New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

Posts

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#26

Re: If by bargain you mean lower-priced...

wilbur

Like I said, for me they work great for examining the edge of a tool while sharpening. I haven't noticed any aberration issues that would interfere with this purpose. I wouldn't want to use them for shooting photos, but when looking at a tool with my eyes, they do the job just fine.

I use microscopes as part of my day job every day, so I think I have a good feel for what's a good magnified image.

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#27

Re: Looks like a real mess. How does it cut?

anotherBob

Pam, that really is the crux of the matter... hope to find out soon. Still working on the plane that this iron will go into, maybe this weekend...

still playing/figuring it out...:

a fresh LN iron for my jointer, as it is delivered out of the wrapper from them... bevel side and back (which they hone)



Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#28

Re: If by bargain you mean lower-priced...

anotherBob

Wilbur, that loupe look great, think it would have me wishing for a third hand! Have you tried one of those flip down Optivisor-style things? Curious if it would make it easier to use when sharpening/filing...

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#29

Re: Not 1 grit, 14000 microns. 14000 grit, 1 micro

anotherBob

David, thanks! Your enthusiasm is contagious. Once the lighting is better figured out, for kicks and grins... calibration and measurement. :) It is fun.

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#30

David Barnett

You're probably right, wilbur

David Barnett

I suppose my judgment's based on examining gems where the geometries, facets with rounded edges, out-of-flat planes, scratches, inclusions and so on make my viewing experience more demanding than looking at blade bevels or edges.

In faceting, and especially for competition cutting, the judging standard for error is whatever can be seen at 10x, and this varies dramatically from loupe to loupe, depending on quality. For sharpening, I'm sure you're right. I'm so used to critically viewing this way I guess I don't shift gears so easily. Besides, when it comes to optics, acoustics, and olfaction, I'm told I can be picky.

Microscopy was largely my day job, too, but if it hadn't been, I'd have done it anyway.

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#31

Re: Embedded diamond particles

anotherBob

Steve, They are (or at least supposed to be) 1 micron from:

http://www.lascodiamond.com/products/dmdpdr.htm

I also have .5 micron... not even made into a paste yet. I need to refine my honing jig(s) first, even for the 1 micron... before even thinking about trying the .5 stuff.

Still working the bugs out with the FrankenScope... the scope itself has 40x, 100x, and 400x magnification, then the camera has a "5.0MP CMOS image sensor that allows you to take still images at up to 10.0MP". 3648 x 2736 as Windows reports in Properties. I don't know at what point the software interpolation kicks in with the stock viewer software, but am curious enough to see what I might come up with using Twain... we'll see.

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#32

Dust

Steve Elliott

Bob,

I think the white specks you're seeing are dust rather than embedded diamond. The most effective way I've found to remove dust from a blade (for imaging purposes) is to use masking tape to lift it off. I especially like the low-tack blue tape for this. Wiping with anything seems to leave streaks or scratches and still doesn't get all the dust off.

One of the tricks to examining edges under a microscope is to learn which features are significant to edge quality and which are not. Dust and streaks are distractions, scratches and wire edges are not.

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#33

View Solutions GE-5 *LINK*

Steve Elliott

Dave,

Fortunately it turned out that the GE-5 isn't "married to its stand." There's a USB connection that allows the scope to be removed, which made it possible to build a fixture for examining blade edges.

I've added a few pictures of the GE-5 and a sample edge image to an obscure page on my website (link below). I hope to do a more thorough job of it now that I've sorted out the software problems I was having. (I'm glad my piano doesn't run on Windows.)


GE-5 Microscope & Sample Edge Image

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#34

Well, OK, sorry for the interruption. 

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#35

David Barnett

It just gets better *LINK*

David Barnett

Oh, I just meant that with its side plug it doesn't as easily fit many interchangeable aftermarket stands for cameras with top wiring. Certainly not a big thing, as your remarkable adaptation demonstrates. Wow! That is perfect! I was going to wait, but now I'm looking at these again.

I'd considered the hybrid DM-220-XY, the industrial version that inspired the GE-5, but couldn't justify it at $2500+. I'm reconsidering but still waiting for the price to drop a bit more. It might not, though. Also, I've been looking for screen shots of the measurement functions on the GE-5 but haven't found anything (I'm assuming the overlay scale on Holtey blade is a sample?). Does the software support other reticle functions; angular, different scales, grids?

I see that View Solutions also makes knockoffs of legendary stereo microscopes, such as my SZ (Olympus) and B&L SZ4. These days, key in the specs and out pops the glass.

"I'm glad my piano doesn't run on Windows."

I've used mine to get away from Windows on occasion.


DM digital video microscope

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#36

The thousandths scale

Steve Elliott

The GE-5 has no reticle functions that I'm aware of. The thousandths scale is something I added in Photoshop, based on making an image of a Starrett 64ths scale.

Eventually I'd like to do some systematic testing of edge wear using better equipment than I used five years ago. I have the GE-5 now and have made a much better apparatus for doing thread-cutting tests for sharpness. I've also made a laser goniometer that gives a very accurate reading of edge angle, even on freehand-honed blades. For honing plane blades I've developed a jig that allows me to use the entire length of an 8" cast iron plate or 8" stone. I can work the bevel and the back bevel alternately by just turning the blade and jig over. The .007" microbevel on the Holtey blade in the sample image is a 2-1/2 degree back bevel that is even across the whole width of the blade.

Eventually I'd like to do a shaving formation study of the type pioneered by Dr. Norman Franz, but using cutting angles typical of hand planes and incorporating a working chipbreaker and an adjustable mouth aperture. I've done some macrophoto tests that make me think the imaging is within my capability. That may have to wait until I'm retired.

On another subject, I now have polycrystalline diamond lapping compound from Pace Technologies and like it. Thanks for the recommendation. I've tried the half micron and will be trying the 1 micron soon. It's good stuff.

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#37

David Barnett

Maybe an add-on *LINK*

David Barnett

"The GE-5 has no reticle functions that I'm aware of."

In the description of the GE-5 from HEI's (Howard Electronics), they mention a measurement function and list View Digital Measurement Software in PDF, but I haven't seen any pics. Maybe it's an aftermarket add-on that comes with their version.

Norman Franz, the waterjet guy, huh? I remember Bruce Hoadley talking about type I & II chip formation back when I was in the Amherst/UMASS area, but that's about all I remember. Don't know anything really about type III or 0. At any rate, that's an interesting and ambitious undertaking. Can't wait to see what happens. You've already done some impressive and valuable stuff.

I've got a lot of illumination equipment; several Fostec EKE and DDL 150w cold halogen light sources with fiberoptic dual goosenecks, ringlights, and so on, but am planning on making some dimmable white LED bars, spots, and rings (I like to make LED interior lighting and luminaires).

As soon as I etch and populate some circuit boards I'll let you know. Might be something you could adapt. As cheap as bulk white LEDs are these days, it'd cost nothing and be no trouble to make a couple extras if you want to play with them. I wanted an LED bar to rake an engraved lapidary surface for a special lamp -- sort of a light sculpture, so figured I should make a few things for my carving arbors.


HeiScope GE-5 Digital Microscope

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#38

Measurement function on GE-5

Steve Elliott

I'm glad I qualified my statement with "that I'm aware of" because it turns out there's a measurement function that works like a line tool in CAD. You click on a starting point and an end point and text appears that gives the distance. Unfortunately for me there are options for 60x and 180x but not for 540x, but I can always divide by three. There's also an angle measurement tool and some others (circle and rectangle tools like those in CAD) that I haven't tried.

I'll post an image of a hair with a length measurement and an angle on it. I couldn't get the text to be larger but then I've just used the tool a couple of times.

One advantage of a digital scope is the ability to make a simple scale that will measure directly off the display screen when the image is shown at 100% size. I have a 3x5 card with thousandths marked off on it which is so easy to use that I'm not feeling any need for another method.

I spent a good deal of time testing angles and placement of different LEDs, trying to find the combination that would reveal the greatest amount of detail at the cutting edge. It turned out that the direction of the scratch pattern dictates the best location for the light source. An edge honed using a side-to-side technique appears to have no visible scratch pattern when viewed using the LEDs on the sides of my scope, but a typical scratch pattern appears when the LED at the back is turned on. This is a long lead-up to politely declining your generous offer of additional LED lighting options. It's just a matter of wanting to use my time on aspects of the testing I'm not yet satisfied with, which is a long list.

One drawback of the white LEDs is the blue cast they give to the image. I've decided to live with it although it's easy to correct in Photoshop. I'll be dealing with a lot of images and it'll be easier if they are all done using default settings.


Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#39

David Barnett

Dose LED blues

David Barnett

Well, it's good to know it's there, and while it's not necessary to your way of working, it's still an amazing feature for that price. I could see myself using both linear measurement and angle functions for gem work.

"Unfortunately for me there are options for 60x and 180x but not for 540x, but I can always divide by three."

"One advantage of a digital scope is the ability to make a simple scale that will measure directly off the display screen when the image is shown at 100% size. I have a 3x5 card with thousandths marked off on it which is so easy to use that I'm not feeling any need for another method."

You know, I'm so spoiled by zoom with fixed detents I might feel limited by fixed powers, which is why I was looking at zoom features on a few other scopes, mostly because I work under magnification. For your purposes, you need repeatability more than zoom, so you're not limited in the least.

As for the LEDs, makes sense. I'd still be dinking with methodology while you're already harvesting data. After I'd start brainstorming on a new idea, my method was to hire and train a manager to limit me in that respect and steer me into getting things done, or at least started. Then, when I'd tire of it, inevitably, I could turn it over and move on to the next thing -- my weakness and my strength. Cross-pollinate and run. Innovation happens at right angles -- side effects. Buckminster Fuller used to call innovators and enterpreneurs money bees.

"One drawback of the white LEDs is the blue cast they give to the image. I've decided to live with it although it's easy to correct in Photoshop. I'll be dealing with a lot of images and it'll be easier if they are all done using default settings."

Since my focus is on working under magnification rather than analyzing and collecting micrographic data: actual science, I don't get dose LED blues, man.