Re: disagree
David Weaver
Did warren get to plane wilburs makore board? I didn't sharpen my plane for that one, and paid the price. I still had it mostly planed, but if I'd have been a little less lazy and sharpened the plane once I figured out which direction it preferred, I probably could've planed it.
What was the contest, what type of wood? If it was about the polish on a piece of wood that wasn't particularly difficult to plane (and that would include something like curly maple), then it's not much of a surprise that it would come down to sharpness and not the type of plane or type of steel used.
The new steels are not necessarily an improvement in sharpness (in fact, I dont' think any of them are at all), they are an improvement in wear resistance and time between sharpening.
Having read through this thread, I still have to disregard anything about there being magical unknowns about the edge of steel that can't be seen with a microscope or even a strong loupe, the same as I'd dispel there being any "magic" with using a double iron. You simply need to set it up so that it is close enough to the edge for it to actually work, and it needs to be prepared properly to do that, there is visual proof of that on the internet, i believe that the setup to break a smoother chip is something like 4 thousandths or less from the edge.
That said, my best finish on a piece of curly maple is still from a standard angle (38 or 39 degrees?) kanna. The steel is fine grain and the sharpness is very good. You cannot take large bites with it, tearout is the obvious result.
But, the infill planes that I have will plane the curly maple in any direction with no tearout to a perfectly acceptable level, and in the end, if you are finishing the wood with anything at all, screwing around wtih the level of polish the kanna makes on curly maple is a waste of time. It is a different story if you are planing a wood that takes a nice polish itself and applying no finish.
Let's not try to get into "mystery spirits" where they don't exist. It starts to sound too much like people talking about musical instruments and arguing about the tone that comes from different pot metals on a banjo tone ring - if you didn't let someone see the rings or talk them up to be something mysterious before they decided what was better, they wouldn't be able to tell the difference.
It is the player's (craftsman's) adherence to proper technique that makes the banjo sound good and the result of the woodworking look good. No mystery is needed - "guild secret" and hocum marketing of "unknowns" is a thing of the past.
Now...if someone can just come up with a plane iron that will keep that immediate level of sharpness warren's #4 had for several hours of work, that would be something.