New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Is this the future ...?

Posts

Re: Is this the future ...?

#27

These problems have already been solved

Bill Tindall


Years ago when we thought we could use a succession of "loose" diamond pastes Steve Elliot solved the jig problem with what I coined the "Chariot Jig". My crude example is shown in the picture along with a vintage 3V chisel on a caste iron plate. Steve's was more elegant and better deserving the name. An added feature is that the cast iron plate can be sloped which will approximate the edge knife makers have found to be most robust. It was along about here that I ran out of enthusiasm for working metal and we never evaluated the benefits of sloping the plate. There is some new research to be undertaken.

Note the plate. If persons using paste see more than what you see on this plate you are charging the plate with way too much stuff. I just charged a new one for someone and it took less than a one cm "worm" of paste for a new plate. In fact I over did it at less than 1 cm and transfered about half to a second plate.

I predict that over time many will adapt diamond abrasives in their routine sharpening scheme. Fixed diamond plates are particularly efficacious in the coarse grits- quick, cheap and long lasting. The hardy will finish with loose diamond on cast iron while others will choose a different final step for the less abrasive resistant steels.

PS: better take your sharpening gear to the demo. You will need it for the 25 degree 3V chisel if it is heat treated for maximum toughness- Rc58-60.

Re: Is this the future ...?

#28

To answer your question.....no

Bill Tindall

I predict 10V will not be sufficiently tough. We never evaluated it so this is a guess based on its properties. After 10 years it hasn't taken over the lath tool world where its exceptional abrasion resistance would be most appreciated.

M4 has been shown by the knife enthusiasts to be the superior steel when robustness is the criteria. A run of M4 plane ions was made some years ago by Phil Smith and they have performed well. We think M4 will be sufficiently tough to serve as chisel steel. BUT M4 is very expensive, and very hard to fabricate and as far as I know it can not be forged which limits it to shapes that Tom, and hence others, wouldn't like.

Some years ago Phil Smith sent Blue Spruce and a small plane iron company some 3V for evaluation. The plane iron maker declared he could not sharpen it adequately with water stones, a fact confirmed by Steve Elliot, and that was the end of that. I haven't seen any 3V chisels from Blue Spruce, for what ever reason. It would be a company like this that would first offer such a product if it had a market.

3V is a world beater for mortise chisels. Abuse as you might it can't be broken even at 25 degree bevels. Its exceptional ease of fabrication makes it the steel of choice for home made tools. It works almost as easily as cold rolled steel before heat treating. But if after a decade or more nobody is selling stuff made from it I am not optimistic its benefits are sufficient to overcome inertia.

That said, if enough people rediscover it maybe it will catch on somewhere.

Re: Is this the future ...?

#29

"We"?

wilbur

Hi Bill,

Out of curiosity, who is "we"? Just wondering who else was involved in your evaluations.

Re: Is this the future ...?

#30

David Barnett

Forging CPM M4 and CPM 10V

David Barnett

CPM M4 and CPM 10V can be forged, sort of. Forging range is narrower and higher (2000-2100�F) than for A2 (1800-2000�F) or O1 (1700-1900�F). Both must be kept above 1700�F and are not as forgiving as other steels at the boundaries of their forging ranges. Not a casual process for most home smiths. Heat treat is complicated and requires a higher heat furnace than for 'lesser' steels.

I do like M4 for certain stone sculpting and lettering tools. You can really take delicate paring cuts in some of the tougher marbles and calcites with a thinner edge geometry than carbide-tipped chisels, and it wears like crazy compared to older steels. It's expensive, yes, which is why only the business end gets the good stuff.

Re: Is this the future ...?

#31

Re: Is this the future ...? -  I think so...

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

I agree with Pam...Please say Hi to Stephen when you see him for me, Joe in Virginia from the Badger Pond days.

JR

Re: Is this the future ...?

#32

PS

Bill Tindall

The liquid you see is WD 40. Note the paste is so dilute that it contributes no discernible color or material to the plate.

Olive oil is traditionally used on these plates.

Re: Is this the future ...?

#33

I had no idea that was a tease. 

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Is this the future ...?

#34

Re: CPM toolsteels + heat treat

George in snowy Lowell, Mich.

We send it to a commercial heat treater in Grand Rapids, Mich. Hansen Heat Treat

Work safe

George

Re: Is this the future ...?

#35

WE

Phil Smith

I'm part of the we. Several years ago when we did the early work I spent significant time along with Bill researching tool steels and their properties. It was a reasonably close choice between CPM 3V and M4. We went with the 3V to make sure we had sufficient toughness. Since we did not have unlimited time or resources we made an educated guess that 3V would make very good woodworking tools (chisels and plane irons). We went with the 3V to make sure we had sufficient toughness for the first round of chisels. My experience is that is the case. With a little effort a complete set of chisels can be fashioned with commonly available tools in the home shop (hack saw, belt sander, and bench grinder for the steel, and lathe for tool handles).

When we did the original work CPM 3V was about $20/lb and CPM M4 was about $40/lb. So for a set of paring chisels (3/16; 1/4; 3/8; 1/2; 3/4; and 1.0") the total steel wt. is 0.86 lbs. $25 in steel will make you a set of paring chisels with performance that is tough to match with commercial chisels.

Later Bruce Norton and I made a custom run of CPM 3V plane irons for Wiley Horne and Steve Elliot. When we made those we also made 4 plane irons out of CPM M4. THESE are now my go to plane irons for both a LN 4 1/2 and a Clifton No. 5 plane. These were heat treated Rc 64 by company that routinely heat treats tool steels for the tool and die industry. Just don't have to sharpen very often. That said the M4 is much harder and wear resistant that the CPM 3V. When we made the original plane iron all of the backs were ground flat by a local machine shop with a surface grinder. Surface grinding of the M4 irons was 2X more expensive than the CPM 3V irons, the steel is very hard and wear resistant and does not grind very fast. In addition when, i polished the backs of the CPM M4 it was slow even with a diamond paste on cast iron.

Next time I make chisels it will probably be out of M4 even though I still have several pounds of CPM 3V left over from my last steel order.

Re: Is this the future ...?

#36

Re: David Barnett how may interests..

George in snowy Lowell, Mich.

do you have??????

I have seen woodworking, precious stone faceting, jewelry making including casting, and now metal working including forging!!!!!!!

Are there other skills that haven't been mentioned yet?

Work safe,

George

Re: Is this the future ...?

#37

You left out jet-setting spy

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

but I don't think David likes to talk about those days.

Re: Is this the future ...?

#38

Re: You left out jet-setting spy

Bob Hackett

He`s also an incredible ballroom and tap dancer too as well as both fixed wing and rotary aircraft pilot,crack shot and former soldier of fortune.

He already mentioned he plays a mean piano.

Perhaps we should try listing the things he DOESN`T do.It may be shorter list. :D

Re: Is this the future ...?

#39

David Barnett

Problem is...

David Barnett

... the airlines now make me purchase and sit in two seats, which wouldn't be so bad if they were adjacent. I almost feel sorry for the passenger in between, but considering the screaming was muffled, the wiggling, well... after awhile, you know, I kinda liked it.

Re: Is this the future ...?

#40

David Barnett

And I speak Esperanto like a native...

David Barnett

... which I've used before, but it's my stock answer for such queries.

Really, George... I do have a few interests, hobbies, some might say proclivities, and am an avid disciple of R. Bucky's doctrine of multiple use. Interdisciplinary cross-fertilization is a big thing with me, which is why I'm very mixed media in my approach to craft, and why you'd get a better answer if you'd asked "what happens when you cross ADD with OCD, a pretty good memory and lifelong insomnia?" Voila! Me!

Which also explains my checkered academic and career pursuits, everything from think tanks to trial consulting to bioelectic R&D to information specialties to industrial design to futures trader to God only knows what else. Some might say eclectic, while others might opt for less polite euphemisms. Whatever happens, just don't let me get bored.

Re: Is this the future ...?

#41

Re:David in the R Bucky vein.....

George in snowy Lowell, Mich.

I built and lived in 2 geodesic domes for 20 years before I moved into a conventional square farm house. I built them back in '72.

Work safe

George

Re: Is this the future ...?

#42

David Barnett

It all comes back to me, yes...

David Barnett

"He`s also an incredible ballroom and tap dancer too as well as both fixed wing and rotary aircraft pilot, crack shot and former soldier of fortune."

Ah, yes... how I remember the night I jetted into Buenos Aries. I danced the tango with the senoritas del barrio La Boca en Caminito until dawn. Then, as the sun rose, we choppered out to the pampas and took out certain elements of the ERP. Sure, it didn't pay much back then, but I was young, full of vinegar and it kept me in practice. Breakfast, a cigar, and to bed. Those were the days.

"He already mentioned he plays a mean piano."

And pretty fair tangos typicos on the squeezebox.

"Perhaps we should try listing the things he DOESN`T do.It may be shorter list."

Then be sure to leave out:

punchcutting

font design and historical scripts

orchid cloning and tissue culture

encaustic art

joined Screen Actors Guild in 7th grade

domestic poultry strangulation

lower primate punishment

flogging the bishop

Oh... I don't always drink beer, but when I do, I prefer Dos Equis.

Re: Is this the future ...?

#43

And your mom's tattoo says "Son"   

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Re: Is this the future ...?

#44

You didn't list scrapbooking as "not done" - hmmm

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Re: Is this the future ...?

#45

David Barnett

It all started when I pressed my first wild flower

David Barnett

Re: Is this the future ...?

#46

Cheap thrills

Bob Hackett

Sort of like an airborne magic fingers bed perhaps?

At the end of the flight do both of you become members of the "mile high club" or just one? :D

Re: Is this the future ...?

#47

David Barnett

I love good architecture

David Barnett

For some reason, two domes present an aesthetic I can really grasp, especially when they're large, symmetical and reasonably close together.

Re: Is this the future ...?

#48

Re: Is this the future ...?

David Weaver

I could swear I posted something on here, but I don't see it.

As easy and quick as chisels are to sharpen and grind (no disassembly of the tool), i would rather have a "supersteel" plane iron.

M4 would be my choice, and I would save the iron for other than smoothing tasks (should be an excellent iron for rough boards that always abrade an edge a little faster, no matter what you do to get the junk brushed off of them).

Power sharpening is nice on high speed steels, but is any of the dust from it harmful? (given that there is chromium in the steel?)

The only place I've ever felt like plain old tool steel was inconvenient is with glinty cocobolo, the kind you cut open and can see silica particles flashing back at you. Regular cheap muji irons handle that very well, many multiples better than A2 and tool steel, which maybe isn't the case if the wood is less abrasive, maybe the difference is less.

Re: Is this the future ...?

#49

chromium toxicity

Bill Tindall

There are several forms of chromium. Chromium is added to my sheep mineral mixes because it is essential to life. Ditto for cobalt, copper, selenium and a host of other elements. While selenium is consider "highly toxic" my soil lacks any and my lambs are born paralyzed if I don't give their moms a shot of selenium as well as a mineral mix that contains some. When considering toxicity the form and dose determine the hazard, or benefit.

Chromium in the +6 valance state- "hexavalent chromium", "chrom 6", "chromIV" "chromate" , "dichromate"- has been shown to be a human carcinogen via respiratory route. It may be via ingestion too. This kind of chromium would only be encountered by most people dissolved in water. It is very difficult to make from the other more benign forms of chromium, so exposure to these other forms will not turn them into the harmful form. Electrolysis to remove rust with stainless steel anodes does not make hexavalent chromium in spite of the hysteria from some quarters. Nor does using stainless steel cookware, or corroding factories. One would not believe the letters and email I get because I claimed stainless steel anodes were useful in rust electrolysis.

Hence, grinding tool steel with 1% chromium will be no more or less harmful that grinding cast iron. That said, dust of any kind is not good to breathe. I always use a dust mask when grinding to protect against grinder wheel dust.

Re: Is this the future ...?

#50

Re: Is this the future ...?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

M4 would be my choice, and I would save the iron for other than smoothing tasks (should be an excellent iron for rough boards that always abrade an edge a little faster, no matter what you do to get the junk brushed off of them).

Hi David

Another view ...

I like the idea of a really tough blade for the really rough work, as you suggest. Indeed, I built a traditional jack plane with a very thick D2 blade just for this purpose.

However ... smoothing interlocked hardwood grain needs to be done with a fully sharp iron, and one that holds its edge. It it begins to dull prematurely or early, then the chance of tearout increases. I'd see an M4 blade would be desirable for this area as well (if you are not prepared to rehone frequently).

Regards from Perth

Derek