New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

Posts

Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

#1

Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Some months ago, around the time I acquired a few Koyamaichi dovetail chisels, there was discussion on the forum of the merits of Matsumura chisels. Stu Tierney, (Schtoo on the forums), who runs Tools from Japan, made the comment that Matsumura chisels are unknown inside Japan. Stu does a great deal of comparative testing, especially of waterstones and chisels, but was stuck when it came saying anything about Matsumura. Since the Koyamaichi were replacing a couple of Matsumura (purchased several years ago from The Japan Woodworker), I offered to compare the steel in each when I had time. I had some time today.


The method for testing was as follows:

Starting out newly honed, both chisels would chop through 30mm deep x 20mm wide Jarrah (very) hardwood endgrain, taking a 5mm slice. They would then be used to pare end grain Radiata Pine as visual measure of edge retention and sharpness. This process would continue until a winner was apparent.


The chisels used were 6mm (1/4�), both hollow ground on a Tormek at 30 degrees, and then honed on Shaptons 1000/5000/12000 grit. The edges were tested on the Pine end grain �

Koyamaichi on left and Matsumura on right

Each chisel then removed a 5mm slice of the Jarrah end grain �


� and then pared the Pine end grain once more �


What is evident here is that the Koyamaichi chisel had no difficulty with the Pine, although this was not as clean a cut as before, while the Matsumura could barely remove a shaving. It skipped out of the wood halfway through the attempted pared cut.

So I decided to do this a second time.


Both chisels were honed through the grits, and preliminary Pine end grain shavings were taken. The Koyamaichi went first �


And then it was the turn of the Matsumura �


Mmm � it left a rough cut, along with evidence that the edge was chipped. I reground the blade on the Tormek and took it through the Shapton grits again. This time the results were better �



Neither chisel pared as cleanly on this second sample of Radiata Pine, indicating that the wood was a little more demanding than before.

The chisels once again chopped off a slice of Jarrah.


And once again they pared the Pine end grain.


The Koyamaichi was just able to pare this wood, with some tear out apparent. The Matsumura could not manage it at all.

A closer look at the edges revealed that the Matsumura had again chipped out �


What is interesting is that neither of the chisels actually felt dull, certainly not the Matsumura, which was capable of chopping away the endgrain Jarrah in spite of the very fine chips to its edge. I had not been aware of such edge deterioration in the years of using this chisel.


Conclusions? Well the obvious is that both chisels can take a good edge. It is no mean feat to pare Radiata Pine and leave a shiny surface behind. Both accomplished this quite effortlessly. The Koyamaichi, however, holds this edge considerably better than the Matsumura when used in hardwood endgrain.

Regards from Perth

Derek


Koyamaichi Dovetail Chisels - review

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

#2

Great review....magazine worthy.

roger lance

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

#3

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels

David Weaver

Derek - can you put this over on SMC? I'd like to comment on it and I am persona non grata on woodnet.

I BEGGED stu to do what he could to carry KI chisels when he said he was going to meet with the blacksmith, as I had gotten those dovetail chisels from LV way back when the exchange rate was more favorable, and I was hoping it would come back around and I would be able to replace my parers (a mix of matsumura and koyama brand - not the same as Koyama-ichi - hard lesson learned!)

If you mention that these (dovetail) chisels are also available from LV, they probably won't wipe the post right away (they do go quite far and fast to protect their ad revenue!!!)

I also may have helped to get Schtoo in hot water when I said "absolutely positively with the samples I have, the KIs are an extremely well made workman chisel and the matsumura are a nicely finished version of a chisel that looks the same or similar but isn't as good, isn't as hard, and doesn't hold an edge as well".

My biggest problem is the matsumura chisels that I am left with now are my *favorite* sizes in parers, and though they are really just fine for practical use, they do display the chipout you show (but on a much much much smaller scale since it's paring - the effect on the edge is premature dulling) and they don't stay sharp like I would like because of it. If the exchange rate ever comes around, I will solve that.

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

#4

I'd be interested in seeing your response here!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

#5

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels

Aaron Rappaport

Derek,

Were the Matsumuras made from white steel? Over on the Japanese Woodworking list, their white steel bench chisels had a bad rep. On the other hand, their blue steel chisels seemed to be better thought of.

See http://www.shizutanischool.org/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=2045.

Aaron

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

#6

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels

David Weaver

I think that's generally the way it goes with inexpensive chisels - it's easier to make the blue steel chisels well than the white steel chisels - qualify that by I hear that the defect rate for blue is higher than for white (thus the higher cost). But for the chisels that don't have defects, blue is easier to get a good result with in hardening and tempering (and easier to forge correctly?).

I think for cheaper chisels, the money to upgrade to blue steel is money well spent, especially now that artificial abrasives don't think much differently of blue and white.

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

#7

Re: I'd be interested in seeing your response here

David Weaver

Well, I guess I mumbled a lot of it out, but here is pretty much the rest.

I have matsumura white steel chisels and koyamaichi white steel chisels (and iyoroi white steel chisels and koyama (without the ichi) white steel chisels and some reform grade chisel stu sent me in white steel and two levels of kumagoro chisels in white steel - one cheap, one not quite so cheap by a different blacksmith). Bought both the KI (from LV) and matsumuras (craftsman studio) a while ago, before stu was selling anything. I liked the KI chisels because of their profile - they are very delicate, and "learned" by experience with both that they were not the same animal. I also like the profile of the matsumura parers - the finish level of the KI and the matsumura is about the same. They both are finished nicer than the iyroi run of the mill carpenter stuff (which is cheaper).

I believe the hardness spec says they are 1 different or so, one says 64, the other 65/66. In reality, there is a larger gap from what I can tell. I believe that the koyamaichi meet their spec or are very close to it, but I also believe that the matsumura - like many of the lower cost chisels (by that, I mean chisels that are less than $100 each) - are left softer than their spec. This is just my opinion (an opinion, though, that is calibrated by having had some of my other chisels hardness tested), the only japanese chisels I had hardness tested was an iyoroi that also said it was hardness 64 and it, in fact, averaged 61 - that is a big difference. I don't notice the matsumuras to be a lot different than that iyoroi in how they go over the stones, how the edge lasts, etc. Hopefully, some day I'll get to hardness test the matsumura - I have to have something to barter with the guy that has the tester.

If you are not doing stuff like derek is doing, but rather just using chisels for normal every day work, you will still have very tiny chipping - that's how the edges fail. The chisel that is the same hardness and the most chip resistant will last longer, even if you can't see either chipping with your naked eye. Apparently, it takes a good bit of care to make white steel very hard and still resistant to chipping, and that care isn't too often done (or done properly) in chisels that are $75 each.

At any rate, I pushed stu when he said he had a chance to meet mr. koyamaichi because of all of the cheaper ($<100) chisels that I have, the KIs are the only ones that actually live up to their billing, and the more expensive kumagoro might also, but it has a monstrous lamination that makes it harder to sharpen (note, this kumagoro chisel has nothing in common with anything available in the US that I know of - it is probably a different blacksmith and it's marketed as "kumagoro gold").

But the KIs "are what they say they are" - straight up.

And I noticed a post on woodnet where people were assaulting stu because he made the comment about KIs being a better chisel (I am probably not the only person who had told him that, but recognizing that it is difficult for him to find matsumura chisels in japan because they seem to be export only or nearly only export), and it really irritated me that a bunch of people who do nothing other than read FWW reviews and have never used a KI chisel and a matsumura chisel in the same session were sitting around hurling insults at someone who is genuinely trying to sell good stuff.

In my opinion from using the chisels, i find reality to be exactly as derek has shown it. The KIs stay very keen longer (I wish I had KI parers where you want that super keen to stay that way) - require less honing and really hold up very well at practical angles here in the US in the mid/high 20s

To me, these chisels that are in the $50-$100 range aren't cheap. I don't consider them to be super expensive, but I think it's worth knowing which ones are really better. You can get good usable western chisels for $15, it's not about whether or not you can use matsumura chisels - certainly you can - it's about getting what you think you're getting and getting your money's worth.

I don't want to get all of the matsumura chisel users in a huff, either, just stating things as I see them. i don't get anything when stu sells KI, and I don't get anything when LV sells KI. I obviously still use my matsumura chisels, i just never got the "wow" feeling using them like I do from the KI chisels. They do get "wow" sharp, but they never are "wow ...sharp and wow for a long time".

I think if I were someone getting bench chisels and definitely going with Matsumura chisels, I would opt for the blue steel and not the white steel. People who have the blue steel always seem a lot more excited about their chisels than I am about mine.

It's funny, going back to LV, that their other dovetail chisels are from Miyanaga, and blue steel. I lucked into some miyanaga blue steel chisels a while ago (not dovetail chisels) used, and they are also really really nice chisels both in the tidiness of the finish and also in how impressive they are at holding an edge and not chipping out in things you'd just about be sure they'd chip or crumble. I wonder how they came across those two makers - if it was by chance, I'd say pretty lucky guesses!

There are other makers that have that great reputation, too, for their plain chisels, like ouchi and imai, but I've not had a chance to use them. The ouchi have a good reputation in japan among professional users, and thanks to some help from stan covington, I got confirmation that the knowledgable dealers in tokyo gave an opinion of the KI chisels of "good - like Ouchi" in terms of performance. In my somewhat limited experience, tools that are well regarded in tokyo seem to be good, tough and hard - just what I'd always shoot for if I was going to spend above and beyond what western chisels cost.

All my opinions and somewhat limited experience above - worth what it costs to get it, i guess!

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

#8

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Aaron

To answer the first part, the Matsumura chisel is made of white steel. These came from Craftsman Studio about 5 or 6 years ago. Initially I thought that they were blue steel since bothe Craftsman Studio and The Japan Woodworker advertise their Matsumura bench chisels as blue steel ... and dovetail chisels are essentially bench chisels.

The second part is more complicated. Blue steel generally is preferred over white steel as it is seen to take an edge better and hold it longer. However it is also considered to be more brittle than white steel. I guess that logic would hold that blue steel is preferred for paring chisels and white steel, which is a little more elastic, makes the better chopping blade.

However my understanding is that this is a rather simpistic perspective. There are a host of other factors involved, and the different compositions of the two steels are not what determines success or failure. At the end of the day it will come down to the skill of the bladesmith in working the steel and laminations.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

#9

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels

David Weaver

The plot thickens - that makes it even more interesting if the matsumura is blue steel.

At that, I am surprised by the differences, especially considering that the angle is fairly steep - an angle that any chisel at any alloy should hold up well.

I guess if I had to go to lloyds and make bets, I would've been hesitant to bet against blue steel regardless of the white steel maker.

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

#10

Re: Blue vs. white...

David Weaver

Derek - am I reading that the wrong way around?

Generally, white being able to take a better edge but regarded as more brittle?

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

#11

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

I corrected an error in my post above. The Matsumura dovetail chisel was purchased from Craftsman Studio, not The Japan Woodworker as I thought I had done, and they advertise it as white steel.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

#12

Re: Blue vs. white...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

My understanding is that blue takes a better edge than white but is harder, more brittle and more apt to chip than white, which has the greater flexibility of the two steels.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

#13

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels

David Weaver

OK, makes much sense.

A lot of the very delicate chisels are white and the pounders blue - the exception that I can think of is the miyanaga chisel that LV offers. I don't know if miyanaga has a preference for blue steel, but his blue steel chisels are finely done.

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

#14

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I don't know if miyanaga has a preference for blue steel, but his blue steel chisels are finely done.

... which comes back to my comment that it is not good practice to assume that white steel will always react one way and blue steel another.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

#15

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Indeed. My approach has always been to purchase edge tools by blacksmith rather than steel, with a little thrown in for trusted sellers; and anything sold on ebay is a crap shoot, so it had better be cheap.

Pam, who just ordered her first Koyamaichi chisels

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

#16

Derek, David, Pam, et al....

roger lance

what sizes of chisels do you recommend for a ww doing dovetails ?? I intend to buy the KIs from LV and want a basic set for working dovetails on drawers and some case work. Want to buy the sizes you use....the others I will look at in a catalog. I'm just a poor boy lookin for a job...but I get no offers...just a come on from the tool merchants....I swear, I've taken some comfort there...hopefully, not this time.

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

#17

Re: Derek, David, Pam, et al....

wilbur

The most common sizes I use for dovetails are 3/8" and 1/2", then 1/4" (or 9 mm and 12 mm, then 6 mm, as it may be, since we are talking about Japanese chisels). Probably the 1/2" chisel gets the most workout with chopping.

It really comes down to the size of dovetails that you want. Derek will probably gravitate to smaller chisels as he likes making those super skinny pins. I tend to go for more even spacing, myself. But this is strictly an aesthetic choice.


The main thing is to size the bases of the tails and/or the narrow side of the gap between your pins to be slightly wider than the width of one of your chisels, to make chopping efficient.

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

#18

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

wilbur

I agree with Pam, and with what Derek said above: "At the end of the day it will come down to the skill of the bladesmith in working the steel and laminations."

Although I obsessed over the white steel/blue steel differences when I was first learning about Japanese chisels (and the O-1/A-2 differences with western chisels), I now think of choosing a Japanese chisel based on the blue/white steel issue this way: it's like trying to decide whether you should pick a chicken dish made with a decent fresh chicken at the grocery store or an organic free range chicken. To some extent it doesn�t matter � Jacques Pepin will still make a better chicken dish than what you'll get at KFC.

I have some more info on blue and white steels on my blog, linked below.


Comparison of blue and white steels

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

#19

Re: Derek, David, Pam, et al....

David Weaver

The ones I use between the tails are probably, as wilbur said, the 6 and 9mm, which might be marketed 1/4th and 3/8th.

I bought the whole set back when the exchange rate was a lot better, and I do use the wide ones, but they are only being used to clean out between pins, and just because I have them. Any flea market bench chisel would do that part just as well.

Take a look at the room between the tails on most of the dovetails you cut and order accordingly. If you do dovetails that are more evenly sized with the pins, maybe adding a wider one makes some sense.

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

#20

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yeah, although it usually works out that my chosen smiths are masters at white steel; but they choose blue steel on occasion for some types of blades; so generally I think I have white steel, but don't really know. And I know that one sharpening stone or another will handle whatever I get.

As to O1/W1 and A2, I always choose O1/W1, because I don't know that my stones will handle A2.

As to chickens, there's nothing decent about chickens hopped up on antibiotics and hormones; so I always choose organic. I can't imagine anyone makes better chicken dishes than I do. :)

Pam

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

#21

What Wilbur and David said, plus *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

for cleaning out dovetails in tight spaces I use a 9 mm fishtail and I'm experimenting with a 6 mm reverse concorde fishtail (the ones from Tasai and LN that look like concorde planes/birds with the heads reversed). I often use a 15-18mm for chopping waste, but that may be because I cut the tails freehand, bifurcating the board with the saw; so it's not like I have any standards at all. :)

Pam


Tasai special dovetails

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

#22

Re: Derek, David, Pam, et al....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Roger

The short answer is that, for the tails, I use a 1/8"(3mm), 3/16" (4.5mm) and 1/4" (6mm).

For drawer fronts I prefer London-style dovetails, which are rather skinny at the ends. However the fact that they are skinny at that point does not determine the width of the chisel (instead, this emphasises having a skinny-bladed marking knife). What determines the width of the chisel is the thickness of the wood you use. For example, the front board may be 3/4" thick, but the depth of the dovetail is determined by the thickness of the side boards. This depth with then affect how long the dovetail goes, how much it splays out, and how wide it becomes at the base .... and the width of the chisel. So if you use 1/4-3/8" thick side boards, then the bases of the dovetails will be quite narrow as well, sometimes as little as 1/8" wide.


The tails do not require dedicated dovetail chisels. The sides of the dovetails here are vertical. You can use any type of chisel for the tails. Firmers are as good as bevel edge chisels. I have Japanese dovetail chisels in 1", 3/4" and 1/2" and have left the sides as per prioginal, that is, with a little shoulder (where I modified my small ones to be shoulder-less).


The only addition to the above are skew chisels for half-blind dovetails. I have these in 1/4" and 3/8".

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

#23

You will have to prove your last statement   

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

#24

Thanks one and all for the replies.....

roger lance

it is kind of amazing to be able to get such instant and thorough advise from such experienced and knowledgeable people. This was all very useful to me as I'm a little lacking in knowing what is good and necessary in the hand tool area. Thanks again. I look forward to learning more from you all in the future. Take care.

Re: Koyamaichi vs Matsumura dovetail chisels *LINK*

#25

Name time & place, bring stuff. 

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX