New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Most of life's problems...

Posts

Most of life's problems...

#1

Most of life's problems...

Joe Shelton

I've been away several days, with tornadoes and then travel shutting me down electrically.

I note with interest a thread below that addresses knives, and I'm glad to see knives, and especially pocket knives, discussed here.

To return to my subject line above, I remember a quote from Ross Seyfried: "Most of life's problems can be solved with a large pistol and a small knife."

Couple folks have mentioned whittlers, and in particular 3-bladed ones. I've recently been captivated with the Case Seahorse Whittler. It offers a huge blade in a Wharncliffe pattern, and two small blades opposed to the large. One is a coping blade, and the other is a sheep's foot. I really like that style knife, and it works for lots and lots of things I need to do. And it fits surprisingly well into my pocket. Not a tiny knife, but worth having with me.

For those of you who don't like guns, I apologize. Not trying to be inflammatory. But Ross was right.

Joe

Re: Most of life's problems...

#2

During Demolitions training...

Bob Hackett

The 1st Sgt had a sign behind his desk that read "There are few problems in life that cannot be eliminated by the expert application of High Explosives"

I thought that pretty well summed it up. :)

Re: Most of life's problems...

#3

Re: Most of life's problems...

Kees

Hope you don't mind too much that I disagree? I can tell you, it kind of sucks to be on the receiving end of said "problem solving" pistol.

A knife is usefull. But being a modern cityboy I have no clue how to sharpen the damned things. With some jiggery I manage to get sharp chisels, but it is completely beyond me how to sharpen a knife. Nowadays I mainly use the throwaway utility knifes. What would be a simple, cityproof way to do this?

Re: Most of life's problems...

#4

Re: Most of life's problems...

David Weaver

Couple of stones and a strop. Put the knife in something (vise, clamp or whatever) and move the stone instead of the knife - it'll make it easier to keep your angles. Paddle strop or a strop made of a folded paper bag or something to remove most of the wire edge and you should be good to go.

Re: Most of life's problems...

#5

Re: Most of life's problems...

Kees

That's the kind of tip I was looking for. Thanks.

Re: Most of life's problems...

#6

Re: During Demolitions training...

Kevin French

And P= "Plenty"

Re: Most of life's problems...

#7

Well, your utility knife blades...

Joe Shelton

...don't have to be throwaways. The only real challenge in sharpening is confidence, from familiarity with the process.

Like Rip Torn said in that Dodgeball movie, "You can sharpen a chisel, you can sharpen anything." Well, more or less.

Anyhoo, use a pair of ViceGrips to hold a used (up) blade from your utility knife. Hold the V-Grips with your strong hand, and use your weak hands fingers to guide and control the blade as you alternate pulling toward you and then pushing away from you. Use the same number of strokes pulling as pushing. Don't hurry.

When you get good at sharpening the straight-edged blade, it's time to try a pocket knife with some curvature in the edge.

It isn't very difficult; just takes some commitment and practice. Ron (from Kokomo) tells us it's a Zen thing...

Re: Most of life's problems...

#8

Here is a jig that a lot of knife makers use *LINK*

Bruce, a MN Galoot

and a useful discussion on a knife making forum. Bear in mind that these guys are really good with grinding equipment, so their methods may be a bit expensive ($4000 for a Burr King is out of my reach too) ( I can't figure out how to post multiple links, so just copy and paste this url) http://knifedogs.com/showthread.php?14357-What-is-your-%28favorite%29-sharpening-method&highlight=sharpen


EdgePro

Re: Most of life's problems...

#9

Re: Here is a jig that a lot of knife makers use

Kees

Maybe I shouldn't read on a knife forum about sharpening knifes. How about information overload :D

I upped the game a bit because I bought an old drawknife yesterday. No idea what I am going to do with it, but it was already fun with the rather dull blade. I have some old oilstones to get some sharpening practice before I try with my expensive waterstones.

Re: Most of life's problems...

#10

You're not the only one 

David Weaver

I bought a belt grinder from someone, one of the 1x42 types. Since then, I've not thrown away a utility knife blade, though I've gotten the utility knife blades at flea markets and I suppose there's a chance that the blades are cheaper than the supplies used to sharpen them.

They go through a cardboard box like nothing right off the belt grinder, though.

Re: Most of life's problems...

#11

Just for kicks . . .

s mackay

take a look at the Boy Scout handbook. For the average mortal (with the average pocket knife) the sharpening method is plenty, easy and practical. Matter of fact, for the accident prone children like me, it is/was MORE than plenty !

Re: Most of life's problems...

#12

Re: Here is a jig that a lot of knife makers use

Bruce, a MN Galoot

In the knife world there are as many different sharpening methods as there are in the woodworking world. People seem to be just as passionate in defending their own particular choice, too :)

Re: Most of life's problems...

#13

David Barnett

Those 1" belt grinders

David Barnett

I've got one of the older Delta 1x42" belt grinders and love it to death. It's one of my most used tools. For sharpening, I mostly use it on knives that get rougher tasks and treatment, and stone sculpting tools. Works great on the machetes which get hard use in the back jungle. For finer knives, I really like the Klingspor gold belts.

Mostly, though, I use it for grinding and making small tools, punches, cleaning up small tools after forging, and so on. Essential for handles, and all manner of small art objects. I've improved the platen, wheels and tensioning mechanism and it's even better for slack belt grinding and shaping. The disc gets a workout now and then, as well. Couldn't live without it.

Re: Most of life's problems...

#14

Re: Those 1" belt grinders

Bruce, a MN Galoot

3M makes some really great belts, the Trizact line, that go up to 2000 grit. I'm not sure about final sharpening since I don't have direct experience with them (at $8 a pop, I can't afford to just piddle around with them) but the knife guys use them for polishing.

Re: Most of life's problems...

#15

Re: Those 1" belt grinders

David Weaver

Someone sold me one that looks like the LV grinder, but with a motor attached. It was kind of cobbled together by a carving shop - the motor is good, but a regular lighting switch was added and it gets in the way of using the rest at an angle around 25 degrees, which is handy for using the belts on cambered irons.

But, no disc (have a leather on a disc on another sander, though).

I put gold carver's compound on a leather belt or use a worn trizact belt for knives and just hold them at a shallow angle (so they get rounded a little bit, i'm sure, but at such a shallow angle, it doesn't matter too much), but I don't have *any* nice knives, even the kitchen knives are cheap imports of a full-tang design so that I can just sharpen them from time to time with a belt. my wife is a notorious knife abuser, destined to frustrate any hand sharpener who supplies nice knives for use and expects the edge to be respected. The belt grinder has been a godsend and ended the squabbling about that.

Anyway, the kit the guy bought (and subsequently came to me) came with two trizact belts - man can they ruin temper on something in a hurry against the platen! But, with a light touch they are great for rough sharpening a knife - a quick run against a 1200 grit worn trizact belt and a strop and the knife will shave, even if it doesn't have the same quality of an edge that i would have run all the way through polishing stones. Great for cambered irons, too.

Re: Most of life's problems...

#16

Re: Those 1" belt grinders

David Weaver

They (trizacts) are very durable and convenient for maintaining tools that are not so convenient to maintain with a grinder and stones. Reminds me of diamonds the way they wear, sort of.

One of my most-used planes is a funjii smoother with a big camber on the iron (cheap japanese plane). It's not so durable if you're used to new alloy irons or high quality japanese irons - it wears fast and you can see the wear much the same as you can on an old plain carbon steel iron. I can put it on a 1200 grit trizact belt for about 10-15 seconds and then zip it up against a leather disc with honing compound on it quickly, turn around and lap the back on a polish stone and in less than a minute, the whole thing is sharp and back in the plane.

Not the purists method, but it is so much better (or at least faster) than pulling the iron across a stone on the diagonal and rotating to work the cambered edge. I just do not get any jollies by sharpening and maintining highly cambered irons by hand, even though it's not that difficult, it's just something so much more easily done on a good quality uniform belt like the trizact belts.

Re: Most of life's problems...

#17

David Barnett

Beyond sanding belts *LINK*

David Barnett

I use a lot of different belts to get the most out of my 1" sander.

As Bruce suggested, 3M Trizact belts are terrific, and so are the little sanding drums for your flexshaft. They last a long time and do an excellent job on a wide range of metals and resin products.

Klingspor 'gold' sharpening belts can be found at:

http://tinyurl.com/KlingsporGoldSharpening

They also carry linen and leather belts:

http://tinyurl.com/KlingsporLinenBelt

http://tinyurl.com/KlingsporLeatherBelt

Lee Valley carries a leather stropping belt and the 3M 15� belt:

http://tinyurl.com/LVleatherand15micron

Supergrit carries lots of special 1"x42" belts; cork, 3M Scotchbrite, 3M micron poly, felt, ceramic, black SiC, and more:

http://www.supergrit.com/products/products_belts.asp

Golfsmith carries cloth, felt, and graphite prep belts:

http://tinyurl.com/GolfsmithFinishingBelts

Bonus Tip:

If you order from Golfsmith, they carry a shafting epoxy with the highest shear strength (club heads would spin on shafts if lesser epoxies were used). Great for handles and anything else you never want to twist off, pull out or come loose, and it's black, if that matters:

http://tinyurl.com/GolfsmithShaftingEpoxy

Extra Bonus Tip and Popular Mechanics article on 1"x42" sanders:

"To polish metals, turn a worn belt inside out and apply a rouge compound. Light pressure produces a bright finish. Be sure belt is completely worn to prevent wear on the pulleys."


Popular Mechanics 1"x42" sander article

Re: Most of life's problems...

#18

Re: Here is a jig that a lot of knife makers use *LINK*

anotherBob

Ya, 4Gs is a lot for something that doesn't make your living or can't be taken out of a lottery windfall. I made a 2x72 for less than $100 using scrap aluminum, treadmill motor and just a bit of bought steel. At the time, I had the time... point is, you don't have to spend that much if you don't/can't wanna.

Bruce you mentioned the edgepro... I'm just about finished with my shop built clone of one, can't wait to try it out! Cast iron, even if it may be the best option for holding diamond paste, would be far to heavy on one of these. Have been in research mode and may have a couple possibilities... time will tell. I think it was David here that linked to a web page at some point that mentioned the best wood, if you use wood is pink ivory. I have one small 2x2x7.5 piece that I'm planning on ripping into thin strips and epoxying to an aluminum carrier, then embedding paste onto that. Another thing that I just read last night from an older discussion at a "razor type" forum (they get pretty fanatical too... :) ) is either CrO2 or diamond paste on .3 AO film that's stuck to glass/corian. I just happen to have some from TFWW...

I must be warped or something coz I'm still curious about this stuff... :)


TFWW - 3M Micro Abrasive Film for Scary Sharpening

Re: Most of life's problems...

#19

Re: Here is a jig that a lot of knife makers use

Bruce, a MN Galoot

The temptation for me is so great you'll never know. The 3M plant that makes all their films and tapes is located 1 mile from my office. I'd love to have access to that place. Unfortunately, they don't sell the fine finishing films in their employee's store. :( However, I can get many of their other abrasives for about a penny a sheet, including the wet or dry papers. :)

My own strip sander is a 1 X 42 built from FWW plans maybe 20 - 22 years ago. The only things I spent money on were pillow blocks and wheel bearings. As cheap as it is, it's one of the handiest gadgets I ever made. Anyone who still sharpens lawn mower blades on a wheel needs to try a strip sander, and they'll never go back. A good 2 X 72 is coming up in the near future.

For a quick finish on my pocket knife blades, I hone up to maybe 1500 grit waterstone followed by a quick trip across the hard felt wheel on my grinder charged with green crayon compound.

Re: Most of life's problems...

#20

Re: Most of life's problems...

TD

"But Ross was right."

Sounds like something he wrote when he was writting for G&A. Things must have changed when he moved to Double Gun Journal.

I'm also a fan of 1x42, never got rid of mine when I moved up to 2x72. There are some cool belts for the big boys. One uses cork and can be loaded with compound. But go to a knife show and you will see dudes using the 1x42s to sharpen knives for passers by. Least up here. LV sells grinding, finishing, and buffing belts for the 1x42