New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

Posts

Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

#1

Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

I've stumbled on a foundry that could cast some cast iron that I could use for diamond sharpening (http://www.bowmanvillefoundry.com).

Beyond the fact that it most probably will not prove economical to get them to cast me a plate (I haven't contacted them yet), what has me puzzled is what grade of grey cast iron I should ask for. They offer three grades (Class 18, 25 or 30), and I don't know which one is best (or if there is a better one they don't make) for diamond sharpening. Before I contact them I'd like to know what I should ask for.

Any help would be appreciated...

DC

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

#2

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

anotherBob

Denis, I can't directly help you with your question, but from my notes, a couple links:

A good web page on lapping plates where they recommend meehanite:

http://www.us-products.com/sitehtml/lapping.html

Where to buy Meehanite Castings:

http://www.meehanitemetal.com/htmlpages/wheretobuy.html

or

http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:h-KV0sjMy8QJ:www.meehanitemetal.com/htmlpages/wheretobuy.html+meehanite+foundry&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us&client=opera&source=www.google.com

looks like they have a couple foundries in Quebec too...

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

#3

David Barnett

Grey cast iron

David Barnett

You're not in it for tensile strength or hardness, so grade 18 is fine. The spec (SAE J431) for 18's Brinell hardness is 187 max. Class 25 can run from 170-229, usually 200 or more, rule of thumb. Class 30 runs 187-241. So G18 should generally be softer than the other two grades, which is good. If they are casting 25 or even 30, though, and will cast your plates (unlikely they'd cast just one) in that pour they might cut you a deal, so I'd say go with whatever they can offer.

I personally prefer Meehanite, a continuously cast grey iron that is very uniform in it's structure and relatively stable throughout seasoning, machining and use, but that's just being picky. Whatever they can come up with is fine. Be sure to ask if they have something on hand that will make a good plate. Could save some effort and expense.

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

#4

I was wondering ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

... if a derelict and damaged (the only kind) Stanley/Record/Other plane's sole could not be used? Two #5s or 5 1/2s could supply enough cast iron for 4 laps (if you freehand blades).

The above assumes if, like I, flat cast iron is otherwise difficult to access. To date I have been using an old saw plate that I cut up (into 4 pieces - 40/10/1/.5 microns) and glued to hardwood. Each piece is about 4" x 2 1/2". Since I side-sharpen, the width is less important.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

#5

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

Bill Tindall

If you cast a plate it will then have to be milled flat and then ground smoother. The milling and grinding will be the expensive parts. If you want to get into the plate business then casting a large quantity could make sense. But for a single plate other sources would be more practical. By its nature all sorts of stiff is made from cast iron which is then milled flat. A trip to any junk yard will reveal a multitude of cast iron pieces that can then be more readily fabricated into a flat surface. Band sawing is cheap. So first of all look for something that is already ground flat such that all you need to have the shop do is saw it into pieces. And don't fret flatness. The piece only has to be flat over the surface area of the bevel.

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

#6

David Barnett

Re: I was wondering ...

David Barnett

Planes soles are perfect, Derek. That's what Cecil Pierce used, although his was an inverted block plane as described (and illustrated) on page 47 of "Fifty Years A Planemaker And User" as "boxed tightly, bottom up".

"Each piece is about 4" x 2 1/2". Since I side-sharpen, the width is less important."

Cecil's lapping plate was presented horizontally to the blade, although I recall that he went both forward-and-back as well as side-to-side.

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

#7

David Barnett

By the way ...

David Barnett

His homemade sharpening jig was similar to the old General 809 outrigger jig, so it would be natural to use circular or oval motion or the radiused sweeping motion I often use when freehanding narrow tool and gravers.

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

#8

Have you sold out of $65 plates?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

#9

Re: I was wondering ...

TomD

I suggested planes a year or so back, and the powers that be in diamond sharpening seemed to think it would work fine. I guess it isn't as neat as a stone sized plate, but with the right support caddy, I imagine it would work fine.

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

#10

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

TomD

Oops, Denis in a post that hasn't cleared yet, I suggest some Montreal sources, maybe not too useful. If I get to my metal supplier I could check out their supply of cast iron. What size of piece are you looking for?

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

#11

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

TomD

For all the effort you put into this Denis, why not just buy one of these.

http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=59752&cat=1,43072,59752

Apparently the bottom is machined flat already. If you are contemplating machining you could machine the swirl pattern off, and have substantial surfaces to work with.

I got a great piece of cast iron exactly what you might want, from a machinery restoration place for free. There are quite a lot of machinery suppliers and maybe reconditioners in Montreal, and on the south shore route to Quebec city. There are also better scrap yards, not the auto type places but places that specialize in industrial metals. I know a few names around Toronto, but I assume there are at least as many in Montreal, given it's heavy and light industry, port, etc...

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

#12

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

What are the soles of clothes irons made of? Maybe just the old ones.

Pam

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

#13

David Barnett

Don't use the Griswold, but...

David Barnett

... cast iron skillets can work if you figure out how to lose the sides. Newer ones have a gritty finish that needs to be machined through. Old ones, just abrade through the seasoning. The insides are usually better than the bottoms, of course, which often have a rim and logo.

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

#14

Thanks.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

#16

Re: Not for hotcakes, but...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Definitely a few possibilities in there, will have to check out the local kitchen places.

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

#17

Check the thrift stores, too

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I would expect them to show up fairly regularly in most thrift stores.

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

#18

Excellent point. Thanks.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

#20

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Not for hotcakes, but...

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Harbor Freight also has cheap cast iron griddles. $10.00 or so when they're on sale.

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

#21

Dont do it.

Bob Hackett

If you flip those Horrible Freight griddles over there`s a picture of Satan on the bottom. :)

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

#22

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

Frank D. in Montreal

Hey Denis,

I have a cast iron tablesaw top which will provide me with more than enough plates... If you're interested you can have a major chunk of it.

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

#23

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

TomD

This being canada, moving metal around sounds like something you would need government money for to do economically. But if you want some of that stuff, stone sized pieces, smaller the better, either surface ground, fly cut, or shaped, let me know. The shaper might be the best bet, but it only does stuff you can fit in a 7" cube. But that sounds like a good thing to me.

My only concern is how to hold it. But if the pieces look tractable, or you could send me pics, go for it. proaconstrictor yahoo

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

#24

Re: Dont do it.

TomD

What might be excellent would be those old irons that are just monoblocs (Is that what you meant Pam) you heat on a stove. Since this could be a passing thing, might not even really wreck them much to use them. Those are the right period and massive.

HF skillets, well you know everything works on the internet. But Asian cast is such garbage even when you pay 30K for a tool room lathe, let alone a skillet If I did use one I would epoxy putty it to something hefty, cause it would have to flex. Don't get me wrong. Chinese stuff is rising in quality, they buy more CNC than the world combined, etc... But Iron that is coming out cheap is really rank stuff.

There is a lot of old iron out there. What about some bitted chisels. Just flatten the iron side and your chisels can sharpen each other. There are some cheap Japanese plane blades that are iron, and the off side is flat. My experience so far, is that I don't sharpen on a huge area with this stuff. I started on a small area, in case I couldn't find other pieces for the other grits I had bought. It worked so well I didn't bother adding to the area or adding other grits. Pieces the size of playing cards would work for me.

Re: Grade of cast iron for diamond sharpening?

#25

Re: Dont do it.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Well, no, I was thinking of all the dead electric clothes irons out there; but good idea. Guess it depends on the cost of one of those old irons. Clearly I'm not so resourceful as most of you. :) Great idea to use a Japanese chisel, except I don't have any ruined ones laying about. I do have an old, wrecked table saw that has this table, but was looking for something smaller.

Pam