We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Yes, honest question. One brought on by our lack of water quality here and recent studies about cadmium and chromium (or some Cs or something).
When you power sharpen and grind these powder metals, or any other high alloy metals for that matter, is there a concern about breathing the dust in the long term?
Re: question answered where you first asked it bel
Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia
I know from personal experience that if I don't use a dust mask when I machine brake rotors at work that a day or two later I get a serious sinus infection. I don't know if it is the cast iron dust or the rust on the rotors that gets me so I wear the dust mask whenever I grind the rust or machine rotors. I second the suggestion in not breathing anything but clean air. Use a dust mask.
I sharpened an axe on a belt sander without a mask some years ago. It took me about 4 days to recover. I think the dust in my lungs interfered with the blood's ability to absorb oxygen.
You certainly want to avoid it. People vary a great deal in their sensitivity, and while workers suffer life shortening consequences, sometimes in the extreme, the home shop at low volume is another mater.
Ashley Isles describes in his book on early Sheffield tool culture, that the polishers lived high, had all the fancy girls, but died within a short while of assuming their trade. I think the most dangerous part is the friable wheel surfaces, which is one up for wet grinding. A lot of wheels are sold to traditional tool users on the basis of their ability to break down and uncover new material. These wheels release small clouds of glassy materials, that one would expect to attack lung tissue. I am concerned enough about this stuff that generally I wheel my grinder out of doors, when doing heavy work. I don't want the workplace covered in dust that could linger and do harm.
I also prefer belt sanders using industrial steel grinding belts. You can get some of these from Lee Valley. They cut with high efficiency, and the metal dust mostly makes for the floor. The belt wears very slowly so there isn't the cloud of dust, and they don't require truing which also releases tons of dust. I have a one QSP vac set up with a hepa filter that I use only for these kinds of nasties. At lower cost the paper vac bags for shop vacs are also pretty good at filtering.
All that said, I have a perfectly healthy friend, who spent a lifetime reconditioning machines. They had a large surface grinder, and they ran it as the first step in reconditioning large lathes, mills, etc... The shop had no dust collection. So some people do survive serious exposure. The home shop is often heavily used and small in air volume, but it shouldn't be impossible to avoid life altering exposures.
I'm sure there are some people here who have the medical knowledge to say about the additives in metal, there is certainly a risk when people weld, though it may take a while to develop. Some say it is a dirty secret that the welding industry does not want to face up to. That US standards have not been as hard in this area as in others since welding is so important, and the solutions to the problem not clear. I did dodge a bullet many years back when Beryllium was popular in golf clubs and hammers. I ground some, but seem to have avoided killing myself. So it is worth asking the question about any new materials you come into contact with.
I have a small belt grinder now with trizact belts, and have been using a regular bench sander on tough irons for a long time. I also use a belt sander some making infill planes, because I don't have proper woodworking machinery and you can remove steel quite fast with a cheap coarse belt and the drum at the end of the belt on a small bench sander. I've probably gotten my share of iron and carbon, but never had any reaction to it. Cocobolo makes me sneeze and hard core solvents give me a headache, that's about it. I avoid the latter when I can.
I guess I'll start putting on a paper filter mask when I'm grinding irons on the belt grinder, there's no real great reason not to - the time spent there will still be very short.
I don't intend to live forever, but in the finite time between now and terminal, I would rather avoid sinus infections and chest tightness.
Any of the copper alloys such as brass or bronze as well as copper will bring on flu like symptoms when inhaled.Zinc(as in galvanizing) will too.
Chrome and cadium will accumulate and build up in your system over time and will make you absolutely miserable before they finally kill you.By the time you begin to feel it it`s too late.
I say this as someone who has spent over 20 years working in shipyards welding and grinding all types of metals and my entire life working metal at home.
Face it guys,we know that fine sawdust is a known carcinogen and we really need to be protecting ourselves against that so the same good quality respirator should be used whenever ANY dust is produced.
I try to make it a habit to place a respirator,safety glasses and ear plugs in a Tupperware container and place it in front of the light switch for the shop.That way I have to move the container in order to switch the lights on and it`ll get me thinking about PPE before the lights go on and work even starts.
A lot of the cheap masks are about as effective as wearing a bandana over your nose and mouth, bandit-style. Look for one with an exhaust valve, and test it for seal against your face.
I prefer a replaceable-filter mask, but they are pricier.
It's amazing what gets through some masks. The Dust Bee Gone comes to mind. It says it's effective down to 3 microns. That's not good enough for me.
Whether is the finest wood or metal dusts, grinding and polishing compounds or airborne colloidal silica, the stuff you don't see is what'll get you. Forget about so-called nuisance dust masks and surgical style cloth masks. Get the best HEPA cartridge mask with close-fitting silicone seals you can afford.
The only types of masks I use are the valve type n95 masks and the same type of cartridge OV mask that everyone else uses (AO saftey with round cartridges). I only use a couple of the n95 masks per year, they're not that expensive, but they are hot to wear in the summer (I wear them for close up work on cocobolo, especially making planes).
I don't use the all paper no-valve types because I can feel my breath rushing through the gaps it instead of through the filter element.
The N95 paper masks with exhalation valves work very well - if they fit. If you're getting dirt on your teeth or black boogers in your nose then the mask doesn't fit.
I couldn't find the really dirty pictures of me :-)
I spend way too much time in a dust mask. I used to work in the hazardous waste clean-up business so was fully kitted out every day. The following pictures are from something analagous to coal processing (not hazardous waste) - where we just want to keep the dust out of our lungs. The project is in China so we see everything from good dust protection to guys with bravado who refuse to wear any protetion
Not me, but a good picture showing N95 mask efficiency. There was a small "oops" when he was working in a relatively clean area. If the area was known to be that dirty he should have had a full face mask to keep his eyes clean or we should have avoided the job altogether. The mask did it's job. They usually leak around the nose. The better masks have a gasket. Personally I like the Moldex N95 masks with exhalation valve and handi-strap:
Me kitted up for an inspection. I've got 20 years of experience so I stay fairly clean. I even know that you need a small piece of duct tape over your boot laces at the toe to keep your socks clean The young folks working with me come out of the inspection filthy from head to toe...all a matter of what you lean against, how you crawl, and if you stir up dirt or not :-) When it's really dirty I wear a silicone half-mask respirator. It gets better fit and better filtration that the paper masks.
Some different mask options: The lady on the left was actually wearing high heeled winter boots for this inspection....I'm sure they were trashed.
The mask of the guy who's face is fogged up obviously does not fit. The internal nose piece should prevent exhalation into the mask area, avoiding fogging issues.
Relatively dirty (that's me on the left), but the face is still clean. The deep smile-lines on the guy's face to the right are a problem when fitting the mask. He could really use a full-face mask; the half-masks leak for him.
Looking cool with the Moldex mask. Machine was still clean so there was no need for Tyvek. The exhalation valve helps to prevent your safety glasses from fogging up - removed for clarity in this photo
Anyway to sum up, the paper masks work great so long as they fit. The cheap masks are worthless, but the N95 or N99 masks with gasketed sealing faces and exhalation valves are pretty good. Silicone half-mask respirators tend to fit better and seal better than paper masks, and the filters have longer life. They tend to be much less comfortable if worn for a long time. Full face masks are the best and provide eye protection as well, but are also the least comfortable, especially if you have to over-tighten the straps to get a good seal. In all cases fogging of glasses should not be an issue if the mask fits well.
Good pics, Steve; that first picture is a vivid demonstration of how much difference a respirator can make.
I use a silicone half-mask with two round filters, and test fit each time by covering the filters and breathing in; when the mask collapses against my face, I am reassured that it's sealing. I know there's a similar test for the disposable masks, but am now blanking on what that test is.
I have a Van Dyke (goatee and moustache) beard, and the half-mask covers it - OSHA is pretty strong on this subject, stating that if the beard extends past the mask edges, it won't, by definition, seal.
At this job site in China there is about 150 people working at the site, 2 holes in the ground for a toilet and NO running water. I get sick everytime I go there.
But, there aren't many rats...anything that moves is food...
I'm still fit enough, and fast enough, that I can get into the grinder and do the dirty deed on a gulp of air. That's a closed pressure system. Very effective. On the other hand the crap that was in the air is still in the shop. To me that is the big deal. I want a clean shop.
With beards, all these masks are pretty much useless, at least they still seem to help nuisance wise, but not toxics wise. For my first 40 years, I was cleanshaven, but since retiring, I have a beard. I bought an airmate system when I went with guitars. All those exotic woods are really toxic. Airmates are great. They have technical issues because they are not effective enough that they would save your life from nerve gas. But they will save you from a huge percentage of the dust, and they will also get you far cleaner air when working with fuming stuff like finishes. They are practical in that they are comfortable, and don't fog up, and relatively cheap to run. The one problem I found with mine is that they used off the shelf parts for the headpiece, and with the extra stuff jammed in there it isn't comfortable. This is an annoying piece of bad design, but for normal hat sizes less than 7.5 should be OK. They may have fixed it.
Instead of dust masks does anyone have a good solution for collecting grinding dust at the source?
Most grinder wheel shrouds are equipped with a dust collection port. I've seen one $700 fan intended to connect to a grinder. Welding dust fume collectors also exist, but they are also $3000+
Is there anything out there for the home hobbiest to collect grinding dust and fumes that won't break the bank? I hate getting grinding dust all over the place, especially when dressing up the wheel.
"Instead of dust masks does anyone have a good solution for collecting grinding dust at the source?"
Unless you're wearing a supplied air system, there's no instead of dust masks in hazardous dust collection -- you should still be wearing a particle mask -- but you can improve on collection and limit some of the debris. Note, however, that the smallest, most-pernicious airborne particles come off the wheel at the point of abrasion and subsequent rotations and never make it through the ports. Colloidal particles, such as silicates (particles so fine we refer to them collectively as smoke), ride room thermals and settle very slowly, and must be filtered through masks, avoided altogether with filtered supplied air, or removed through ambient filtration.
Also, these particles permeate clothing and hair, so wear at least a shop apron and perhaps a hair cover and remove them before leaving the shop -- especially following exposure to fine silicates (which can even arise from working clay bodies and some woods). Fine silicates, for example, can lodge in a shirt until your changing body temperature causes them to rise into your breathing path hours later. Wet-wipe work surfaces and tools regularly. Sounds like a lot of trouble, right? It is. But if you've ever been around silicosis victims or other sufferers of industrial dust overexposure, you'll consider it.
Wet grinding is preferred wherever possible. The wet-wheel lapidaries of Idar-Oberstein, barring catastrophic accidents, lived long lives, whereas dry-wheel lapidaries and metal polishers died much younger.
Another thing -- never connect grinder ports to shop dust collections systems or shop vacs where a spark could ignite wood flour, dusts, and so on -- rare, but it does happen. If you must vacuum, use that machine only for metals grinding and equip its output with HEPA. Dedicated motorized dust collectors for bench grinders are available*, of course, but you should still wear dust masks. While more efficient solutions exist, they're expensive and more intended for highly toxic or costlier metals recovery, such as in the jewelry industry.
Do not insert filters or other materials into dust ports or attached hoses. Dust-laden air will rebound back through the wheel guards. To improve on dust collection through the ports, hang downward-facing hoses and direct the grit and dusts into a passive trap resting on the floor. This can be a simple box with a sloping top, or a more-elaborately baffled trap which may even include a wet (or damp) reservoir. Hose ends should hang loose above the collection trap bottom to avoid static or rebounding air. I don't have a picture but you can imagine what would work and DIY one. In many shops, the heavier debris and dusts settle until they're swept or vacuumed. Combined with ambient air filtration, this can be acceptable.
As for fumes, the least expensive safe solution is still a mask. Laminar flow systems coupled with supplied air is not overkill for frequent and long exposures in manufacturing environments. So wear a mask, use ambient air filtration, and ventilate work spaces thoroughly. Ideally, you should continue to wear filtration masks throughout an aggressive ventilation cycle, or at least for 30 minutes following a grinding session. I realize this is not going to happen in most shops, but it's recommended.
Buffers are treated differently, but you'll still need the mask. Fact of life.
While I believe these to be sound recommendations, I'm no expert. Seek expert advise. The technical and safety reps from companies such as 3M can be very helpful and there's plenty of good literature on the subject, online and otherwise.
If you toddle on up a couple posts, I think you'll find that Steve is fairly expert with masks, their use, and their need.
Prudence compels many to grind metal using a mask, and that is fine.
I grind metal now and then without a mask, lots of people do. My time exposure is low, and I don't find that carborundum dust irritates me.
Silicon carbide dust is not in the same class (not even in the same school system ) as silica when it comes to health risks. To quote from OSHA's page regarding exposure limits (link provided):
"Inhalational studies in rats with silicon carbide dust (20 mg/m3) reported no significant effects on the lungs, in contrast to marked adverse effects of quartz dust."
And
"Potential symptoms: Irritation of eyes, skin, upper respiratory system, cough
Health Effects: Nuisance particulate-Accumulation in lungs (HE19)
Affected organs: Eyes, skin, respiratory system"
Bottom line is this. If you grind all day every day, wear a mask to prevent accumulation in the lungs.
If an individual finds they have a particular irritation caused by silicon carbide or metal dust, then yes, that individual should wear a mask.
If one uses silica wheels instead of carborundum (silicon carbide), then yes, they should wear a mask.
All the rest of us probably don't need to worry much about it. It's not a matter of machismo, going commando, or any other BS, it's just a matter of common sense and knowing the materials with which you're working.
For what its worth, I do wear my seat belt while driving, use push sticks with the table saw, don't hunt while drinking, and never kick my dog
That most ports on bench grinder dust shrouds are too small for effective collection. You probably won't get OSHA level collection without a large port and a dedicated dust collector (which you'd want to use in any case, with the fire concerns).
However, I have seen standard small dust collectors used to effectively control the mess. The wheel geometry and speed, in addition to the higher mass of the particles does make it easier than with wood. If I was making tools and doing lots of grinding, I would probably get a small DC to hook up to the grinder. It would be interesting to use some of Bill Pentz's site info to systematically see how metal grinding dust compares to wood.
"If you toddle on up a couple posts, I think you'll find that Steve is fairly expert with masks, their use, and their need."
As I said in my reply to Steve, (no need to toddle -- good word, that -- I read his post and appreciate his knowledge) I didn't actually expect everyone would take all those precautions, but just wanted to list a simple solution and recommend safe practices with which I am familiar.
I wasn't talking only about silicon carbide, the wheels, that is, but rather anything that may get ground as Steve didn't specify only grinding tools steels. Perhaps I was too broad or too general. Obviously, silicosis is more serious when buffing. Everything from buffing compounds is to be avoided. I don't go to unusual lengths but use whatever's appropriate to stay safe.
Didn't mean to be terse or slapdash but wanted to reply quickly before turning in.
From what I`ve read effective dust collection needs to be addressed on two fronts,source capture at the machine(where the production of dust is taking place) and ambient filtration(filtering what`s left floating around out of the air).
It makes little difference to wear a mask while grinding and then take that mask off and sweep the dust up later or let the dust settle on every surface of the shop only to be stirred up days or weeks later as you move things around.
For me the best approach is to either move the worst offenders outside and set up a fan to blow the dust away from me or during this time of year to tent off an area for grinding and then either filter the air in the tent or move the dust out a window with an exhaust fan.
As others have said,there`s more than one element at work here.There`s the metal particles and then there`s the stuff that becomes airborne as the abrasive wears away.That abrasive dust consists of whatever abrasive makes up the wheel or belt and also whatever reinforces and binds it together.While you may not currently be sensitized to things like aluminum oxide or silicon carbide (the two most popular abrasive types) many people have reactions to things like the binders used to bond wheels or abrasives to a belt as well as the fiberglass and other reinforcement particles used on wheels and belts.
I would also keep in mind that just because you don`t have any reaction YET to something doesn`t meant you can just ignore respiratory protection.The fact that you`re inhaling this stuff means that sooner or later you will probably become sensitized to it.Once that happens you have it for life and the consequences are several orders of magnitude worse than what an average person would exhibit under the same circumstances.
I know people who worked with epoxy resin and different finishes such as Waterlox for years and suddenly developed major reactions to it.Now they can`t be in the same room with the product unless it`s in a tightly sealed container.
I have a real problem being in the same room as someone working mahogany as my sinuses swell,my eyes water to the point of impairing my vision and my nose runs like a leaky faucet.If I get the dust on me I break out in a rash.Two decades of being around boats brought that on.I was fine for the first 15 and showed no reaction at all.Now mahogany may as well be cocobolo as far as I`m concerned.My wife has the same problems with red oak from handling my work clothes.I can`t even have green red oak in a closed car without her sinuses giving her problems.
"It makes little difference to wear a mask while grinding and then take that mask off and sweep the dust up later or let the dust settle on every surface of the shop only to be stirred up days or weeks later as you move things around."
Exactly, 'cept you said it better.
"I would also keep in mind that just because you don`t have any reaction YET to something doesn`t meant you can just ignore respiratory protection."
I know of cases where onset of lifelong symptoms presented within hours of exposure, and other cases where it took 40 years.
"I know people who worked with epoxy resin and different finishes such as Waterlox for years and suddenly developed major reactions to it."
Add me to that list. I now wear organics filters when doing Waterlox and a couple other solvent-rich products, even if I'm only in the room for a moment where I applied it hours earlier. I would casually add another coat to small projects and even though I should've known better, still developed enhanced sensitivities.
"For me the best approach is to either move the worst offenders outside and set up a fan to blow the dust away from me or during this time of year to tent off an area for grinding and then either filter the air in the tent or move the dust out a window with an exhaust fan."
I meant to address that earlier. I do that every chance I get, which is often. Because I work with pure 300 mesh and finer silica flours -- the nastiest sharp-edged lung-killing stuff around now that asbestos is rare -- mixed 50/50 with Hydrocal and other niceties; diatomaceous earths, toxic metallic oxides, and so on. I do everything I can to work outdoors or on an expansive screen-enclosed lanai. My fans are on remotes so I don't track anything.
After a session mixing my refractories and charging moulds with glass frit, powders and pastes, I wet-wipe surfaces, hose the floors, vacuum, throw the clothes in the washer, then shower. Before a new session, I vacuum or change mask filters. My woodworking routine isn't quite so stringent, but you've seen my shop pics. So maybe John in NM has a point. I am rather fastidious where dusts are concerned.
Besides, the way my asthma can get, I'll do anything to avoid taking prednisone (one reason I've been online so much these last few weeks).