Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Some months ago, around the time I acquired a few Koyamaichi dovetail chisels, there was discussion on the forum of the merits of Matsumura chisels. Stu Tierney, (Schtoo on the forums), who runs Tools from Japan, made the comment that Matsumura chisels are unknown inside Japan. Stu does a great deal of comparative testing, especially of waterstones and chisels, but was stuck when it came saying anything about Matsumura. Since the Koyamaichi were replacing a couple of Matsumura (purchased several years ago from The Japan Woodworker), I offered to compare the steel in each when I had time. I had some time today.

The method for testing was as follows:
Starting out newly honed, both chisels would chop through 30mm deep x 20mm wide Jarrah (very) hardwood endgrain, taking a 5mm slice. They would then be used to pare end grain Radiata Pine as visual measure of edge retention and sharpness. This process would continue until a winner was apparent.

The chisels used were 6mm (1/4�), both hollow ground on a Tormek at 30 degrees, and then honed on Shaptons 1000/5000/12000 grit. The edges were tested on the Pine end grain �
Koyamaichi on left and Matsumura on right
Each chisel then removed a 5mm slice of the Jarrah end grain �

� and then pared the Pine end grain once more �

What is evident here is that the Koyamaichi chisel had no difficulty with the Pine, although this was not as clean a cut as before, while the Matsumura could barely remove a shaving. It skipped out of the wood halfway through the attempted pared cut.
So I decided to do this a second time.

Both chisels were honed through the grits, and preliminary Pine end grain shavings were taken. The Koyamaichi went first �

And then it was the turn of the Matsumura �

Mmm � it left a rough cut, along with evidence that the edge was chipped. I reground the blade on the Tormek and took it through the Shapton grits again. This time the results were better �


Neither chisel pared as cleanly on this second sample of Radiata Pine, indicating that the wood was a little more demanding than before.
The chisels once again chopped off a slice of Jarrah.

And once again they pared the Pine end grain.

The Koyamaichi was just able to pare this wood, with some tear out apparent. The Matsumura could not manage it at all.
A closer look at the edges revealed that the Matsumura had again chipped out �

What is interesting is that neither of the chisels actually felt dull, certainly not the Matsumura, which was capable of chopping away the endgrain Jarrah in spite of the very fine chips to its edge. I had not been aware of such edge deterioration in the years of using this chisel.

Conclusions? Well the obvious is that both chisels can take a good edge. It is no mean feat to pare Radiata Pine and leave a shiny surface behind. Both accomplished this quite effortlessly. The Koyamaichi, however, holds this edge considerably better than the Matsumura when used in hardwood endgrain.
Regards from Perth






