New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

japanese plane making

Posts

Re: japanese plane making

#26

Re: japanese plane making *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

1/4" (6mm) is a good thickness for the blade top, matches up with most of the Japanese blades I have. The bevel side of the blade matters a lot, so it might be a good idea to review this area at the Japanese Tools forum linked below.

I got a two-lb hammer to bash in the blade a la Inomoto-san. Of course, if the blade's too thick for the dai, you can bust out the abutments. What wood are you using?

Pam


Japanese Tool forum - how to sharpen blades

Re: japanese plane making

#27

Re: japanese plane making

dburnard

Actually, the faces of the top and bottom dies of their power hammers are purposely crowned, so when a plane blade blank emerges from rough forging it is already slightly concave on both front and back. However I have a few hand forged blade blanks from demonstrations that show the same hollow. If they wanted them to be flat it would be easy to make them that way, but they don't.

When I showed a couple of my early blades to visiting japanese smiths, the bevel side hollow was one of the first things they checked (the ura side is too obvious), and they were amused when I said I had ground mine in. ;)

I remember asking why the hollow was there, and the translation I got back was something like "because that's how a plane blade is supposed to be". That was good enough for me, I was just trying to mimic the shapes back then and didn't understand how they got that way.

Re: japanese plane making

#28

Re: japanese plane making

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Ha! See Thom, it IS something to do with forging. :)

Thanks, Dave.

Pam

Re: japanese plane making

#29

Re: japanese plane making

TomD

Not really, you can forge convex if you want to. And for it to be forged-in then finish ground, what is the explanations? Japanese tools are finish ground you can see the marks. And I have chisels where this wasn't done, ostensibly anyway. It isn't plausible to me that it is forged that way out of necessity, that they end up that way because it is forged. As an inevitable byproduct of forging. If you want a given shape, you forge to that shape. It just makes for less wasted metal, and less grinding or finishing. It does work both ways, there are products that look like they look because that is what happens when you start whacking on a piece of metal. Clipped knives for instance, that is what hppens to a square billet when you put the bevel in, though it begs the question of where the billet came from. But with Japanese tools I figure they look the way they do for more refined reasons than that.

Re: japanese plane making

#30

Re: japanese plane making

TomD

For the benefit of people who don't work with this stuff, a power hammer has numerous dies. The convex dies are for drawing out, which is stretching metal in various directions. Normally, one axis. This, depending on how you start out is often the first step you start with a lump and need to thin it and/or elongate it to make a knife, etc... It is not a stamping die that finishes a product. So in this case the finished result over different sizes of blade is one side that is the section of a sphere, but also flat, and the other than is a section of a cylinder. I'm cutting them more credit than that they just came stamped from the hammer... It is actually a fairly complex shape.

Dave, possibly they thought grinding the hollow in was funny because they hadn't seen a Burr King, traditionally. :)

Re: japanese plane making

#31

Because

Bob Hackett

I am always amazed by people who insist that something HAS to be done a certain way and then their only explanation as to why that is so is "because that is the way is has always been".

I have seen people do incredibly complicated and even dangerous things in industry and and manufacturing only to find out that they are just repeating things as they had been shown with no real understanding of the "why" of it.

These people just never see a better way to do what they do and continue to ape the mistakes made by the folks who came before them.They learn the job but not the trade.

My usual approach to these people is to suggest that if we were all were taught from birth that the proper way to sleep every night was by knocking ourselves out with a 3 pound hammer blow to the head they would go their whole lives never wondering why they had a headache in the morning.(I`m using a very toned down version of my approach here :D )

Most of these type of people have no understanding of what they are making,what the things they produce do after they leave their hands or how they function in the bigger picture.These type of folks are just semi-skilled workers producing a paycheck and should not be confused with craftsmen who fully understand a trade.

Blacksmiths or bladesmiths who have a firm grasp of their craft treat metal like an artist treats clay.They move it where they want it to go.Their prime concerns are having enough of the proper metal (the shape is secondary) and enough power(through the proper tooling) to move that metal.They also need enough heat and a way to control that heat,obviously.

The final product has exactly the rough shape the smith requires in order to fill a need.A trained smith will refine with heat and hammer to the point where there is very little "finish work" involved after forging.The finish work was traditionally handed off to a "whitesmith",who used files,grinding and other abrasives to bring the metal to a bright or polished finish.If you didn`t want the folks further down the line to consider your work as substandard then when the work left your hand it needed only minimal finishing to bring it to exactly what was needed.

Any hollows,swells or deviations from dead flat were there because they were required in the finished product.There is a HUGE difference between blacksmithing/bladesmithing by hand or power hammer and closed die forging(think drop forged) where metal is fed into a machined set of dies which decide the size and shape of the final part.One requires a skilled tradesman/craftsman.The other requires a minimally trained machine operator.

Re: japanese plane making

#32

Re: japanese plane making

dburnard

Wow Tom, we're on different wavelengths today. :)

If it sounded like I was saying planes blades end up hollow as a "not necessarily intended side effect" of forging or using a power hammer, that was the opposite of my intent. Ah the power of the written word. Anyway, curved dies are used intentionally, and the curvature is ground to closely match the desired curvature of the finished product. As Bob says, forging close to final shape saves time later on during cold forging, grinding, etc.

As we've all said, i they wanted them flat or convex or whatever, they'd forge them that way or as close as practical. If you were to hollow a plane by grinding alone you would have to remove too much of the cutting steel in the middle of the hollow, yet as you use up a blade the steel thickness remains uniform across the width of the blade. You could grind out the bevel side hollow without obvious detriment other than spending more time at the grinder. It's just easier and faster to roughly create the hollows and tapers all while it's hot.

Re: japanese plane making

#33

Re: Because

dburnard

Let me explain why I don't think "because" is an accurate assessment of why I got the answer I did.

The question was through a translator who knew very little about woodworking or smithing, and whose english was not so great either. And I was just getting started. I might as well have tried to explain the physics behind how Rayleigh scattering makes the daytime sky look blue through the translator back to the smith. Impedance mismatch. If we were two professionals speaking a shared language, that would be a different story.

Those same smiths have been more than generous over the years in answering my questions, demonstrating various processes and techniques, advising me, helping me find tools, materials and equipment, etc. Having a knowledgeable translator has been essential in all of that. They do think I'm a little crazy for being interested in such things. :)

They are indeed highly skilled at what they do, and there are many different tasks to perform from start to finish on each object they produce, typically in a one or two man operation.

Re: japanese plane making

#34

crawling back under my rock now

dburnard

>;)

Re: japanese plane making

#35

No need to slink.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

And please come back whenever.

Pam

Re: japanese plane making

#36

Translators

wilbur

"The question was through a translator...whose English was not so great either."

Kind of defeats the purpose of having a translator, no? ;)

Re: japanese plane making

#37

Re: Because

Bob Hackett

Didn`t mean for my post to be directed at you or your smith friends/translators,hope it didn`t come off that way.

What I was aiming at was the difference between someone working in a job shop making a part to complete a work order and a skilled tradesman who understands the nuances of what he is creating and the part it plays in the bigger picture.

There is a big difference between a blacksmith and a bladesmith and each operates within their sphere of expertise.

The blacksmith usually has a very wide range of skills as far as forging and repair goes.The bladesmith is more focused on things such as metal selection,forge welding and heat treating in relation to edged tools.I think an appropriate comparison might be like the difference between a family doctor and an orthopedic surgeon.

Re: japanese plane making

#38

Oh, please stick around in the sunlight

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Although I may never get involved with Japanese planes (hard enough to deal with the stuff I already have), I've found this conversation, and your contributions to it, interesting.

Amazing how complex simple things can be.

Re: japanese plane making

#39

Re: Because

TomD

Bob, Japanese way is different, and I'm no expert on what it is. Without nitpicking through your post, their working conditions, their traditions, their way of explaining things is not really consistent. At least as far as I understand it. US industrial paradigm is not the same.

Re: japanese plane making

#40

Re: japanese plane making

TomD

"Wow Tom, we're on different wavelengths today. :)"

That could be because you get a lot deeper into this stuff.

"If it sounded like I was saying planes blades end up hollow as a "not necessarily intended side effect" of forging or using a power hammer, that was the opposite of my intent."

My bottom line is whether the bevel side longi curvature is intentional or not. However it gets there is a different, if interesting, subject. My working assumption is that it is intended. If intended, then I also assume there is a reason for it. That reason could be lost, non-functional, not actually useful/mistake/mythical, or it could be something that can be explained and understood as useful. It could also be useful in some way that was never in their tradition. My nominees is in prepping the ramp, but I can think of other reasons. What I notice about the Japanese tradition is you get different explanations, as one would in any tradition. But I am not sure there is a central story. There seem to have been a lot of different dictatorial apprenticeship models. I have only been in the presence of actual Japanese craftsmen for a relatively few hours, separated by decades. But if they are in any way similar to craftsmen over here, they have widely divergent views that really have to be sorted out somewhat vigorously. What I get mainly out of the discussion so far is that there isn't a commonly promulgated explanation. That is something at least.

"As we've all said, i they wanted them flat or convex or whatever, they'd forge them that way or as close as practical. If you were to hollow a plane by grinding alone you would have to remove too much of the cutting steel in the middle of the hollow, yet as you use up a blade the steel thickness remains uniform across the width of the blade. You could grind out the bevel side hollow without obvious detriment other than spending more time at the grinder. It's just easier and faster to roughly create the hollows and tapers all while it's hot."

The only hollow I am talking about is the bevel side one.

Re: japanese plane making

#41

Re: Oh, please stick around in the sunlight

TomD

Japanese planes are complex, compared to what meets the eye. But the real complexity is only in working out the manual of arms, and getting buy-in from other people. Not all that much has changed in my use of them since first exposure 30 years ago. The internet is a bit of a trap. There used to be almost no interesting information to exchange on these subjects, and one filled in the 5 or so years between shots with actual work. These days one can talk virtually endlessly, and I have pretty much given up on doing work when it is cold.

In this given example. Whether the cross sectional curve in the ramp helps to fit the blade is a moot point. Most of my planes are built, and I have moved on to western ones. Whatever anyone says about it won't change the experience of fitting future blades, whether my perception is correct or not. Reality and an enjoyable discussion have little overlap.

Re: japanese plane making

#42

Tell me about it.

Bob Hackett

They may have Mcdonalds in Japan but I`m told they don`t have any Wal-marts yet.Good for them!

Management in the last shipyard I worked at wanted all the union workers to read Gung-Ho and get behind their switch to JIT manufacturing lifted from Toyota.That went over like a lead balloon.Just In Time,that aptly describes my departure.

Old school craftsmen around the world do have at least one thing in common though.They all hold their cards very close to their vests.

Re: japanese plane making

#43

Re: Tell me about it.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I'm a big fan of JIT. When it first hit my ears sometime in the '80's, I questioned its practicality; so I decided to try it at home (software developers don't get a lot of chances to manufacture physical things besides manuals and disks). I stopped buying multiples of things just to have on hand and started grocery shopping weekly with an occasional trip during. It worked fantastically. I'm still practicing it, and you wouldn't believe how little storage space we require, all but two cabinets are for pots, pans, dishes, and glasses, plus the refrigerator, most of which is still filled with film.

And we eat very well.

Pam

Re: japanese plane making

#44

Re: Tell me about it.

Bob Hackett

The unfortunate thing is that building Navy destroyers is several orders of magnitude different from building sub-compact cars.

Even more unfortunate is that management once again underestimated the huge differences between their paperwork and reality.They had no idea how many modification work orders had come into play between the original contracts and the ships being built at the present time.Needless to say they also seriously underestimated the role the union folks out on the deck plates played in pulling their fat out of the fire on a continuing basis.

I am SOOOO glad I am no longer there.With a little distance it became easy to see that there was so much I hated about the place and so little I liked.

Re: japanese plane making

#45

Yeah, understood.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: japanese plane making

#46

Re: Tell me about it.

David Weaver

I worked at a cabinet factory that was transitioning to JIT the second year I was there. It as a large 500 employee factory and not a small operation.

It greatly improved their productivity and brought back a lot of capital for use elsewhere. It was a situation a lot like a car manufacturer, simplified in a lot of ways, but a little more complicated in others. Mostly the former, though, which is why it worked well.

I can see where it would not work well in a shipyard building low-volume where flexibility is key. Our orders didn't change once they were in, the product was relatively simple and everything on it could be made in a day - far different than getting parts for shipbuilding from outside sources. In our case, it was an improvement though we did continue to stock common doors even after JIT because they are most often the part that throws off the color match if the frames are OK, and it's nice to have a few extra when one glares at you on a cabinet.

That place has now closed - I think JIT helped them last longer in a low margin business.

They took the JIT experience so seriously that we did stretches for the first five minutes of work every day. :b the "elders" didn't think so highly of that.

Re: japanese plane making

#47

Sounds like the problem wasn't JIT itself

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

but management's cluelessness about the organization and its people.

JIT and the other "Japanese" management and production innovations borrow heavily from American models, dating back - depending on whose history you read - to Eli Whitney. Their success, in any organization, requires clear, no fantasies understanding of the environment and the organization; and trust between management and labor built upon good communication and faith in each other.

The admin VP at my old university purported to be introducing quality circles, but he couldn't let go of his power, nor could he communicate honestly enough for them to succeed. The problem wasn't with the model, but with pretending to be introducing the model while really maintaining the old structure. I was right glad to get out of that division and over to the academic side, where labor-management communication happened because (most) workers, whether "labor" or "management," trusted each other enough to talk.

Re: japanese plane making

#48

Re: Tell me about it.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yes, it could be great in most any production line manufacturing business. I find I do have to plan meals a week out; and I was able to minimize accessories (e.g. we have no electric mixers or food processors, only a microwave, a blender, and a hot popcorn popper). The only time it fails is when Jack shops behind my back and brings home three weeks worth of garbage ground beef and freezes half of it, buys nonsense like multiple cans of corn, multiple loaves of cheap bread and freezes it since it takes us at least a month to eat it (and I never eat that stuff). If it were up to me, we could do with even less storage space. I'd never thought of it before last night, but I'd probably be better off if I had taken a JIT approach with woodworking tools. :)

Pam

Re: japanese plane making

#49

Steven Antonucci

Imagine JIT with customization

steven antonucci

I worked for a company that helped a German Automotive manufacturer not only implement JIT, but with line sequencing. Everyday, sometimes multiple times per day, they would send out their supplier orders and the suppliers would not only provide the inventory, but they would sequence it so that it unloaded directly into their manufacturing lines.

Brown seat, blue car, red engine...

This reduced their rework from about 10% to under 1% daily. For years, this is how we bought groceries (walking to the corner store). JIT works, but you have to have buy in and that's not always easy.

Steve

Re: japanese plane making

#50

It strikes me that at some point in the chain

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

somebody's got to carry inventory. Isn't JIT just moving the problem of who's carrying the inventory?

This whole problem will be solved, of course, when the replicator is finally perfected; but that seems to be a ways away yet.