New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

A question about dovetail chisels.....

Posts

A question about dovetail chisels.....

#1

A question about dovetail chisels.....

roger lance

just seeking advise, input on what is or isn't a good dovetail chisel....are the Blue Spruce or Matsumura Blue Steel chisels worth their price or are they just a pretty face ??....and what sizes are necessary??...if 1/4" will work in most situations, then maybe buy just that chisel for a little hands on testing ??

Re: A question about dovetail chisels.....

#2

Stephen Shepherd

Re: A question about dovetail chisels.....

Stephen Shepherd

I bought a cheap Narex brand 1/4" chisel and worked down the side bevels to make it into a dovetail chisel. I also made the black round handle, tapered octagonal, so it wouldn't roll off the bench and to remove the black stain. The blade holds an edge even with a very shallow bevel.

Stephen

Re: A question about dovetail chisels.....

#3

Re: A question about dovetail chisels.....

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Like Stephen, I took a $4 Stanley 60 that I picked up at a tool meet and turned it into a fishtail, specifically for half blind DTs. It started out life as a 3/4".


It didn't have a handle, but I'll put one on it as soon as I can get my lathe set up.

However, having said all that, I have lust in my heart for the Blue Spruce dovetail chisel.

Re: A question about dovetail chisels.....

#4

Re: A question about dovetail chisels..... *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I think there is some confusion being perpetuated about "dovetail" chisels.

1. Good dovetail chisels are good chisels for other uses, too.

2. Chisels shaped like dovetails are called dovetail chisels, but don't necessarily work better for dovetailing, which is why I prefer to call them shinoji whether they're Japanese or not (but they usually are).


3. In order to facilitate cleaning out corners, you need probably two skews (I can see how one could do) or one fishtail (bachi nomi) chisel, wider at the edge than at the shank.


And LN's example of extreme fishtails, for which nomenclature I applaud them, to say nothing about their use of O1 tool steel.


4. To chop out the gross waste between dovetail elements, you only need regular chisels; but I'd also go for super sharp and balanced. Or: top form.

5. What are also being called dovetail are the type 2 chisels detailed in the link below.

All comments and corrections are welcomed. :)

Pam


A page of Tasai's Dovetail chisels

Re: A question about dovetail chisels.....

#5

I can't recommend the..

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

Matsumura Blue Steel chisels. They have to large of a shoulder on them. I had to grind the shoulders to get a true triangular shape on them.

You can't go wrong with anything from Blue Spruce tools.

I'd start with a 1/8 or 1/4" one to start. With bigger DT's you can use a bench chisel.

Re: A question about dovetail chisels.....

#6

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: A question about dovetail chisels.....

Jack Guzman from Maine

I ground the sides down on a couple of two cherries bench chisels to make them better at cleaning out dovetail waste. That japanese chisel is alot to spend just to test. I'd try a cheaper alternative for now.---Jack

Re: A question about dovetail chisels.....

#7

Two questions

Bob Hackett

First,are you looking for chisels to chop out the waste or are you wanting something to pare into the corners and clean things up?

The second question depends on if you`re looking for a chisel to be used strictly for clean up.How do you feel about a reground older chisel like Stephen suggested and do you have the gear and expertise to grind one yourself?

I ask because I have access to more than a few donor chisels and I`m sure I`m not the only one here who might be willing to help a brother WWer out. :)

Re: A question about dovetail chisels.....

#8

think short

Bill Tindall

I got hand cramps holding the typical tall heavy handled chisels. I am very fond of the short light weight ones I made. Had I not made some I think I would have settled on the Japanese style for the same reasons- short and light. The sizes you need depend on the size dovetails you make. I just chopped something near 200 for a large chest of drawers and I used 3/16, 1/4, 3/8 1/2 and 5/8 mostly. I find I use these short chisels for everything. I have some long chisels and never reach for them.

I seldom use anything over 3/4" unless I am using it like a free-hand plane. A big heavy chisel is good for these operations, like shaping the sockets for sliding dovetails. It falls in use somewhere between a draw shave and a plane.

Re: A question about dovetail chisels.....

#9

DT Chisels

RJ Whelan

Roger,

The Blue Spruce are a delight, but I also like Japanese in $30-50 range and L-Ns.

As far as size goes: I've found it easiest to use the largest (widest) chisel available for each operation - walking a 1/4" chisel across 2" of waste takes a long time and puts a lot of wear on the chisel.

FWIW

rj

Re: A question about dovetail chisels.....

#10

Probably more than you wanted to know .....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Roger

Choosing dovetail chisels depends on the type of dovetails you make, the method you make them, and the type of wood you use .....

Further, dovetail chisels are essentially for the tails, not the pins. Pins are vertical and the only angle lies with half-blind dovetails. For the latter a skew chisel is helpful.

If all your chisels were wide, and the chisel width you choose is narrower, even the tails could be undercut with a firmer/slab-sided chisel used on an angle.

It is really when you plan to cut narrow tails (where there is restricted movement) and/or pare/chop into the corner at the baseline that a chisel with a minimal shoulder is needed. I enjoy making drawers with narrow, London-style tails in hardwood, and for this special dovetail chisels are indicated. The sizes I use are 1/8", 3/16" and 1/4". Wider chisels are used for the pins, such as the 3/4" super-steel versions I posted very recently.

As Pam noted, Japanese dovetail chisels are not the same as dedicated Western dovetail chisels, such the Blue Spruce. The BS are designed with minimal shoulders (as are the LN bench chisels). I have a set and they are superb for detail work. The A2 steels takes and holds a very sharp edge. Japanese dovetail chisels have shoulders. These can be ground away (be aware that the laminated steel layer is very hard). I recently posted a mini-review of custom Koyamaichi dovetail chisels. The standard Koyamaichi dovetail chisels are available from LV. I think that they are superb value for money, but still they are in the same range as LN.

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/KoyamaichiChisels.html



The reason I have a set of these is that they are my preferred chisel for chopping, which is necessary with some of the local hardwoods. For those occasions that I work with softer woods - more typical of the US I expect - I will use a set of modified Stanley 750s. These have shoulders I ground away. There is a tutorial on my website if you want to go down this path ...

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/Soyouwanttomakeadovetailchisel.html


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A question about dovetail chisels.....

#11

How short is short, Bill?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I like shorter chisels, too. I'm curious what length yours are. Most of my Bergs, especially in the less than 1" range are 9" or less. They're the ones I grab first.

Re: A question about dovetail chisels.....

#12

Re: How short is short, Bill?

Bill Tindall

Blades are 5" long, handles to fit hand. There is a picture of one in the recent tool steel discussion. They are also thinner than what Derek showed.

Re: A question about dovetail chisels.....

#13

Yes, but

Bill Tindall

Making that first strike at the base line with a 1" chisel puts a lot of backwards force on the chisel, possibly "bruising" the baseline. . I waste out what I can with the band saw and make one downward cut at the baseline. I find walking across the baseline with about a 1/2" chisel ideal for keeping the baseline crisp. Lazy that I am I have tried going wider and I can't keep the baseline crisp with blows to a wider chisel.

Indeed 1/4" is useless small for pin waste, could be ideal for tail waste. Can't get it parallel to the baseline reliably, or at least I couldn't on tail waste.

Re: A question about dovetail chisels.....

#14

Re: think short

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Speaking of dimensions, how thin do you think your CPM 3V chisels could be /are?

Pam

Re: A question about dovetail chisels.....

#15

Optimum thickness

Bill Tindall

My short chisels are made from "1/8" which in fact is 0.142". The tools steels are made over sized assuming they will be ground after heat treating. I left them at 0.142. This thickness is perfect for this length and use. It leads to a feather-light chisel, ideal for dovetail chopping where I, at least, hold the chisel near its bevel. I get hand cramps holding tall heavy handled chisels this way. I noticed when we took the class at the Headley shop that the used some variety of vintage short chisels for dovetail shopping.

If struck hard the midrange sizes have some spring at this thickness, which is not desirable. But I find I rarely have any occasion to bash them hard for what I do. With taps typical for chipping out dovetail waste there is no spring down to the 1/4" size.

For a longer chisel that will be struck, the next size thicker material would be essential to avoid any spring in the blade. Spring is very annoying.

I have, and have had, some longer commercial chisels of typical shape. I find I never reached for them and hence sold them all but the Two Cherries set. I should sell them too as I never use them either. I just don't have any use for a long chisel for what I find myself doing. The exception is a 2" monster that I use for heavy duty paring of stuff like sliding dovetail sockets which I can cut by hand faster than with a router with the aid of this bug guy.

Re: A question about dovetail chisels.....

#16

Instead of lusting......

Bill Tindall

Make them. He uses the same technique that we did for our chisels, which I have described in detail in earlier posts on chisel making. Somewhere in the twin cities there will be a place to buy steel and a place to have it heat treated, which is cheap. The only other thing you need is a hack saw and a grinder. If your are lusting after the function, it is trivial to cut them out, grind the bevels and install a handle. If you are lusting after the beauty, then you needs some metal working skills. But as that famous Polish song goes- "If you want to be happy for the rest of your life, don't make a pretty chisel(girl) your wife."

Re: A question about dovetail chisels.....

#17

I stand corrected

Bill Tindall

I should be saying "dove tailing chisels" . If you get chisels with blade shaped as shown in your Figure 1 they can be used for all aspects of dovetail making, and in my hands everything else too. I find no compelling need for any other shape of chisel. Personally I have never had the need for a fishtail for half blinds. A small dovetailing chisel reaches in the corners just fine, as well as the point of a knife if there is a stubborn splinter to be extracted. I think owners of several chisel varieties are smitten by using them rather than making stuff, which is fine so long as it is made clear when offering advise.

Re: A question about dovetail chisels.....

#18

Great, thanks.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: A question about dovetail chisels.....

#19

Lusting is bad for the soul, but chisels...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I've never seen your chisels in person, Bill, but I have examined Dean Jansa's and he appears to have used pretty much the same procedure, except his chisels are O-1. I don't recall how much he has into that set.

Besides, the ability to make handles to your own fit is worth it. I might give that a shot.

Thanks.

Re: A question about dovetail chisels.....

#20

Re: I stand corrected

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I had no idea you made CPM 3V versions of shinoji. That's way cool. I say they're not that great for cleaning out the corners, but that's dependent on whether the side bevels essentially form a sharpish edge with the back. The Japanese versions I've seen don't.

Pam

Re: A question about dovetail chisels.....

#21

Re: A question about dovetail chisels.....

Warren in Lancaster, PA

It could be that calling these chisels "dovetail chisels" has helped sell them, but there is no need for special chisels for making dovetails or half blind dovetails. I don't think the term "dovetail chisel" appears in print before 1980 or so. The Seaton Chest has lots of neat dovetails in its drawers and construction, but of the 48 chisels in the inventory, there are no skew chisels, no fishtail chisels, and no dovetail chisels. There are about eight chisels that are narrower than 1/4 inch.

Re: A question about dovetail chisels.....

#22

Re: A question about dovetail chisels.....

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Well, I find the fishtails very handy. For dovetails, too. Necessary? Probably not. There are many ways to meet one's goals in woodworking. For example, the Mac Headley video on making a Philadelphia gaming table, for which he carved the knees (acanthus leaf) and feet (ball & claw) using no carving chisels, maybe only a low sweep striking gauge.

Pam