Re: japanese plane making
TomD
"Wow Tom, we're on different wavelengths today.
"
That could be because you get a lot deeper into this stuff.
"If it sounded like I was saying planes blades end up hollow as a "not necessarily intended side effect" of forging or using a power hammer, that was the opposite of my intent."
My bottom line is whether the bevel side longi curvature is intentional or not. However it gets there is a different, if interesting, subject. My working assumption is that it is intended. If intended, then I also assume there is a reason for it. That reason could be lost, non-functional, not actually useful/mistake/mythical, or it could be something that can be explained and understood as useful. It could also be useful in some way that was never in their tradition. My nominees is in prepping the ramp, but I can think of other reasons. What I notice about the Japanese tradition is you get different explanations, as one would in any tradition. But I am not sure there is a central story. There seem to have been a lot of different dictatorial apprenticeship models. I have only been in the presence of actual Japanese craftsmen for a relatively few hours, separated by decades. But if they are in any way similar to craftsmen over here, they have widely divergent views that really have to be sorted out somewhat vigorously. What I get mainly out of the discussion so far is that there isn't a commonly promulgated explanation. That is something at least.
"As we've all said, i they wanted them flat or convex or whatever, they'd forge them that way or as close as practical. If you were to hollow a plane by grinding alone you would have to remove too much of the cutting steel in the middle of the hollow, yet as you use up a blade the steel thickness remains uniform across the width of the blade. You could grind out the bevel side hollow without obvious detriment other than spending more time at the grinder. It's just easier and faster to roughly create the hollows and tapers all while it's hot."
The only hollow I am talking about is the bevel side one.