New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Historical techniques in modern furniture

Posts

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#26

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

Sgian Dubh

Does this one minute doodle help Pam? It took longer to scan and mess about with a bit in Photoshop than to draw, ha, ha. On a side note you can slap two, four, six, etc pairs of sides together to speed up the sawing process a bit more.

Incidentally, I haven't really been away: it's just that I've had more pressing issues to deal with of late, so I've mostly just lurked for the last few months. Slainte.

Photobucket

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#27

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Aha, thanks, I guess it's the tiny pins that let you do this, understood; however, I've never made them and can envision all sorts of problems trying to use the same kerf, but that's me. BTW, I already know I can cut several tail boards at once, it's one of the main advantages of cutting tails first. :)

Pam

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#28

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

Andrew F in Australia

Hi Bill,

I can't really add to Richard's comments. I use secret haunched tenons in something like a door frame where I need to keep the rail (horizontal component) level with the face of the stile (vertical component.)

The haunch stops it from twisting in the frame during glueup and during dimensional changes.

I think I understand what you're saying on the drawer components. I'm confused as the drawer blade is the rail at the front of the carcase that a traditional drawer closes against. Are you talking about the drawer runner (the piece of wood under the side of the drawer that it runs along as it slides in and out?)

This is sometimes mounted in a trench/housing in the carcase side, but the rear of the drawer blade is typically tenoned into a separate frame, and held with a tongue and groove at the front. The T&G allows for seasonal movement of the sides, while the rear end of the drawer runner is fixed into a horizontal blade/rail separate to the carcase back. I don't understand the 'dovetail' you refer to, unless you are talking about dovetailing this in instead of using a M/T.

The only time that I've seen a drawer runner dovetailed into a carcase is if it's the bottom drawer runner so there's access to the bottom edge of this carcase back. You can't dovetail a drawer runner into the middle of a carcase.

Alternatively, you might be saying that both ends of the drawer blade are dovetailed into the side of the carcase, and slide in.

As drawer runners also double as a kicker for the drawer below (usually,) they have to be the same thickness as the drawer blade. I'm having some trouble conceptualising how the blade is dovetailed in by enlarging a groove that's already full thickness. I have probably missed something obvious.

Typically, the drawer blade is held into the side with a twin stub tenon in my training/experience.

Do I understand you correctly?

A sketch would help if not.

I trust that this may be of use.

Cheers,

ANdrew F

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#29

Clarification of drawer runner discussion

Bill Tindall

The hypothesis: Some details of modern woodworking that have become a fashion or/or advocated technique, and seem to have no valid engineering purpose, derive from a traditional construction technique. They are a by product of some other traditional hand tool operation that made cabinet construction quicker. To wit, tiny English style dovetails were the quickest way to make a drawer from hard white oak sides and soft mahogany fronts. Or, a haunch in a cabinet door was the result of plowing the groove for the panel with a hand plane for it has no practical purpose in a typical cabinet door. However, in modern times, perhaps without recognition of its origin, it has been advertised as preventing twist , a dubious enhancement in a small cabinet door.

The technique that seems most vestigial is inletting the drawer runner into a dado into the side of a cabinet. Surely this engineering excess derives from some other part of making the cabinet and I think I know what.

I am never certain of drawer engineering nomenclature so to begin with a definition: "Blade"- the support, front and back, that is perpendicular to the cabinet side. "Runner"- the support on each side parallel to the cabinet side.

A common way to assemble a cabinet is to dovetail the blades into the case sides. From my observation of old stuff this construction keeps this joint tight better than mortise and tenon and indeed it seems the joint of choice in high end period furniture. I think the quickest way to make this joint with traditional tools is to begin by plowing a dado across the case side. This dado quickly establishes the location, depth, and minor width of the dovetail socket in the case side. It is then but a minute operation to complete this part of the dovetail to accommodate the mating dovetail on the drawer blade.

However, this approach leaves a dado on the case side, to be filled by the runner. Happily, this dado also aligns the runner. Hence, the dadoed runner is a by-product of some other operation, not an engineering enhancement to holding up a drawer.

Perhaps others can think of some other reason a runner would be dadoed into a case side. It certainly can't be for any engineering purpose, though it might be advertised as such in modern times.

Someone with a flair for writing articles might find it an interesting topic to speculate on what modern techniques and fashion derive from efficiencies in traditional hand tool construction.

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#30

Re: Clarification of drawer runner discussion

Warren in Lancaster, PA

A couple of notes here, Bill. It is no problem making a dovetail housing without the dado behind. It takes more time to make the dado and the housing than just the dovetail housing by itself. Sometimes the dado is only 1/8 deep, but the width of the dado is the full thickness of the blade and runner. The dovetail can extend most (or all) the thickness of the carcass side, but the dado needs to be shallow to avoid weakening the carcass.

I don't want to get carried away with analysis, but consider that the runner is cross grain to the case side so you might not want to nail it or glue it in place. Also we usually glue the carcass together with hide glue and do not want to fool around with the interior structure while we have little time. Then the drawer support stuff can slide in place and a dado can serve to locate the runner. The dado also gives support for the runner and the drawer that sits on it.

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#31

Re: Clarification of drawer runner discussion

Andrew F in Australia

Hi Bill,

Everything's always done for a reason, you are correct.

Secret haunched tenons, I believe, are also centuries old. They were designed separately to frame and panel construction, and allow you to locate the entire with of a rail and stop it from moving with moisture changes on say, for example, a table rail/table leg junction.

I understand what you're saying re the drawer blade. Warren's got the reason for locating a runner in a trench/housing. It pins it and physically stops it from moving, especially as it can not be glued to the side (differential timber movement.)

I'm guessing that the drawer runner has a small rebate planed on both sides to locate it in the trench, as the width of the trench you refer to has to be smaller than the width of the blade, as the widest part of the dovetail is the thickness of the blade. Fine quality furniture I see that's old has the vertical line uninterrupted by the drawer blade, and the drawer blade meeting the edge of the leg/carcase side without interrupting it's line.

Googling images of furniture made by Gillows of Lancaster (who survived from 1760? to 1960ish) will show this - they'll probably be on Sotheby's website.

Cheers,

Andrew F

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#32

Carcass construction- parts ID

Sgian Dubh

Bill, your descriptions of the parts in a carcass that has to carry drawers have been puzzling me-- blades and and so on are a mystery. I thought I'd knock out a sketch that includes the names I'm familiar with to identify the main items. The only significant part I've not included in the following sketch is the dustboard that was (or is) sometimes fitted into a groove in the framework made up of the front and rear horizontal divider and the two runners/kickers. Wide carcases often included an additional centrally located front to back muntin.

One reason often given for sinking the runner/kicker into the carcase with a trench (dado in American usage), but often only by two or three millimetres [1/8" or so] is to reduce the likelihood of them bending as a deep and heavily laden drawer slides in and out. I suppose the greatest loading on the kicker (and the front upper corner and edge of the front horizontal divider) is when a drawer is about 7/8 open-- the front of the drawer in this circumstance is unsupported and tending to droop towards the floor, and the rear top corners of the drawer box sides are levered up into the kickers. I'm not totally convinved by this reasoning for sinking the runners/kickers, but I've heard and read it often enough.

In my experience it's relatively rare for the horizontal dividers to be joined into the carcass sides with a sliding dovetail. In high quality work I think the only times I've seen it are when there is a lipping of some sort at the front, or veneered edge, to hide it. Country style or vernacular furniture is a bit different and I've seen quite a few items of that type with front drawer dividers, both horizontal and vertical, put together with sliding dovetails. I quite often see the form in contemporary solid wood furniture where the designer want to display the joinery.

On the whole, I believe in British furniture that it's more common to see the horizontal rails attached to the carcase sides with double or triple stub tenons-- these are usually full rail thickness, ie, no shoulder on the top and bottom faces. Sometimes I've seen such tenons pass all the way through the carcase side and wedged to create a dovetailed effect-- this practice doesn't usually do a lot for me on an aesthetic front, but can sometimes look okay. Slainte.

Photobucket

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#33

Re: Carcass construction- parts ID

Andrew F in AUstralia

Thanks Richard,

Just to let you know our training was to call the rail under a drawer a 'blade rail,' (or drawer blade.) I dug out my training notes as I couldn't for the life of me remember the name of the rear horizontal rail. It wasn't specifically named in my trade notes, and my copy of Joyce is at work, so I can't check it out in Joyce at the moment either. Different local terms in UK originally?

The drawer runners that I've made have been either tenoned at the rear (or dovetailed if it's a writing table and the lowest pair of runners are level with the underside of the table rear skirt/back/rail,) with a tongue and groove holding them in to the front. THe T&G was unglued to allow for flex/movement.

I was planning on doing something similar to your very clear sketch, but I'm up to my armpits in alligators at the moment.

Thanks again,

Andrew F