A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening
Bill Tindall
David Barnett, in a post below on diamond sharpening, quotes a sharpening scheme described by a noteworthy woodworker.
I repost it as follows: "For those who don't subscribe to FineWoodworking.com or have a slow connection, here it is:
1. 600 grit 10" DMT DuoSharp diamond stone with oil
2. medium india with diamond paste and oil, says it cuts like 1000-grit
3. hard Arkansas surgical black with oil, says it's around 5000 grit cutting action
4. 8000 grit Norton waterstone with water
5. cherry block with 1 micron diamond paste and oil, "used just like a stone""
Rather than point out the numerous less than optimum materials and techniques used in the unnecessary steps, I will just bury the procedure with a simple experiment .
The experiment: I ground a Two Cherries 3/4" chisel on a 600 grit DuoSharp plate. My plate is fairly new so it likely left deeper scratches than a broken in plate, but I knew that detail was insignificant to the result. I followed with 15 pull strokes on a cast iron plate charged with 1 milligram of 1 micron diamond powder and lubed with WD 40. Examination of the edge revealed hints of a few stubborn 600 grit scratchers that were removed entirely with 5 more pull strokes.
Conclusion: One can step from 600 grit diamond to 1 micron. I have stepped from an 80 grit wheel to 1 micron diamond but that jump is not optimum. The 1 milligram of diamonds wasn't wasted on the experiment. I will not have to add more to shapen numerous additional chisels.
Apparently steps 2, 3 and 4 are designed to dissuade the timid from using chisels.







