New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

building with green wood

Posts

building with green wood

#1

building with green wood

StephanieSuesanSmith

Other than greenwood.com, where can I find information on building things with green wood? I have to remove some healthy oak trees and want to use them to build things, but am not sure what I need to do different if I use the wood green as opposed to allowing it to air dry for a year or so. Thank you.

Re: building with green wood

#2

two problems

Bill Tindall

1. Green wood will not stay that way very long. Soon you will have dry wood and if it isn't dried properly it will be hopelessly split and cracked dry wood and perhaps moldy to boot. A local Windsor chair maker has a freezer where he stores his green wood to keep it frozen and in its green state till he needs it.

2. There is very little in the grand scheme of woodworking that can be successfully built from green oak. Barn siding and fence rails come to mind.

If the logs are of sufficient quality it would be best to sell them or saw into lumber. Otherwise the best use is firewood.

Re: building with green wood

#3

Re: building with green wood

Larry Barrett

The answer may depend on what you want to build.

You can find much useful info on

http://www.greenwoodworking.com/

which is what I think you are referring to. If you want to build an "Alexander" style chair, get Alexander's "Make a Chair from a Tree" dvd.

Peter Follensbee makes wonderful chests, chairs, and other things using mostly green red oak. Look here:

http://pfollansbee.wordpress.com/

Peter Galbert has a great blog with a lot of tips on making Windsor chairs and other things involving green wood:

http://www.chairnotes.blogspot.com/

If your question really is about how to keep green wood green until you are ready to use it, some folks like to keep a log or parts of a log under water. I have done this with red oak and it seemed fine even after more than a year. Some surface stain, which can be removed with oxalic acid (Deck cleaner at Home Depot). If you have smaller parts, some keep these in a freezer until ready to use.

Re: building with green wood

#4

Re: building with green wood

Larry Barrett

Should add that much (everything) depends on the quality of the log. If nice straight grain that splits easily, with no twist or bends, then you have a chance. If not this nice, then probably not much use green or air-dried.

If you do want to try to keep some in green state, usually best to split it now into quarters or eighths and keep it under water this way, but no guarantees.

Re: building with green wood

#5

Green wood left in the log

Chuck Nickerson

can stay green enough for working for months.

For lots of chair work green oak is used.

In addition to Follansbe, Drew Langsner at Country Workshops has lots of info.

Re: building with green wood

#6

Re: building with green wood

Mike in Suffolk Virginia

Stephanie

In addition to the books already mentioned there are three excellent books by Drew Langsner that are excellent. They are Green Woodworking, A Hands-On-Approach, Country Woodcraft, Country Woodcraft; a Handbook of Traditional Woodworking Techniques and Projects.

I have some red oak and white oak that I kept green for approximately 10 years. I have 2 six hundred gallon tanks back of my shop that I keep oak in for Windsor Chairs. The tanks were made from 2 three hundred gallon poly proplene tanks that I bolted together with stainless steel bolts and stainless steel self locking nuts. I cut out the middle walls with the bolts loose and then squeezed a large amount of black silicone sealant between the two tanks and then tightened the bolts. I have equivalent of a 16� X 19� x 16� long oak log in it. If you decide to go this route it does not have to be a tank. A pond, lake or stream is fine as long as the wood will stay totally submerged. The only thing that will rot is the bark and eventually the sap wood. If I can be of any help please feel free ask.

Mike in Suffolk Virginia

Re: building with green wood

#7

Re: building with green wood

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have often worked with green oak for timber framing, and outdoor work like benches. I would not hesitate to use green oak for a work bench. If you are going to rive the stuff, I recommend splitting each piece in half right away and do further work at your leisure. Also sections with branches I would use for firewood. We generally work green wood the same as dry wood, but it is helpful to clean tools right after using to prevent staining and rust.

I think you should look at Peter Follansbee's blog for a feel for working green oak. Peter usually splits the wood wet, then lets it dry for a while before planing, then dry a little more before carving, but you can work the wood at any stage of drying.

Peter once was a presenter at the Williamsburg conference and I made a carved box ahead of time so I would get more out of his talk. My neighbor had given me some green firewood and I split the wood and planed it one day, then carved and assembled it the next. It was so wet the water came out with every cut.


img

Re: building with green wood

#8

Re: building with green wood

StephanieSuesanSmith

I appreciate all of the information. I am mostly thinning my woodlot and hated to waste all that wood. It is not really cold enough here to have a fireplace, even in the winter, so firewood is out. I can use it to BBQ with, though. I will check out the resources and see what I can do. Thanks again.

Re: building with green wood

#9

Re: building with green wood *LINK*

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Here's a long shot. Sometimes, blacksmiths like to have real charcoal to stoke their forges, and some of those blacksmiths like to make their own. Check with a local ABANA (Artist-Blacksmiths Association of North America, inc.) and see if there is any interest. A friend of mine is always scrounging wood to make charcoal.


ABANA

Re: building with green wood

#10

Re: building with green wood

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Another option is to mill the trees into lumber and air dry it and use it the same as any other wood you would get from your regular lumber supplier.

I have been milling my own wood with a chain saw since 1994. it is the slowest dirtiest, hardest most inefficient way to make lumber, but it is also the simplest and cheapest way. I bought my saw and alaskan mill used for $250 in 1994, which was less than the value of the wood from the first tree I milled. The nice thing is my milling equipment fits on a shelf above the door to my shop.

If you are interested in learning more about milling your own wood there is a great milling forum over at arboristsite.com

Robin

Re: building with green wood

#11

Re: building with green wood

TD

I spent about a K on my mill, new, and I had the same result, instant payback, assuming the wood gets used in the end. It sure is a cheap way to get wood to store. :)

There is a third option which can be the best, and that is turning. Turning has a lot of advantages over other things you can make with wood:

1) It is very fast, so you can actually get through the large amount of wood you will potentially receive.

2) speed and other factors mean the storage and drying, etc... options are pretty easy to deal with

3) You can use much smaller pieces of wood, and often get away with wood that is of a quality that you could never really use for much else. Though if you start with a perfect tree, you can often use the wood that gree woodworking would of the split and shave side would leave behind.

The biggest problem with wood is quality. Procuring your own wood will instantly give you a lot of respect for the trees that show up as perfect boards in your local supplier. Green woodworking sounds all funky, but it actually traditionally uses the very best wood there is. After that wood is gone people then figured out historically how to saw and produce wood products from the just that was lefte. And this is a process that is ongoing, and goes through multiple stages, right down to the point where they start making wood out of pop bottles. :)

Thinning out sounds as though you could be removing the bottom of the barrel, but so long as you are flexible about what you will make, you should be able to find some useable wood.

On option is a composite approach tool wise, where you use both modern and older techniques. I have spend a lot of labour getting a seemingly beautiful log out of the woods, down the beach, through the water, up the beach, sectioned, split, etc... only to find it really wasn't quite as nice as I had hoped, yet it would have been grade A if it was broken up on a bandsaw. The reality is that split wood construction requires wood that is above the grade required for aircraft and archery (arrrows), about the two highest grades I know of.

Also, consider that not all wood used in green construction is green. If you are using the method where dry and wet wood are brought together to shrink to a tight fit, your schedule will require that wood is available both wet, and dry.

Re: building with green wood

#12

Very Nice !!

roninkokomo

Re: building with green wood

#13

Nice!  and questions

Bill Tindall

I love that pattern. If I could carve( a hopeless notion) a trunk with that pattern would be high on my list of things to make .......and I have just the white oak plank for it.

What joinery was used in the corners and how was it hinged to allow for that fact that it was going to shrink some?

Re: building with green wood

#14

questions

Warren in Lancaster, PA

This is pretty easy carving, much easier than 18th century stuff. The pattern is laid out to the size of your gouges so all the curves are just arcs of circles. I probably used only three gouges.

I recall that the hinge was a pin that went through the back end of the batten that you can see on the under side of the lid. The batten is screwed to the lid, but Peter probably would have nailed it. I may have left the screws a little loose at first or I may have had oversize holes for the screws. One thing that is rarely mentioned in cross grain construction is that the scale of the piece is important. Smaller stuff like this box is not as vulnerable. Small drawers often have bottoms nailed or glued in place; the same construction in a large drawer invites trouble.

The front of the box has rabbets that the sides fit into. I glued them with hide glue then pinned with small tapered pins.

Re: building with green wood

#15

Re: building with green wood

Bruce Willman

Green oak is excellent for making Windsor chair spindles and backs.

Don't know what part of the country you are in, but Homestead Heritage has an excellent Windsor chair class. They are near Waco, TX:

http://www.homesteadheritage-woodworking.com/

Bruce

Re: building with green wood

#16

Re: building with green wood

Bob Hackett

Mike Dunbar(as well as others)here in New England and Brian Boggs and Drew Langsner (as well as others) in the Southern Atlantic states area are some other instructors that come to mind.

Up here The Center for Furniture Craftsmanship In Rockport and Haystack Mountain are 2 places I know of that have also held green woodworking seminars and workshops with nationally known instructors such as Daniel Mack and others listed above.

One of the books that got me interested was Welsh Stick Chairs by John Brown,from there I went to Dan Mack`s books as well as Langsner,Alexander and finally Kerry Pierce for a combined machine and handtool aproach to limited production of chairs.