New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

Posts

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#26

Re: Ah... the fragrance

Bob Hackett

Even cutting bone will usually get a co-worker`s attention. I`ve used it on high wear areas of tools like wood spokeshaves and it`s something you really have to want to do. :^(

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#27

Re: I don't understand

Ron Hock

That's basically how it was done in the day. Iron bars were sealed in a long cylinder with carbonaceous material packed in around them (bones, etc.) The whole thing was left on a fire for many hours so that the wrought iron would absorb the carbon. As to the temperature, I honestly don't know how hot it would need to be. The closer to critical temp (1450F for simple high-carbon steel) the more freely the carbon moves about. I was cautioned many years ago to move quickly through the diy heat treatment process as the carbon starts to burn out at about 1200F, even though you have to wait for 1450F to soak and quench. No dawdling.

I've often wondered, in the case of laminated/folded/layered/Damascus steels how much of the carbon migrates into the low-carbon layers from the high-carbon ones. Seems like all those heats would homogenize them to some extent.

Again, I'm stepping a little ways over the line into an area in which I'm not expert. Someone out there who knows more about historic steel-making should step in here and set straight my limited historical knowledge.

Oh, and Pam, I kinda think that there are better ways of adding carbon to steel than by dissolving diamonds into it. I also have this hunch that CPM3V has all the carbon it needs. Good luck with the grinding wheels. Let us know how they work for you.

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#28

Talk about a closed system!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

So, when making a (horse)shoe rasp, you'd be using the very product that your tool will generate when it's done.

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#29

Re: Talk about a closed system!

Ron Hock

And with a methane digester you could use other by-products from said horse to make the heat...

I got those Foxfire books around here somewhere...

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#30

Re: I don't understand

Larry Williams

Ron,

I understand the cementation process but we're talking about open atmosphere grinding. Any fine particle carbon will be long gone before it reaches 1450� F. Fine particles of carbon will literally vanish into thin air, oxidize to carbon monoxide or carbon dioxide, before it gets to 1300�. This diamonds dissolving into steel during grinding just can't be right, I'm sure it's a myth.

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#31

Re: I don't understand

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Oh, and Pam, I kinda think that there are better ways of adding carbon to steel than by dissolving diamonds into it. I also have this hunch that CPM3V has all the carbon it needs. Good luck with the grinding wheels. Let us know how they work for you.

You're probably right on both counts, and I certainly will.

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#32

Re: I don't understand

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

How would you (dis)prove this? Odormeter? Steel assay?

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#33

easier than that

Larry Williams

I'd assume the people who've been dressing grinding wheels with diamond dressers and the manufacturers who made those dressers for more than a century have done more than I ever could to prove this.

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#34

Re: easier than that

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Good point. I bought my first diamond dresser from LV this week.

However, this brings up another point: How do you dress a diamond wheel? Or is this not an issue?

Pam

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#35

You don't dress 'em

Larry Williams

The diamonds are in a nickel matrix that's electroplated over the diamonds. This is thin and the soft nickel is intended to wear away to expose the fresh diamond cutting edges as the individual crystalline layers of each diamond spall away after getting so dull they fracture. The nickel wears away by abrasion from the granular swarf from what you're grinding. Materials like carbides, glass or stone will generate the granular swarf. If you grind steel or other metals, the swarf will be tiny shavings and not granular. Stringy swarf from most metals quickly wears away the nickel and it undermines the diamonds. You'll wear out a wheel very quickly if you grind metals these wheels weren't intended to grind. At least that's the way the tech rep for the company that makes the wheels for our grinder explained it to me when I called to see if the expensive wheels I ruined in a few minutes of grinding were in some way defective. I don't grind steel on our diamond grinder any more.

BTW; when you use your diamond dresser, keep the heat issue in mind. It'll last a lot longer if you use a very light touch and never force things. It'll cut plenty quickly with a little finesse, just let it do the work.

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#36

Re: You don't dress 'em

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Thanks, Larry, sounds like diamond wheels are totally inappropriate for my uses.

On the dresser, I'm too cheap to cram it onto the wheel, barely touching is more my style.

Pam