New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Veritas -vs- LN

Posts

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#26

Re: Just for clarity....

charlie belden

John:

You might find one difference - if you have to resurface/flatten an old cast iron table saw table, bandsaw table or joiner table. The older cast iron develops stresses and strains as it cools - sort of like wood develops stresses and strains as it dries. If you've ripped a board and had it Wish Bone on you or Spread Leg on you you're familiar with the phenomenon. I'm told that Ford use to let their cast engine blocks age/cure for almost a year before machining

them.

I got a Not Flat bandsaw table on a Laguna Tools LT 16 SEC. I sent it back and asked for a FLAT table - and specifically asked them not to machine the one I returned and send it back to me. LT ignored those instructions, had the table reground to make it flat and sent it back to me. In two months it was no longer flat. Getting that resolved took a significant amount of time and effort.

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#27

The Swedish equivalent of that impossibility

Bruce, a MN Galoot

is "seven thousand, seven hundred, seventy-seven."

My grandfather used to say it to impress us, but I never once got close.

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#28

LOL!

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

I tried it in Google Translate, and it is indeed a mouthful! :D

DC

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#29

Hi Bud...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

LN or LV is a personal choice. It depends on what you like. Both planes have good points and bad. It depends on ergonomics for the most part. If you can try a LN to compare to the LV you have now, you'll have a good idea of what is one of my most important features, comfort. If your looking to buy a old Stanley, I have two nice Stanley 4-1/2 that I'm going to be selling. Email me if your interested.

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#30

That difference isn't in the iron so much...

John in NM

It's in the corner cutting in manufacturing, and the seasoning of castings is exactly what I was discussing earlier. Part of the expense and quality of old American iron machines is in the practice of letting the castings sit long enough to not have the problems you describe. I remember a reference somewhere to Powermatic letting their castings sit for a year or so (going on memory here, might not be 100%), buried in a sand pit. That is a lot of money tied up for 12 months in inventory that you can't move.

I'm afraid my off the cuff comment was more a matter of doubting some of Tom's more romantic tendencies, and not really very serious.

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#31

Re: Grey vs. gray

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Sure, understood. We sold software into multiple countries, and it was hard. Honestly, Pinehill was too small to accommodate much variation; so whenever someone complained, I empathized and explained that we were a small company. Fortunately I have brief skills in many Latin languages and watch a lot of foreign films.

Pam

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#33

If you work big...

Bob Hackett

And have good upper body strength then a 4 1/2 is the smoothing plane for you.

My brothers both love the ones I set up for them. :)

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#34

Re: That difference isn't in the iron so much...

TomD

Rather than doubting my more romantic tendencies, my wife has yet to notice any, you are free to simply find me some actual quality machine tool that has for reasons of playing in the tens, tosses the old world iron for the sewer pipe. I'm just asking, so far no takers. I am happy to hear of it either way.

There is no romance in distinguishing various iron properties, any more than knowing the differences between pine and ebony, or engleman spruce from sitka, or WRC from Port Orford, etc... Just the product of a sufficient exposure. I make musical instruments, archery equipment, boats, aircraft, and general woodworking, so the distinctions are a mater of survival one way or another.

General, the Quebec tool meisters, were superior for so long because they were known to age their castings long ofter others decided to take shortcuts. They still may. Though I was recently talking to a dealer about one of their CNC machines, and he enthusiastically told me the one I was looking at was made by General, not General International, their Chinese import arm. That seems like a distinction without a difference when on considers the likely origin of CNC machine parts. :)

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#35

Better for a bar than the internet...

John in NM

I really think this kind of subject would do better over a couple beers, there's so much missing when I get tempted to try to rib you a bit in type :D I don't really consider the debate important, but it's worth engaging in for the fun of it.

I think from a logical point of view, the everyday differences between the two iron's are not discernible in everyday use. Take an old hand plane and a new LN, demonstrate for me that one is superior to the other due to one iron casting vs the other. I use both, not preferring one over the other.

My General bandsaw is a newish Canadian made model. I suspect the castings are ductile iron due to how easy it is to drill (holes in the frame to mount a brush that wipes the bottom wheel). Drilling cast iron is not pleasant in my experience, whereas ductile iron drills like bronze. I notice no difference in using the bandsaw vs any of my old machines, most of which are pre-1960.

I claim the difference does not exist in everyday use (the warping example aside, that was not demonstrated to be intrinsic to the material, rather to the manufacturing process). It is not possible to prove non-existence, therefor I claim the burden of proof is on you to demonstrate the existence of a difference.

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#37

Re: Interesting point...

Tony - Memphis

Fortunate for us, we have the National Ornamental Metal Museum here in Memphis. They offer lots of neat classes. I was surprised to learn what a "big deal" it was to cast iron when I took a casting class. We poured our own Al. The intructor poured the bronze (mush heavier and hotter). They had an event when they cast iron October before last. It was quite a show! We melted the Al and bronze inside for our class. The iron was done outisde and it took a team of many to handle it all. They did it at night and it was quite spectacular. I'm not sure what al they cast that night, but they had groups of school kids scratch a design into some sort of ceramic looking material (about lik ea 4" tile" and poured those for the kids. Neat place to visit if you pass through. It is a workign museum and they make a real effort to answer questions and such. Felt like I was in an aquarium when I was in class there. I thought about taking the casting class again and making some sort of pattern for a tool, but I never got around to it. I don't really have a good way to do any secondary ops on soemthing like that anyway. I still have some pieces from class I never finished up.

Tony

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#38

Demonstrate a difference?

Bob Hackett

Too easy!

Stand at the bar with one of each type of plane in front of you.

Pick up the first plane and heave it as herd as you can at the concrete floor beneath you(I`m assuming we`re standing in a Texas bar).

Now do the same with the other plane.

The plane in pieces is the cast iron plane.The bent one is the ductile.

Ready for the bonus points round?

Chuck that bent plane up in the handy handy vice at the end of the bar(remember,Texas bar) and bend it back with a few mallet blows(the barkeep`s bat will do in a pinch) then put it back to work to get bonus points.

Any takers? :D

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#39

I'll supply the labor...

John in NM

If you supply the planes! :D :D :D

Since its a Texas bar, once we straighten the ductile iron one back out, it gets tossed in the air and a patron draws his six shooter and drills a nice .44 caliber hole in the heel, handy for hanging the plane from a peg!

Seriously though, I don't claim there is no difference at all, just that one who waxes rhapsodic about the bygone days of good old grey iron would be hard pressed to discern a difference without either research or destruction.

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#40

Oh.

Bob Hackett

You meant no difference in the operation of the planes.

Never mind(said in his best Emily Latella,SNL voice)

Guess I can down this Lone Star(the National Beer of Texas) and leave the bar now.Then again,maybe I`ll stay a little longer and give the mechanical bull a try. :D