New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

My first Krenov plane

Posts

My first Krenov plane

#1

My first Krenov plane

John M in Mid Mich

Trying out the Krenov plane instruction from David Finck's highly detailed book. The pic below is my very first result. Posted it to the "dark side" forum since it was made with filthy electron motive apparatus. One response there questioned my use of a chip breaker. In my defense: after all, Finck uses 'em, and when I ordered the blade from Ron Hock, he includes 'em. But I'm no expert, so I ask here: what's up with chip breakers on thick irons in hand made planes? Pointless? Essential? Optional?

Cheers.

Link to the other post:

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/messages.pl/page/1/md/read/id/428273/sbj/new-year-s-plane/


img

Re: My first Krenov plane

#2

Re: My first Krenov plane

TomD

Yes!

I started out making Krenov and Japanese planes, and using various records and Stanleys. One thing that is different about the Japanese planes is that the breaker is a separate piece, it is not attached to the main blade. Whether making Japanese planes and agonizing over getting the CB fit just right, or just being lazy, I would leave the CB out. Also, my first Japanese plane cut .0003 shavings, and was made from a scraper that did not have a CB. That was thirty years ago, and I always sorta felt bad about it, but continued on using planes without CBs as well as those with. I have to credit a piece on the C&W site for releasing me, now I feel trendy, after all these years without CBs. As well as with.

There is also the whole block plane and bevel up plane thing. They don't have CBs, though they probably could. The Japanese system where the CB is independently adjustable is a great idea, and could be used on a lot of other types.

That said, there has been a lot of CB use over the years.

One thing is the wood. While wood is soon to be completely unavailable, and we will have to move onto plastics, or soliant green composites, the actual wood we have today, has never been better. in the global economy you can get wood the likes of which craftsmen of the past did not always have. I think of guitars. A home luthier today, working on "guitar # 1" may well use a piece of soundboard wood the likes of which Tores never saw. Also, Mission furniture, and previously Shaker, or Krenov, or Nakashima, or Maloof. Not exactly making veneered pastry for the Sun God. So one possibility is we can do what we are doing, and we can get away without breakers, because we work easy wood.

One other question for the backwards boffins is how they managed in the past to use all those breakerless molding planes. Some of that wood could be choice pieces, but some of it was attached to the casework itself. I smell very good wood.

Keep in mind that those who embrace the CB-free lifestyle, may be complicating their lives in other ways. They may be playing around with super sharpening, micro bevels, pitch, skew, toothing/serrations, speed. Life is not as worry free as it might at first appear.

Re: My first Krenov plane

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: My first Krenov plane

Moses Yoder

I use chip breakers in most of my planes because I want to. No other reason. Your plane looks good, but I have one note I guess. It appears the wedge sticks out past the iron, which seems like it would make it hard to tap the iron down to get a thicker cut. Just wondering. Your first plane looks much better than my first plane.

Re: My first Krenov plane

#4

Re: My first Krenov plane

TomD

The Krenov planes do have the wedge shorter than the blade, as you say. It's a delicate balance because the Hock blades are really short. I think they work in the square section .Krenovs that have been popular of late, but not the Ruebenesque earlier planes. One point also is that Fink sells his own blades, not sure what length they are.

Re: My first Krenov plane

#5

Very nice looking!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

I like the shape of the top plane. Have you experienced any problems holding on to the back of the plane with the way it's shaped?

The bottom one looks like a WIP. Any differences between the two besides the wood?

Re: My first Krenov plane

#6

Re: My first Krenov plane

Ron Hock

We've made our Krenov-style blades 3-1/2" long ever since Jim spec'd them that length. We've recently added 4-1/2" versions of them to the catalog as well. The longer blades permit taller planes or low bed angle planes to have proper blade access for adjustment. They're a couple dollars more, include the same cap iron or we'll deduct $10 if you don't want the cap iron (say, for a bevel-up configuration.) Using them without the cap iron, the blade will have a slot that isn't used...

By that same token, the cap iron is also standard JK spec. Whether or not to use one is the subject of considerable discussion. I contend that the cap iron stiffens the cutting edge which is unsupported in a bevel-down plane. Thicker blades don't add anything at the cutting edge (see: http://hocktools.wordpress.com/2010/06/14/of-thick-and-thin/) so a cap iron can improve performance by pre-loading the edge. That said, I think even greater improvement can be realized with a sharp iron and a tight mouth on the plane. At that point the cap iron is like chicken soup (can't hurt.)

And that's a FINE looking plane you've made. Congratulations!

Re: My first Krenov plane

#7

Re: Very nice looking!

John M in Mid Mich

Thanks! Same wood, upper one is shaped and has a coat of Watco natural, lower is raw ready for my ministrations. Actually, shaped it yesterday, pretty much like the top one. I may not apply any finish to the second one. Any thoughts?

John

Re: My first Krenov plane

#8

Re: My first Krenov plane

John M in Mid Mich

Funny. I already trimmed the wedge WAY back, but didn't really know what I needed. Was thinking that if I had one of those totally spiffy brass hammers that Finck specifies, I could get at the iron even with a longer wedge. But my mallets are wooden (local hornbeam) and not so svelte, so shortening the wedge even more is no doubt in order. Do you think equal to the iron?

Re: My first Krenov plane

#9

Re: My first Krenov plane

John M in Mid Mich

>It appears the wedge sticks out past the iron, which seems like it

>would make it hard to tap the iron down to get a thicker cut.

Well there you go. This is why we post and hope the knowledgeable respond. I had no idea how long to make it. Seems I need to be able to whack the wedge perhaps more frequently than the blade, so maybe a little wedge projection is good? Do I have this wrong? I'm currently using a home-made mallet, which doesn't allow precise insertion to the iron, so a shorter wedge is probably a good thing. What is your advice - equal/shorter?

Re: My first Krenov plane

#10

Re: Very nice looking!

John M in Mid Mich

Oops, forgot to reply to the question about rear shape;

Actually, it seems pretty good: comfortable, but lots of grip. And who doesn't like a classic speedboat shape?


img

Re: My first Krenov plane

#11

Re: My first Krenov plane

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I read your article and agree that all edges can vibrate; but I think that a thicker blade prevents the vibration from traveling much beyond the edge whereas the thinner blade doesn't, thus allowing some real chatter. Why is this wrong?

Pam

Re: My first Krenov plane

#12

Re: Very nice looking!

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I don't finish my Japanese planes, but they're made of kashi, Japanese white oak, for the most part. I plane and/or scrape them to eliminate the possibility of splinters.

Pam

Re: My first Krenov plane

#13

Re: My first Krenov plane

Bob Hackett

I rarely have to drive the iron forward on my wood planes.I do the initial set and then any small adjustments to advance or retract the iron are made by tapping the plane body then seating the wedge.I like strike buttons on my planes for just this reason.

My advice would be to use it for a while before you cut the wedge any further.If you`re anything like me it `ll be fine.

I tap the sides of my irons more than I tap the top and reducing the length of the wedge doesn`t help that as much as mitering and rounding the corners does.

Re: My first Krenov plane

#14

Strike Button?

John M in Mid Mich

Can you show me a strike button, or point me to a reference? If I can imagine what they are, I think they might be something worth trying.

Re: My first Krenov plane

#15

Same here...

John in NM

But of course most of my wood planes are molding planes rather than smoothers. Hornbeam mallet sounds perfect for this to me :D A strike button is a little chunk of wood or metal let in to the plane body where you want to tap so that the body doesn't get all dented up.

Re: My first Krenov plane

#16

Grip

John in NM

If you did find you had some gripping trouble, you could always stipple the grip areas. It's texturing like checkering, but more random and much faster to do. Only trouble is the best tools I've used I had to make myself :D Tools I've seen for sale don't really look aggressive enough to me.

Re: My first Krenov plane

#17

Re: Strike Button?

Bob Hackett

I`m not adept enough at this digital stuff to be able to post pics yet.

On some of the old wood smoothers you`ll find these "buttons" of end grain wood,iron or my favorite,bronze at the toe, heel and sometimes on the top face of the toe.

You strike these buttons rather than the plane body itself to avoid denting and damaging the wood body.

The one at the heel or top face of the toe retract the iron.The one at the toe advances it.What you`re doing is relying on the "inertia of rest" of the iron to hold it in place while your mallet strike moves the body around it .

It also helps you develop a feel for how well tuned you plane is by how hard you need to hit the wedge to set it and hold the iron securely yet still let you make adjustments without hitting the iron directly.If you need to pound the wedge down to hold the iron then that`s a sure sign that something needs to be adjusted for a better/proper fit.

Watch someone who knows and uses wood planes frequently and you`ll see it`s usually a process of taps(not hits) to the wood that make up the bulk of the adjustment process. As I said in my previous post I tap the sides of the iron more than I tap the top so access to the sides is more important to me,especially on a plane iron with little to no camber to the edge.

Re: My first Krenov plane

#18

Re: Strike Button?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yeah, but when you strike the back button you need to hold onto the iron, right? The view of the plane indicates that it would be very hard to do that.

Pam

Re: My first Krenov plane

#19

Re: Strike Button?

John in NM

No, I don't think you do. Why would you have to hang on to it? Iron only moves a smidge with each tap.

Re: My first Krenov plane

#20

Re: Strike Button?

Bob Hackett

Can`t remember ever having done that Pam.

Most of my planes have the old tapered type iron so they do need to be tapped a bit more forcefully in the heel to get the iron to move much and I usually hold them from underneath when I try to retract the iron a bit.

May be force of habit but I hold my Steve Knight smoother that way too and it has a parallel iron.

Anyone heard from Steve lately?

Re: My first Krenov plane

#21

Re: Strike Button?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Why? Why not? If you want to move the iron relative to the plane body, and you want to do this via hitting the plane body, it seems obvious you'd need to hold onto the iron. I always hold the plane (Japanese style, but very close to the Krenov/Fink) upside down by the iron, hit the back end as needed to make the adjustment.

Pam

Re: My first Krenov plane

#22

Re: Strike Button?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Might want to give it a try, Bob. I hear that Steve is making plane kits.

Pam

Re: My first Krenov plane

#23

If you like...

John in NM

By all means hold the blade, but it doesn't need that to move. Tap in the right place, inertia does the rest. If it's going to fall out, might be tapping a bit too hard :D

Re: My first Krenov plane

#24

I will try it.

Bob Hackett

Seems like it might give me a better indication of how the iron has moved.Having "blacksmith`s hands" I usually place one finger over the mouth to gauge this.Most folks cringe when they see me do this.

Now to find a comfortable way to hold both sides of the iron with my left hand while tapping with my right.I have been holding my planes in the same attitude as working but suppose flipping them over is worth a try.

Trying new things is how we learn after all. :)

Re: My first Krenov plane

#25

Re: I will try it.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I hold the blade with my left hand in the middle of the top and brace the plane with left ring finger in front of the mouth. This is also not a technique for metal planes, and only when fairly large movement is required.

When trying for minor adjustments John and you are right, there's no need, I just tap on the back while, like you, holding my left hand on the edge.

I think maybe I've made much ado about very little. Sorry.

Pam