New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

Posts

FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#1

FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

anotherBob

Last weekend I was looking at some of the images over by Brent Beach at http://www3.telus.net/BrentBeach/Sharpen/qx3.html and it got me wishing that I could better see for myself what I am doing to my irons/chisels... here at home. Ran across an this:

The article - Make a USB microscope (there is a PDF of the article at that site)

http://pcformat.techradar.com/article/make-usb-microscope-11-06-10

then picked this up at a local computer shop:

The webcam - Logitech 1080p Webcam Pro C910

http://www.amazon.com/Logitech-1080p-Webcam-Pro-C910/dp/B003M2YT96/ref=sr_1_sc_1/187-3855673-6192607?ie=UTF8&s=electronics&qid=1298343150&sr=1-1-spell

and ordered this at Amazon... ought to be here tomorrow :) :

The scope - Celestron 44102 400x Power Laboratory Biological Microscope

http://www.amazon.com/Celestron-44102-Laboratory-Biological-Microscope/dp/B000Q7964S/ref=sr_1_4?ie=UTF8&qid=1298258228&sr=8-4

Anyone try something like that around here?, or what have you tried? I'll post some pics after it's together... just real curious for now...

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#2

David Barnett

Digital micrography - options for blade watching *LINK*

David Barnett

I'm all for looking at blade edges through microscopes, and those camera scopes are really very useful, whether home built or otherwise. One advantage is that you have a digital camera to begin with and don't need to match a separate digital camera to a non-camera microscope.

One thing to remember, though, and I'll try to keep this simple, is that there are two basic types of microscope: the compound microscope and the dissecting microscope.

The microscope you're looking at on Amazon is a compound microscrope intended mostly for biological work. It has a mirror underneath to transmit the light through an aperture, then through the sample, usually held on a slide.

As blades are opaque, light cannot be transmitted through them to the eye. Also, the field of view in these microscopes is very limited and the objective lenses are too close for thick samples. Now if you're intending to use this scope to explore what's in your water, thin sections of plant tissue or insect wings, this will do it. However, for looking at blade edges, not so much.

For that, you'll need reflected light, that is, light bounced off the surface of what you wish to see rather than through it. This is what's often called a dissecting microscope, and the most useful these days, outside the video camera microscopes, is the stereo microscope (not to be confused with the binocular compound microscope).

An example of this may be seen in this article:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stereo_microscope

Notice that this microscope has no mirror and that the space beneath the optics is capacious. As the field of view, what you can see all at once, is very broad, these microscopes use two independent optical paths -- one for each eye -- so that depth of view is enhanced through stereo vision. These scopes therefor excel at viewing thick objects, such as circuit boards, small animals, coins, and blades, as they have exceptional depth of field. An external light source will generally be required to bounce sufficient light from the viewed object back to the observer.

For viewing blades, looking at tool edges, chunks of wood, or sharpening fine-toothed hand saws, the stereo microscope is just the thing. However, the camera microscope may be a better value for simply looking at tool edges. You've seen what Brooks Beach was able to do with what many would consider a toy.

BTW, you might wish to look at Dino-Lite camera microscopes. They're pretty impressive and do depth of field rather nicely.

http://www.dino-lite.com/

For a dependable Dino-Lite dealer (and all stereo microscopes and photomicrography equipment), I'd suggest The Microscope Store in Roanoke. Mike carries a line of very inexpensive Omano stereo microscopes with limited features that might work for you -- just don't expect high power or wide range of power options. On the other hand, I can see everything I need to at 20 or perhaps 40 power, and a stereo microscope with these two powers can be had for $129.

Most people are overly concerned with power. There are many other optical considerations beyond power alone. My scopes all zoom and can go to much higher powers, but rarely is that needed. Remember, as you go up in power you see less of that object at any one time (field of view).

I hope this helps rather confuses or disappoints you. I do half my work through the microscope and have rebuilt these things, so if you need further help, feel free to ask. And remember, you don't need an expensive scope for blade watching.

I'm eager to hear your USB cam results. Be sure to post. I just love this stuff.


The Microscope Store -- basic stereo microscopes

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#3

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Another to look for is the Digital Blue QX5, which I have. This is a discontinued model but many are available on eBay, amongst other places. It is an upgraded version of the QX3, which Brent started on (and may still use).

The magnification is up to 200x. It has more LEDS to illuminate than the QX3.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#4

David Barnett

Correction

David Barnett

I meant to type Brent Beach -- not Beach Brooks. My apologies.

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#5

unnecessary for your stated objective

Bill Tindall

For following wear and sharpening all that is needed is a high quality 10X or 15X hand lens. Let me repeat--high quality. It does not have to be a big lens, mine is only 1 cm across, but it needs to have optical clarity to the edges.

If you want to take pictures, that is a horse of another color. Lighting is everything. When we were doing our studies I had access to an industrial microscopy lab and its skilled technicians and gear costing 10's of thousand bucks. We still had problems getting pictures that clearly showed what could be easily revealed with modest magnification and an eye ball imaging system.

Also, as you go up in magnification you loose depth of field. In the trade off of depth of field vs magnification I find 10-15X acceptable. To get depth of field necessary to study a worn edge at higher magnification costs staggering bucks. Without inadequate depth of field you can't see the whole wear profile in focus.

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#6

Re: Digital micrography - options for blade watchi

anotherBob

Thanks for the info guys, and I'm sure you're right about stereo would be optimal with more DOF and all... just curious here. It's the kind of thing where anyone with access to their local Craigslist, and a little time and patience, could cobble something similar at little or no cost. I decided to get a webcam with better than average optics (pretty darned good for what it is actually), and was impatient. :( . For lighting, I have one of these:

Sylvania LED Light Flute

http://www.amazon.com/LED-Light-Flute-Portable-Silver/dp/B003OX82KA

...noticed that it went MIA recently, turned out that my daughter was using it for a night time reading light. ( but Dad... it's so much easier to turn off than having to get up and turn off the switch! :) ) Anyway, it's a really decent light source, easy to place/move around and doesn't get hot.

Should have mentioned... gonna be dinking around with a few different style home made honing guides for use with diamonds, so this should show me what's going on at the arris very nicely.

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#7

David Barnett

A real bargain *LINK*

David Barnett

If you don't need to photograph the edge -- just need to inspect it, then you're absolutely right, Bill. A good quality 10x folding loupe will do the job quite well. But you're also right about good quality optical performance. There's a world of difference between a good and bad loupe, but it needn't cost a lot of money.

The Belorussian-made BELOMO 10x 21mm triplet loupe hand lens is a terrific buy at around $28. It's wide lens is bright and easier to see what you're looking at than loupes selling for far more. It's well-constructed, sturdy and quality control has been outstanding.

http://www.belomo.us/

Is it as good as my Harald Schneider or Swiss-Axe Hawk? No, but it's surprising close to my Zeiss with its smaller lens at three times the price, and these Belomos are cheap enough that I keep one in each tool chest and work station for everyday use. When I bought mine they cost half as much, but even at current prices they still kick optical butt.

These also comes in a 20x quadruplet, but start with a 10x. Here's a link, but you can also find these on eBay.


BELOMO 10x Triplet hand lens

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#8

Even more of a bargain

wilbur

Go to eBay and search for "20x 21mm led loupe". You'll find a bunch for $13 delivered to your door. I have one of these, and they are great for examining the edge of your tool, and they have a built in LED light.

There are also a lot of 10x versions on eBay. The body looks a little different than the one that I have, so I don't know how good they are.

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#9

David Barnett

If by bargain you mean lower-priced...

David Barnett

... then yes, and they may suit you fine for examining blade edges. If nothing else, the LEDs can make up for some of the lens aberration. Do realize, though, that direct LED lighting can obscure image features for brightness, and remember, what you don't see, you don't know is missing.

Again, there are many I haven't encountered, but most of the cheaper 10x and 20x loupes I've seen, especially the LED ones, have fallen far short of my minimum standards.

I do love bright white LEDs, though.

[optional stridency-amelioratory your-mileage-may-vary kumbaya statement]

We all sure have different needs, different ways of working, don't we?

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#10

Re: eyeball vs camera

bugbear

Agreed. I don't think the difference is the eyeball, I think the difference is interaction.

Consider how we normally "look at" something. We strongly want to hold the object in our hands. In fact, when we "look at" something, we normally twist and turn it, and combine (in the brain) all the instantaneous views and angles our eye has seen.

This also applies when looking at an object with a hand lens. In particular, traversing a shallow DOF across an object does create a good impression of the whole object, despite the fact that any instaneous image on the retina did (indeed) have the shallow DOF that would make a photograph unhelpful.

There *are* ways to capture photographs with high DOF and high magnification, but they're tricky, expensive, or both.

BugBear (who think the brain is a marvellous thing)

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#11

agree entirely

Bill Tindall

I was amazed how difficult it was even with state of the art equipment to digitally capture was was so easy to discern either with a lens of binocular scope. And I suspect you are right that the ability to interactively "scan" was the main difference.

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#12

Re: eyeball vs camera, Like a little kid in awe...

anotherBob

...of seeing a bee's mouth parts under the scope for the first time... that's me right now. :)

Long day yesterday but the box came in!... After dinner I only had time to open it up, put it together and have a quick look at a CPM3V iron that I started honing last weekend. Shock!!!... would you just look at all those diamond particles embedded in the iron! Already it's shown me that I need to alter my honing strategy... need to drag the iron instead of back and forth motion. Really surprised at how smooth/flat the bevel is and how well defined the arris is... better than I had hoped for.

Pics tonight at 11 or at least by the weekend hopefully. This certainly isn't necessary... but fun!

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#13

David Barnett

Hand-eye, and lighting *LINK*

David Barnett

I'll take a hand lens any day for spontaneous up-close viewing. While I have stereo microscopes on articulated multi-axis booms, there's nothing more natural and easier than a hand lens for quick inspection iterations. When I'm faceting gems, I can lift the handpiece to the lens every few seconds when I need to. In fact, I loop my finger through the hand loupe while I'm working, wearing it. I lift my left hand to my eye as I bring up the faceting handpiece with my right. Very fast.

On the other hand, when I need DOF in a more restricted position on workpieces that are also in jigged or restricted positions, the stereo microscope is just the thing. I've tried CCD systems but am much happier with the stereo-optic DOF. CCD systems are fine for industrial inspection, some forms of surgery and diagnosis, and very convenient for teaching environments, but have significant disadvantages in the way I prefer to interact, as you say, with things.

It has a lot to do with lighting, too. CCD systems are best with highly-coordinated lighting, especially in machine-vision applications. As for the common CCD microscopes on the market, such as Dino-Lite or the 'toy' scopes, they generally rely on direct LEDs circling the lens. While this may seem like a great solution, it lacks versatility. Look at a dollar bill with direct lighting, such as a ring light provides, and it's excellent. Look at a blade bevel with strong direct light, you'll miss a lot.

I use lighting combinations of direct and indirect raking light to get the maximum visual information from an image. With a hand lens, this is intuitive and easy. You just move yourself, the viewed object and the light source into convenient aspect.

I will say when you're doing a task requiring both hands, a CCD or stereo microscope can be pretty convenient, such as sharpening a fine-toothed dovetail saw under low power, which is how I do mine. But I'm also happy doing lots of sharpening tasks with very low power, such as an articulated wide-lens magnifier with left and right daylight fluorescents. It's only 1.75x (with an added 2.25x swing-over lens), but you can really see what you're doing when sharpening saws or small carving tools, and depth of field and field of view seems almost vast.

Also, this works extremely well for sawing and chiseling dovetails, making it much faster and more reliable. No kidding. I keep an Aven 6" x 7" at my workbench and another at the grinder and 1"x42" belt sander. The price has gone up on these but they're worth every penny to me with my presbyopic and diabetic eyes, and nowhere near as expensive as my O. C. White (crown optical lens and dimmable illumination).

Then there's optivisors, Galilean binocular loupes, Keplerian surgical telescopes, and... well, it does add up.


Aven Mighty-Mag

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#14

David Barnett

"Like a little kid in awe" -- well put.

David Barnett

Hahaha -- I know exactly how you feel. And what's more, it never really wears off, even if you use scopes everyday. Just looking at stuff can keep one occupied for hours at a time for a whole life. I got my first compound scope when I was kid and I'm still excited.

Beyond just looking at things, it's pretty neat to actually work under magnification, too. Engraving, goldsmithing, enameling come to mind, but there are jillions of other things. Boy, is there a lot of optical glass in this house.

A neuroscientist friend brought one home from Yale to show his kids. I think they got to look through it. At least when dad wasn't around.

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#15

Embedded diamond particles

Steve Elliott

I'm curious what size the diamond particles are that you're seeing. I've used a 540x microscope to inspect edges but the 1-micron diamond I'm using is too small to be visible.

Also, what did you see that suggests that dragging the blade will be better than moving it back and forth?

When I went from a 200x scope to 540x I could see that increased final honing continued to improve the quality of the edge more than I had realized. In particular it removed the final bits of wire edge that I didn't even know were there.

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#16

David Barnett

Question, Steve

David Barnett

What scopes are you using? CCD? Inverted metallurgical? I was playing with a trinocular IM with USB digital in the camera port. Fun. Fairly powerful, too -- up to 1000x. Almost wish I needed one.

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#17

you are enhancing my credibility

Bill Tindall

Embedded diamonds in the scratches and pull the tool.

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#18

My microscope

Steve Elliott

Dave,

I'm using an inexpensive USB inspection scope made by View Solutions. (I think that makes it a CCD device.) I bought a 9x lens that brings the power up to 540x and have made a fixture that gives me good control of the focus. In addition to the microscope's built-in ring of LEDs (which are useless with the 9x lens because the object being viewed is in the shadow of the lens) I've mounted three white LEDs that shine in from the sides and back of the blade edge and an amber LED that reflects off the wear surface of a used blade. With that much light I was able to increase the depth of focus by stopping down the lens using a black disk with a small hole drilled in it, inserted just behind the 9x lens.

When I went to use the scope yesterday the software for it was screwed up so today I've been completely re-installing my entire operating system. Right now I haven't gotten to installing the microscope but when I get there I'll try to post an image or two of blade edges.

It's a good thing I enjoy this stuff or it would drive me crazy.

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#19

Re: eyeball vs camera, Like a little kid in awe...

anotherBob

Well, maybe not the best... but for now, a start:





it is so darned easy to just use if you're not trying to take a pic... :\

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#20

Looks like a real mess. How does it cut?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#21

David Barnett

Not 1 grit, 14000 microns. 14000 grit, 1 micron

David Barnett

Seriously, though, your images look great for your first efforts. Certainly worth doing and the worth the investment.

As for your sharpening results, your scratch patterns don't look like anything I've seen after 1 micron. Steve wondered why you could see the diamonds. I'm wondering why you wouldn't trip over them.

The scratches in picture #3 look particularly deep and far apart. Any ideas? You've piqued my interest.

Really does seem like a pretty good scope.

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#22

Re: My microscope

bugbear

It's a good thing I enjoy this stuff or it would drive me crazy.

So say we all.

BugBear

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#23

KUDOS - VERY GOOD IMAGES!

bugbear

Re: FrankenScope for digital microphotography...

#25

David Barnett

Your microscope's...

David Barnett

... got me all wee-weed up!

View Solutions makes some impressive stuff, and their GE-5 is a home run for the educational market, as an integrated turnkey system right out of the box at an amazing price. The only slight drawback might've been that it's pretty much married to the stand that's boxed with it, but that's also a strength. It's a good one. Love the boom extension. However, it sounds like you made a workaround for the higher power focusing sensitivities (I'm impressed).

Even though it's feature-rich, the real clincher is its glass. You get a lens comparable to inspection micros costing much more. Damn, I want one -- don't need one -- but I want one, heh. China kicks U.S. and even Japanese butt with high-quality optics that are way too inexpensive to ignore.

I've become a big fan of the upper end Omano stereo microscopes and View Solutions owns a couple key digital market segments. The Omano 99 scope is a drop-dead knockoff of the Olympus SZ optics and functioning. The Oly is more ruggedly built and a little more solid feeling, though not by much, but the optics are truly spot-on. I'm a confirmed Zeiss surgical (which I don't own) and Olympus SZ fan but I bought one of these, too, and just love it.

The old B&L, my sentimental favorite with the sturdiest optical pod ever built, doesn't get much use these days, although I still prefer it for gem carving and faceting. Mine has the SK stand which is what really makes it. The stand alone used to cost $2,800 in the 1960s, and is the most adjustable, articulated heavy boom ever made for a table top stereo. I took it all apart, realigned and cleaned the glass and mirrors, and used several viscosities of Nye damping greases on the motion components. It moves and feels like the yoke on an old 747.

[WARNING -- my absolute all-time best tool gloat: Years ago, I got both the stand and optical zoom pod for $135 on eBay!] That'll never happen again.

I gotta say, if I didn't need very 3D stereo depth of field for what I do at the jeweler's bench, I'd definitely get one of these digitals. As for jumping through hoops to get what you want it to do, especially with the LED-9x Barlow thing, yeah, that's a challenge, but your fix with the amber and raking white LEDs and homemade lens aperture (which is pretty damned clever IMO) -- as Bill T. once remarked "lighting is everything" -- you've got a totally workable system, and that's way cool.

For all the optical glass around me, I still have no micrographic capability. I'm inspired now. But it'll probably pass. :)

Did I say that I just love this stuff?