New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

Posts

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#26

The point is ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

All true Bill. I use M2 chisels for my lathe work. Grinding HSS is far less stressful than O1 and, especially, A2 since both of these are easily harmed by too much heat (at least O1 is easy to re-harden in the average workshop. A2 is not).

This advantage of HSS, and thus the PM steels, is not as obvious to the average woodworker who does not use a lathe. The forums are filled with comments about the relative difficulty in honing A2 steel! Good Grief, if A2 is considered a chore, then what do you imagine these people will think of PM steels?! This is the reason I included the comments on grinding and honing - to de-stress those who may fear working with these steels. It is not new information to you, but likely to be for others.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#28

Agree.... with an additional comment

Bill Tindall

"With regard the Real World methodology, in your argument having production woodworkers use the chisels ... Well all I can say is that this is impractical (at best) and likely to lead to unreliable data collection. One needs reproducibility - that is one criterion for scientific research from which one may generalise results."

I agree entirely with your statement. What I did not make clear is what comes next.....beta testing and these data are already out there according to the chisel maker. But we don't have it.

After "lab testing" of a product shows promise, the next step is beta testing where the product gets in the hands of experienced users. The chisel maker named two people using PM steel chisels. Their web sites would indicate they have experience making stuff where a chisel is a key tool in the construction process(Period Furniture). While we all might not make Period Furniture the unit operations in its construction are the foundation of much fine furniture construction. Your data, Steve's data, and my impressions show these steels have promise. Now I would like to see what these, or some other, pros think of it. Perhaps you can get John to get them to post their impressions here.

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#29

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

Charles Stanford

Thank God for the sanity check provided by your post.

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#30

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

Charles Stanford

Ding, ding, another winner!

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#31

Re: I think that you'll find ...

Phil Smith

Thanks for pointing out my mistake. I missed the diamond honing in the link.

Can you comment on your experience with 0.5 micron diamond paste for the final hone. I have had only marginal success using 0.5 micron diamond on M4. My typical procedure is to hollow grind the bevel on 7 in grinder, then sharpen on fine fixed diamond plate, till I get a uniform wire edge on the plane iron and then hone with 1 micron diamond powder on cast iron plate. If I go directly from the fine fixed diamond plate to 0.5 micron on cast iron the process is very slow and do not seem to get as sharp on edge.

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#32

Re: I think that you'll find ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Can you comment on your experience with 0.5 micron diamond paste for the final hone. I have had only marginal success using 0.5 micron diamond on M4. My typical procedure is to hollow grind the bevel on 7 in grinder, then sharpen on fine fixed diamond plate, till I get a uniform wire edge on the plane iron and then hone with 1 micron diamond powder on cast iron plate. If I go directly from the fine fixed diamond plate to 0.5 micron on cast iron the process is very slow and do not seem to get as sharp on edge.

Hi Phil

Your 7" grinder sounds like a Baldor .. ?

I have no difficulty using and getting the desired results with the 0.5 micron paste. The reason may be because I work through the grits differently to you.

If you are using a fixed diamond plate (such as a DMT), then it cannot be better than 1200 grit (extra fine). If you are using a fine DMT then this would be a 600 grit/20 microns.

My regime is 40 microns (to straighten the edge off a Tormek, which is 220 grit compared to the 45 grit of the Norton white wheel on my 8" dry grinder). The next plate is 10 micron diamond paste, and then to the 0.5 diamond paste.

I also think that the action of diamond paste on cast iron is likely to be different to loose diamonds. The loose diamonds may (?) not present a sharp edge to the steel as they roll. The paste beds diamond into the substratum, and this both secures it as well as ensures that the substratum is kept flat. Rolling loose grit may wear both substratum and the steel, and cause the substratum to dish.

I am sure that more experienced diamond users will comment on this.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#33

Re: I think that you'll find ...

Phil Smith

If you are using a fixed diamond plate (such as a DMT), then it cannot be better than 1200 grit (extra fine). If you are using a fine DMT then this would be a 600 grit/20 microns.


I am using a well used fixed DMT plate. Think it was extra fine when new but not sure. It's several years old.

My regime is 40 microns (to straighten the edge off a Tormek, which is 220 grit compared to the 45 grit of the Norton white wheel on my 8" dry grinder). The next plate is 10 micron diamond paste, and then to the 0.5 diamond paste.

Your results with the PM metals are consistent with the expected difficulty in sharpening and honing. My experience with M4 is that it is significantly more difficult to hone than 3V and I would expect 10V to be much harder still. I expect that you may have good success with the front bevel but getting the significantly larger area on the back to the same level of finish is much more difficult. When I polished the backs of the M4 plane irons I used the 30; 15; 3; 1 micron sequence and the time to polish was MUCH longer than required for the 3V. If you get any stray scratches from carry over diamond from the previous plate your stuck with going back and starting over. I am concerned that the step from 10 micron to 0.5 micron is too large, especially for the backs.

I also think that the action of diamond paste on cast iron is likely to be different to loose diamonds. The loose diamonds may (?) not present a sharp edge to the steel as they roll. The paste beds diamond into the substratum, and this both secures it as well as ensures that the substratum is kept flat. Rolling loose grit may wear both substratum and the steel, and cause the substratum to dish.



When I started using diamond for sharpening several years ago I made cast iron plates for 30; 15; 3; micron diamond using paste, and 1 micron using diamond powder. They all sharpen fast and effectively on most materials. I recently picked up some 0.5 micron paste and it simply does not make the black swarf that I see with the other plates. . Makes steel shiny but does not cut like the others. Current 1 micron cast iron lap still shows no sign of dishing

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#34

A little late to the party.

John Payne

Been in the air 7 out of the last 8 days. When I had a chance to respond it was by iPhone and that is not fun. Home for several days so will respond to several questions tomorrow. I'm just glad people are interested, I think it's a worthwhile test.

All the best,

John

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#35

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

John Payne

Will try to answer several questions here. First, why did I do this. Probably the same reasons you did. Curiosity and I am also cheap. As for background on me. Grew up working with metal. My father owned a body shop and I grew up working in it. So grinding, shaping, welding, sanding. etc was something I did since I can remeber. Woodworking was not a part of that, my father hated it, although he did when he had to. I'll never forget what he said about woodworking, "I hate this stuff, if you cut off too much you can't weld it back on". Amazing how some things stick in your mind. Anyway, with this back ground I've been comfortable with metal for a long time. Started making knives out of leaf springs and grinding them on a bench grinder and I was hooked, that was 39 years ago.Since then I've been making and selling knives at various times depending on what was going on in my life. There are some big gaps there as when I was in the military and moving and building houses. Right now I'm kind of out of the knife stuff, but still make a few for people.

Woodworking - Got into it when my new wife told me she was into riding horses and I saw what a tack trunk cost. I was shocked and told her that I could build a much better one for less and did. That started a business that lasted many years with me building them for a large tack supply company here. All of that work was powered stuff. It ended with the birth of my daughter and us builind a new home, everything went into storage for a couple years and I never got back into it. Getting into the handtool stuff was kind of an odd thing. My daughter wanted a certain toy that was made of wood and I was too cheap to buy it. Was having a hard time figuring out how to make it when my father(who hated working with wood) just said, "come one, glue up several pieces of wood and shape just like we did with with fenders and such, wood is soft, will be a piece of cake." That got me into using chisels, rasps, etc. and I've been using them since. There are just some things that you can do better by hand, some you can't.

New steels - as Derek said with me working in the knife and woodworking side I was curious why the wood side was using these "old" steels. On the knife side they had been surpassed a long time ago by newer steels. So I set up a test in woody's using O1, A2, D2, and AST34. The results were as I expected(non scientific), ranking them D2,ATS34,A2, and O1. Not a lot of fanfare after that test. When I got on woodnet I noticed Derek did a lot of testing so I contacted him about doing some tests with various steels. He was up for it so this started at least 2 years ago. This would have happened quicker, but unfortunately I hit that time in life when stuff happens so the past 2 years have been consumed with family issues, I'll leave it at that. I'm now just getting back to semi normal. On the chisel side, a guy know as EODdave(Dave Diaman) put up a post that he wanted a chisel this size that would hold an edge and couldn't find one. I contacted him about me making one and that's how this got started. I research the CPM steels quite a bit and was surprised that this had been done before with very good results, but kind of ended there. So even though they had been used before, we pressed on with great results. So here we are.

As far as a toolmaker - I do sell these but not on a production basis, can't with the family issues but as they are cleared up I will produce quite a bit more if people want them.

Hope this fills in a few squares, if you have questions, please ask.

John

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#36

Great story, and many thanks

Bill Tindall

So, what is the best way to contact you if one needs one of your handsome chisels?

Do you think you could get one of your 3V chisel customers to post here his impressions of its performance in building furniture (in a new thread)?

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#37

Re: Great story, and many thanks

John Payne

Bill

I know I didn't answer all the questions, a big one is why I passed the testing in wood on to others. I do make things out of wood but nowhere on the same level as EODdave. He produces world class stuff and at a rate I couldn't image, then again I've got 30 years on him. So, he was a perfect test guy who uses stuff day in and out. Dereck was perfect also as one who does the analytical tests. The results have been different, and I'm OK with that. Dave thinks there is nothing better, and Derek's results have shown it is good but not on another magnitude. I guess we'll see where this goes from here. The biggest supporters of the steel (not my chisel making) have been from people that use them to make a living. They all could afford whatever chisel they wanted, and they have chosen 3V. I'll do what I can to get them to post their opinions. Dave, probably, Chuck, maybe, and the other I doubt. But you would recognize the name.

Again, let me know if you have questions.

John

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#38

Re: Great story, and many thanks

John Payne

Forgot, and not familiar enough with this forum to know but jcpayne01@yahoo.com works around the world.

John

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#39

Re: Coating of a plane blade.....

George in mosquito filled Lowell, Mich.

We have2 coating companies competing for our business. I will ask them if they will do a free "favor " coat. I have 1 blade that I have made out of CPMM4 and a few made out of D2. These could be used in the test.

Work Safe

George

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#40

Re: Coating of a plane blade.....

Bill Tindall

The experiment would have to be as follows. Steve would need to measure the blade's performance before coating and retest after. Would be best to coat a blade Steve already has wear data on.