New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Historical techniques in modern furniture

Posts

Historical techniques in modern furniture

#1

Historical techniques in modern furniture

Bill Tindall

There are puzzling practices to be found in modern wood working whose modern explanations seem lacking. I have come to the conclusion that some are vestigial, a result of what used to be done with the tools of the day. To speculate on two examples, and a question about English Dovetails......

Haunched mortise and tenon: The explanation for this joint in modern woodworking just doesn't make any structural sense. However, if we think how a M&T joint for a frame and panel was made in days of old, the haunched tenon is a logical consequence. The groove for the panel was plowed in the stile with a plane and the haunch filled the gap from this operation. It had nothing to do with engineering and everything to do with convenience.

Drawer runners inlet to the case sides: If one contemplates how to hand cut dovetails for drawer blades the most efficient approach is to first plow a dado across the case and then enlarge the front and back for the tail socket for the dovetailed blade. This approach leaves a dado across the case side to be filled by the drawer runner. Again, the inlet runner is a consequence of technique not a meaningful structural improvement. Drawer runners simply nailed to case sides have lasted for centuries.

Skinny English Dovetails: I think this style was not about style at all but some consequence of how they were made or the material or tools employed. Note these are made in thin oak drawer sides. There were made by the millions in production shop environments, an environment more interested in efficiency than making a statement inside a case where the joint is not normally seen. Can you think of some practical (efficiency) reason for making these skinny dovetails as opposed to larger ones? Alan Batty(the English turner) who worked in a shop making drawers would know but the email address I have for him is invalid.

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#2

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

Dean J in MN

On the skinny DTs -- for one, clearing the waste of the "pin-hole" is quite fast. With a 1/16" or 1/8" chisel you really don't even need a mallet, just push with your shoulder and the waste pops out. Making the tail waste just a little bit larger doesn't really add a significant amount of time in clearing that waste, so I think you are correct Bill, this was an efficiency (which may have been a pleasant side effect of an aesthetic or visa versa).

I'm not sure I agree on the housed DT drawer blades. Yes, nailed runners last a long time, but it really isn't any harder to cut a sliding DT on a drawer blade with or without a dado. And the shoulder of of that dado is supporting the runner which is a nice benefit. But, you may well be correct, as the dado serves to align the blades without a lot of layout. I place my case sides front-to-front, nail on a fence, and cut the dado. So that may be the efficiency here, serving to make a matching left and right case side, and not speeding up the DT joint?

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#3

Leo Cuellar

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture *LINK*

Leo Cuellar

Hey, Bill, didn't know if you'd heard, but I remembered seeing this short thread on the round side about Alan Batty having recently had a stroke. There is an address where you might be able to contact him.


Alan Batty thread

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#4

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

TD

"Haunched mortise and tenon: The explanation for this joint in modern woodworking just

doesn't make any structural sense."

I'm not sure what you mean here, but if you are referring to the idea that it is said to maintain

alignment of the parts out to the edge, and otherwise control rackingI don't think that is untrue.

It would be particularly valid in the modern context where there is little to guarantee that the

parts will be quartered. I don't like haunches, so I share your distain, but so long as experience

shows the joint part is strong enough, then the haunch is not useless.

" However, if we think how a M&T joint for a frame and panel was made in days of old, the

haunched tenon is a logical consequence. The groove for the panel was plowed in the stile with

a plane and the haunch filled the gap from this operation."

Well myself, I always found this detail on modern furniture, and thought it arose from the need

to run these parts on a table saw, or a shaper.

"It had nothing to do with engineering and everything to do with convenience."

Well whatever the dominant reason may be, the subsidiary reason still exists.

"Drawer runners inlet to the case sides: If one contemplates how to hand cut dovetails for

drawer blades the most efficient approach"

There is evidence that in the past inefficiency was viewed as a positive good. This kind of

thing still exists, think of those droopy pants people wear, or the Japanese overt preference for

gifts that operate on the motto, "it's the price that counts". So the most efficient means to the

high value product was the most inefficient technique possible. The only real economic problem is whether you have the market. When one considers the huge amount of work to be done, anything that spikes the price is a small price to pay as a craftsman, if you can get the price in your market. For instance it is much more expensive to buy guitars made of rosewood. And it can be slightly more difficult to work. But it is a huge upcharge, so the inefficiency pays for itself.

" is to first plow a dado across the case and then enlarge the front and back for the tail socket

for the dovetailed blade."

The most efficient method in that case would be to saw the dovetail, plow the groove, then

clean out the dovetail.

"This approach leaves a dado across the case side to be filled by the drawer runner. Again, the

inlet runner is a consequence of technique not a meaningful structural improvement. Drawer

runners simply nailed to case sides have lasted for centuries."

What does "a consequence of technique" mean. It may have been an available technique, but it

isn't faster than nailing. It is certainly a structural improvement, without doubt. The idea that

some nailed rails have survived is only relevant if you have numbers for all the cases, and how

they all failed, not just that a few survived somewhere. And in any case a structural

improvement that is not relied upon is still a structural improvement.

"Skinny English Dovetails: I think this style was not about style at all but some consequence of

how they were made or the material or tools employed."

You might be right, but there seems to be ample historic evidence that there was a style

difference, or almost a guild difference. I am not the keeper of that kind of thing, but I see no

immediate reason to doubt it.

"Note these are made in thin oak drawer sides."

point being?

"There were made by the millions in production shop environments, an environment more

interested in efficiency than making a statement inside a case where the joint is not normally

seen."

Efficiency is not what it is today, think of the Baker's dozen example, the punishment both in

the marketplace, and the law was pretty severe, I don't think one can simply make modern

statements about this stuff as though 2011 rules apply. But efficiency is always a part of it.

" Can you think of some practical (efficiency) reason for making these skinny dovetails as

opposed to larger ones? Alan Batty(the English turner) who worked in a shop making drawers

would know but the email address I have for him is invalid."

The fact that something is a style is not exclusive of the idea that it is efficient also. Part of the

style statement can be that we have the skill to execute in this style. That is in fact the ultimate

in efficiency and differentiation, you get a toofer, exclusivity/respect, and cheapness. Crafts

are full of examples like that. There are arty decoration on modern day bowls that look

complex but take less time than clear finish. Or signature carvings that are a few strokes for the

skilled, but give a piece value.

In the narrow dovetail example, the tails are super fast to cut. They can be cut out with two

blows of the hammer. This then leaves the receiving piece, normally half blind in those days

whether a drawer or case. Two features there. One, you have more room to get the half blind

socket cleaned out. You have more material to remove, but it is easy to do so, since you have

space. Two, the half blind means that while I would not expect and expert to make a mess of it, the

worked surfaces can't be seen.

Also, knowing how little to leave in the joint can be a feature of the woods used, and the

situation. A lot of cabinetry is directionally loaded. A drawer, versus a box, so one can make

biases to the strengths of different parts. So yeah, it could also be efficient. But keeping in

mind we have the internet, video, and books, and are just communicating these thoughts 40

years into the craft resurrection, it seems possible that carpenters in a jealous time did not have

this information or the desire to use it, while joiners had their tricks.

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#5

without getting into a lot of stuff

Larry Williams

I find haunched tenons functional and a huge benefit. You have an area around the tenon that, with just a little movement over time, can become a gap. In things like architectural doors, haunched tenons are critical for that reason. The haunch seals any small void caused by movement of the stile or rail. Haunched tenons also prevent light from showing through small voids around the joint which are likely to appear over time and can even help make small flaws in shoulder fits less noticeable.

In my spare time, I'm some replacement sash for my 100+ year-old house. I wouldn't consider making them without haunched tenons.

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#6

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think you are on the right track here, Bill. Historic work was designed with both strength and method of construction in mind. That is why it is often more efficient to make reproductions with hand work (the techniques they were designed for) rather than machines- machine work is designed differently. And trade practices sometimes persist beyond their usefulness and they did in the former eras as well.

I'm not sure I agree with all your examples. For instance a haunched tenon is sometimes helpful, sometimes not. However I do agree with your main line of thinking. It also happens that craftsmen abandon good old practices which they are not able to appreciate or understand.

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#7

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

wilbur

The first time I went to a SAPFM meeting, I was struck by the amount of work that went into making a jig to allow a router to add a traditional detail, when the same task could have been done with hand tool methods with much less effort.

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#8

exciting last 24 hours of weather

Bill Tindall

Thanks for the insight. Now that the weather has cleared my computer is back on.

We were in a gap of the tornado spawning cells and came out ok but there is death and destruction all around here. Our weather is typically benign, but not yesterday. I haven't been waked up by tornado warnings since I left MN.

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#10

thanks for the insight

Bill Tindall

As I moved toward making more historically inspired pieces I have been drifting to your line of thinking with out realizing it. Indeed, I find the best way to make a precise dovetailed drawer divider is to make it the way they were made historically.

I was in a class where I encountered my first requirement of a dovetailed drawer divider and asked to be shown how they were historically made. One instructor showed me while the other set up a router, etc for the others. We were done first! That was a epiphanal moment for someone motivated by getting on with a prorject.

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#11

The devastation in your neck of the woods

Bruce, a MN Galoot

is mind-boggling. I'm glad to hear that you've escaped the carnage.

We haven't had to worry about tornado warnings in the middle of the night. Last night, Mpls got snow. Uffda!

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#12

Re: exciting last 24 hours of weather

Dean J in MN

Glad to hear you escaped any damage/harm. It looks like some wild weather.

-D

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#13

Re: exciting last 24 hours of weather

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Impressive storms, a couple hundred people actually died. The avenging earth has opened up the spigot.

Pam

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#14

17 dead in our area

Bill Tindall

Dozens injured. We never get tornadoes so people were not prepared for them. One F2 leveled an 8 mile stretch. Tractor trailers were stacked at a truck stop. It blew the gas pumps off their moorings and out into the parking lot.

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#15

David Barnett

The earth avenges nothing...

David Barnett

...but it is fun being colossally and poetically anthropomorphic now and then.

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#16

Re: 17 dead in our area

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Spooky. In Alabama the earth had been soaked by Monday's storms, so lots of trees were uprooted, very messy and scarry.

Pam

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#17

Re: The earth avenges nothing...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I guess I'm sympathetic with the idea that systems of things can gather intent. Whether that's anthropomorphic or not, I don't know; and actually, it doesn't seem to matter. Dead is dead, regardless of whether the storm meant to hurt or not, so why not have a little fun with brain games.

Pam

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#18

David Barnett

Re: The earth avenges nothing...

David Barnett

Truth be told, I'm sympathetic to that notion, as well. Sometimes, at least. I just get queasy when ascribing retribution to Gaia belittles the undeservedly affected, but I guess that edges on theology, which sure as hell isn't my bailiwick. If you can't have a little irony, though, what's the point?

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#19

Re: The earth avenges nothing...

Bob Hackett

I think that if the Earth were in an avenging mode it would start with things such as coal mines that cut the tops off mountains and push them into surrounding valleys,open pit mines,clear cut logging operations and factories that dump pollutants into the atmosphere and water unchecked.

I do think that Gaia is more likely to act like a dog with too many parasites on board and just randomly start removing them. Things like the weather and geological disturbances makes an effective set of teeth to start the removal process.

Having lived in "Tornado alley" and having seen up close the devastation these storms can bring my heart goes out to those people who`s lives have been turned upside down by loss. When the Earth decides to turn it`s fury loose none of us are safe.

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#20

David Barnett

Re: The earth avenges nothing...

David Barnett

The flea and tick paradigm works for me, Bob.

Just like Gaia to get all 'ticked' off at North Slope drilling operations and then take it out on Haiti.

From the Gaia Green & Blue Planet Songbook

You better watch out,

You better not cry,

You better not pout,

I'm telling you why,

Mother Earth is coming to town.

She's making a list,

And checking it twice,

Gonna find out who's naughty and nice,

Mother Earth is coming to town.

She sees you when you're sleeping,

She knows when you're awake,

She knows if you've been bad or good,

So be good for goodness sake!

O! You better watch out,

You better not cry,

You better not pout,

I'm telling you why,

Mother Earth is coming to town.



When I was growing up in St. Louis, a tornado took one of my school friends just one block away. My family slept through the whole thing, storm sirens and all. Our block, untouched. A block away, sticks. Just sticks.

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#21

Re: 17 dead in our area

TD

This is certainly tragic, and if I recall correctly, on the back of a previous set of of violent storms.

Uprooted wise, this is a great opportunity for the chainsaw mill equipt. Though there are so many opportunities it doesn't make that much difference. A few hiricanes ago people in florida noticed there were rosewoods being bowled over, and they got right busy.

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#22

Re: 17 dead in our area

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yes, it is tragic to die in a storm, seems so unnecessary these days.

"rosewoods down"

It appears that earth can even avenge our sustainable forest laws. (:

Pam

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#23

Heck, even Minnesota

Bruce, a MN Galoot

had an earthquake last night, a little bitty 2.4, which Bill assures me wouldn't even make the papers in CA.

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#24

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

Sgian Dubh

Haunched M&Ts. The haunch is of limited use where there is no groove to fill. I will use a haunch where there isn't a groove in some circumstances. For instance, if the front faces of a leg and rail (or other structure) are flush. The haunch helps keep them flush because it reduces the chance of misalignment later if either part tries to cup or shrink-- see sketch below. The haunch can be square or sloping (secret) depending on the preferred appearance. A haunch can also help prevent daylight showing through a joint if the shoulder line opens up a bit in use due to shrinkage, racking, etc.

Photobucket

I don't understand the question about let in drawer runners-- a sketch would help here.

Skinny drawer dovetails. There are I believe both aesthetic and practical reasons for making very fine dovetails. They suited the taste of those that purchased fine furniture for one. Secondly, typical British practice is to cut the tails first and the pins second. The only exception to this is in executing secret mitre and secret lap dovetailing where the pins must be cut first so that the marks can be transferred across to the tails�it�s impossible to do the job the other way around.

Anyway, cutting the tails first at the front of a drawer side I suspect was done by eye rather than by measure. By that I mean the worker would start from the outside edges of the side, cut the rakes to accommodate the half pins there. Then he would eyeball the centre point of the front edge of the drawer side and cut a rake for the one tail, withdraw the saw and, using the same kerf as a starting point, cut the opposing rake for the next dovetail- this saves having to start a new kerf. Subsequent spacing would continue with eyeballing half between each tail until the job was adjudged complete. I do this myself quite frequently, although on a wide drawer side I will often measure and mark the centre point to get started.

I seldom set out the rakes of tails and just angle the saw a bit� it�s worked well enough for me for quite some time now. I just kind of know how much space I need to leave at the root of the tails to get a chisel in to pop the waste out. Slainte.

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

#25

Re: Historical techniques in modern furniture

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Welcome back, Richard. I don't understand exactly what you're saying here:

Anyway, cutting the tails first at the front of a drawer side I suspect was done by eye rather than by measure. By that I mean the worker would start from the outside edges of the side, cut the rakes to accommodate the half pins there. Then he would eyeball the centre point of the front edge of the drawer side and cut a rake for the one tail, withdraw the saw and, using the same kerf as a starting point, cut the opposing rake for the next dovetail- this saves having to start a new kerf. Subsequent spacing would continue with eyeballing half between each tail until the job was adjudged complete. I do this myself quite frequently, although on a wide drawer side I will often measure and mark the centre point to get started.

If you're cutting tails first, why do you start with rakes (which I'd interpret as angled horizontally, which tails aren't)? And why do you start the first full tail in the center? And how does withdrawing the saw and using the same kerf even do anything useful (this implies cutting the same kerf again)? I agree that starting with tails is the easiest way to freehand dovetail joints; but I have a real problem reconciling what you say you're doing with how I actually do it.

Pam