Re: My first Krenov plane
TomD
Yes!
I started out making Krenov and Japanese planes, and using various records and Stanleys. One thing that is different about the Japanese planes is that the breaker is a separate piece, it is not attached to the main blade. Whether making Japanese planes and agonizing over getting the CB fit just right, or just being lazy, I would leave the CB out. Also, my first Japanese plane cut .0003 shavings, and was made from a scraper that did not have a CB. That was thirty years ago, and I always sorta felt bad about it, but continued on using planes without CBs as well as those with. I have to credit a piece on the C&W site for releasing me, now I feel trendy, after all these years without CBs. As well as with.
There is also the whole block plane and bevel up plane thing. They don't have CBs, though they probably could. The Japanese system where the CB is independently adjustable is a great idea, and could be used on a lot of other types.
That said, there has been a lot of CB use over the years.
One thing is the wood. While wood is soon to be completely unavailable, and we will have to move onto plastics, or soliant green composites, the actual wood we have today, has never been better. in the global economy you can get wood the likes of which craftsmen of the past did not always have. I think of guitars. A home luthier today, working on "guitar # 1" may well use a piece of soundboard wood the likes of which Tores never saw. Also, Mission furniture, and previously Shaker, or Krenov, or Nakashima, or Maloof. Not exactly making veneered pastry for the Sun God. So one possibility is we can do what we are doing, and we can get away without breakers, because we work easy wood.
One other question for the backwards boffins is how they managed in the past to use all those breakerless molding planes. Some of that wood could be choice pieces, but some of it was attached to the casework itself. I smell very good wood.
Keep in mind that those who embrace the CB-free lifestyle, may be complicating their lives in other ways. They may be playing around with super sharpening, micro bevels, pitch, skew, toothing/serrations, speed. Life is not as worry free as it might at first appear.