Notes and Comments
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Hi Bill
John Payne, who supplied the blades for the PM chisels, has many years of experience as a knifemaker. He is also a woodworker. A few years ago he and I began corresponding about steel for blades of planes. With a foot in both camps he wondered why there was so little interest shown by woodworkers in the PM steels. Probably much as you have done, and nagged us to do, for a decade. 
Eventually people sit up and take notice. Look at Lee Valley: They are soon to release, or perhaps have already done so, HSS (M2) blades for their planes. I know that they are looking at a wide range of steels since I have done some testing for their new chisel line, which comes out later this year.
John developed an interest in chisels (as well as plane blades) as he was able to obtain samples of steel from Niagra Specialty Metals (who bought out Crucible when they went to the wall) in convenient sizes. The heat treating was done by a professional company (name escapes me) who are experienced with these steels. HOWEVER (which became apparent through the first experiment) they are not knowledgeable in producing PM steels for chisels or plane blades and therefore only guessing at the hardness needed. I have been arguing that this needs to be a few orders greater.
With regard the Real World methodology, in your argument having production woodworkers use the chisels ... Well all I can say is that this is impractical (at best) and likely to lead to unreliable data collection. One needs reproducibility - that is one criterion for scientific research from which one may generalise results.
I spent a few months prior to this test just using the PM chisels in furniture building. It was difficult to be objective about their performance. The problem is that a chisel may work well - so what ... as well as ... better than ... less than ....
Comparitive testing is needed to gauge where something lies on the totem pole. And we need baselines and references (hence the Stanley #750 and the Blue Spruce - they are known, qualifiable products).
How to create a method for testing paring chisels? That is a question, indeed. Most paring is done bevel up. I also pare BD, but this is in close-up situations. BD does offer more control as it is less likely to "run away" from you (especially if paring with the grain .... and I can see David Charlesworth over my shoulder wagging his finger
). Neither method should affect the quality of the cut.
I am not looking at paring end grain. I should add that paring end grain is different from chopping end grain. The latter must place greater stress on the blade edge. Paring face grain is more akin to planing with a BU plane. Not exactly the same, since the former is really a mix of paring end grain and planing face grain together. The problem is that I do not have a method to apply to the latter condition, so that it remains the same for each stroke every time, and for all chisel blades. What I came up with is a compromise. Let me know if you can think of an alternative. All offers greatly received.
Another comment on the bevel angles chosen. I retained them from the first experiment as the focus was on the steel, not the chisel. The question asked at the end of the first experiments was "would the order of the chisels alter if the demands on the steel changed from impact resistance to abrasion resistance"?
There are a few other tests I have planned. One is planing with a range of blades. The will use a LV BUS. That is for later (I am accumulating the blades still, and all this is done while I'd rather be building furniture).
Regards from Perth
Derek