New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Is this the future ...?

Posts

Is this the future ...?

#1

Is this the future ...?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

For the past two years John Payne and I have been discussing steels used in knife-making, and their has potential application to woodworking tools. He has already produced a number of chisels in CPM 3V steel, and these have demonstrated superior edge-holding to A2.

John sent me a three chisel blades and 1 plane blade to test. I have not reached the testing stage yet, but I thought I would show the steel and pass on my observations with regard sharpening them.

This weekend has been all about painting. Oh how I hate painting walls! Every now-and-then, however, I managed to escape (while the paint dried) to the workshop to make the chisels.

This is what I produced over yesterday and today:


From the top: Jarrah handled CPM 3V, She-oak handled CPM M4, and Bloodwood handled CPM 10V.

The Bloodwood handle is rather special. Exactly 2 years ago Tony Zaffuto (TonyZ) sent me a piece of Bloodwood infused with Resinol, a piece large enough for one chisel handle. I've been saving it for something special. I think that 10V qualifies. Thanks again Tony!


All of these handles can take a serious beating, but the Bloodwood/Resinol is effectively indestructable.

The chisels are all 3/4" wide. I plan to test them out chopping the endgrain of dovetail pins. So I have also hollow ground the shoulders to make it easier to avoid bruising the edges of the dovetails.

The 3V is ground at 25 degrees (as it will cope with this), while the M4 and 10V are ground at their preferred 30 degrees.

How tough are these steels? Here is a chart comparing them ..


Source: http://www.hamiltonknife.com/CPM_V10.htm

M2 steel is the HSS with which we are familiar. This has more than double the wear resistance of A2. Now M4 is about double M2 (with 3V a little behind M4), and 10V is more than double that!

Sharpening ...

I hollow ground all the blades on an 8" grinder with a Norton 46 grit white wheel. Grinding was not too bad, but clearly slower on the 10V. The advantage to using these steels is that you do noit have to be concerned about overheating them.

I have been using a couple of CPM 3V plane blades for a while. Sharpening has been hit-and-miss. Pro Shapton 1000 ceramic waterstones remove the steel without any difficulty (in fact this stone is fast), but I have been less happy with the 5000 and 12000 Pro Shaptons on this steel.

Consequently I decided to just use oil based diamond paste on all the stones. I have a set up that uses steel plates (from an old saw) glued to hardwood. The set comprises 40, 10, 1 and .5 microns.

This combination quickly created a razor edge on the 3V and M4 (the M4 literally laughed at the Shaptons, which made no impression on them). However try as I might, I could not get past fine scratches and a dull grey finish with the diamond paste on the 10V. Out of sheer desparation I turned back to the Pro Shaptons ... and you know what - they rapidly turned the scratches to a shine! Go figure.

I have lots of dovetails to chop/pare in my current project, so the next month should see these blades getting a solid workout.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Is this the future ...?

#2

David Barnett

Could be, but not for the casual heat treater

David Barnett

My limited experience with CPM 10V is that it doesn't seem to affect performance whether it appears polished or not. Also, I prefer grinding with CBN wheels as it can eat away at an SG faster than most metals. Lots of vanadium. Lots of tough.

Although CPM Rex M4 Hc(HS) is easier for me to get, both tax the upper limits of my furnace so I doubt I'll try more of it for now.

Those are very nice, very beefy chisels, Derek. Truly serious chisels.

Re: Is this the future ...?

#3

I just googled "Resinol"....

John in NM

And got a whole lot of hits on some medical ointment :D:D:D

A couple weeks ago I was messing around with vacuum treating walnut with a few types of oils, tung, BLO, and Waterlox. Waterlox was the only one that got any kind of decent penetration, being so thin - no surprise there. I may build a pressure vessel (not as easy as a vacuum chamber :D) and try again with the heavier oils.

But I'm also interested in other resins to try. I've read about using Minwax wood hardener, and something called B-69, which is an acrylic that gets dissolved in acetone. So naturally, I'm wondering what Resinol really is.

Re: Is this the future ...?

#5

Various comments

Bill Tindall

Glad to see these steels being evaluated again by woodworkers. It would appear that the audience is now more receptive. When we first made the suggestion nearly ten years ago on Badger Pond that 3V steel would offer better performance for woodworking tools the idea was met with derision, nasty derision from some of the turners. I have been quite happy with the performance of 3V for chisels, plane irons and lathe tools(especially scrapers) over the past 9 years I have used them. We now think that M4 would be even better, as the knife makers have discovered. At the time we thought it lacked sufficient toughness, but that does not seem to be the case.

How these tools will perform is strongly dependent on how they were heat treated. Absent from your report is the heat treatment schedule. For our first round of chisels we heat treated 3V to achieve maximum toughness. It turns out that the material is sufficiently tough to be taken to a greater hardness, which will reduce deformation wear (see below) and not lead to chipping wear.

Steve Elliot studied sharpening tool steels and his results should be studied before any conclusion is made on sharpness, for it depends on the means to achieve it.

The Crucible Products graph included shows comparative wear resistance, largely dependent of vanadium carbide content. (see Crucible Products web site for comparative hardness and toughness graphs) I think this graphic data is relevant to plane irons and lathe tools and not a useful metric for chisels.

From our micrographic studies of chisel edges we concluded that they fail rather than wear, wear being a descriptor for loss of material by abrasion. When they became dull the edge of chopping chisels were either deformed(crumpled) or chipped which led to poorer edge penetration. I believe the proper metrics for chopping chisels is hardness ( which is a measure of resistance to deformation) and toughness, which is a measure of resistance to chipping. Chopping chisels simply don't rub against sufficient material to abrade during their useful edge life. Every steel we studied- O-1, classic carbon, 3V and M2) got dull(failed) by either chipping or deformation.

It does not take high magnification to determine the failure mode of the edge. I encourage you to follow the progress of the edge in your evaluation by examining it with some sort of magnification optics.

Re: Is this the future ...?

#6

Re: CPM toolsteels

George in snowy Lowell, Mich.

Hi all,

We use all of these toolsteels that you have listed to stamp out stainless steel that is up to 1/2" thick in the stamping factory where I work. I work in the tool & die dept. The CPM steels are definitely the "go to" materials for our problem dies. Their resistance to chipping and wearability is amazing. Stainless steel is a highly "abrasive" material to stamp but this is what the automotive companies want for their exhaust components. We even have stamped 3/8" titanium for exhaust systems for Corvettes. That was one of our biggest challenges. The "experts" said that it couldn't be stamped, but we were able to do it! The bad part is one of our exhaust systems was installed on a Corvette, found to be defective and the car was then used as a crash test car. What an expensive defective exhaust system!!!! I guess maybe this strayed from the topic a little ;^)

I have made various woodworking tools with it and I will echo what Derek has said. It is a top of the line toolsteel. The wear resistance of D2 is great but the CPM's are fantastic. I will have to say as far as sharpening, I preshape on a power grinder then hand sharpen from there. It does take a little longer but the length of life is worth it.

Work safe

George

Re: Is this the future ...?

#7

edge failure pictures

Bill Tindall

This picture shows a deformation failure of a carbon steel chisel edge in a dovetail chopping test. The metal is all there, it is just deformed.

This second picture shows a chipping failure in a dovetail chopping test. This steel is M2 and there are divots missing from the edge. This M2 steel taken to its optimum hardness lacks sufficient toughness for a chopping chisel. The deformed edge can largely be restored with something like a hard ARK stone which straightens it back into cutting position.

These are low resolution pictures. If I can find the CD with the high resolution pictures which show the failures more clearly I will post later. Woodworking to be done now. The last of the 9 bow front drawers to be fitted.

Re: Is this the future ...?

#8

Re: CPM toolsteels

Bill Tindall

CPM 3V was developed for dies. Does you company heat treat it or do you send it out?

Re: Is this the future ...?

#9

Re: CPM toolsteels + flattening the backs...

anotherBob

Bill, I have had a keen interest in these CPM metals since I first saw that "Unbelievable New Chisels" thread over at WoodNet. Found a knife material supplier ( http://www.alphaknifesupply.com/bladesteel.htm#BS-CPM3V ) for the stock, rough ground the stock, then sent them to ( http://www.buckknives.com/index.cfm?event=bio.paulBos# ) for heat treat.

That brings me to today... Last night I finally had some time to use your honing regimen (rough grind on the belt grinder followed by 1 micron paste embedded on flatly ground cast iron) WOW!!! :) Beautiful mirror finish on the bevel edges... but now my next concern... the back(s). So far I've tried WD-40 wet, WD-40 mopped kinda dry... same problem: stiction. I think what I need to do next is flip the CI disk over and cut some channels for swarf removal/stiction eradication... questions: 1) simple cross-hatch or grid pattern? 2) How best to cut the grooves?

Derek, my apologies if I am hijacking your thread... not my intention... but thought that it would fit as another problem to overcome when using these superman-metals.

Re: Is this the future ...?

#10

Re: CPM toolsteels + flattening the backs...

TomD

How do they compare to the performance of your new art level Japanese chisels Derek? At a Bill T level of nuts and bolts performance.

I wouldn't buy those CPV chisels you have on the basis of the toolmanship, rather crude. To me that is the problem. For me, the art chisels I have don't have a problem, Maybe there is a Nascar car out there that is faster than my F150, but I don't see the benefit. And on the other hand I can't make tools in the shop with the CPV, so it doesn't fit my boxes. Not saying it isn't good. Been using HSS in chisels and plane blades since 1981. And Diamnd sharpening (not powder until last year) for about the same time. Where is the news these steels wear better, I sure don't use O1 on my metal working tools. No resistance here, but someone is going to have to offer a product that works for what I actually do, and is worth switching to.

Remember Shapton. We all had to change, and then one day apparently they suck. Just the other day I noticed Lee Valley has introduced two new levels of water stone. I'm not buying all this crap. Practice and diligence is what gets the projects done, not wasting time changing all the tools every time something new comes, out. And when you stand up for that, you aren't being Luddite, just a woodworker.

Re: Is this the future ...?

#11

clarifying a point or maybe forcefully making it a

Bill Tindall

To take my own case as an example, suppose you are starting with a table saw, router, modern Stanley plane with a dull iron and some blue handled chisels that are also dull because you hadn't learned to sharpen. Your goal is fine furniture fitted with the precision only attainable with hand tool fitting. Given my skills and resources, what makes sense to get from here to there when $$ are a consideration? You all would have information that I should find useful.

Anyone with a good set of chisels and a sharpening scheme that works for their needs is wasting their time reading these posts. They should be spending the time in the shop making stuff, and many have fled this Forum to do just that. As you aptly point out, the improvement/$$ spent for many of these improvements isn't favorable if you already have stuff that works. I don't know how/why Warren stands these discussions.

But to get back to my case. I needed chisels and a means to sharpen. It seemed I could make chisels. I research stuff and I have vastly more faith in technical service departments than many of you do. I researched how to abrade hard steel. The modern answer is with diamonds. So I went from an oil stone which never abraded at a a rate that seemed to accomplish anything, to sand paper glued to a piece of glass the glass plant gave me, to some diamond paste a machine shop gave me applied to a chunk of cast iron this same shop found for me.

For chisels I told tech service at Crucible Products the product I wanted to make. The tech service person is a knife maker and he put me in touch with some knife makers for additional advice. I settled on 3V which is exceptionally easy to fabricate with hand tools. In the end I had a set of chisels from 1/8" to 1 1/2" in small increments and the total cost was no more than one LN chisel. They look crude by anyone's standard. I didn't even remove the oxide coating from the shanks. But, damn, they work well and I have used them exclusively for the past 9 years. Over this time I have acquired some other of what you would recognize as quality chisels, but my home made ones are what I reach for. And I might add that I have been making some very fine furniture with them as demonstrated in posts, if you have been following.

In my case I have posted my experience not to change the practices of persons that have successfully acquired tools and procedures that meet their needs. Nothing I have found would add significant improvement to what these people are already doing. Rather, the information is for those that have not settled yet, particularly persons like myself that are in the early stages of acquiring skills and materials. They should have the information to enable them to make the best choices of tools and procedures for their situation. Appreciate this fact.

As a result a small number of people have found diamond abrasives advantageous. And most have justifiably not. Ditto on making chisels or using CPM 3V to do so. If someone is intent on making a chisel and they are about to make it from A2 I will jump up and suggest there is a better choice. If someone says they have or they are going to buy a set of Japanese chisels for $500 I don't have horse in that race.

That clarified, I'm back to finishing drawer 9.

Re: Is this the future ...?

#13

Re: CPM toolsteels + flattening the backs...

Bill Tindall

I am confused by the "problem" Indeed, tools stick to the cast iron, which I find to be its advantage. The sticking keeps the tool oriented properly, be it a bevel or a back. How is this sticking a problem for your sharpening?

For backs I put a spot of WD40 on the plate, paste the chisel to the plate and rub back and forth. The stickshion keeps the iron flat to the plate. I only pull to do the bevel.

Re: Is this the future ...?

#14

Re: Is this the future ...?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Consequently I decided to just use oil based diamond paste on all the stones. I have a set up that uses steel plates (from an old saw) glued to hardwood.

Very clever solution. Now I have something to do with that old Tyzack saw besides sell it.

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Is this the future ...?

#15

Re: CPM toolsteels + flattening the backs...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

The problem with stiction is that I can not move the blade across the (in my case) Shapton stone. Thus, they don't get sharp.

Pam

Re: Is this the future ...?

#16

fatal flaw

Bill Tindall

As I have posted numerous times the diamonds from the coarse plate will embed in the tool, then transfer to the next plate and contaminate it. This flaw is not theoretical. We have microphotographs to prove it and he phenomena is described in old machinist books.

Re: Is this the future ...?

#17

Re: fatal flaw

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yes, but there's nothing that says I have to make more than one plate, nor that all plates would be used for chisel sharpening. :)

Pam

Re: Is this the future ...?

#18

Thanks David

John in NM

Basically looks similar to the acrylic I've seen.

Re: Is this the future ...?

#19

Re: Is this the future ...? -  I think so...

John Aniano in central NJ

Derek, et. al.,

For my 50th birthday last year, Stephen Thomas (of the "Loopy plane" fame) made me a CPM M4 blade for my Stanley 102 - the plane I use to rough out bow blanks. Blanks of hard and abrasive woods like pernambuco, ipe, massaranduba, swartzia species, snakewood, etc. This blade is AMAZING!

Stephen welded the CPM M4 steel to a larger soft steel backing that comprises the majority of the blade's length.

I haven't had any great difficulty sharpening the blade. Just the Tormek wheel and strop on the bevel and the back done with 600 and 1200 grit EZLap diamond plates.

I'd like to get more of these CPM blades for my even smaller bow making planes. Think ~1/2" wide x 1" long x 0.093" thick blades, and smaller. Any suggestions?

John (sorry for the gloat...)


Re: Is this the future ...?

#20

The sucking sound from NJ is strong tonight

Bruce, a MN Galoot

That is a major reason for gloat! Congratulations. How well does it stand up to those nasty woods?

Re: Is this the future ...?

#21

Re: The sucking sound from NJ is strong tonight 

John Aniano in central NJ

Hi Bruce,

I've sharpened the blade maybe only twice now, and used it to rough out maybe 8-10 blanks. I would usually have to touch-up sharpen the standard issue Stanley blade (high-carbon I'm guessing) after every other blank in pernambuco. I have a pretty high bevel angle of ~40-45 degrees on the blade, the same as what I'd have used on the high-carbon blade. Less tear-out that way with the more scraping type of cut. I'm pleased with how well it works.

Roughing out a blank entails planing a ~30" long x 1/2" square piece of wood into a tapered octagonal cross section. The taper goes from ~7mm to around 12mm. I use flat rasps and files to get at the 3 inaccessible facets behind the head section at one end. They are planed while basically straight. The image below shows the sticks after being cambered (bent) using an alcohol lamp as heat source.

John


Re: Is this the future ...?

#22

So, is this the future we want?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tom

You touch on important points.

My new Japanese slicks are excellent, thank you. They get very sharp (the cuts on my fingers are a testament to this) and hold the edge very well in abrasive hardwood. I am very happy with them and do not care if there is something better around.

So why do I bother with these super-steel chisels and plane blades? Well I am curious about them. And I do see an advantage in steel that holds an edge a long time - some may enjoy sharpening, but not I. As I have mentioned many times, the local hardwoods are abrasive (contain a high level of silica) and edges do not last long.

It is ironic that I choose high carbon steel (in the Japanese chisels) for my preferred sets of chisels in place of A2 or HSS, both of which are common these days. I do prefer A2 for plane blades. But the steel in the Japanese chisels is tempered rather differently to that of my Stanley #750s (which I love to use but require frequent sharpening).

The bottom line for these exotic steels is that they are only as good as their ability to get sharp, and the ease with which they are sharpened. They are useless if the effort to sharpen them is unreasonable. I should add that there is the cost of sharpening materials as well, plus this steel is not cheap!

Why do I add sharpening media to the negative side of the ledger when diamonds are so cheap? Because the oil-based diamond paste I have is Horrible to use! It is messy beyond belief. It limits the user to freehand sharpening because it would get into the wheels of a honing guide and destroy them. I am very comfortable with freehand sharpening, but many are not. Further to this, high angle BU plane blades require the use of specific microbevels if you wish to camber the blade, and so looking down the track this becomes a potential issue. As a result we will need an alternative to diamond paste. Perhaps water-based diamond paste is easier to flush from a roller? Otherwise we need a new breed of waterstone to work these steels. Interestingly, I was able to use my Pro Shaptons on the 10V, the hardiest of these hardy steels!

I suspect that the "average" woodworker will not see the point of a supersteel. Soft- and non-abrasive woods do not test plain ol' O1 much, and O1 sharpens easily on just about anything out there. That is one of the reasons I enjoy my Stanleys - they are so easy. However, if I were a Pro and chopped dovetails all day (as I know some that do), I'd be looking for a steel that only needs touching up at the end of a day (and CPM 3V can do this from reports). In a few weekends time I will be a presenter at one of the LN workshops. It is planned that I demonstrate dovetails for two days. These 3 chisels will get a good workout over this time, and I look forward to not needing to re-sharpen them.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Is this the future ...?

#24

Re: Add soap to the water, Pam, add soap

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yeah, I know that now; but I made the mistake of being an early adopter; so the disgust is now intrinsic. But I was responding to Bill's question about "what does stiction matter?"

Pam

Re: Is this the future ...?

#25

Re: Is this the future ...? -  I think so...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

God, I'm so jealous that you've got Stephen Thomas making blades for you. I miss him.

Pam