek said with me working in the knife and woodworking side I was curious why the wood side was using these "old" steels. On the knife side they had been surpassed a long time ago by newer steels. So I set up a test in woody's using O1, A2, D2, and AST34. The results were as I expected(non scientific), ranking them D2,ATS34,A2, and O1. Not a lot of fanfare after that test. When I got on woodnet I noticed Derek did a lot of testing so I contacted him about doing some tests with various steels. He was up for it so this started at least 2 years ago. This would have happened quicker, but unfortunately I hit that time in life when stuff happens so the past 2 years have been consumed with family issues, I'll leave it at that. I'm now just getting back to semi normal. On the chisel side, a guy know as EODdave(Dave Diaman) put up a post that he wanted a chisel this size that would hold an edge and couldn't find one. I contacted him about me making one and that's how this got started. I research the CPM steels quite a bit and was surprised that this had been done before with very good results, but kind of ended there. So even though they had been used before, we pressed on with great results. So here we are.
As far as a toolmaker - I do sell these but not on a production basis, can't with the family issues but as they are cleared up I will produce quite a bit more if people want them.
Hope this fills in a few squares, if you have questions, please ask.
John