New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

Posts

Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

#1

Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

One of our two persimmon trees appears to be dying. We cut it back pretty fiercely (probably completely killing it in the process -we'll see), and I wound up with some short pieces of trunk.

I've dried some before, but smaller pieces, and it seems to go gray but get very hard. So maybe not such a good furniture wood. It appears that it's a fairly shock-resistant wood - since one of its historical uses was in golf clubs.

I'm wondering if I should cut these pieces up as stock for chisel handles down the line? One online reference I read said that it's best to dry it in log form -- too late, I cut the pieces I have in half.

Anyone have any experience with persimmon?

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

#2

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

David Weaver

I have no idea how it dries (as in how much bigger the blanks need to be wet than they'll need be to get a good workable damage-free spot out of)...

but I can't see why it wouldn't be a great chisel handle wood, definitely worth trying.

If it turns out to be brittle, you can always hoop the ends.

The only bit I've worked with it was thicknessing some resawn boards to make boxing for a plane. getting toward an eighth, it was a bear to plane or scrape (it's dry) just because of the combination of the (lack of) thickness and the hardness. It was one of the few times where I really thought having a small infill plane really made a big difference in how easy it was to get a job done. Pretty easy with it, miserable without it.

Mine also has the coloration you talk about, but I have a bunch of it in 4/4 thickness. I'll bet it would finish to a nice smooth surface off a lathe and be pretty nice in the hand.

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

#3

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Bill, in the eastern states our persimmon is Diospyros virginiana. Diospyros is the ebony genus. Our wood is very hard, fine grained, and takes a nice polish and lustre. It is a fine wood for turning and tool handles. I have split green wood for seasoning and I use a persimmon mallet for carving. It was the wood used for wood golf club heads. I think our wood may get darker if it is left in log form. You may have an oriental persimmon, maybe the widely cultivated Diospyros kaki, which I would expect to have similar qualities.

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

#4

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

Stephen Shepherd

'One online reference I read said that it's best to dry it in log form -- too late, I cut the pieces I have in half.'

I was under the impression that all fruit and nut woods season best if quartered [or halved] and not allowed to dry in the round. And persimmon is a tasty fruit.

Stephen

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

#5

Sounds like a good material to me...

John in NM

But I don't have any actual experience with it. I would certainly try it though, if such things would grow out here.

I've made mallet heads out of Emory oak (named for an army leutenant, not emery in reference to hardness, though it is hard enough to warrant either name :D ). For fun I dried them in the round and turned the heads around the center of the branch.

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

#6

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I'd sure give it a try. I just read Remarkable Plants of Texas, and the two persimmon descriptions made me want to go out and find some seeds/seedlings.

Pam

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

#7

Texas persimmon

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Pam, I would be interested in which persimmon you see in Austin area. I have never seen Texas persimmon and I think it is only found in Texas. Our common persimmon seems be native to the eastern part of Texas at least. The common persimmon has small orange fruits (about 1 1/4") and the Texas persimmon has purple or black fruits.

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

#8

Chris Scholz

Re: Texas persimmon

Chris Scholz

Check out the Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center

http://www.wildflower.org/

From there we learn that the Texas persimmon (aka. Mexican persimmon, Black persimmon, Chapote, Chapote prieto) is the common name for diospyros texana

http://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=DITE3

If I remember correctly the Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower center has a few Texas persimmons in their gardens and I believe you can see a few in the Fort Worth Botanical Garden, too.

All persimmons I found in nurseries were grafted, might have to grow from seeds. I hear the make decent pensai, too.

Chris

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

#9

Re: Texas persimmon

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I don't know that I ever have seen any persimmons anywhere, but I plan to keep an eye out for the dark fruit, the blossoms and fruit look distinctive. Maybe I should start taking a camera to the dog park.

Apparently eastern Texas is the southwest boundary for the eastern/common persimmon. In Austin, we're at the meeting point of the black prairie and high plains, just two or three miles west of my house, neither of which qualify like the pine woods starting 30-40 miles east or the swamps 100+ miles east.

There is a stand of Osage Orange on both sides of a creek/drainage ditch that I walk through most every day. They all look like they'll fall into the bed during the next high water, but they don't; and I can't seem to interest the dogs into chasing the oranges.

Pam

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

#10

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

The persimon I have came from a standing dead tree in the Santa Cruz mountians (high rainfall area) I hae no clue what variety it is but it does have the typical greyish streaked coloring with a very small heart of pure black. It is hard when cutting with a saw or chisel but it dents fairly easily with a thumb nail.

My prefered wood for chisel handels and mallets is chinese elm. I turn my handles with a round butt so they are comfortable to push with the palm and the wood is tough enough that I can strike it with a mallet and not slpinter or deform. My mallet is of the round type and it shows no wear from repeated strikes on the domed end of a handle. Ive tried black locust, white oak, madrone, mullberry, purple heart, walnut, beech, rock elm, hickoy, ash, cherry, and yew and Chinese elm is the hands down winner.

Robin

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

#11

Re: Chinese elm *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I read about the genetic makeup of Dutch Elm resistant elms in DC last night. I thought it interesting, especially since it involves something called the Southern Elm.

BTW, is Chinese Elm available in the US?

Pam


Dutch Elm resistant elms

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

#12

Stephen Shepherd

Chinese elm is a weed tree that grows everywhere.

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

#13

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

Blue

It makes a good walkin' stick, er, cane.

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

#14

Re: Chinese elm

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Chinese elm was planted as a wind break in the northern plains in the late '40's and early '50's - these rows or trees were called "shelter belts," as a soil conservation measure. Thousands of miles were planted - they're all over North and South Dakota. Unfortunately, they have a relatively short lifespan of 50-60 years, so they're also dying all over the place. The next time I go home I'll try to get some. I've been meaning to try it myself. It has highly interlocked grain, which is probably what makes it so tough. A chunk might make it your way in June.

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

#15

Re: Chinese elm

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

That would be cool, a nice mallet, a few chisel handles. After looking it up, I think I've probably seen some around here, will keep and eye out while looking for persimmon; although even if I find one or two, it might be a bit difficult to cut down from someone else's yard. :)

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

#16

Re: Chinese elm

Warren in Lancaster, PA

There are two oriental elms called "Chinese elm"

1. Ulmus pumila Chinese elm, Siberian elm. This tree is rather like our American elm with ridged bark.

2. Ulmus parvifolia Chinese elm, Lacebark elm. This tree has very small leaves and mottled bark somewhat like sycamore.

I don't know which Robin uses, but I am pretty certain it is the first that you are thinking of, Bruce. It was widely planted when the American elms started dying. Lacebark elm does better in a warmer climate, although we have both in Pennsylvania and I think both grow in California. In Botany class I was taught the name Chinese elm for U. pumila, but lately I have seen claims that this name should only apply to the other. It will remain confusing for quite some time.

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

#17

Re: Chinese elm

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I think it's the latter, Warren, based on your description of the leaves. They are decidedly smaller than most.

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

#18

I love persimmon

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

Not only is it quite hard and fine grained, but it shapes with a rasp better than any domestic I can think of. It really is a joy to work and is certainly up to the chisel handle task. I have a dozen persimmon chisel handles with no problems.

Drying the wood is another issue. It moves as much as any wood I have tried to dry, and my experience covers most domestics that grow in my area. I had a crotch piece dry into a 90 degree angle. Cut the pieces you want to dry extra large in every dimension so you can have room for dealing with waste.

Here is what I made from the persimmon hockey stick crotch:


img

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

#19

Chris Scholz

Yu mu (Northern Elm) and Ju Mu (Southern Elm)...

Chris Scholz

...are common woods for traditional Chinese furniture.

Considered softwood often used as base for lacquered furniture or used for lower grade furniture.

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

#20

Re: Yu mu (Northern Elm) and Ju Mu (Southern Elm).

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

How does that correspond to mallets and chisel handles?

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

#21

Re: Yu mu (Northern Elm) and Ju Mu (Southern Elm).

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Chris, neither of the trees you mention is commonly planted in the United States. Yu mu is an elm, either Ulmus sinensis or Ulmus davidiana. Ju mu is in the elm family, but not a true elm. It is Zelkova schneideriana. Zelkovas are very popular as bonsais because they have small twigs and small leaves

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

#22

Diversity within tree varieties

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

That (your information coupled with Warren's confirmation that one of the two is a true elm) is very interesting, given that the elm species native to the eastern U.S. was considered robust enough to serve as the hub for wagon wheels.

We used to have a Siberian elm (not sure that it was ulmus pumila, but think it was) near the house. After reading of the characteristics of the elms of the eastern U.S., including interlocked grain that made it perfect for wagon hubs, I found it hard to believe at first that it could be an elm: dead straight grain in the trunk, split easily. A fairly hard wood when it dried. Also an interesting wood that I wish I'd managed to save some of - but we had small children and way more things to do than time.

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

#23

That is one spectacular piece of wood and

Bruce, a MN Galoot

the box is pretty darn good, too! What are the dimensions? Is it solid or wrapped around?

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

#24

Gorgeous.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Persimmon wood as a chisel handle material

#25

Re: That is one spectacular piece of wood and

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

Thank you.

The box is maybe 10" long with african blackwood and holly accents. I resawed and bookmatched the persimmon so each corner matches. Sides are under 3/8" thick.

The smokey coloring of the persimmon is typical but the figuring is the crotch bonus. Top is another crotch piece and opens by pushing down at either end. Buffed shellac finish. Persimmon, like ebony, polishes up beautifully, which is why I showed it.

Funny, but as much as it moves when drying, persimmon seems well behaved once in service.