Re: Veritas -vs- LN
TomD
Quality wise, I think the Lee Valley stuff is similar in quality to the LN stuff.
The most important part of a plane is the blade, and current blade production seems similar, and to be similar materials. Cast Iron, can vary great deal in quality, I don't see any obvious differences in quality there, but it would be hard to know. Bronze is something I will pay a premium for, having had bad luck with cast iron on a few occasions, and just generally prefering the slickness of bronze, not to mention the look. LN does more bronze, and now LV also has the chrome look finishes, as another option. I was just watching this ten video set where a guy did the majority of planing with an LN block plane, looked like a sponsorship thing. As I watched, I couldn't help daydreaming about machining a nice piece of bonze to swap out for that cast body...
Design wise, I look carefully at a particular plane to sellect it according to my needs and preferences, That has lead me to buy LV when they had wider blades, or mouth adjust on their low angles. LN got the low angle thing rolling, but LV has kept it going, and they can be useful planes, and easy planes. I have had concerns about some parts in LV planes, the extended tab for the handle on one of mine I found looked weak. But it has held up.
Design wise, experimental vs classic, as I like to say about shooting, "I don't think there are any tens in it" Meaning that's a nice change but there isn't any score moving points in it. Planes are simple, there are many ways to avoid the basics, but eventually that is what it comes around to. Keep them sharp, well set, and learn how to use them. While my heart is in the change and experimentation that LV is doing, it can lead to a plane shelf that looks like a prototype lab. You can buy their best plane, and next year they will top it, dropping your version to an also run status. They started with Bailey repros, and now are pushing the Miller Falls type cars with fins planes. LN makes beautiful versions of Stanley planes, but best case, it's still a stanley look plane... I rode most of this roller coaster through the local LV stores, where I first bought their early planes, then LN when LV was a dealer, and more recently some of the interesting Veritas offerings. I'm a devoted LV customer.
All the above said, I would make a wooden plane, they are ultimately better ATMO, metal planes are to wooden planes like the internet is to the newspaper, except only the bad part, none of the functional improvement. Like jeans to a hand made suit? Hard to say. For the most part, at higher levels the best planes are wood. Partly function and partly economics.