New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

Posts

Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#1

Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

Doug Trembath

I happen to have two 6" X 1-1/2" Lapcraft 180 grit diamond lapidary wheels. As far as I know they're unused. I "inherited" them years ago on a Baldor grinder I bought.

Anyone have a use for them? The Lapcraft site lists them at $169 each new.

I thought if there was any interest I'd put them up for a WC Benefit Auction. Hard to know if they would be an appropriate donation, considering they're lapidary wheels, but I gotta help Ellis any way I can.

Link is below, select Diamond Wheels on the Home Page.

Any thoughts?

Doug Trembath


http://www.lapcraft.com/

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#2

NOT an April Fools Joke, guys and dolls...

Doug Trembath

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#3

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Based on price, this is a 6" X 1-1/2" 180 grit?

Do you have the bushings for different arbors?

Pam

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#4

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels...

Doug Trembath

Sure do, Pam, down to 1/2".

Doug Trembath

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#5

If the question is: would someone bid?

Chuck Nickerson

The answer is yes, I would.

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#6

I might, too, but there's no entry in Benefits.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#7

OK, great!

Doug Trembath

I'll put it in now...

Doug Trembath

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#8

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels...

Ron Hock

Before anyone thinks these wheels will solve their sharpening/grinding problems take note from Lapcraft's website: Always use coolant when grinding with diamond wheels. Always wear safety glasses. Do not exceed 2000 RPM spindle speed.

Safety glasses goes without saying but the other two caveats should not be ignored. I don't know what happens if you exceed the spindle speed but I did learn why coolant is so important when grinding steel with diamonds. As the steel approaches red-heat it will begin to dissolve the diamonds into the steel. That's an expensive way of adding carbon to steel, btw, and the reason cubic boron-nitride is used for grinding steel instead of diamond.

These wheels would be a great addition to the sharpening station assuming you can keep them slow and cool. (I use a flat diamond lap on a platter-type sharpener. It works great (slow and cool) and saves a lot of abrasive discs.)

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#9

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Thanks, Ron, might be kind of fun melting some diamonds. :)

However, I plan to use a diamond wheel for gross shaping of CPM 3V. Will your cautions still be in effect?

Pam

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#10

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels...

Doug Trembath

I doubt these would be helpful in that regard, Pam. Diamonds are great for honing, much less effective in shaping. These are lapidary wheels. I haven't done any lapidary work since the early '70's, but we used coolant (and lubrication) with all of the cutting and shaping tools we had. Actually, they were just drum sanders, if you will, with different grades of abrasive, all running in a water container, and your hands were always wet.

Diamond wheels, for honing, are great to put that last refinement on an edge, similar to the ones currently popular among the turning community, but they can only be used effectively for that last little touch-up, the equivalent of stropping. Not so much for shaping. I'd look at something else for shaping metal, like a good quality abrasive belt, or just careful attention at the grinder.

Doug Trembath

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#11

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Thanks, Doug, can I take back my bid? :)

Pam

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#12

Grinder in a box!

anotherBob

http://www.polarbearforge.com/grinder_kit_parts.html

Pam, I made my own belt grinder before I saw this one... it's powered by a treadmill motor. If not this one or one that you cobble together, maybe Craigslist... they are unbelievably useful, can't imagine not having one now. Definitely worth a small spot space-wise in your shop if you want to do any grinding/shaping, and again it doesn't have to be expensive!

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#13

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)

David Barnett

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#14

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels...

Ron Hock

I see you've already talked yourself out of the diamond wheels, Pam, so this is moot. But, in case someone is looking for an answer to your question, it's yes, 3V will dissolve diamond at temperature. CPM3V is still steel (mostly iron) and steel is happy to accommodate carbon (up to a point of saturation which I believe is around 3% C.)

The diamond/steel caveat only applies to grinding steel with diamond at red-heat. Powered diamond grinding is used mostly for rocks and gem stones (lapidary) and cutting concrete, etc.

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#15

I don't understand

Larry Williams

"...an answer to your question, it's yes, 3V will dissolve diamond at temperature..."

I don't understand this. I'm not sure what critical temperature of 3V is but diamonds, natural or synthetic, oxidize or auto-ignite at 700� C or just under 1300� F. Diamonds are carbon fuel just like coal and should burn off in a normal atmosphere long before steel reaches a temperature where the carbon can fluidly flow through it.

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#16

Re: I don't understand

Ron Hock

Without stepping too far over the line that separates what I know from what I don't know, I suspect that the reported absorption of carbon from the diamond into the steel happens as the grinding temperature approaches the kindling temperature of the diamond. It is my understanding that carbon begins to move as steel begins to glow, at around 1200F. If diamond burns at 1400F, that's 200 degrees' worth of reason to use CBN for grinding steel instead of diamond.

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#17

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Actually, I haven't completely talked myself out of the diamond wheel. The problem here is that I think I'm planning too far in advance, because of the availability of the diamond wheel at a potentially good price.

On one end of my lathe I've installed a double ended mandrel with stepped speed adjustment, which provides a pretty good set of options for buffing, grinding, and turning; so I doubt that using a diamond wheel is impossible. And, after all, 3V is cut by diamond.

I'm willing to try several things before deciding how I'll proceed. Also, I'm not dismissing your advice, not by any measure. If I do get a diamond wheel, I'll be sure to rotate it slow enough to avoid red heat; although, my twisted mind wonders whether it might add something good to 3V tools to have more carbon melded into it.

Pam

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#18

Re: I don't understand

Larry Williams

So making steel from iron involves only heating the iron to 1200� with a little coal?

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#19

Re: Grinder in a box!

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Thanks, Bob, I've bookmarked this honey for future consideration. I know a belt grinder is too large for my shop as it is now, about all I can handle is an upside down belt sander, not permanently vise mounted.

Pam

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#20

Re: Grinder In a Box, indeed.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yeah, right now it looks like it never ends; but hey, if my process for making the first chisel or two doesn't work, it can be amended. I'm in no particular hurry.

Pam

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#21

Re: I don't understand

Larry Williams

I've been searching for anything about this and I'm coming to the realization diamonds aren't absorbed by the steel. I think knife makers, who seem to like thaumaturgy as much as some woodworkers, didn't understand they burned up their diamonds, e.g. converted them to carbon monoxide/carbon dioxide, and decided the diamonds had magically dissolved into the steel they were grinding.

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#22

Re: I don't understand

darin

Neither graphite nor diamond melt when heated - at a temperature of about 4800 �C, they sublime into gases. It takes a lot of energy to make them sublime as many strong covalent bonds need to be broken.

So what is happening at 2000 degrees?

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#23

David Barnett

I think Ron's right. Let me clarify (hopefully).

David Barnett

We're not talking about melting or vaporizing diamond, not sublimation, but simple absorption.

Ron Hock said:

"I don't know what happens if you exceed the spindle speed but I did learn why coolant is so important when grinding steel with diamonds. As the steel approaches red-heat it will begin to dissolve the diamonds into the steel."

Then Larry Williams said:

"I've been searching for anything about this and I'm coming to the realization diamonds aren't absorbed by the steel."

...concluding from his less-than-fulfilling search that diamond is perhaps not absorbed into steel.

Ron adds:

"As the steel approaches red-heat it will begin to dissolve the diamonds into the steel. That's an expensive way of adding carbon to steel, btw"

Larry, Darin...

Diamond is absorbed into iron, readily so -- converting iron into steel. Furthermore, it's absorbed into steel*, thereby increasing its carbon content if the steel is not heated to the point of decarburization. This is pretty much high school chemistry, or at least it was when I was in high school. Pretty basic stuff.

From the Encyclopedia Britannica:

"...like charcoal, diamond converts soft iron into steel."

http://tinyurl.com/diamond-absorbed-into-iron

Larry theorizes:

"I think knife makers, who seem to like thaumaturgy as much as some woodworkers, didn't understand they burned up their diamonds, e.g. converted them to carbon monoxide/carbon dioxide, and decided the diamonds had magically dissolved into the steel they were grinding."

I took this as being wryly tongue-in-cheek, as I'm fairly sure Larry gives due credit to the many bladesmiths who demonstrate specialized knowledge in their handling of blade steels, whether thaumaturgically transmuted or otherwise -- hardly a group ignorant of basic metallurgical processes. As for thaumaturgy-loving woodworkers, I wouldn't mind transmuting some of my Brazilian Pepper Trees into some nice buxus sempervirens.

All silliness aside, though...

What's really happening is that the diamond grit is sinking into the wheel substrate when it reaches temperatures that soften the plating (nickel alloy) that embeds it, which is what Ron meant by 'dissolves'.

*Of course, as soon as iron has absorbed carbon, it's technically steel. What I meant here is that steel, which is iron with carbon already in it, will readily absorb even more diamond into it, increasing that steel's carbon content at the site of absorption.

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#24

Riding the coat tails

Bob Hackett

The process that most blacksmiths and bladesmiths use to take iron and turn it into steel (blister steel to be exact) is to pack the iron into a closed container surrounded by carbon and then heat it in the forge till the carbon is absorbed into the surface of the metal,effectively case hardening it. The steel is then worked by forging it out,folding and forge welding the folded steel back onto itself into a solid mass again repeatedly in order to distribute the carbon throughout the material. Some folks know this as Damascus steel or pattern welded steel. When etched the layers can be seen without magnification. High dollar stuff.

A similar process was used to case harden rasps after the teeth were punched into them. One of the traditional materials used to pack around the rasps was hoof trimmings from animals. Bet that made the forge smoke smell wonderful.

Re: Speaking of Diamond Wheels... *LINK*

#25

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)

David Barnett