New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Cutting gauge?

Posts

Cutting gauge?

#1

Cutting gauge?

Joe Shelton

Anyone have a (commercially available) cutting gauge that they really like? I'm not doing well with my current lot.

I'm looking at the Woodjoy, and seething with desire for the one from Awstrelyuh by Colen Clenton, but I'm not sure that's my pearl of great price.

And for gawd's sake, don't nobody tell me to make my own. I have a boat, too, and I'd like to have a life...

Joe

Re: Cutting gauge?

#2

Re: Cutting gauge? *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I have a large Kinshiro mortising gauge that I also use as a cutting gauge, love it. The blades are very, very sharp.

Pam


Kinshiro gauges

Re: Cutting gauge?

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

Lee Valley

Jack Guzman from Maine

Lee Valley has a nice looking cutting gauge. I was just looking at them in their new calalog. They have a good selection of new gauges.---Jack

Re: Cutting gauge?

#4

Re: Lee Valley

James Watriss

I remember owning a Crown marking gauge, which LV has listed as a rosewood gauge... the fence was thick, the beam locked up nice and tight.

I also owned one of the deluxe gauges. Thin fence, didn't lock up very well at all, and fence would wobble, even when tightened. Maybe they've gotten better, but I'll never know.

I will say that I'm a big fan of wheel gauges in general. I really like LV's small 3 in 1 marking gauge, and I've had an eye on the pocket marking gauge for a while.

I have a tite-mark at the shop, and it's been my go-to gauge for about 5 years. I've been about a full size wheel gauge for the home bench... I'm thinking about the LV wheel gauge with the barrel adjuster, but haven't heard much about that one, and how it compares.

Re: Cutting gauge?

#5

Re: Lee Valley

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I've got that 3 in 1 gauge from LV and like it quite a bit; but I think it's too small and lightweight to be used as a cutting gauge.

Pam

Re: Cutting gauge?

#6

Re: Cutting gauge?

Gary Hodgin

I have the same gauge. Nice fence and sharp blade. Works great.

Re: Cutting gauge?

#7

Re: Lee Valley

James Watriss

Agreed... as a cutting gauge it's a wash. It is too small, the blades stick out too far, and they're beveled on both sides. I like it more when they're only beveled on the side facing the fence.

As a wheel gauge, it's a gem. A little gem, to be sure. But a gem all the same.

For what it is, it's a neat design, but even if all it can handle is pin gauge and wheel gauge, that's not too bad.

Re: Cutting gauge?

#8

Re: Lee Valley

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

It's good, certainly better than "not too bad;" but Joe specifically asked about cutting gauge recommendations. :)

Pam

Re: Cutting gauge?

#9

Re: Cutting gauge?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Kinshiro is definitely a master. There's something about his gauges that makes them work perfectly. I bought just the two blades to make a small version, and haven't been able to replicate the performance.

Pam

Re: Cutting gauge?

#10

Re: Cutting gauge?

bugbear

Are you looking for a marking gauge that uses a knife (for cross grain marking) or a tool that makes parallel cuts (e.g. for cuttting veneer strips), sometimes called a "slitting gauge" ?

BugBear

Re: Cutting gauge?

#11

Jack Guzman from Maine

Their new stuff *LINK*

Jack Guzman from Maine

These are the new ones that caught my eye as promising. My go-to cutting gauge is an old one I found on ebay.Before now I haven't been happy with what was available new for a reasonable price but these new ones from Lee valley look good.---Jack


Lee Valley Deluxe gauges

Re: Cutting gauge?

#12

Re: Their new stuff

James Watriss

Yeah... those are the ones I had bad luck with.

Like I said, that was years ago, maybe they're better now.

Re: Cutting gauge?

#13

Moses Yoder

Re: Cutting Gauge

Moses Yoder

If I was making a cutting gauge I would make the fence about 1-1/2" thick and the arm about 1" x 1". This would make a nice solid gauge. The cutting gauge at LV looks like they used nominal 4/4 stock for wood parts, so it appears to be built on the light side for cutting.

Re: Cutting gauge?

#14

Lets not muck about now!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I'm looking at the Woodjoy, and seething with desire for the one from Awstrelyuh by Colen Clenton, but I'm not sure that's my pearl of great price.

And for gawd's sake, don't nobody tell me to make my own. I have a boat, too, and I'd like to have a life...

Hi Joe

You could make your own Woodjoy :D

Actually, I did: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/A%20Marking%20and%20Cutting%20Gauge.html


You know what they say - you can't have too many marking/cutting gauges :) ...


Even the tiny LV Pocket Marking Gauge is used - excellent for small areas ..


For marking the baseline for dovetails, the wheel gauges are hard to beat as they offer so much control.


Their downside is that they need lots of downforce to score a deep line. That is when I turn to a cutting gauge, such as a Colen Clenton or my favourite, the large Kinshiro below, which may be used with a single or double cutter ...


I used to use a knife to score the baseline of dovetails ...


Now I use the kinshiro. This creates a deeply scored line, which is perfect for undercutting the baseline with a chisel ...


... to act as a fence when chiseling out the waste.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Cutting gauge?

#15

Re: Cutting gauge?

TomD

I like the simple Japanese ones with the screw. One of these from LV has been my favorite gage for 25 or so years. Like this but no numbers:

http://japanwoodworker.com/product.asp?s=JapanWoodworker&pf_id=15.255&dept_id=12996

One like this is goo for actual cutting:

http://japanwoodworker.com/product.asp?s=JapanWoodworker&pf_id=15.258&dept_id=12996

JW also sell quality laminate blades for peanuts, either to upgrade these tools (not particularly necessary) or to make your own.

These ones are small but they used to have a wide range"

http://japanwoodworker.com/product.asp?s=JapanWoodworker&pf_id=15.261.06&dept_id=12996

What is good about this design. Thought the captured nut doesn't seem fancy, it has the advantage of being very positive, it will never slip on you. It can be cranked down tight, or left a little loose so you can easily adjust it, with great precision, or take a mark off a caliper, or snug it up to a piece of work. The fence is very postive, the perfect length. It's warm, never rusts, slides nicely, and the blades make a nice mark. All around perfect.

Re: Cutting gauge?

#16

Re: Their new stuff

TomD

http://www.leevalley.com/US/shopping/AddViews.aspx?p=49941

That would be y preference. I realize there are many beautiful gauges out there. I was given a Bridge City mortising gauge. But these cheapos are the best.

I haven't tried one of these yet:

http://www.leevalley.com/US/shopping/AddViews.aspx?p=50327

But I find the cheap thumbscrew so effective, I would wonder. With the thumbscrew, the beam has no bias when you go to creep it. With the wedge, there is one direction where it tightens, and another where it loosens.

I have several of the round ones. Don't like them. They are cold, the beams rust on the LV ones I have. Move it back, and the cutter unscrews. It is tough to get the mark exactly where you want it, since there isn't a point. You can't sharpen the blades, though the replacements are... available. Some might say cheap. I prefer a longer fence... Seem to be popular though.

Re: Cutting gauge?

#17

Re: don't make - convert!

bugbear

I took an old (and nice - wooden screw) marking gauge (cheap and reaily available s/h), and added a blade holder.

The holder is simple a threaded brass "slug" let into the stem, and the visible machine screw passes down a longitudinal hole, via the brass, and bears down on the blade, sitting at the bottom.


BugBear

Re: Cutting gauge?

#18

Lots of good answers...

Joe Shelton

James Watriss and I have, or had, the same problem with that Lee Valley tool. In a way, I'm glad to learn my experience wasn't solitary, so thanks, James.

I've pretty much fixed the problem: I planed the beam to much more nearly uniform width, then glued two pieces if lignum vitae on the sides of the penetrating cut in the stock. That resulted in far less wobbling of the stock on the beam. Then I ground a slight hollow in the face of the brass screw that engages the beam, so it now locks up better than before. It is now useable.

Surprisingly, the catalog describes the tool as having "...excellent fit and finish...", if I recall. When I get through filing and buffing the edges, it will.

After that, I'm going to try the same thing Bugbear demonstrates. That looks like something I can manage. Bugbear, did you grind your own blade, there?

Thanks again to all...

Joe

Re: Cutting gauge?

#19

Re: Lots of good answers...

bugbear

After that, I'm going to try the same thing Bugbear demonstrates. That looks like something I can manage. Bugbear, did you grind your own blade, there?

Ah.

Yes.

It wasn't easy.

Because I made it from an "all-hard" power hacksaw blade, which was not tractable to hacksaw or file!

I used a tungsten carbide "tile saw" to cut the blank, and then ground the profile on stones.

On the plus side, I've yet to need to resharpen it!

I wrote a few thoughts on the blade here:

http://swingleydev.com/archive/get.php?message_id=103919&submit_thread=1#message

and discussed cutting marks in some detail here:

http://www.ukworkshop.co.uk/forums/tite-mark-gauge-details-req-d-please-t7715.html?highlight=titemark

BugBear