New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Denatured alcohol stratification

Posts

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#26

Jesper, Denmark

Re: You cannot.........

Jesper, Denmark

Ethanol, methanol and water are fully miscible in all concentrations, so you cannot separate them by stratification.

I do not know why you are concerned about methanol. It is not the typical denaturant today, as it is toxic and does not (apparently) taste bad. The most comon denaturant today is MEK, which does taste bad and makes you puke, rather than cause you any serious harm. It also cannot be separated by gravity.

All of the denaturants used are selected so that they cannot be easily removed - that is the whole purpose of their use.

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#27

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Ethanol details from Wikipedia....

Jesper, Denmark

For those interested in the gory details:

For the ethanol to be usable as a fuel, water must be removed. Most of the water is removed by distillation, but the purity is limited to 95-96% due to the formation of a low-boiling water-ethanol azeotrope. The 95.6% m/m (96.5% v/v) ethanol, 4.4% m/m (3.5% v/v) water mixture may be used as a fuel alone, but unlike anhydrous ethanol, is immiscible in gasoline, so the water fraction is typically removed in further treatment in order to burn in combination with gasoline in gasoline engines.

Dehydration

There are basically five dehydration processes to remove the water from an azeotropic ethanol/water mixture. The first process, used in many early fuel ethanol plants, is called azeotropic distillation and consists of adding benzene or cyclohexane to the mixture. When these components are added to the mixture, it forms a heterogeneous azeotropic mixture in vapor-liquid-liquid equilibrium, which when distilled produces anhydrous ethanol in the column bottom, and a vapor mixture of water and cyclohexane/benzene. When condensed, this becomes a two-phase liquid mixture. Another early method, called extractive distillation, consists of adding a ternary component which will increase ethanol's relative volatility. When the ternary mixture is distilled, it will produce anhydrous ethanol on the top stream of the column.

With increasing attention being paid to saving energy, many methods have been proposed that avoid distillation altogether for dehydration. Of these methods, a third method has emerged and has been adopted by the majority of modern ethanol plants. This new process uses molecular sieves to remove water from fuel ethanol. In this process, ethanol vapor under pressure passes through a bed of molecular sieve beads. The bead's pores are sized to allow absorption of water while excluding ethanol. After a period of time, the bed is regenerated under vacuum or in the flow of inert atmosphere (e.g. N2) to remove the absorbed water. Two beds are used so that one is available to absorb water while the other is being regenerated. This dehydration technology can account for energy saving of 3,000 btus/gallon (840 kJ/l) compared to earlier azeotropic distillation.[19]

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#28

Stephen Shepherd

Re: You cannot.........

Stephen Shepherd

'Ethanol, methanol and water are fully miscible in all concentrations, so you cannot separate them by stratification. '

Isn't there a chemical bond formed?

Stephen

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#29

Everclear is here

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

My local liquor store has Everclear 190 in pints and quart, no licenses required. I'd be happy to send you some.

Pam

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#30

Re: Please one of you Southern

George in Lowell, Mich.

"good ole' Boys" send this man some Everclear. Everytime I've been south it was as easy to get as soda.

George

in COLD Lowell, Michigan

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#31

Re: So what about gold from lead?

ThomD

That is a very kind offer, but they really frown on that kind of thing at the border. It would be breaking a lot of laws, and potentially hurt both of us. I have a bad track record with law breaking. I never break the law but get tickets etc... just for casting my shadow over a handicap parking space etc... I have just had to face the fact that there is some force at work to keep me on the straight and straighter. But thanks.

I might think over that stuff Joel sells if it comes with some kind of "oops", who knewable labeling.

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#32

Re: Denatured alcohol ...

ThomD

Thanks Frank. Keep me posted, if you don't mind. I think 180 is probably too watery, but maybe they have 190 in a different part of town?

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#33

Re: One caveat

ThomD

I have always wanted to go to Wyoming. Wind River Range just sounds dreamy.

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#34

Re: So what about gold from lead?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Have a seance with Newton on the alchemy thing.

Pam

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#35

Re: Please one of you Southern

Phil Joines

you mean it's not?

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#36

Better yet...

John in NM

Georgius Agricola :D

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#37

JL

No chemical bond ... beyond hydrogen bonding

JL

You have covalent bonds - these are the bonds between atoms - such as carbon to carbon or carbon to oxygen.

You have ionic bonds - these are the bonds that happen when atoms "share" or "exchange" electrons. As an example, sodium and chlorine form sodium chloride (salt).

You have hydrogen bonding - these are the bonds formed when the hydrogen of alcohol groups (-OH) or an amino group bonds with an oxygen atom, a nitrogen atom, or sometimes a fluorine.

Hydrogen bonding is weaker than any of the other bonds.

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#38

Re: Better yet...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Hmmmm, Agricola was a mining engineer, not an alchemist, according to Wikipedia; so I doubt he tried to turn lead into gold.

Pam

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#39

True....

John in NM

But he likely knew it was impossible :D

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#40

Jesper, Denmark

Re: No chemical bond - just a mixture

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#41

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Everclear is here

Jesper, Denmark

US post Office prohibits sending alcohol in the mail.

I had an Italian customer send me 12 bottles of nice wine for Christmas once. It got stuck in a Post Office depot in NJ to be collected personally. Had to have a friend pick it up and deliver - strangely enough on of the 12 bottles got replaced with a bottle of Thunderbird. :D

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#42

Re: Everclear is here

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yeah, well I'd planned to transfer it to another container and include some more finishing goodies in the box; but that was for Canadian laws. I didn't know it was illegal in the US. Guess all those Christmas gifts are done person to person, to say nothing of those online auctions of cases of wine?

Thanks, I'd hate to have done something illegal, :)

Pam

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#43

May I suggest UPS

Patrick Gibbons

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#44

Yep!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

I've shipped items through UPS that the post office refused. Never had a problem with them, even when they (UPS) knew what it items were.

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#45

Sure, or FedEx....

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

They both seem to clear the border better anyhow; but Thom doesn't want it, so moot.

Pam

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#46

Just for the record...

John in NM

Shipping potable alcohol is against UPS policy as well. There are some exceptions but they make them complicated. Fedex, without a doubt, has similar policies. They do this to avoid running afoul of the widely varying local ordinances concerning taxation and of course alcohol content. Shipping to another country is bound to be forbidden by those who forbid such things :D

Now I don't care if someone wants to do it anyhow, just be aware that they don't want you to... I don't believe there is much of a penalty other than losing the shipped item, but depending on locality it could be more serious as well.

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#47

Ship it from Texas

Bob Hackett

According to some of my friends in Texas;"It ain`t illegal ,till you get caught". :^O

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#48

Re: Ship it from Texas

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I certainly wouldn't judge legality based on most Texans' assessments, they are particularly uneducated, and proud of it.

Pam

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#49

I got so excited by this thread

Jay Samuels

that I went to the liquor store and bought a pint of Everclear 190. $9.99 plus tax here in NJ. Based on the look I got from the clerk, I think the usual consumer for the product is a good deal younger. Jay

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#50

Stephen Shepherd

To kind of answer your original question

Stephen Shepherd

I talked to a physicist friend of mine and asked him about stratification. He said that it would work, given enough time [he wasn't specific], the heavier benzene will settle out, the ethanol on top of that and the methanol on top because of their molecular weight.

He suggested a centrifuge would be quicker, but the stuff might remix when it stopped. He also said that alcohol just doesn't behave itself,

If you distill denatured alcohol the methanol will come off first at a lower temperature, then the ethanol and then the benzene.

Other countries just make ethanol unpalatable instead of poisonous. A hold over from prohibition day, the U.S. has some archaic laws about alcohol.

Stephen