New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

Posts

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#26

Re: disagree

TomD

That could be, whatever the explanation is. The explanation really doesn't mater, if your interest is woodwork. The Japanese seem to have a lot of time for what I would consider excessive edge work. They can spend hours on it for certain uses, and go several stones into the honing range we don't bother with. they can also get quite into what kind of stones and steel. I tend to listen for discordant practices since that is often where the interesting new info it. Though in this case my main sense of discord is that I don't want to spend that long sharpening, unless it's a hobby all it's own.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#27

Re: The real answer is...

TomD

I don't think you need a burr, you need to grind right through the dull edge, and you may need to grind far enough through that you can sense a burr just to know you are there, but the burr does nothing for you, and I don't always have it. Not all steel seems to support it as well, and not all methods of sharpening need it.

I think part of the answer with methods has to do with two different ways of sharpening. One works the bevel as much as the back. Call this the Japanese method, though everyone uses it on certain tools. In this method, if you grind down far enough with a rough method to get the back where you want it (or just work it on an intermediate stone, or lower level finishing stone), It takes a lot more work to get the damage out, and intermediate stones will prove useful. Same applies to really big chisels or plane blades that aren't hollow ground, and take a lot of work. Presumably there is something here to do with PSI, one just can't get the same action on the larger surface. And some people use this method on Western chisels where the back isn't even hollowed out.

The other method preps the back, and later you don't touch it as much. Maybe just hone it, or buff it. Lots of ways. this method is a lot more amenable to the two stone turn around.

Speaking generally, everything is an integrated system, and how much anyone needs of something is going to be a personal decision. Taking the first exit, means you will never discover what else is down the road. Thirty years or more into this, I'm kind at the point where I need to weed out steps that haven't really added anything to my results. But I'm glad I didn't have to be too quick to judge in the early stages.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#28

Re: disagree

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Probably a good idea to keep in mind that a lot of those Japanese specifying extensive sharpening tactics are temple renovators and builders. That is, they work on contract to various governments.

Pam

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#29

5% Improvement

Warren in Lancaster, PA

So there have been sharpening techniques reported here that result in 5% improvement? I would like to know where this 5% figure comes from. Surely not from experimental evidence? If I report that a technique improves edge life, I am more likely thinking of a difference between 80 strokes of the plane and 150 strokes, not 140 versus 147. I have spent my life trying to discern how subtle changes in technique affect performance, but I have doubts about whether I would notice a 5% difference, let alone report it on this forum. I like a technique that adds 10 seconds to the sharpening time and gives noticeable results. Let's hear it from the 5% crowd. Just where does this number come from?

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#30

Much better than 5%

Bob Hackett

I can tell you that the switch from waterstones(I had previously been using oil stones) to diamond sharpening has cut my sharpening time at least in half to get what I feel is an equally usable edge.So let`s just call this a 50% improvement in efficent use of time.Now what that 50% savings in time equates to in increased planing time I haven`t yet gone to the trouble to figure out.

I also have spent a lot less on sharpening equipment and the savings alone on stones if I look at the market value of all my accumulated stones compared to the cost of diamond powder is well over that 5% threshold.I would go so far as to say the increase in savings surpasses even the previous example of a 50% improvement.

These are two examples of where I have seen gains of over ten times 5%.

Now there is no doubt in my mind that there are people here who can take one of my working planes,pull the iron and make more than a 5% increase in performance in the edge.The question I need to ask is what will I personally have to invest in money/tooling and time/training in order to duplicate their results.That means what tooling will I need to buy and training must I provide in order to get my new employee up to speed on these advances?

The next questions from me;will my customers be able to detect and appreciate these improvements and/or will they cut my time and allow me to increase my profit/output by moving through a project more quickly than I can using the methods I now employ?The improvement must make a difference in customer satisfaction and my bank account in order for me to take notice.

Very few of the people who buy my work care about the quality of shavings on the floor or what I went through to get that foot deep look to the finished product.What they care about is the price and the look/maintenance of the finished product.

I have never had a client run his hand over a finished product and be able to tell me what tools were used to make it,never mind how those tools were sharpened.

Those of us doing this as a hobby rather than a source of income can do whatever they find entertaining and satisfying to get from rough material to finished product.Those who sell their work are the ones most interested in keeping track of time and effort and want to minimize both.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#31

David Barnett

Re: 5% Improvement

David Barnett

"So there have been sharpening techniques reported here that result in 5% improvement? I would like to know where this 5% figure comes from. Surely not from experimental evidence? ... Let's hear it from the 5% crowd. Just where does this number come from?"

I'd guess that it comes from your misreading or misinterpretation of Bill Tindall's post, the one to which you affixed your reply:

"If one develops a sharpening technique or material that improves edge life 5% it should be reported as a technique that improves edge life 5% ..."

Do notice, Warren, that Bill wrote "If one develops ...", not that someone, in fact, did develop and quantify a 5% improvement.

If this is an honest misreading, then hopefully this clears it up.

At any rate, I believe the subject deserves further discussion and I'll be glad to participate if the level of discourse remains civil (now where have I heard that lately?) and focused upon openmindedly and genuinely exploring how, and to what extent, quantitative methods are or are not germane to sharpening technique, and in this interest, endeavor not to muddy the waters along the way.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#32

Re: 5% Improvement

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Sorry, David, I may have misread. In the same post Bill suggested that the bizarre method might have "infinitesimal improvement in edge", and I thought the implication was that people were suggesting techniques that were of trivial utility "improve edge life 5%" and not labelling them as such.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#33

David Barnett

Re: 5% Improvement

David Barnett

Thank you for explaining, Warren. I understand completely, and truthfully, do more than my fair share of that, as well. So, as Emily Litella would say, "Never mind."

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#34

Boy do I miss Gilda.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#35

Re: Boy do I miss Gilda.

wilbur

"What's all this I hear about endangered feces?"

;)

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#36

Re: disagree

David Weaver

Did warren get to plane wilburs makore board? I didn't sharpen my plane for that one, and paid the price. I still had it mostly planed, but if I'd have been a little less lazy and sharpened the plane once I figured out which direction it preferred, I probably could've planed it.

What was the contest, what type of wood? If it was about the polish on a piece of wood that wasn't particularly difficult to plane (and that would include something like curly maple), then it's not much of a surprise that it would come down to sharpness and not the type of plane or type of steel used.

The new steels are not necessarily an improvement in sharpness (in fact, I dont' think any of them are at all), they are an improvement in wear resistance and time between sharpening.

Having read through this thread, I still have to disregard anything about there being magical unknowns about the edge of steel that can't be seen with a microscope or even a strong loupe, the same as I'd dispel there being any "magic" with using a double iron. You simply need to set it up so that it is close enough to the edge for it to actually work, and it needs to be prepared properly to do that, there is visual proof of that on the internet, i believe that the setup to break a smoother chip is something like 4 thousandths or less from the edge.

That said, my best finish on a piece of curly maple is still from a standard angle (38 or 39 degrees?) kanna. The steel is fine grain and the sharpness is very good. You cannot take large bites with it, tearout is the obvious result.

But, the infill planes that I have will plane the curly maple in any direction with no tearout to a perfectly acceptable level, and in the end, if you are finishing the wood with anything at all, screwing around wtih the level of polish the kanna makes on curly maple is a waste of time. It is a different story if you are planing a wood that takes a nice polish itself and applying no finish.

Let's not try to get into "mystery spirits" where they don't exist. It starts to sound too much like people talking about musical instruments and arguing about the tone that comes from different pot metals on a banjo tone ring - if you didn't let someone see the rings or talk them up to be something mysterious before they decided what was better, they wouldn't be able to tell the difference.

It is the player's (craftsman's) adherence to proper technique that makes the banjo sound good and the result of the woodworking look good. No mystery is needed - "guild secret" and hocum marketing of "unknowns" is a thing of the past.

Now...if someone can just come up with a plane iron that will keep that immediate level of sharpness warren's #4 had for several hours of work, that would be something.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#37

 

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#38

Re: Novices

Charles

Well, his regimen is a little different. He goes on to make stuff with his edge tools. Most of the rest of us turn off the shop lights and call it a night and hope, on the way back into the house, the Mrs. doesn't inquire about what we got done this evening -"whatdja do tonight dear" "honey, I re-sharpened the already sharp tools, you know I read a new article about sharpening" "Dear, do you ever think you'll be juried into the New Hampshire Furiture Masters like Garrett Hack?" Ahem, cough, sputter, "well no sweetheart, you actually have to build furniture in order to do that, you know have a portfolio and stuff." "OK, dear goodnight."

Guys like Hack get to be guys like Hack 'cause they're guys like Hack.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#39

There was an absolutely wonderful article

Bruce, a MN Galoot

many years ago in FWW: Cousin Fred�s wonderful woodworking shop

FWW Nov/Dec 1985, pp 122-124

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#40

Re: 5% Improvement - The miracle of compound inter

TomD

The miracle of compound interest. 5% here, and 5% there, and after a while it ads up to real money. A real 5% improvement would be pretty fabulous. Always, as you say assuming it didn't result in a lot longer time spent messing with stones.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#41

A story from Marc Adams

roninkokomo

When he went to apprentice with Tage Frid, he told him that he came to learn how to properly hone hand tools. The master asked him.

"you wanna hone tools, or you wanna work with wood?", Then proceeded to produce a chisel like a razor with a couple of seconds on a belt sander and a couple of more seconds on a powder charged strop.

My impression is that we amateurs spend way more time with some of the little fussy things in the shop and not enough time with our hands and minds actually creating in wood.

Perhaps we are more comfortable that way, particularly since time is NOT money to us.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#42

Re: A story from Marc Adams

TomD

"My impression is that we amateurs spend way more time with some of the little fussy things in the shop and not enough time with our hands and minds actually creating in wood.

Perhaps we are more comfortable that way, particularly since time is NOT money to us."

Well if you are an amateur, which is basically a fancy word for a lover off, why would you spend more time in the shop doing stuff you don't love? I think it is unlikely that the "I only see value in time management and dollars" crowd is actually spearheading the quality woodwork we presumably admire.

Frid is an interesting example, I have his books from when they were first published and have built several of his pieces. Myself I think a lot of the furniture in those books is pretty awful. Typical 60s stuff, that has a nostalgic resonance for me. I don't believe that much of it is original or memorable, and some of the problems like the turned round legs are obvious time saving dodges. His best piece the stool is a great piece, ATMO. And interestingly it came from an insight of typically cheap inclination. Basically, what is the least that can be put into a stool/chair. So he channeled a great personal characteristic into a distinctive piece, which is sorta what second rate artists (but artists!) do, the one novel guys.

He was right about buffing chisels, wrong about Japanese saws, wrong about dovetail endgrain, another cheapness endeavour. Possibly he was right about the dovetails if his furniture proves as durable as anyone else's, it certainly won't be as easy to repair.

Money is a universal value, by definition. So while it is rarely anyone's first passion, it is everyone's second. So for instance, while my kids are priceless to me, I might well agree that your kids eduction is important so that the tax base can be ultimately expanded, and crime, and social services reduced. So monetary arguments are convincing because everyone sees the value. But it is well to remember that money is fungible and everyone agrees only because everyone can spend those dollars differently. So when you agree over money, there is really no agreement at all on matters of values. So why bring it up?

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#43

Read a similar anecdote....

John in NM

In a biographical article by Hank Gilpin shortly after Frid's death.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#44

Huh???

roninkokomo

I was not extolling Frid's furniture. I really am not enthralled with a lot of Krenov's furniture. I admire his genius and his approach to the craft

I was pointing out that they want to work wood and they will take what they believe to be the most practical approach to doing so. I really believe that among hand tool enthusiasts there is a large group of folks who really want to collect and admire and fiddle with the tools. They say they are woodworkers to justify their habit... but how much woodworking comes out of their shops?

Please understand that I am NOT making a value judgment here. It is their shop, their time, and their money.

I am just saying that there are a lot of people who really would rather sharpen tools than actually use them.

Those folks will spend their time differently that the guy who actually went out in the shop to make something.

Ron

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#45

Re: There was an absolutely wonderful article

Charles

I'll see if I can find it....

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#46

Re: Huh???

TomD

I agree with that. My point is that the just getting on with it attitude, as necessary as it is, is not conducive to the other stuff, and that it showed in Frid's work. Cutting corners is no different applied in one area or another. He extolled the virtues of power sanding his furniture with a belt sander. I have one, they are fast, and they can be mighty useful. But there are people who still use planes. Even at this level of criticism, it isn't saying he was wrong. What I am rejecting is the idea that there aren't any downstream consequences to these choices.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#47

Re: Read a similar anecdote....

TomD

You can see it in his video.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#48

OK

roninkokomo

I understand.... but in almost all cases, to workman has much more profound influence than the tool. I have seen sculpture done with only a hatchet that is much finer work than I am able to produce with the finest carving tools.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#49

And that is the difference...

John in NM

Between making money and not making money for a professional like Frid was. The skill of a professional is measured by how small they can make those downstream consequences and still have little enough time invested to remain profitable. Like many other amatuers, I'm very glad to have the freedom to not worry about profitability. When I sell some work, I don't worry about how much time I spent on it, I'm just happy to have the extra $$$ :D