New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Veritas -vs- LN

Posts

Veritas -vs- LN

#1

Veritas -vs- LN

Bud

Hello everyone. I'm new to the handtool world, been using juice for 30 years. I'm completing a new workbench and have discovered the joy of whisking away shavings with a good plane. I've just received a new Veritas #6 foreplane and, well, wow.

I'm hoping you guys can share your expertise with me. Though the plane slices easily, I am left with some gouging on the sides. I know thru reading that there are 2 ways to deal with this, radius the entire iron or radius just the corners. I'd like some opinions on both and instructions on how to accomplish either. I think I'm asking the right group of guys after reading some of the strings.

Also, one other thing. I think I'll take the plunge on a good smoothing plane next. I've rolled the dice on ebay for a few #4 Bailey's but I keep losing. I've shopped the local antique marts, but the few Baileys or Sargents I've found cost as much as a new Veritas, or nearly so. Now I'm thinking new. My question is, why is there a $100 difference between a Veritas #4 and a Lie-Nielsen #4? The Veritas I just got seems like a well built piece of equipment, is LN that much better?

Thanks in advance for your advice.

Bud

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

Moses Yoder

On a smoothing plane you are looking for a nice flat surface so the iron should be straight across with just the corners radiused. On a jack plane or scrub plane you are looking to remove wood, not finish it, so the entire iron can be cambered. More camber means more agressive wood removal but then it also means more work to smooth afterwards. A #6 could have a very slight camber across the entire iron and work pretty well for its intended purpose. The reason the LV costs less than the LN is because that is the price point LV aimed for. It's a matter of taste I guess which look you prefer, LN traditional or LV contemporary. The LN is a little heavier I think and in my opinion looks a little better but so far as I know they leave pretty much identical surfaces behind when they are used. I have a few LN and LV tools and like both companies. I think LV has done a good job of developing an innovative look and features to their tools.

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#3

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

David Miller from Iowa

With regard to the gouging, just radius the corners as Moses indicates, and then reduce the blade depth when you are getting near the end. Make sure your cutter is in straight. And get yourself a scraper as well - a Stanley #80 is a great starter piece.

With regard to product references, there is no right answer. The traditional route is to start with the vintage Stanleys (or Sargents - whatever you find cheap) and learn to tune and and use them a lot. No only are there differences between brands, but there are often noticeable differences between individual planes of the same brand (this is probably more true of the vintage planes, and less so on the than the newer LV or LN.) I subscribe to the school of thought that you can't truly appreciate a plane upgrade until you have reached the technical limits of your previous plane (although I have a number of planes that are are way better than my primitive skills require).

I have several LV and LN planes and I would hesitate to recommend one over the other. LV is revising the designs and coming up with a lot of new looks and ergonomic products, and that is very exciting. LN makes a great quality example of a tried and true design. My answer is that you need all of the above.

One nice thing about LN is that if you don't like the plane, you can sell it on eBay for 80-90% of what you bought it for. I have seen LN planes sell on eBay for the same price as their factory list, and the buyers have to pay shipping, where the could have gotten free shipping straight from the source. I guess I never looked at LV stuff on eBay.

Good luck, David

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#4

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

Jerry Nicholson

Be very very careful about buying those old Stanley and Sargent planes. It is easy to step out on one of those slippery slopes. I had a couple of completely useless Craftsman planes for years and then bought a beat up #8 at an antique shop in Eureka Springs. Sharpened the blade and WOW it actually worked. I started haunting E-bay and learned about sniping. Bought a #5. And another. And a #4. Of course I told myself I could stop anytime but once I headed down that slope there was no stopping. Of course the 50 or so planes I bought look really neat (to me anyway - my wife is less impressed) on display in my workshop. Some of them have been adorned with Veritas blades and Hock chip breakers. Then I bought an LV plane. And then another. And then another. And on and on.

I have nothing at all against LN but I really like those LV low angle bevel up planes. I have several blades so I can change cutting angles at will. The Stanleys? I use one occasionally.

Jerry

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#5

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

TomD

Quality wise, I think the Lee Valley stuff is similar in quality to the LN stuff.

The most important part of a plane is the blade, and current blade production seems similar, and to be similar materials. Cast Iron, can vary great deal in quality, I don't see any obvious differences in quality there, but it would be hard to know. Bronze is something I will pay a premium for, having had bad luck with cast iron on a few occasions, and just generally prefering the slickness of bronze, not to mention the look. LN does more bronze, and now LV also has the chrome look finishes, as another option. I was just watching this ten video set where a guy did the majority of planing with an LN block plane, looked like a sponsorship thing. As I watched, I couldn't help daydreaming about machining a nice piece of bonze to swap out for that cast body...

Design wise, I look carefully at a particular plane to sellect it according to my needs and preferences, That has lead me to buy LV when they had wider blades, or mouth adjust on their low angles. LN got the low angle thing rolling, but LV has kept it going, and they can be useful planes, and easy planes. I have had concerns about some parts in LV planes, the extended tab for the handle on one of mine I found looked weak. But it has held up.

Design wise, experimental vs classic, as I like to say about shooting, "I don't think there are any tens in it" Meaning that's a nice change but there isn't any score moving points in it. Planes are simple, there are many ways to avoid the basics, but eventually that is what it comes around to. Keep them sharp, well set, and learn how to use them. While my heart is in the change and experimentation that LV is doing, it can lead to a plane shelf that looks like a prototype lab. You can buy their best plane, and next year they will top it, dropping your version to an also run status. They started with Bailey repros, and now are pushing the Miller Falls type cars with fins planes. LN makes beautiful versions of Stanley planes, but best case, it's still a stanley look plane... I rode most of this roller coaster through the local LV stores, where I first bought their early planes, then LN when LV was a dealer, and more recently some of the interesting Veritas offerings. I'm a devoted LV customer.

All the above said, I would make a wooden plane, they are ultimately better ATMO, metal planes are to wooden planes like the internet is to the newspaper, except only the bad part, none of the functional improvement. Like jeans to a hand made suit? Hard to say. For the most part, at higher levels the best planes are wood. Partly function and partly economics.

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#6

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

wilbur

There is one important difference between the Veritas #4 and the Lie-Nielsen #4, and that is in the mechanisms used to control the blade. Since you already have a Veritas #6, you're familiar with the control mechanism -- a knob to control the projection of the blade, and that knob can be moved left or right for lateral adjustment.

On the Lie-Nielsen #4, and on vintage Stanley/Bedrock bench planes, the knob that controls blade projection is tucked under the frog, and the lever used for lateral adjustment is a separate mechanism. One thing that this allows is for adjustment of the projection of the plane on the fly as you push it. This is a hard thing to describe in words, but if you see this in person it's pretty intuitive. There may not be many occasions where you'll need to do this, but the other thing I've found is that this knob position makes it quicker to fine tune your blade projection as you make your test passes with the plane.

The Veritas #4 also has set screws that can be used to lock the blade in place to keep it from moving side to side, like you have on your Veritas #6, but not very many people that I know that have this plane use this feature.

As for the gouging, if you are trying to use your Veritas #6 for removing a lot of stock, I'd put a radius across the entire width. If you are using it for jointing, just knock off the corners.

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#7

Not all iron is created equal

Bob Hackett

When you buy an old cast iron plane you have the potential for loss if it`s dropped.Cast iron doe not bend ,it breaks.

The new iron planes(like LV & LN) are usually made from ductile iron,a completely different animal.If you drop one of the high end iron planes onto a concrete floor it will dent or bend rather than break and be ruined.

A huge difference that should be pointed out.

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#8

Re: Not all iron is created equal

TomD

I just wonder about that. This ductile iron thing is apparently the bees knees for sewer pipe, and not that common on machine tools as far as my inquiries would indicate. Forming pipe may bring with it different demands... I haven't had any problems using the new stuff so possibly picking up a few thumps to the ground is a good trade-off. I could get all high and mighty about what kind of nitwit would drop a plane on a concrete floor, but that was a field test I felt compelled to undertake, and can report that all that happened is you chip the handle. But buying old machines etc... has made me a connoisseur of old iron, so I still wonder. Iron is like wine, and is there to be appreciated.

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#9

Re: Not all iron is created equal

Bob Hackett

Ductile iron is used for much more than pipe.

Two applications that really jump out at me are the castings for automotive differentials(if you`ve ever broken one of these you`ll appreciate the difference) and the biggest difference for folks like us is between the C clamps coming out of China that are made of cast iron and can be snapped rather easily when you try to clamp with too much force or bend them back after they`re sprung.

The ductile iron(and they`ll say DUCTILE on `em) are more resistant to deformation and can be brought back and returned to service if they are sprung.

Well worth that little extra cash IMO.

In larger machinery,just like in the car differential,ductile brings the increased strength (closer to steel) yet retains the stability and vibration damping of cast iron.Thinner cross sections and weight in the casting as compared to CI and yet less vibes and less costly to cast and easier to machine compared to steel.

But I digress.

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#10

Re: Not all iron is created equal

Rob Lee

Hi Tom -

It's not just drop protection that makes ductile a better choice - it's literally the ductility of the material. We can use thinner sections, and not have to worry about material failure- in areas like plane beds... no chipping, blown corners, or cracks.

Often overlooked too - is the stabiltiy of ductile over grey iron... gray iron can continue to move over time, where ductile will stabilze quite quickly.

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#11

Interesting point...

John in NM

"Often overlooked too - is the stabiltiy of ductile over grey iron... gray iron can continue to move over time, where ductile will stabilze quite quickly."

I remember reading that part of the expense of large cast parts was in letting them sit buried in sand for months or even years, hoping to achieve some measure of stability before machining. I wonder if that was part of the driving force in the development of ductile iron - save time, save money.

Incidentally, its nice to see grey spelled grey :D I used to buy fly tying materials as a kid, and about half the time "grey" was on the label for the "grey squirrel tail" or whatever. I see though, you've covered all bases by using the alternate spelling right after :D:D:D

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#12

Grey vs. gray

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Since Rob runs a company with international markets, he's probably just trying to respect all spellings. Here's hoping the Australians don't start spelling it "grae," or he'll really be in trouble.

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#13

Re: Grey vs. gray

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

My middle name is Grey, and I always get a little irritated when I see it used to describe a color; but of course that's silly. According to the OED, "grey" is British "gray." So the question is how conflicted are Canadians over this issue? My guess, based on Rob's equivocation, is very. :)

Pam

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#14

Re: Grey vs. gray

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

at least he didn't feel an obligation to call it "fer gris," out of respect for his Quebecois neighbors.

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#15

 

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#16

Re: Grey vs. gray

TomD

Since they are locked in time over french, you run into the same problem of who to please for the french usage. Canadian spelling, who knows any more. The computer is putting paid to that. You select Canadian Engish in the MS world for your computer, and it makes the keyboard unusable, and then doesn't actually allow most Canadian spellings anyway. Nice Job, maybe the next 20 years and it will sort out.

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#17

Re: Interesting point...

TomD

Cheaper is better, and smaller sections though scary, is also cheaper. But LV is never driven by cheaper where it would otherwise count. I just wonder why it wasn't used in old machines, when they made good stuff, though large section as Rob says. Cast iron is like a lot of old things, like shellac polish, or hide glue, hidden depths, with people scavenging for particular types and cutting it up and passing it around, or using it as found.

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#18

Just for clarity....

John in NM

I was intending to refer to cost savings in the "seasoning" time of large castings such as used in machine tools and heavy woodworking tools, engine blocks, etc. I think you took that meaning, but I would like to be clear that I'm not claiming ductile iron was developed to save money in the manufacture of hand planes :D

Smackipedia says it was patented in 1949, while actually invented in 1943, both dates somewhat earlier than I would have guessed. It would be interesting to know when the material percolated from pipes and engines to machinery castings to hand planes.

Romance aside, I don't believe I could tell the difference between cast iron from different foundries or even from ductile iron in the everyday use of hand planes or table saws.

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#19

Re: Grey vs. gray

Rob Lee

Hi -

Bill is correct - I do change my spelling and use of language to fit the intended recipient. That usually means changing some idiom, using alternate spelling, or evem alternate words.

On the UK boards - you'll find our catalogue has cramps, most of which are a great piece of kit, and the majority work a treat, whilst others are just your standard good value.

In the US - we have a color catalog, and issue refund checks - while in Canada, we have a colour catalogue, and issue refund cheques.

Then too - spelling will depend on if I am writing personally, or using the company voice - where we have adapted "mid-Atlantic" spelling (closer to the American, than the British).

Up here - spelling can be quite contentious. I know that we receive lots of mail about about spelling choices - just a week ago, I received a letter from an ex-customer who refuses to buy from us until we revert to the British versions.

Now if you think all of that is difficult - try doing it all in French (as we're doing right now). Not only can the names be different on either side of the pond - we're actually having to establish names for tools....

One almost needs to cultivate multiple personalities to write correctly for every audience!

Cheers -

Rob (and Rob, and Rob...)

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#20

Re: Interesting point...

joel moskowitz

Casting cast iron is hard. Just take a look at Stanley castings from the pre-WW2 era. Their cast planes from the period are lighter than the modern versions - something that I find a big advantage. Also by and large they are flatter. Cast planes do move over time but considering the age of some of the old planes and wear - the planes are pretty darn well made. Modern casting has real trouble making stuff that thin and light.

American cast iron from the 19th and early 20th century was amazing. Huge casting, light, weight only where you need it, A real lost art. I have a friend who collects patterns and it's really amazing how complex the mold, cores, and patterns were.

On big machines of course heavy casting are fine and give nice stability. Of course casting really big stuff has it's own issues.

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#21

Actually...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

That would be "fonte grise" :)

DC

Who would go for some poutine at lunch but the scale says "NO"

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#22

I sit corrected

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Way too many years since I sat in class and tried to learn French from Mlle Dunphy, who once spent five minutes trying to get us to understand the difference in sound among "eau," "eaux," and some other spellings that sure all sounded alike to us.

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#23

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Grey is Grey, eh or is it Gr eh?

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#24

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Grey vs. gray

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

My Heavens Rob....all that to keep the peace...

:-)

I can just imagine some of your meetings and the concepts that come and go based on language alone...

Take care.

Jim

Re: Veritas -vs- LN

#25

Re: I sit corrected

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

If you want to get back into practicing French, repeat

"trente-huit truites cuites"

ten times in a row :D

DC

(that means 38 cooked trouts, in case anyone wondered)