New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

Posts

Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#1

Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I have completed the second part of the chisel steel testing. This involves the durability of 6 steels when paring. The link below is to my website:

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/ChiselParing.html

I have also posted the first assessment, for reference. This dealt with the behaviour of 5 steels used to chop dovetails:

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/ChiselBladeTesting-5Steels.html

Looking forward to the discussion.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#2

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

joel moskowitz

An interesting test but when I was learning and doing serious work my paring chisels were (and still are) all honed at 25 or lower degrees (which was how I was taught) - the additional control the lower angles gave me were well worth the shorter blade life.

It is interesting that even at the higher angles the newer steels didn't blow away the traditional steels.

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#3

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Joel

The bevel angles were retained primarily to be able to directly compare their paring performance with their earlier chopping performance. Keep in mind that these are the recommended bevel angles for these steels. For example, A2 chisels are rarely used below 30 degrees. White steel laminated Japanese paring blades are used at 25 degrees (well my Kiyohisa are) compared to the 30 degrees used in this test. O1 is often used at 20 degrees for paring, but 25 degrees is acceptable (which was the angle used here).

And, no, the "new" steels did not blow away the "traditional" steels. Indeed!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#4

What a relief!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Now I know I don't have to dump my Berg chisels at garage sale prices. :D

This doesn't stop me lusting after a set of Blue Spruce, though.

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#5

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

joel moskowitz

Derek,

I understand why you did this but 30 degrees is a little arbitrary and for paring chisels the angle should be lower of you don't get the performance. All you are doing is testing how how chopping chisels pare.

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#6

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

Steve Elliott

Good work, Derek. Your first test got me to experimenting with bevel angles for chopping, using an old laminated carbon steel plane blade and a CPM 3V blade at Rc 61. So far I've found that increasing the bevel angle from 30 degrees to 35 degrees significantly increases performance when taking 1/64" slices off hard maple endgrain. The more acute edges show significant deformation under magnification--sort of a cresting wave look to the edge. I'll be posting detailed results later.

With your use of the plane with a 25 degree bed I'd guess that most of the blade wear is on the back, the way it is for plane blades. The width of the wear surface on the back corresponds pretty well to how the blade cuts (or doesn't cut).

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#7

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

Bill Tindall

I think the chisels were wear tested as plane irons, not paring chisels. The strong correlation of dulling with published abrasion resistance supports this notion. I think the dovetail "chopping" is a better test of paring performance than using the chisels to plane end grain, especially if the "chopping" involved forces not much larger than paring.

When I "chop" (I think this word may not be the most precise word to describe the procedure in dovetailing) the jackhammer taps of the mallet are more for control than to exert forces much greater than when I pare. As I considered it, dovetail waste removal is more akin to carving than deep mortise chopping.

Second, I question the fact that there is some such a metric as "recommended" bevel angles. If there is one thing we never agree on it is what bevel angle to sharpen anything. It was reported by your collaborator, for example, that one experienced woodworker used 3V chisels at 25 degrees and another 35. I use (arbitrarily) 27 and Steve is likely to recommend something over 30. The most one could hope to do is compare everything at the same angle, and then vary the angle as an additional variable.

The deflection forces in dovetailing will be directly proportional to the bevel angle (well actually a geometric (tangent) function of bevel angle. ). Keeping deflection under control is my main dovetailing challenge. I'm whacking them today so this topic is fresh on my mind. Deflection limits the chip size, thickness and depth, and threatens base line integrity.

The data I would want to base a metal decision on (the metal being of less importance than feel in the hand) is how low an angle can I successfully use the chisel at, presuming lower angle would provide ease of penetration. Hence, bevel angle would be the primary experimental variable tested with edge survival as a response.

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#8

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

With your use of the plane with a 25 degree bed I'd guess that most of the blade wear is on the back, the way it is for plane blades. The width of the wear surface on the back corresponds pretty well to how the blade cuts (or doesn't cut).

Hi Steve

Paring with a chisel has more in common with planing with a BU plane blade than a BD plane blade. Wear is therefore expected on the back of the blade. I am going gto try and re-do the photos there and see if more details can be extracted. More light may help.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#9

a comment on your conclusion

Bill Tindall

"their (the tool steels) performance was not far off the pace, and possibly close enough that many may question whether PM steels are enough ahead of the game to warrant their use".

If you are not making a new tool, it is reasonable to look at the data from the perspective of how much better is something new. For in this case it is a cost benefit analysis and "better" may indeed be judged not worth the price of changing. I certainly haven't junked any of my O-1 plane irons or chisels, for as you conclude, they work acceptably good.

However, that is not the point.......

I wish your collaborator had been introduced. Let me presume he at least enjoys making chisels or maybe even sells them. For him, or any maker of "home made" chisels, there is nothing in your data that would lead one to use anything except 3V or M4 for the task evaluated. Why wouldn't many, if not most, use the best performing material to make a tool? I have preached this point since we first made 3V and then M4 tools years ago. The tool steels are the logical choice. Over time our claims have been supported by experience and data.

Well in fact, if you get into making tools for enjoyment, for sale, or in my case you are too cheap to buy store bought ones, there are other very important factors besides how well they wear and sharpen. The tool steels are more expensive than O-1. M4 is more difficult to fabricate. However, 3V is easier to fabricate than O-1. It is nearly as easy to fabricate as cold rolled. It may well be that neither 3V or M4 can be forged into a socket chisel if that is essential. Etc. Some 3V was sent to the Blue Spruce person for chisel evaluation. If someone knows him see why he rejected it. There could be some useful data.

As far as sharpening, the immunity of the tool steels to loss of temper during grinding on an inexpensive grinding wheel could seem an advantage. Diamond sharpening gets treated as something too exotic to consider, even by people paying hundreds of dollars for a set of high performance water stores used after grinding on a water cooled Tormek wheel ($$$). A hundred dollar multitasker bench grinder, a $60 fixed diamond plate and $15 of diamond dust seems pedestrian by comparison.

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#10

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I think the chisels were wear tested as plane irons, not paring chisels......Second, I question the fact that there is some such a metric as "recommended" bevel angles....

Hi Bill

I noted to Steve (above) that paring is more akin to planing with a BU blade. I should add that it also involves deeper penetration, but this is progressive and lacks the impact of chopping. In other words, the focus is on abrasion resistance rather than impact resistance.

With regard the bevel angles, I agree that we vary these amongst ourselves. Still, there are angles presented as "guidelines" (if we would rather not use words like "rules"). As Joel noted earlier, paring tends to use lower angles than chopping (as the forces on the edge are different). Here I wanted to see how the steels reacted to a different demand. So the angles remained the same for comparison. How would all the steels react if we dropped the angle to 20 degrees? We should find out!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#11

The collaborator, if I'm not mistaken,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

is John Payne, an occasional poster hereabouts. I expect you'll hear from him shortly.

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#12

I think......

Bill Tindall

one could build furniture every day for a year and a chisel, only used for paring nearly parallel to the grain as in your planing test, would never experience the wear you observed. Of course in a practical situation the typical cabinet maker has one set of multitasking chisels that get used for whatever a chisel can do. At least this is the situation I see in professional and most amateur shops. I think it is all this other stuff that assaults the edge of a chisel. I know that is the case in my shop. Hence, it is your first test that is most relevant to a chisel used in a shop making stuff for profit, for example.

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#13

But...

Bill Tindall

it would be useful to know why he is making chisels out of high performance tool steels-curiosity, to cheap to buy some(my case), has a woodworking tool business, has data or experience that shows they are best, ??? What is his horse in this race?

From what he has done I'm impressed he has done his homework and knows his materials and processes. I'm guessing he is an experienced metal worker. Is he a woodworker. He deferred to others for woodworking experience with his tools. I wish they would post their experience with his tools. Testing is fine but he has tools in the hands of people making stuff. If experienced woodworkers prefer one of his chisel metals that would carry more weight than any testing that could be done. The best test is someone cranking out a sets of furniture they will be paid for, in typical furniture woods.

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#14

vist Steve Elliot's web site

Bill Tindall

You will see that with a quantitative measure of wear under carefully controlled conditions the more abrasion resistant tool steels do in fact stay sharp significantly longer. I have a 3V and an O1 plane iron for a favored plane. The 3V iron stays in it. Disclaimer: I plane till I can't push it or it won't pick up a shaving. I use a plane to remove wood, not produce a finish. Others may have differing results.

I think Derek;s test measures planing wear and he results correlate with abrasion resistance of the metal , except 10V which he never got sharp. The turners know this metal to be greatly more abrasion resistant. An acquaintance uses a similar metal for stone cutting tools (stone mason) .

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#15

Interesting but flawed test

Phil Smith

"Should the PM steel prove to have a significant advantage in edge-holding, the big issue with be in edge-taking. In other words, if these chisels require too great an effort to achieve a sharp edge, then they will not be worth serious consideration. One of the attractions of O1 and W1 steels is that they are easy to hone on basic media, such as oilstones, waterstones and sandpaper.

Allied to this is the ease or difficulty in grinding a primary bevel. The PM steels are rated highly for abrasion resistance, and this includes resistance to grinding wheels. We know that PM steels respond well to honing on diamond, but the question is whether they will work acceptably with the same equipment used for O1 and A2 steels.

"

The answer to this question is an emphatic NO. Based on my own experience with both 3V and M4 you cannot sharpen these steels with oilstones, waterstones or sandpaper or a wet grinder such as the Makita. You can rub M4 on an oil or water stone till the cows come home and still not have a sharp edge. Steve Elliot has quantitatively tested this and suggest you refer to his site for data.

"For this experiment I chose to use a Tormek wet grinder with its original 220 grit wheel. The advantage of this machine was that I could create a hollow grind with an accurate and repeatable primary bevel angle. "

Would expect this to give good starting bevel angle but you will need the much harder diamond to refine the edge. If you are not willing to use diamond in the appropriate grit sizes, all you will show is that a initially dull particle steel edge has better edge retention than an initially sharper O1, A2, etc.

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#16

Re: Interesting but flawed test

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Don't know about that, but Derek stated in a leading paragraph that to use these powder metals you'd have to forget about everything but diamonds for sharpening. All he was doing on the Tormek was basic shaping, establishing the bevel.

Pam

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#18

Notes and Comments

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

John Payne, who supplied the blades for the PM chisels, has many years of experience as a knifemaker. He is also a woodworker. A few years ago he and I began corresponding about steel for blades of planes. With a foot in both camps he wondered why there was so little interest shown by woodworkers in the PM steels. Probably much as you have done, and nagged us to do, for a decade. :)

Eventually people sit up and take notice. Look at Lee Valley: They are soon to release, or perhaps have already done so, HSS (M2) blades for their planes. I know that they are looking at a wide range of steels since I have done some testing for their new chisel line, which comes out later this year.

John developed an interest in chisels (as well as plane blades) as he was able to obtain samples of steel from Niagra Specialty Metals (who bought out Crucible when they went to the wall) in convenient sizes. The heat treating was done by a professional company (name escapes me) who are experienced with these steels. HOWEVER (which became apparent through the first experiment) they are not knowledgeable in producing PM steels for chisels or plane blades and therefore only guessing at the hardness needed. I have been arguing that this needs to be a few orders greater.

With regard the Real World methodology, in your argument having production woodworkers use the chisels ... Well all I can say is that this is impractical (at best) and likely to lead to unreliable data collection. One needs reproducibility - that is one criterion for scientific research from which one may generalise results.

I spent a few months prior to this test just using the PM chisels in furniture building. It was difficult to be objective about their performance. The problem is that a chisel may work well - so what ... as well as ... better than ... less than ....

Comparitive testing is needed to gauge where something lies on the totem pole. And we need baselines and references (hence the Stanley #750 and the Blue Spruce - they are known, qualifiable products).

How to create a method for testing paring chisels? That is a question, indeed. Most paring is done bevel up. I also pare BD, but this is in close-up situations. BD does offer more control as it is less likely to "run away" from you (especially if paring with the grain .... and I can see David Charlesworth over my shoulder wagging his finger :) ). Neither method should affect the quality of the cut.

I am not looking at paring end grain. I should add that paring end grain is different from chopping end grain. The latter must place greater stress on the blade edge. Paring face grain is more akin to planing with a BU plane. Not exactly the same, since the former is really a mix of paring end grain and planing face grain together. The problem is that I do not have a method to apply to the latter condition, so that it remains the same for each stroke every time, and for all chisel blades. What I came up with is a compromise. Let me know if you can think of an alternative. All offers greatly received.

Another comment on the bevel angles chosen. I retained them from the first experiment as the focus was on the steel, not the chisel. The question asked at the end of the first experiments was "would the order of the chisels alter if the demands on the steel changed from impact resistance to abrasion resistance"?

There are a few other tests I have planned. One is planing with a range of blades. The will use a LV BUS. That is for later (I am accumulating the blades still, and all this is done while I'd rather be building furniture).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#19

craigd

Re: But...

craigd

>I wish they would post their experience with his tools

I have several of John's plane blades, 2" x �" in A2 and D2. They work quite well but I don't seem to have any issues with O-1 either (I don't spend enough time in the shop). I've been very happy with them, plus he did some custom shaping at no extra charge. So happy, I've got four more D2 blades on order.

Craig

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#20

I think that you'll find ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Phill ... that we are in agreement. I discussed the futility of honing PM steels with anything but diamond in the first experiment. Indeed, over the past months I have posted cast iron substratums and discussed diamond paste ad nauseum. :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#21

Re: grinding CPM steel

George in almost spring Lowell, Mich.

Hi all,

As I have stated in the past I work in a toolroom doing die making work. We use CPM 3V, CPM 10V,M2 ,M4, and other toolsteels. My "job" at the moment is to grind these die components so they have a sharp cutting edge. Admittedly the preferred edge angle is 90*. What I have noticed is that of all the toolsteels the CPM's and D2 are the ones that cause me to dress the wheel the most often. They are all grindable though. Our surface grinders are water cooled or "wet". The wheels are 46 grit and 14" diameter spinning at about 3000 RPM. The surface of the steel when I get done is quite smooth but I have never seen it under the kind of magnification of the amazing pictures that Derek and others have produced. It probably would look like a plowed field! I'm sure a few strokes on a diamond plate would bring it around though! The plane blades that I have made out of CPMM4 are all virtually wear proof! Sharpen once and forget it.

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#22

Grinding CPM steel - More notes

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi George

Thanks for your post.

I agree about the issues in grinding D2 plane blades. I find the D2 "gummy" and very abrasion resistant ... and this was first on a 10" high speed grinder with a 45 grit white Norton wheel. That machine was terrifying - it would walk towards me menacingly. Thereafter it was on an 8" half-speed dry grinder with a 45 grit white wheel.

With the PM steels, I originally used the 8" dry grinder, and this was not too bad. Certainly chisels are narrow and do not take much extra time over steels such as A2. The advantage of these steels when grinding is that you do not need to be concerned about overheating them and affecting the temper. Their reputation for being difficult to grind made me hesitate when using the Tormek - many balk at using this for even O1 blades! I have never experienced the Tormek as "slow" .. as long as the wheel is freshly dressed.

With a hollow ground to the edge of the blade, freehanding the CPM blades on 40 micron diamond paste required 2-3 strokes for a decent primary bevel. The 10 micron paste needed about double that, and the 0.5 micron about double again (front and back). After this, the M4 and 3V pared pine endgrain effortlessly. The 10V pared as well, but not effortlessly.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#23

We are making progress.....

Bill Tindall

Look at Lee Valley: They are soon to release, or perhaps have already done so, HSS (M2) blades for their planes.

Some years ago I asked on Badger Pond why high speed steels were not used for woodworking hand tools. The Forum Mavens agreed that "they wouldn't take an edge", there was no room for improvement over what was available and the idea was dismissed. The fact that it is no longer heresy to consider something other than classical steel is encouraging.

I am anxious to see how M2 is marketed. Will economic realities doom these steels to niche markets? The roll-out could force LV to finally release their testing data that they have been accumulating for some years..... I hope.

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#24

Re: We are making progress.....

Schtoo

Looks in drawer, modified SK5 HSS chisel. First released nearly a decade ago, I've owned for over a year now.

Looks on top of the drawers, HSS plane. First released 3 decades ago. Was given it 3 months ago, never used it in anger. All it needs is to be pulled out of the box, a few mallet taps and it's ready to use. No sharpening required (it's factory sharpened, HSS bonded to mild steel and a specially shaped edge so it's easier to sharpen with conventional abrasives).

Checks catalog sitting next to me. Currently open to a page with a mess of planes, all with HAP40 powder metal HSS blades. Again, pre-sharpened and only need a few mallet taps to get to work.

Want to know how they're marketed? To those folks who work with stuff that kills regular tools, and those folks who know they're going to damage the edges and need to be able to fix the damage quickly, with a grinder. All specially made so that they'll put up with horrific abuse, but still be relatively easy to sharpen.

The lack of ultimate sharpness is never mentioned. And this is in the land where the edge is king.

These tools have been readily available for a very long time, and are popular enough, but still have not edged out the more conventional steels (white and blue predominantly) for supremacy.

To rub it in, I've got a full set of 5 sharpening stones specifically designed to work with these HSS tools. Who needs diamond paste, which I find to be superlatively obnoxious to actually use, as much as it does actually work.

But what do I know? I'm a nobody... ;)

Re: Chisel Paring � 6 Steels

#25

check the turning Forum...

Bill Tindall

Turners grind these metals routinely and I never heard one complain about difficulty grinding tool steels. Edge renewal takes literally seconds on a bench grinder. Any increased grinding resistance is actually an advantage for it enables better control of metal removal. Personally, I am un-stress when grinding a 3V tool edge. Not the case with a too easily abraded Stanley plane iron.