Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture
TD
"Haunched mortise and tenon: The explanation for this joint in modern woodworking just
doesn't make any structural sense."
I'm not sure what you mean here, but if you are referring to the idea that it is said to maintain
alignment of the parts out to the edge, and otherwise control rackingI don't think that is untrue.
It would be particularly valid in the modern context where there is little to guarantee that the
parts will be quartered. I don't like haunches, so I share your distain, but so long as experience
shows the joint part is strong enough, then the haunch is not useless.
" However, if we think how a M&T joint for a frame and panel was made in days of old, the
haunched tenon is a logical consequence. The groove for the panel was plowed in the stile with
a plane and the haunch filled the gap from this operation."
Well myself, I always found this detail on modern furniture, and thought it arose from the need
to run these parts on a table saw, or a shaper.
"It had nothing to do with engineering and everything to do with convenience."
Well whatever the dominant reason may be, the subsidiary reason still exists.
"Drawer runners inlet to the case sides: If one contemplates how to hand cut dovetails for
drawer blades the most efficient approach"
There is evidence that in the past inefficiency was viewed as a positive good. This kind of
thing still exists, think of those droopy pants people wear, or the Japanese overt preference for
gifts that operate on the motto, "it's the price that counts". So the most efficient means to the
high value product was the most inefficient technique possible. The only real economic problem is whether you have the market. When one considers the huge amount of work to be done, anything that spikes the price is a small price to pay as a craftsman, if you can get the price in your market. For instance it is much more expensive to buy guitars made of rosewood. And it can be slightly more difficult to work. But it is a huge upcharge, so the inefficiency pays for itself.
" is to first plow a dado across the case and then enlarge the front and back for the tail socket
for the dovetailed blade."
The most efficient method in that case would be to saw the dovetail, plow the groove, then
clean out the dovetail.
"This approach leaves a dado across the case side to be filled by the drawer runner. Again, the
inlet runner is a consequence of technique not a meaningful structural improvement. Drawer
runners simply nailed to case sides have lasted for centuries."
What does "a consequence of technique" mean. It may have been an available technique, but it
isn't faster than nailing. It is certainly a structural improvement, without doubt. The idea that
some nailed rails have survived is only relevant if you have numbers for all the cases, and how
they all failed, not just that a few survived somewhere. And in any case a structural
improvement that is not relied upon is still a structural improvement.
"Skinny English Dovetails: I think this style was not about style at all but some consequence of
how they were made or the material or tools employed."
You might be right, but there seems to be ample historic evidence that there was a style
difference, or almost a guild difference. I am not the keeper of that kind of thing, but I see no
immediate reason to doubt it.
"Note these are made in thin oak drawer sides."
point being?
"There were made by the millions in production shop environments, an environment more
interested in efficiency than making a statement inside a case where the joint is not normally
seen."
Efficiency is not what it is today, think of the Baker's dozen example, the punishment both in
the marketplace, and the law was pretty severe, I don't think one can simply make modern
statements about this stuff as though 2011 rules apply. But efficiency is always a part of it.
" Can you think of some practical (efficiency) reason for making these skinny dovetails as
opposed to larger ones? Alan Batty(the English turner) who worked in a shop making drawers
would know but the email address I have for him is invalid."
The fact that something is a style is not exclusive of the idea that it is efficient also. Part of the
style statement can be that we have the skill to execute in this style. That is in fact the ultimate
in efficiency and differentiation, you get a toofer, exclusivity/respect, and cheapness. Crafts
are full of examples like that. There are arty decoration on modern day bowls that look
complex but take less time than clear finish. Or signature carvings that are a few strokes for the
skilled, but give a piece value.
In the narrow dovetail example, the tails are super fast to cut. They can be cut out with two
blows of the hammer. This then leaves the receiving piece, normally half blind in those days
whether a drawer or case. Two features there. One, you have more room to get the half blind
socket cleaned out. You have more material to remove, but it is easy to do so, since you have
space. Two, the half blind means that while I would not expect and expert to make a mess of it, the
worked surfaces can't be seen.
Also, knowing how little to leave in the joint can be a feature of the woods used, and the
situation. A lot of cabinetry is directionally loaded. A drawer, versus a box, so one can make
biases to the strengths of different parts. So yeah, it could also be efficient. But keeping in
mind we have the internet, video, and books, and are just communicating these thoughts 40
years into the craft resurrection, it seems possible that carpenters in a jealous time did not have
this information or the desire to use it, while joiners had their tricks.