New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

My first Krenov plane

Posts

Re: My first Krenov plane

#26

No need to apologize

Bob Hackett

Sharing different techniques is what we`re all here for.

We all tend to do things as we saw them demonstrated because we know we`ll get the desired results .Unless we are open to suggestions such as the ones you made we may never stop and consider there may be a better or easier way to do something.

As you probably know by now,I like to question everything,especially the things I think I know for sure.An inquiring mind is one of the requirements for learning and growth and I hope I never stop learning.

Allowing yourself to see things from another person`s perspective is the first step to gaining new insights.The next step is to actually try those new ideas out so you can find if they`re applicable to the way you operate.Even if you find them to be less comfortable than what you are presently doing they may lead you in other directions and if they do nothing else but help you refine your present techniques then taking the time to explore them has been time well spent IMO.

One of the new ideas I`m trying to integrate into my life is to stop thinking in terms like right and wrong.Many people think that their way is "right" and any other way is "wrong".If something works and is safe then it`s not "wrong" it`s just different.Doing things differently from time to time can bring discovery and amazing results.

Sanding to get more consistent finishing results,especially on end grain,was a huge eye opener that I would have completely missed if I had kept telling myself that my way was "right".Coloring wood and using colored filler as well as using texture to enhance my work was another departure into different that brought my work to another level.

I`m experiencing a lot of growth since discarding "right vs wrong" mentality and looking at "different" as an opportunity to learn.

Re: My first Krenov plane

#27

Re: No need to apologize

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yes, I think we discard right and wrong as we age, which is when we must prioritize with a vengeance.

Pam

Re: My first Krenov plane

#28

Re: My first Krenov plane - for Pam

TomD

The case Krenov made for the thin blade is that it had less bevel, so it was less flexible. If all surfaces where equaly continuous, and equally rigid, the thin blade is supported nearer the end than the thick one. Because the metal continues to fall away on the bevel of the thick one. On the other hand, it is likely that not all surfaces are equally etc... And if the blade isn't well supported, the ramp isn't perfect, or flexes, then blade stiffness is a big factor.

Hock blades are a lot thicker than the blades Krenov shows in his books. I prefer them that way.

Re: My first Krenov plane

#29

Re: If you like...

TomD

On Krenov planes I normally do what Pam does, and you can depending on the wood, and fit, just have the whole mess discharge on you. I dropped a very heavy and sharp blade on my sandled toes, once, or actually caught it on my toes, and it was a bloody mess. The alternative would have been a lot of grinding. You would be unlikely to loose the blade if you always do the adjustment with the mouth down. Some folks have dropped, particularly breakerless blades through the mouth onto their toes.

Pam can more than handle a hammer and a plane. :)

Re: My first Krenov plane

#30

Re:The real answer.  Hit it like you mean it

TomD

Two other minor points. When removing the plane, the blade is going to loosen, so I hold it the same way I do for adjustments. It's all part of the same continueum, and I am going to pop that sucker out.

The other point is the whole Japanese thing, and for all we know the Western thing to. Often at a seminar, one doesn't learn that much about the stuff one went to see, particularly if one is already up on that as an interest. One learns stuff around the subject. I have attended two Japanese plane seminars in NH, one was the original one at Bear Brook park, and the other was Harrellson's about 10 years ago. In both, one of the lasting impressions is how hard they hit stuff. They aren't messing around with some modern, white collar hammer than belongs in the treble range of a piano. They hit stuff so it stays hit. One of my two strongest memories from Bear Brook, was watching the guy set-up the bench with a sledge sized hammer, mortising out the hole for his stop. And a similar memory is watching the teacher wedge in the plane blade on a Japanese plane. I normally set mine just south of hand tight, up till then. Not these guys, they set it like a railway spike. The benefit of that, is that it is well held, but also that it is at a repeatable depth, because that is pretty much as far in as that thing is going to go. You set your blades like that, and you better hang on when you pop the blade back out.

This might also be a Western thing, we just don't know because much of the craft revival thing was the product of energetic hippies. Their day didn't start as my father describes the day starting around his father's shop. There they did everything by hand, piecework, and maybe they used a 4 ounce brass hammer, to "get 'er done", but I doubt it.

Re: My first Krenov plane

#31

Re:The real answer.  Hit it like you mean it

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Oh, yeah, I use a 2-lb hammer, mainly because it hits the wood with its weight so it's very easy to control. A lighter hammer and I'd have to wail away, thus increasing chances for misdirection.

One minor correction, I think Harrelson's still in MA, very close to NH, but still MA.

Pam

Re: My first Krenov plane

#32

No granola here

Bob Hackett

I learned how to adjust wood planes by watching and asking questions of the joiners in the boatyards I worked in.No brass and wood designer hammers here!

Most used fairly heavy mallets made from wood like hornbeam,lignum and mesquite.

It was a series of firm taps but I`m taking about tapping with a dense wood mallet about the size of a blacksmith`s hammer.

Their philosophy was that if you had to hammer the wedge home then the fit of the wedge needed to be looked at and tuned.A heavy handed joiner didn`t know how to tune his tools was how they looked at it.

This is coming from old hands who used these tools for 40+ hours a week and made their living by them.

Re: My first Krenov plane

#33

Re: No granola here

TomD

Yeah, well what do they know, they were making boats. :) I have to admit I don't smash away on wedges with a sledge either. Just pointing out different cultures.

My Grandfather did a stint working on boats as well, but a rather different scale. He probably worked on the Titanic, or one of the sisterships, since he worked for that company for some time. There was a massive amount of interior woodwork on those ships. The main staircase of the Olympic survives in a Hotel in England.

Re: My first Krenov plane

#34

Joiners are my heros

Bob Hackett

We think we do some high quality work in our shops.

Try making furniture that must fit precisely into place against surfaces where nothing is square or plumb and the surface you are trying to match is a compound curve that accelerates rather than follows a constant radius.

Now measure that surface,build the furniture off ship,in a shop sometimes miles away and bring it back and install it with little to no fitting on site.

Keep in mind this furniture must sit level with the boat in the water and when you take your measurements the hull is sitting on inclined ways so that has to be taken into account too.

Most of the stuff I saw and helped build looked like it belonged in museums.Exotics wood veneers over high tech substrates and it all looked like it grew there.You think it`s a modified antique till you go to lift it and find it weighs about 1/2 of what you expected.And the stuff has to be bulletproof,waterproof and stain proof.

Are you beginning to get the picture why these people are my heroes?

Yacht work,gotta love the opulence and over the top extremes people go to just to outdo the boat in the next slip.

Re: My first Krenov plane

#35

Don't have any wedges to smash. 

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX