New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

Posts

3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

#1

3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I received a package from Japan today (via So Yamashita in Sydney). I must share this with you all as I am thrilled, absolutely thrilled.

7 Kiyohisa paring chisels were ordered for my birthday 3 years ago. The wait was longer than I anticipated, but shorter than others have been waiting, so I understand.

You cannot disguise the Japanese packaging ...


But under that was a really friendly touch ...



Then a box made of Kiri (Paulownia) ...



So had written to me about the box ...

First of all kiri is generally considered in Japan to be the best material for making boxes/cases to store objects that doesn't like moisture. Also, it is very light in weight as you know. So in Japan, any super expensive stuffs were/are always stored in kiri boxes, from national treasures to private collections. For instance, various tea ceremony equipments, ceramics, porcelains, and bamboo made tools, sword and related equipments, etc. etc. are ALWAYS stored in kiri boxes.

Now, what's specifically great about Kiyohisa-san's box is that, it is made by a kiri tansu (the most expensive cabinet in J, which cost about 1,000,000JPY for a simple drawers of three~! No mistake in the numbers of zeros here, so in AUD about $12,000) maker as his side business. Normally kiri boxes are made by kiri box specialized makers using less expensive Taiwanese kiri material.

Anyway, this box..., the lid is made so accurately, when you place the lid on the box and let it go, it slo~~~~~wly sinks down. This is the traditional way of making the kiri boxes, a way to show off the craftsman's skill as well, but not too many kiri boxes are made in this manner anymore. In fact, this is the only one that I know that's made this way. Because of such precise fitting, the box is basically airtight, so a kiri box that's already very rust preventing is even more so with these.

When opening this box, one can feel the air sucking the lid back. And then when replacing the lid it sinks ... floats downward on a cushion of air.

So finally this was revealed (actually, each chisel was wrapped separately. I have set these out) ...

7 Kiyohisa paring chisels in 6, 9, 12, 18, 24, 30, and 42mm. These are the sizes I most commonly use when paring.



A few close ups ..



I'm really pleased I went with white oak for the handles. Kiyohisa-san's chisels have a gentleness about them, and the white oak complements this, unlike a darker wood.

So had written, (The handles are) White Oak with Core material. The branch part of Japanese white oak. If you already have high quality white oak handled chisels or kanna dai, you should know that these are very different from European white oak. J oak is much denser and harder. But these days even the most expensive tools (chisels and kannas) are using less expensive less dense Niigata oak, rather than Kyoto oak, so you might be surprised to see Kiyohisa-san's white oak quality.


The finish to the steel is superb, and the handles are smooth and warm to the touch.

And finally (for now), the angle of the handle to the blade ..


I do hope that Wiley is following the forum. He would be excited by these chisels, waiting as he is for his own.

Thanks all for sharing this with me.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: 3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

#2

Re: 3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

David Weaver

Wonderfully precise looking chisels, and very thin and delicate.

Very very nice. I can admit I am a bit jealous :D

Re: 3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

#3

Worth the wait.

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Those are fine looking chisels. They will serve you well for a lifetime. Your post reminded me of the wait I had for my Tasai bench chisels. It was like Christmas morning when they arrived!

Enjoy them! Tom

Re: 3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

#4

Oh, wow, gorgeous. Happy Birthday.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: 3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

#5

Re: 3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

That is a gorgeous set! Congratulations!!

Re: 3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

#6

Question about oak handles

Patrick Gibbons

I wonder if the tree the wood comes from is a live oak? Live oaks here in the US are quite dense with interlocking grain and would be good, I would think, for handles. Your handles appear to have straight grain though. I'm impressed with your knowledge of the various aspects of your chisels. I know that makes using them that much better.

Re: 3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

#7

Re: Question about oak handles

TomD

Live oak is considered to be the closest wood to their white oak, and workable for planes etc...

I think the White oak handle is the best bet. I have told here before, but it seems, appropriate, my experience looking through a large rack of chisels. All the fancy handles were on reject grade chisels. I had really wanted some boxwood handles, which seems ok to me on pairing chisels, but I looked all the examples over and the heads were misaligned, etc... These were multi thousand dollar sets. I settled on a really solid set that had the white oak handles, not tourist grade. It seems that if you want to let them know you are serious...

I do have an Ouchii set in ebony, and it is well put together, though the ebony itself isn't that practical.

Great looking set there Derek. These things, at least, my Tasai, can be sorta super human. It is hard to explain the ease of sharpening, the edge holding, the cutting power and accuracy. We had that laser guided saw a week or two back. The idea one could be laser guided is nice, but the reality is with these chisels. No laser, but that is what it will feel like.

Re: 3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

#8

Well their very pretty...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

But I need to ask what makes them so special? I never could and probably to afford something like these. Ya know, if you have to ask...

So Derek, why get these and a 3 year waiting period to boot?

Re: 3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

#9

Why .....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

But I need to ask what makes them so special? I never could and probably to afford something like these. Ya know, if you have to ask...

So Derek, why get these and a 3 year waiting period to boot?

Hi Scott

I was looking at getting some really good paring chisels. Japanese paring chisels (better than Iyoroi, which is what I have largely used for the past 10 years). Everyone raves about Tasai. I was thinking of them as well. I decided to consult So, who is extremely knowledgable about anything to do with Japanese tools (So has not been taking orders for about 18 months now as he is also running the family business and short of time. However he is still in business, trying to fill the many orders he has. Keep an eye out for his site - and be aware that it takes several minutes to load - amazing information there: http://www.japan-tool.com/ )

So recommended I look at Kiyohisa. He couldn't say enough good things about his work. To this end I am going to copy-and-paste a page from So's website as he describes it so well ...

Kiyohisa


Watanabe Kiyoei is a very gentle person who looks more like a University professor. His tools are as gentle looking and very handsome as the creator himself. Very fluid in the line around the neck, and the back hollow meticulously crafted. Kiyohisa specializes in White Steel #, the toughest Japanese steel to forge. WS#1's range of temperature when hardening is only about 5 degrees. You go above or below and the hardness will dramatically decrease.

The White Steel #1 he uses is not just White Steel #1, but it is a certain lot from the 80s. Although the steel makers wouldn't admit, there seems to be a slight difference in quality between each ingot. Skilled blacksmiths can discern this slight difference, and prefers to use the better (purer = less impurities such as sulphur, manganese, silicon, phosphorus) lots. Since these better ingots are so rare, blacksmiths are desperate to keep such material as a stock, but naturally they cannot afford to buy lifetime supply, so sometimes they go as far to make a loan from the bank to buy as much as they can.

You could say Kiyohisa is the next generation Hidari Ichihiro. They are similar in many aspects. The steel, the fineness of the finish, and overall aura you feel from his tools. Since his tools are very reasonably priced, there are many users who orders his tools repeatedly, thus there is a bit of a long waiting list, half year to one year. He is a quite talented calligrapher as well, so you can have your box signed and stamped by Watanabe-san himself. His tools will be more expensive as his name spreads. Definitely one of my most recommended White Steel #1 chisel brand.

Kiyohisa tools can be ordered by the piece as well. Bench, timber, slick, crank neck, kiridashi, etc. He basically makes everything but saws and hammer heads. He makes plane blade in very limited quantity as well.


The box signed and stamped by Watanabe-san.




Beautiful black back. Hollow handmade by sen (a handtool to grind steel).


Meticulous file work. "

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: 3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

#10

Re: 3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

bugbear

I am put in mind of Gr�nsfors Bruks axes - a simple kind of unadorned perfection.

BugBear

Re: 3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

#11

Re: 3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

Bob Hackett

The closer you get to simple perfection the harder it is to attain it.

Re: 3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

#12

Re: Question about oak handles

John in NM

I don't know how close it is to live oak, but the Emory oak we have out here makes fantastic mallet heads. Emory is a name, after an Army surveyor, rather than emery abrasive - though as hard as the local oak is, many think that is where the name comes from :D

Re: 3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

#13

Re: 3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

Mark Meier

Wow, those are really beautiful. Thanks for the pictures.

Mark

Re: 3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

#15

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Sweet Slicks!

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Good for you Derek,

I am sure the wait had it's moments, but as we know 3 years can slip by quickly with other distractions.

Photobucket

I ditto the Japanese packaging comment, the chisels that I had made for me by Imai all came in special packaging, distinctly Japanese, with hand written comments.

Photobucket

Photobucket

Happy Birthday and Enjoy your new tools!!

Enjoy

Re: 3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

#16

Thanks Jim

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I think your slicks are beautiful, wonderful tools. They were my original consideration.

Looking at the photo of your shop, I cannot find those BS-modified-LN chisels ... possible the most stunning looking Western chisels ever!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: 3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

#17

Jim in Burlington Ont.

BS Modified LN's

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

You mean these,

The handles were made for me by Dave Jeske at Blue Spruce.

Photobucket

At the time of the bench picture in my previous post I was still waiting for these.

Dave made these for me with African black wood,

Take care,

Jim

Re: 3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

#18

Yes!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

As you will recall, I used them as my inspiration to make these modified Stanley 750s (which included regrinding the side bevels). The wood here is West Australian She-Oak.


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: 3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

#19

Hey, Slick!

Joanne in Point Pleasant

I love how the hockey and golf "tools" are at the ready--pretty handy right next to the work bench! Good thing you post pics of your pens fairly often or we might think you sit out in your shop to stare at those sticks to dream of "playing" elsewhere. :-)

Re: 3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

#20

PS--Hey, Derek

Joanne in Point Pleasant

Your new chisels look beautiful and I can't wait to see what you create with them. I love the final rendition of the curved leg table. Everything came together nicely. I really appreciate when you share your processes and progress on your work. And you inspire me to use hand tools more and more.

Re: 3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

#21

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Angles Covered

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Dreaming?

LOL, I am playing hockey several times a week now, the new hip is great.... and so are the new goalie pads and gloves... I love new tools of any kind, most of mine are electron free now, yup, even my hockey stuff!!

So you've seen a few pens eh? ;)

Take care,

Jim

Re: 3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

#22

Re: 3 year wait for these chisels finally over!

Jorge Casta�eda

Derek,

Those are very slick! (pun intended) Looking forward to see what you make with them.

Happy Birthday!