New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

Posts

A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#1

A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

Bill Tindall

David Barnett, in a post below on diamond sharpening, quotes a sharpening scheme described by a noteworthy woodworker.

I repost it as follows: "For those who don't subscribe to FineWoodworking.com or have a slow connection, here it is:

1. 600 grit 10" DMT DuoSharp diamond stone with oil

2. medium india with diamond paste and oil, says it cuts like 1000-grit

3. hard Arkansas surgical black with oil, says it's around 5000 grit cutting action

4. 8000 grit Norton waterstone with water

5. cherry block with 1 micron diamond paste and oil, "used just like a stone""

Rather than point out the numerous less than optimum materials and techniques used in the unnecessary steps, I will just bury the procedure with a simple experiment .

The experiment: I ground a Two Cherries 3/4" chisel on a 600 grit DuoSharp plate. My plate is fairly new so it likely left deeper scratches than a broken in plate, but I knew that detail was insignificant to the result. I followed with 15 pull strokes on a cast iron plate charged with 1 milligram of 1 micron diamond powder and lubed with WD 40. Examination of the edge revealed hints of a few stubborn 600 grit scratchers that were removed entirely with 5 more pull strokes.

Conclusion: One can step from 600 grit diamond to 1 micron. I have stepped from an 80 grit wheel to 1 micron diamond but that jump is not optimum. The 1 milligram of diamonds wasn't wasted on the experiment. I will not have to add more to shapen numerous additional chisels.

Apparently steps 2, 3 and 4 are designed to dissuade the timid from using chisels.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#2

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

John Aniano in central NJ

Hello Bill,

I have to agree with you on the (2) steps needed to get a tool sharp enough to continue working. Today, I touched up my high-speed steel rehairing knife, a basic single bevel tool, 5/8" wide with a ~45 degree angle to the blade; bevel angle ~30 degrees.

Process: I used a 600 grit EZLap plate to take a tiny nick out of the edge. I then used my now - "souped up" soft Arkansas stone with the same 1 micron diamond paste I had put on it last week. Added a drop of odorless lamp oil. Honed the back, maybe 60 strokes, honed the edge, maybe 30 strokes. No jig - hands only.

Result: As sharp a cutting tool as I would have gotten if I had used my 800 and 4000 grit waterstones. The knife easily shaved an endgrain maple wedge which I needed to do since I was rehairing a bow.

Total time to remove the nick and sharpen the knife: Maybe 2 minutes.

Conclusion: I like the diamond sharpening method! Looks traditional, with a twist!

Yes, I know the diamond will "contaminate" the stone. This stone was one of a group of four Arkansas stones I got at a flea market for ~$30 and had not really used up till now (because they were so slow). Yes, I know the Arkansas stone alone would work, but the cutting speed is radically increased with the diamond paste. I can always resurface the stone with a diamond plate or my Norton surfacing plate if I feel nostalgic.

John

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#3

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

wilbur

That's really interesting.

I tried to replicate Bill's experiment tonight. I took a 3/4 Marples chisel, established a bevel on a coarse DMT diamond plate, then went straight to my natural Japanese waterstone (don't know the grit but it erases 8000 grit waterstone scratches), and I had obliterated the scratches from the diamond stone with 15-20 strokes. So clearly, natural Japanese waterstones are the way to go. :D

I did see one issue where intermediate steps might be useful. The scratches on the bevel were gone, as I could see with a 15x loupe. But the burr that was raised on the coarse diamond stone took some doing to be chased off with the fine Japanese natural waterstone. Redoing the experiment with one intermediate stone (another natural Japanese waterstone that's about 3000 grit or so) made the burr much easier to manage, and added a trivial amount of time and effort to the sharpening process -- another 15-20 strokes, and less than 30 seconds to set up the intermediate stone.

FWIW, my usual sharpening routine is 1000 grit man-made Japanese waterstone, then the ~3000 grit natural Japanese waterstone, then the very fine >8000 grit natural Japanese waterstone. Most of my sharpening time is spent on the 1000 grit waterstone, and then moving through the next two steps takes about a minute or two, max, mainly because I'm never trying to set speed records.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#4

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

John Aniano in central NJ

Hi Wilbur,

In your posting you said "... made the burr much easier to manage, ...", and it made think about my sharpening experience this morning. I don't really aim for a burr or wire edge when I'm sharpening. If I consistently aimed for a burr, a great many of my edge tools would be much shorter! I aim for not seeing light on the edge as the point when to stop. Sometimes this can be done, at other times, yes, there is a wire edge. I just don't aim for forming one, and then having to remove it.

My $0.02...

John

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#5

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

wilbur

Going for the no light stage is what I usually do, too. I noticed this tonight mainly because I couldn't help but raise a burr with that coarse DMT stone.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#6

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I could ridicule the regimen you outline as easily as you, Bill, but your comparison is quite weak. You did not compare the performance of chisels sharpened your way with the bizarre method. We do not evaluate chisels by how they look, either by eye or magnification. The hardest parts of learning to sharpen are discerning when the tool needs sharpening, and noticing how subtle changes in sharpening routine affect performance, whether it be initial sharpness or longevity. My experience suggests that intermediate steps are worthwhile both for speed of sharpening and performance of the edge.

John, there is little danger of wearing out a chisel just by forming a burr each time. Until recently I had only five bench chisels and some I have been getting a burr every time since the 1960's. Certainly 10,000 times won't wear out a chisel. And without burr formation I doubt you are getting the best performance.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#7

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill

I cannot criticise the regime of a novice, even though to you and I it may appear excessive. Learning to sharpen is a rite of passage we all take, regardless of the path we follow in this regard. There are shortcuts to discover, but who can say when one is ready to find them?

John, as Warren has already pointed out, creating a burr is the cornerstone of sharpening. You cannot get a proper edge without one. Indeed, I use the burr as an indicator that I am progressing appropriately, and remove the burr at the end of each stone (on the final polishing stone) just so that I can create it all over again!

I am happy with my sharpening, yet another may dismiss the methodology as inefficient.

Rule #1: Keep the amount of steel as small as possible - use microbevels.

Rule #2: I hollow grind all my blades, Japanese included (the 10" wheel of a Tormek creates a shallow hollow and keeps the reinforment where it should be).

Rule #3: the 1000 grit stone is the most important. I am not too fastiduous about keeping my Shaptons flat (as I believe this is not as important when freehand sharpening), but the coarse stone sets the stage for all that follow, and this one must be flat. I need no more than 2 stokes on a freshly hollowed blade to get a burr on the 1000.

Rule #4: You can jump to your polishing stone if the microbevel is small. I often go directly to a 12000 Shapton, and this requires around 5 strokes to complete polishing. However, if I am re-sharpening for the fourth or fifth time, I will use an intermediary 5000 Shapton.

Generally sharpening a freshly hollowed blade takes about 30 seconds.

Hope this helps someone.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#8

Novices

wilbur

The "novice" is Garrett Hack. He describes this sharpening routine on the FWW website.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#9

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

James Watriss

I'm a little timid about jumping into the middle of this, simply because sharpening as a subject is almost as incendiary as politics these days. If it helps y'all to picture me in a skirt, and saying 'yoo betcha,' feel free...

After 2 years at school of sharpening every day, or at least every other day, I found that repetition was more important than sharpening media or anything else. I had Norton waterstones, Shapton, Japanese stones, diamond paste... and very little money left. : )

Every time I switched to a newer, better media, I felt like it was doing a better job. But after a while, I went back to some of my earlier stones, and realized that my better edges were due more to my experience sharpening, than to getting something newer or better. I will say that diamond media is a wonderful thing, and it does seem to cut faster and better than most of the oil stones I've tried, and it does polish better.

I will add that while I didn't always go for a burr, there were a few times when I had some very finely polished blades that simply weren't cutting very well. Eventually I had to admit that as nice a job as the diamond paste was doing, the polish clearly didn't extend to the very edge. The burr is my proof that the stone has worked that face to the very edge. Sometimes it felt like I'd managed to polish the edge back up without making a burr, but it proved to be an unreliable method.

I think that, in all honesty, the biggest contributor to speed is practice, and infrastructure. Having a sharpening station that's maintained and always set up encourages proper and regular sharpening like nothing else. Unpacking, shuffling, soaking, cleaning, and repacking of stones or strops or plates or whatever takes more time than the actual sharpening does. If everything's already out and ready to go, and stays there, those quick touch-ups are much more likely to happen.

I think there's a time and a place for more elaborate setups, with more steps, and making sure the edge is as pristine as it can be. But regular chisels don't typically fall into that category... unless they're my sword steel chisels. They go the extra mile for me. So I go the extra mile for them.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#10

Re: Novices

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Wilbur

Well as we know Garrett Hack ain't a novice! My observation is that it is more likely the novice who will use a multitude of sharpening grades in their regime. For example, sand papers 240-400-600-800-1200-1500-2000, and spend a long period on each. That is not a criticism, just an observation. As I noted earlier, I think we all search for a shortcut as we become more experienced.

I looked up the video of Garrett sharpening on FWW. The context of his demonstration was to show that the wire edge (burr) formed during sharpening was important.

http://www.finewoodworking.com/SkillsAndTechniques/SkillsAndTechniquesArticle.aspx?id=28819

Garrett begins with the diamond stone (red tab -600 grit?) to obtain a decent wire edge. Although he does not state this, I think that he was just grinding a new primary bevel. He moves onto a medium India stone with diamond paste (as the India is "somewhat glazed"), which he estimates at 1000 grit. This is generally where most of us begin and where, I suspect, Garrett would also begin were he not making this video. He does about 20 strokes on this. The next stone is a Hard Arkansaw Surgical Black, estimated at 5000 grit. Garrett turns the chisel blade over to remove the wire edge at this stage (- something I would not do with an intermediary stone). He moves on to the 8000 waterstone with the comment, "this is where I definitely do the back". It sounds like the 8000 is where is stops for general work, but to get that extra edge for detail work he ends with a 1 micron diamond paste strop.

All-in-all, I would say that Garrtt's regime is very much the same as many of us. I may also incorporate a final strop to ensure that the wire edge is removed and to add a little extra smoothness to the blade edge. My preference is .5 micron mylar film (from Lee Valley), which I contact glue to a glass-cladded hardwood block the size of a waterstone. This makes a terrific strop to use between honing the blade, and extends the life of an edge very well.

http://www.leevalley.com/en/wood/page.aspx?p=33004&cat=1,43072

I will add that I also have a dedicated sharpening station, so it is all set up ready-to-go when needed. My interest in sharpening derives from my desire to get it out of the way as fast as possible.


The 1000/5000/12000 waterstones are side-on as I use a side-to-side freehand method when sharpening most blades. A honing guide is used when preparing high angle blades for BU planes.


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#11

Ellis Walentine

Nice setup, Derek!

Ellis Walentine

Someday I will have to take organizing lessons from some of you folks. I don't even have running water in my shop.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#12

Re: Nice setup, Derek!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Ellis

I got lucky. Three years ago we decided to build a suite of rooms for my private practice above the garage, which is also home to the workshop. The garage/workshop had to be gutted as the roof came off (that was a source of Jarrah and Karri!). I woodworked from under the vines at the rear of the house while building was underway (that sounds romantic, but the summer flies and heat in Perth was murder). The addition gave me the opportunity to add running water - something I had long dreamed about. Having this dedicated sharpening centre makes handwork so much easier. Rebuilding the workshop has been an on-off affair. I guess I'd rather build furniture.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#13

disagree

Adam Cherubini

Hi Warren,

I think I disagree. And I'm surprised by your answer. I would think that all that matters is the geometry and surface of the cutting edge. Whether you achieve that by dutifully stepping through the grits or not shouoldn't matter, only the end result.

My sense has always been that we step through the grits because our finest stones cut so slowly that to use them to polish out deep scracthes would be inefficient. Now that folks have fine stones that cut fast, I too question the sense of stepping through the grits.

FWIW, my touch ups are now almost all done with a Oachita and a fine ark, raising a burr on both stones and a quick swipe with a strop.

Knowing Warren, it could be that his edges are just far superior to mine tho. Wht he thinks of as sharp may be way sharper than what the rest of us think of as sharp.

Full disclosure: Warren (is my friend and) came by for a visit before Christmas. He brought with him samples of stock he planed in some smooth plane contest (was that in WiA?). Warren beat the competition with a plain ole Stanley #4. I'm sure a certain degree of skill is required to plane wood PERFECTLY smooth. Not to diminish Warren's skill in any way, but my guess is that he simply showed up with the sharpest plane.

Think about that as we argue these sorts of things and Warren has a different answer than the rest of us. Warren outsharpened Marcou, Konrad Sauer, Clark and Williams etc etc.

I still think you're wrong tho buddy! A microscope should tell the tale.

Adam

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#14

Re: disagree

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Adam, I think empirical evidence suggests that things are a more complicated than either you or Bill have suggested. I think there is a lot we don't understand. As bizarre as Garret's method seems, there may be buried in his steps something that is actually helpful to his edge.

As to plane comparisons, some of the planes (at the time I tried them) were not so sharp. However, planing angle is also a big factor. Higher angle planes just do not cut as cleanly as planes in the 40 to 45 degree range. Andrew Hunter, demonstrating at Williamsburg last week, gave a fine surface to figured maple planing at 42 degrees.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#15

Re: disagree

Adam Cherubini

Metal is funny stuff. It's possible all that rubbing does something wierd. (let's just let that lay there, shall we?) There's this thing called edge morphology which I believe involves how (or that) steel grains can change their shape, or realign themselves etc with stress or abrasion. At the very least, honing in a single direction (especially front to back)can effect the longevity (as well as performance) of the edge.

Hard to argue with the guy whose Stanley plane iron outperforms everyone else's laser cut cryo treated A2 whatever.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#16

Let me clarify a point

Bill Tindall

Even if we allow that his bizarre choice of materials and technique leads to some infinitesimal improvement in edge, does it serve the readers well to advocate such a technique? Rather than potentially improve reader's planing I think it discourages people from considering the merits of hand tools. And that is my complaint with this and a lot other stuff that is advocated by the "experts". The complexity, and cost, becomes an impediment to using, or learning to use, hand tools.

The furniture built in the 18th and 19 century is beautiful and lasted because it was exquisitely shaped and fitted with hand tools. It doesn't take nanometer edge refinement to do this work and it certainly doesn't take such sharpening efforts to begin the path toward acquiring the skills and experience to use hand tools for this work. To that end, in most cases we should be exploring and advocating the simplest and cheapest means to achieve an edge that works adequately.

If one develops a sharpening technique or material that improves edge life 5% it should be reported as a technique that improves edge life 5%, and not as "the way" sharpen. If the technique or material results in an improved finish in cases where no further surface refinement will occur, again state this fact. It will be irrelevant to all that sand or scrap before finishing. I can imagine 5 metrics to be used to compare techniques and materials-will it cut, cost, time, skill required, edge life and surface quality. News Flash- the last two are irrelevant to many, but that is where most claims are made. With such truth in reporting the novice trying to get a shaving off a new plane can better judge whether lack of a 5 step sharpening is the problem or whether step 1 failed.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#17

Here,here

Bob Hackett

I`m moving over to Bill`s side of the room on this one.

The idea is to go a new woodworker`s feet under them and getting their tools to make shavings and leave an accectable surface while producing those shavings.

Let`s focus on what gets the job done effectively at the lowest level before we wander off into the land of diminishing returns.Most folks want quick and easy with a minimum outlay of cash.They want to work the wood not the steel.I think what people like Bill,David and others are suggesting here will do just that.

You guys with the electron microscopes that scan and enlarge the grain structure of different alloys in order to establish baseline for engineering software that empirically proves that quantum mechanics does in fact play a part in obtaining as near a perfect edge as humanly possible will have to hold off till we can get past showing the new guys how to remove the thin metal part that is supposed to curl the chip from the thing we want to rub on the stones OK?

Please continue to admire each other`s micro thin test shavings and feel free to stretch them out and read your engineering test books thru them while we show the new guys how to put their irons into their new sharpening jigs(horrors!!!). :D

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#18

I think one of the dilemmas of online fora

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

particularly open-entry fora like this one, is the multiplicity of audiences served. I agree with Bill T.: a newcomer needs a sharpening regimen that will efficiently - and, if at all possible, simply - make for a sharp cutting edge, or s/he will get discouraged and move on to or return to electron-eating tools.

Advanced woodworkers also need an efficient regimen, but have reached a level of proficiency such that they can explore whether this approach or that one will allow for an edge that generates see-through shavings from impossible wood planed against the grain, leaving behind a surface you can see yourself in, even before the finish is applied.

I have the same reaction every time the subject of braces comes up. Yes, the North Bros. Yankee 2101 brace is probably the best one ever; but a $2 garbage sale Stanley no-reputation brace, if it's not clapped out, will hold bits and bore holes, 95% as effectively as the best. Maybe, if you need a brace to bore dozens of holes a day, seeking out a 2101 is vital; the beginner just needs something that will aid in boring a hole or two a week. Conversations among the advanced that imply you shouldn't even consider a brace less than the best are not necessarily helpful to the young beginner whose budget is limited.

There's obviously a middle ground here: if I'd had better tools when I started frightening wood than the junky 1970s Craftsman jack plane and chisels I acquired then, my learning curve would have been a lot quicker. But there's a level of sufficiency in tools and in techniques; and then there's high end refinement. I wouldn't turn down a set of Barr chisels if I found them on the street, but I doubt I'll ever pony up for them over the ragtag assortment of old Stanleys, Pextos, Greenlees, etc. that I've acquired. What I have works just fine.

While I like Bill's approach conceptually, I'm not sure how many people could quantify results; but maybe every conversation about the (many) subjects in this field could emphasize "I take this approach because it gives me this."

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#19

David Barnett

And clarify you did

David Barnett

"If one develops a sharpening technique or material that improves edge life 5% it should be reported as a technique that improves edge life 5%, and not as "the way" sharpen. If the technique or material results in an improved finish in cases where no further surface refinement will occur, again state this fact. It will be irrelevant to all that sand or scrap before finishing."

You couldn't have made it clearer and you couldn't be more correct.

There is a corollary to skipping intermediate grits in cutting, faceting and polishing corundum; rubies and sapphires -- second only to diamond in hardness. A typical cutting progression for beryl (aquamarine, emerald, etc.) might be 300, 600, 1200, 3000 prepolish, and polishing with 8000, 14000, and perhaps 50000. The only reason for all these stages is for speed and effect. That is, the lower grits get you to a shape and initial planes, the medium grits get all the facets ready for polishing, and the polishing sequence removes scratches from each prior step.

Believe me, no faceter will retain an unnecessary step. Each step introduces chances for error and wastes time. If a faceter can skip a grit stage without adding time, you can bet that stage will get removed from the sequence.

More interesting, though, is that some grit stages can actually prolong the sequence and even have deleterious effects on the facet surface for future stages, a regression, that is. When cutting sapphire, a 1200 stage brings out the absolute worst in sapphire and requires that one go back and recut at a lower grit. This not only results in lost time but also cuts away valuable gem material with loss to size and weight. So faceters cut to 600 grit, generally skip trying to prepolish at 3000, and jump directly to 8000 grit to begin polishing.

While steel isn't nearly so costly in respect to wear, time does matter to most woodworkers, and intermediate honing steps should be abandoned if shown to be unnecessary. Granted, performance of the steel edge is everything in sharpening. Performance in a faceted gem is purely aesthetic and optical. Nevertheless, here is where what can be measured meets praxis, rationalism intersects empiricism, where plain evidence quashes superstition.

Jumping from a medium or medium-fine stone to a 14000 diamond lap is an order of magnitude gain in technique, in time and accuracy both. That's how you sharpen Occam's razor.

In all fairness and with all due respect, I believe Warren's laudable results are more due to his long experience and fastidiousness in sharpening than to his sharpening methodology alone. And if I had a burr since the 1960s, I'd probably be just a crusty as he is. :)

"A microscope should tell the tale.", says Adam, and so it shall.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#20

David Barnett

Perfection is the enemy of "git 'er done"

David Barnett

"Let's focus on what gets the job done effectively at the lowest level before we wander off into the land of diminishing returns. Most folks want quick and easy with a minimum outlay of cash. They want to work the wood not the steel."

There have been times that I enjoyed working the steel, but ultimately it was toward working the wood.

I learned to sharpen because I had to. Paring and skiving book leathers is not a casual process. Knives had to be sharp. Holes in thinned leather edges show beneath endpapers, and holes were more often caused by a dull edge stretching and tearing the leather rather than too-aggressive technique. There was no mystique to sharpening. You just did it.

When I later took up woodworking, I brought my sharpening skills with me, giving me a leg-up with hand tools. English parers were skewed single-bevel blades, so chisels and planes were nothing new, and French parers had single bevels with a turned edge similar to a card scraper. One difference, though, I had more tools to sharpen and they needed sharpening far more often.

I got drafted into teaching others to sharpen when I attended my first hand tools woodworking class. I was good at it and enjoyed helping others get good at it. Somewhere I realized I was sharpening for the fun of it -- the Joy of Sharpening. And being immersed in an environment with a long history of craft; industrial machining, woodworking and so on, in no time at all I discovered scraping. Metal, that is.

Well, after flattening plane soles, I quickly progressed to other flattening interests. Anything scraped or abraded or burnished to a high level of surface refinement became my raison d'�tre. And from there I went from micromachining and finally, to faceting and gem carving. In fact, my love of cold working and polishing eventually led me to glass casting and p�te de verre, which is where I've pretty much dropped anchor for good.

But for all that grinding, scraping, rubbing, honing, polishing, buffing, and whatever obsessive frottage sublimated my baser animal drives, it's always been about the work, about ultimately making things, even though I will admit to having way too much fun along the way. I'm just fortunate to have had the time to experiment and enjoy the journey.

I've too often seen beginners without sharpening skills struggle and give up, how incomprehensible and daunting sharpening is to some, and how rapidly an aspiring craftsperson progresses when this hurdle is overcome. We all know woodworkers who were initially drawn to hand tools, who ended with a whole shop full of power tools just because they never learned to sharpen.

Beginners should learn to sharpen as quickly and cheaply as they can. After that, improving those skills will be an intriguing and pleasurable quest, if one is so inclined, rather than a daunting and desperate necessity.

And to think this verbiage started out as a pithy *NM* subject title, heh. Happens.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#21

The understanding of it is key

Bob Hackett

As someone who used to be tasked with keeping an entire boatyard sharp and working I can say that yes,there are many ways to refine an edge to the Nth degree.

What is crucial to getting something back to work and the bills being paid is an understanding of how a tool works and especially what is actually taking place at that intimate meeting of work and edge.Once the light goes on for you there the rest is cake.How you choose to cut that cake and what color plate and what type of fork you use is up to you.In reality a stick will still allow you to""git-r-dun" and eat your cake.

I have heard people say things like you "absolutely have to flat grind and hone a turning skew to make this cut".That just kind of flies out the window when I step up and make the same cut with a hand hatchet that everyone just saw me hollow grind.

Likewise the time someone insisted "this cut can only be made with this type of gouge ground in this manner".I took a piece of water pipe and quickly ground it on a belt sander and made the cut.

What can I say,I`m a smart ass.

Knowing how a tool works allows you to both keep it working and further refine it`s action.Whatever you choose to sharpen with is a tool.Understand how that tool works and doors begin to open.How many of those doors you choose to walk thru depends on your needs, commitment level and the time you have available to explore.

Complicate things before you even start and you`ll be stuck at that first door far longer than you need to be.The frustration of all that wasted time is what causes many potential craftsmen to throw up their hands and walk away.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#22

Definitely agree...

John in NM

People often get into their own pet regimes, simple on the one hand, complicated on the other. We have the regime under discussion on one side, and another famous craftsman (now deceased) who reportedly sharpened his chisels by a quick swipe on a big belt sander. Both craftsmen do fine and somewhat famous work. In this context, does it really matter how one sharpens?

Seems like sharpening was historically the apprentice's job. Tedious and time consuming, yet important to learn. In the modern world, sharpening has been elevated from a job to an art, and really, I'm not sure this promotion is really appropriate. Work should be judged by the final results, and while a "perfect" edge tool might be nice, you don't see plane blades displayed in museums, galleries, and magazines (well, not in most magazines :D). Sharpening techniques are interesting as points of discussion, but we tend to gloss over the fact that no one cares how you do it if the resulting furniture looks great.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#23

this sentence:

Bruce, a MN Galoot

"You guys with the electron microscopes that scan and enlarge the grain structure of different alloys in order to establish baseline for engineering software that empirically proves that quantum mechanics does in fact play a part in obtaining as near a perfect edge as humanly possible will have to hold off till we can get past showing the new guys how to remove the thin metal part that is supposed to curl the chip from the thing we want to rub on the stones OK? "

very well might be one of the finest ever writ on this here forum.

Applauds all around!!

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#24

Interesting point

James Watriss

Most of the regular chisels I own always started to get shiny, or downright reflective, as they approached a final polished state.

By contrast, my laminated Japanese chisels move from a semi-gloss even shine, to a hazy surface with a clear demarcation line between the soft steel/wrought iron back, and the hard tool steel that makes up the cutting edge. So the additional rubbing clearly does do something.

If Warren showed up with an old laminated SW iron, this may be part of it. I haven't the faintest idea how it all plays out on a microscopic level, but I do know that those old irons have a bit of magic in em.

Re: A case of "Excessive Compulsive" sharpening

#25

Gotta love a good smart ass

James Watriss

Better a smart ass than a dumb ass, I like to say.

Your sharpened water pipe reminds me of the time I used a carving knife to scrape down a cutting board in a friend's kitchen. Used one knife to turn the edge of the other... thought my friend was going to thoroughly soil himself.

From a simple historical perspective, considering the steels being used, and the amount of alcohol being consumed, and some of the stories I've read of drunken tradesmen sweating out a living, I think the level of precision we're talking about in here would have gotten our ears boxed by now.