New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Lacey Act

Posts

Lacey Act

#1

Lacey Act

TomD

I am starting to get wound up on this subject. Basically the act will affect you if you transport exotic woods (or ivory, shell, etc...) across US borders, or within the US, or are involved in trade of them. It creates responsibility to document origin of banned materials, so just because you know that wood in your Noris plane or sideboard is pre Lacey, you still have to be able to document each piece of wood. It can cause trouble for you even if you don't have banned materials, just stuff that looks banned. you could find yourself in forfeiture merely on their suspicion, resistance could lead to a costly legal struggle, destructive testing, etc... Non-resistance could lead to fines and notes on your file, or worse. So you could go down for that nice looking piece of Diamondwood.

In general this stuff doesn't affect me, on my woodworking side. I am not terribly tropically involved. I am more worried about my guitar and boat side. Think of that cheap indonesain underlayment you have in your house. :) But those of you who travel across borders to to summer shows or events, and have fancy handles on you chisels, or make pens, better watch out.

http://www.fretboardjournal.com/features/magazine/guitar-lover%E2%80%99s-guide-cites-conservation-treaty

Re: Lacey Act

#2

This is why government is hard . . .

CJ in MPLS

We are a big enough nation that no policy or regulation will always have a good outcome. There are just too many variations. Writing these things to cover what should be covered without covering what shouldn't is difficult.

I'm working on learning how to export controlled defense articles at work these days and it is maddening. The only way I'm able to not blow my top and cancel the project is to remember why the ITAR regulations are in place to begin with.

On another note, I just flew from Chicago to MPLS this last Thursday and apparently the TSA agents were having a bit of a tiff that worked its way out by having the bloke that instructed everyone on how to approach the X-ray machine demand loudly that every last thing, including bits of paper, had to be removed from pockets. The demand was a bit hollow as I was stand two feet from this guy with a boarding pass hanging out of my shirt pocket and he didn't say a word to me even though he had just been yelling at us to remove ALL paper and other stuff. The TSA agents are kind of interesting as they have gotten to the point where the travelers moving through the security area are really just another type of cargo that apparently cannot hear them. They talk to each other as if no one else is around. If I sound that bitchy when I talk to my co-workers, I certainly hope that someone tells me. ;)

Cheers,

Chris

Re: Lacey Act

#3

Re: This is why government is hard . . .

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I had to fly to St Louis from Mpls last fall, my first flight in 4 years. The TSA crew in Mpls were cordial, but the crew in St Louis were out and out friendly. While I like to talk to people next to me while standing in line, I was joking and laughing with the scanners and such in St Louis. That's okay, because I'm just plain nasty if someone else starts it.

Re: Lacey Act

#4

Re: Lacey Act

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

It's a mess; but the obvious way around it is to reconstitute musical instruments, which is the result the powers that be want anyway. Let's dumb down everything so that the least among us can understand it; or, let's accommodate the severe limitations of TSA et al. And how about AT&T buying T-Mobile? Ugh!

Pam

Re: Lacey Act

#5

I hear you Bruce

Bob Hackett

I always try to lead with my calm and friendly face but when it becomes apparent that it`s not working and other participants want to play rough then they better strap in and hold on tight. As most of the folks here know I can run for a rather long time/distance and am not afraid to jump off the edge of the earth to make a point.

My wife hates it when I get what she calls "The Face".She`ll see it,sigh, sit down and prepare for a long wait,either that or go looking for a place to get more coffee.

Re: Lacey Act

#6

Re: Lacey Act

TomD

I agree Pam, there is a work around, even if at the moment it is greeted with the same enthusiasm as if one were to ask a devote of Norris planes to suck it up and for the good of the planet start using Japanese planes. Also it isn't just a problem of the future, it is arguably a problem for all the old stuff as well. Which applies to older tools with tropical woods in them.

Re: Lacey Act

#7

Re: Lacey Act

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yeah, and it would be so simple to fix if they just asked for date of manufacture certification. This is the one, and probably only, area in which I agree with conservatives: gov't, while maybe well meaning, is getting in our faces too much these days. I think it's due to population size explosion. For example, if there weren't so many of us, killing species simply wouldn't be such a problem. So, go forth and depopulate. :)

And if you ask nicely, I'll tell you about the $10000 worth of cars the City of Austin confiscated from us last week.

Pam

Re: Lacey Act

#8

Cagney Act

Joe Shelton

Depopulation?

Confiscation?

And they're doing this in Austin? I thought Texas was still one of the bastions of the republic.

If you come back and tell me that some of those vehickuls were pickup trucks, I'm really gonna be upset.

Joe

Re: Lacey Act

#9

One more example...

John in NM

Of how it's impossible to write a law that covers all possible eventualities, closes every loophole, yet allows all legitimate activity to continue. As we see with TSA and numerous others, the regulations that implement such laws are written to remove human judgement from the equation. At some point, the regulating agencies must simply learn to trust their employees judgement - such as when a plane looks old, it probably is old - but I've yet to see much evidence of this in any Federal agency.

Re: Lacey Act

#10

Re: Lacey Act

TomD

This is one of those rules that is designed to deal with the regulatory failings of other countries. In general it is going to re-direct these materials to other countries like China, that will be happy to have them.

There is an element of date of manufacture with this rule, but wood is difficult to identify. At least with current technology. A lot of makers have large stocks of wood and no paperwork, because it was not required.

But again, what is worrying me is the tools side of this, and travel with tools. And also, the boat side. I have a couple of boat projects right at the moment that I am going to have to rethink materials wise, since I may some day want to either sell them on, or more likely, use them in the US.

Re: Lacey Act

#11

Re: Cagney Act

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

They were a Vanagon and a BMW 318i, both ran fine but the cop wouldn't let me prove it.

Pam

Re: Lacey Act

#12

Re: Lacey Act

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yes, but the date of manufacture, plus perhaps some certification regarding the materials used, would eliminate most of the problems that regular users might have.

Pam

Re: Lacey Act

#13

Precisely.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Lacey Act

#14

Re: Lacey Act

TomD

Woulda coulda. From what I hear those kinds of solutions are off the table. I have a macassar ebony chisel set. I don't know when it was manufactured, and have no idea where the ebony came from. I don't think I will be crossing the border with them.

I'm in favour of the enviro objectives. Even these methods. But I think over time this thing could get pretty far reaching. Mahogany is a hair's breadth away from Cities 1. Just think of that for a moment. Admittedly it has been a hair's breadth for a long time. Usually what happens is as the stocks wain to the point where the dollar value is declining, then pull the lever.

Given the way this thing currently works, i am going to change my approach to some of the stuff I do. Boats is a biggie. All that stops me from going composite at the moment is cheapness, and of course my love of working with wood. But given the fact it could take 10 years to complete my next project and that the date of manufacture thing isn't really going to help, I am going to go all composite in that area, if there is any chance of the boat crossing borders.

Re: Lacey Act

#15

Re: One more example...

TomD

In this case I think they want to shut it down and don't care what the cost is.

On judgment, that is part of the problem. It is the border guy judging that any wood that is brown and striped may be Brazilian that is causing the uncertainty. I think the combo of zero tolerance, settling examples, hiring from the thin end of the gene pool, harsh penalties, underfunding, giving people judgment, etc... Is achieving exactly what they want.

There is no winning. If I shift boat construction to cored composites, and avoid lacey, can you imagine how easy it would be to conceal drugs in the skin of that boat? This kind of thing is why I haven't traveled to the US in ten years, for the most part.

Re: Lacey Act

#16

Re: One more example...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

But you were in MA less than 10 years ago. :)

Pam

Re: Lacey Act

#17

Re: One more example...

TomD

That's the for the most part, part. The only other time I went down I got arrested for failure to appear. Mistaken identity. The second time previous I nearly got arrested for some stand out legal scholarship by a fool they posted to the northern Maine border ( at least management is on the ball deep sixing that dude). I have no record, and am so proper, it's almost an embarrassment. Boring. Private schools, good family, posh sounding business card, at the time, and shy respectful attitude. Anyway, maybe when the kids are old enough to get a laugh at seeing their old dad get sent to the slammer...

Re: Lacey Act

#18

Re: One more example...

TomD

In fairness to the people on post at the borders. I realize they have no idea who anyone they are dealing with is. My lily white background just strikes me as funny in the circumstances.

Re: Lacey Act

#19

Man oh man!

John in NM

With luck like that, stay out of Mexico :D

I avoided a couple of immigration run-ins down there by playing dumb, really dumb. Just think how dumb you have to be to annoy a border guard to the point he just wants you out of his hair :D

Re: Lacey Act

#20

Re: Man oh man!

Dan Donaldson

Had an experience like that once. I lived in Chihuahua for a couple of years on a foreign service assignment for my employer. One time we were going back down from a trip to El Paso. We were in two cars because of the number of kids we had and my wife got through no problem. When they got to me, I had a few things that we had purchased in the car and I assume the guard wanted money. Every Question that he asked me, I pretended not to understand and just answered "Chihuahua". This was to questions like what was my name, where going, what in car, etc. Every answer "Chihuahua. My wife had stopped ahead waiting for me, and another officer asked her what she was waiting for, and she said for me "esposo". He looked at her, then at me and called out to the one questioning me, and he just waved me through.

Re: Lacey Act

#21

PS

Dan Donaldson

I would not even go that way these days. That trip went through Juarez, which is one of the most dangerous cities in the world now and traveled through another small town where there were 30 or so people shot by drug lords. Too bad things have changed so much in the last 20 years or so.

Re: Lacey Act

#22

Two times I remember...

John in NM

They were definitely looking for a bribe, but luckily I was small enough potatoes that they wouldn't expect much and thus were quick to give up in the face of the dumb routine. A driller I knew went through this for about 2 hours before the Jefe came over and just bluntly told him how much it would cost to get through with all the machinery parts he was bringing back from Phoenix.

Couple other times I got searched by the army or federal police, and those guys were definitely not just fishing for bribes, they were a scary bunch. In the mid 1990's the cops down there were far more scary than the gangs.

Re: Lacey Act

#23

Re: Two times I remember...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yeah, the federales were much scarier than anyone in the mid-'70's, even went to the point of stopping us in a highway blockade and planting a fingernail of grass in Jack's pocket, then trying to charge him piles of money to leave. They also tried to dismiss me (we were on separate motorcycles). Pigs.

Another, in San Blas, where we were living, tried to convince me to bring back a handgun from the US for him. Pigs.

I know it was all because they weren't paid very well, and a lot of them were/are psychopaths; but it's hard to get all that upset that a few of them are getting theirs these days. And if anyone comes across Miguel Gallado Comache, you have my permission to shoot him.

Pam

Re: Lacey Act

#24

Re: Two times I remember...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Back in the late 80's my family and I were returning from a long trip in Canada, Banff, Winipeg, etc. We were crossing into ND and one of the US border guards copped an attitude. One guy took my license over to their kiosk to check the information. I was just going along with the program, even though my wife and kids were sleeping, and the van was packed to the roof with camping gear. The guy talking to me was getting pretty nasty when the other one came back with my license, handed it to me, apologized for the inconvenience and wished me a good day. To this day I don't know what kind of information they had access to, but I was in a position to make life very, very miserable for them, and I suspect they found out.

Re: Lacey Act

#25

Paradigm shifts

Bob Hackett

The one thing those people who are intent on flexing what little bit of authority they have been entrusted with always seem to forget is that you never really know who that is in front of you.

It always brings a smile to my face when they get the wake-up call,their dream goes up in smoke and they realize the toes they were stepping on a moment ago are connected to the ass they must now kiss to make things right.