New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Opinions of Swan-Neck Chisels....

Posts

Opinions of Swan-Neck Chisels....

#1

Opinions of Swan-Neck Chisels....

roger lance

are these the tools to have for cleaning up the bottoms of a mortise after your hollow-chisel electron burning mortiser has done its thing ??....what size is necessary ??....1/4" or 3/8" or both or neither ??....what say you ??

Re: Opinions of Swan-Neck Chisels....

#2

Re: Opinions of Swan-Neck Chisels....

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I suppose that would do the trick if your electron burner has given up the ghost and if you absolutely insist on having the bottom neat. My tenons never reach the bottom of the mortise, so I don't care what it looks like. I always leave at least 1/32 - 1/16" gap, to account for glue and fit.

Re: Opinions of Swan-Neck Chisels....

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

Unnecessary

Jack Guzman from Maine

I've always thought that I could use one of those but never bothered to get one. For most mortises I just leave the bottom a little deep and don't need it very even or smooth down there. The one place I think it would be handy would be in mortising for an old style door latch mechanism. Those tend to be pretty deep and long and need to be fairly even at the bottom.However,I don't find myself doing much of that . Save your money and buy another more useful chisel.---Jack

Re: Opinions of Swan-Neck Chisels....

#4

Architectural mortise locks

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

And you're often working end grain at the bottom of the mortise, when installing a mortise-type lockset in a door. Takes a certain amount of cussing.

Re: Opinions of Swan-Neck Chisels....

#5

Stephen Shepherd

You don't often need one, however...

Stephen Shepherd

the smaller size is not a bad tool to have around. As the others have said the bottoms of mortises are not that critical, a good place for the hide glue to squeeze into.

But the chisel can come in handy for finishing off mortises that might be seen or if you are particularly particular. And any good or fairly good or even weak reason to buy another hand tool is always a good thing.

Stephen

Re: Opinions of Swan-Neck Chisels....

#6

Save your money

Todd Nebel

Hi Roger,

It's not a requirement to clean the bottom of the mortise. Like the others have said I too leave a small gap in the bottom of the mortise to save time and collect the glue squeeze. If there's another use for the chisel I haven't found it. Save your money or put it towards a different tool purchase.

Todd

Re: Opinions of Swan-Neck Chisels....

#7

Re: Opinions of Swan-Neck Chisels....

TomD

Depending on the proportions of your mortise, you can use a hand router plane, which is a far more useful tool. With a hollow chisel mortiser, your bottom is pretty well incised, so you don't need a lot of power to get it out. You can use the router plane with quite a lot of overhang.

Re: Opinions of Swan-Neck Chisels....

#8

Re: Empirical information

bugbear

Here in the UK I don't see these tools very often.

When I do, they show little wear.

Conclusion: not many people bought them, and those that did found little use for them.

BugBear

Re: Opinions of Swan-Neck Chisels....

#9

Alternatives

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Roger

99% of the time I do not think of a smoothed bottom for a mortice. What I do find useful is a chisel to remove some of the waste on the floor. I'd rather use a separate tool and save the sharp edge of the mortice chisel for chopping mortices. Dragging a chisel along the floor will dull it some.

I made a "chisel" out of a hex wrench ...


For that 1% of the time I need a smooth floor, then I use a router plane with a scraping blade, again made from a hex wrench ...


Pictorial: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/Scraper%20blade%20for%20the%20router%20plane.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Opinions of Swan-Neck Chisels....

#10

Re: Alternatives

TomD

That's a good one Derek. I was going to suggest making your own Japanese bottoming chisel. I do use those at times, and they are ideal in the already incised bottoms of mechanical mortises. It is a very easy tool to make, but I figured it would be just another suggestion with a zero chance of really helping out the poster. Using a hex key is a great idea though. Dick's used to sell a Japanese bottoming chisels that was made out of an integral knurled bar, very sturdy tool and one that could be forged pretty easily out of a variety of metal punches, such as are used for draw boring.

Re: Opinions of Swan-Neck Chisels....

#12

Re: Alternatives

TomD

I don't have anything for show an tell on this file. I did a fairly long search on the Dick's and JW sites before I posted, but they don't have the one I was interested in posting. There are lots of them in wooden handles. I can't post links, but a search of Bottom Cleaning Chisel (Sokozari Nomi) will bring up picks of what I use.

Re: Opinions of Swan-Neck Chisels....

#13

Sokozari Nomi

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Here's one:

I also use these "shoji" chisels for cleaning up mortises.

Pam

Re: Opinions of Swan-Neck Chisels....

#14

Re: Sokozari Nomi

TomD

That's the deal. I saw this one version that was full length integral steel. Not sure it wants to be that stout, but it did look solid. I wonder what a Chinese bottoming chisel looks like.

By the way. The set of chisels I got back in the early 80s was pretty cheap, no laminated surfaces, so I didn't twig for a while that the stupid things were supposed to be sharpened! :o

Re: Opinions of Swan-Neck Chisels....

#15

 

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX