New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Denatured alcohol stratification

Posts

Denatured alcohol stratification

#1

Denatured alcohol stratification

ThomD

For years I have been fuming about the fact that I can't get clean alcohol for french polishing. Periodically I get the idea I will make my own moonshine... I should add I am pretty much teatotal. I did once get some 190 proof alcohol in Nashville, and strung out that little bottle for quite a while in the making of french polish. I was like working with honey and had none of the bad habits of the high priced trash I otherwise have to use. Anyway, I got a brainwave tonight, what about just distilling denatured alcohol, none of that nonsense about making mash, it would be 190 proof to start with, with the rest methanol. It was hard to get reliable info, because much of the discussion concerns residual toxicity for winos. I am under no circumstances drinking the stuff, just spending hours moving it around the dance floor.

So here is the idea. Some folks mention simply putting denatured alcohol of the 95/5 ethanol/methanol variety in a tube and letting it settle out for a week. In my particular application I could wait much longer, because I use very little of the stuff. A tube with an ID o 3/4", and a length of 6' has been mentioned, then you capture the middle 50%. I was thinking a flexy pipe where I could simply clamp off the middle half and dump the upper and lower segments.

So here are my questions:

1) will it work to the extent that the resultant material while still not safe to drink will be significantly reduced in nastiness;

2) how long till something significant happens, and what about the other details of the rig. Any suggestions on a good hose that won't just load the alcohol up with a lot of plasticizers;

3) for the time being, I don't care about legality because it is highly context specific, or the fact than many regions have different recipes for their denatured alcohol, or sell Everclear. Assume logical parameters.

How can I cheaply test my results (burn flame colour, hydrometer, smell, taste (a wet finger presumably would be safish)...

Any better ideas? I know we have a lot of smart technical people here...

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#2

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

joel moskowitz

I don't know if it will work. my guess is no, but even it it does the alcohol will absorb a lot of water in the process from the air. - which you cannot remove without fancy equipment. Also the cheap alcohols on the market are about 30-50 % methanol so I doubt you will save any money even if it works.

We stock 200 proof ethanol (actually 95.5% ethanol). we may run out soon - as we need to get a different license for it - but that's in the works.

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#3

Jesper, Denmark

Re: The simple answer is...

Jesper, Denmark

I am afraid that it will not work.

Both ethanol and methanol are completely soluble in/with water in all concentration ratios, and will not separate by gravity.

One possible anvenue to get a cleaner ethanol is if you can find a source of bioethanol, manufactured for combustion engine fuel or fuel(gasoline) additive. To be used as motor fuel, this ethanol has to have the water removed, or it will separate out when added to the gasoline. It is also denatured, so not potable, but you did not intend to drink it anyway. The water is removed either by distilling with a co-solvent, that removes the water or by passing through a pervious membrane sieve, which allows the smaller water molecule through, but not the ethanol.

The moonshine route is also not feasible, as ethanol forms an azeotrope with water and will not distill any further than the 190 proof - 95% ethanol and 5% water.

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#4

Re: The simple answer is...

joel moskowitz

"The moonshine route is also not feasible, as ethanol forms an azeotrope with water and will not distill any further than the 190 proof - 95% ethanol and 5% water. "

While I don't think Moonshine is ideal - the water thing as you mention it should work pretty well. If you think about it our ancestors didn't have anhydrouse alcolol so that they would have been using is 190 proof material. Also before 92 proof everclear was taken off the market a lot of people got great results with it. - so it's worth trying

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#5

Stephen Shepherd

Distilling Denatured alcohol

Stephen Shepherd

Thom,

It is not a good idea to distill denatured alcohol and many of the nasties still remain or go through the distillation process.

Better idea is to start with some cheap whiskey, make a simple still [I use a curcubit and alembic] heat it up to 172 degrees {F} and out run excellent shellac thinner. You can also use cheap or bad wine or any other liquor, the higher the initial alcohol content the better the results.

Making shine is easier than most people think. I don't think you will run afoul of the law, but do be careful with your heat source.

Stephen

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#6

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification *LINK*

Larry Barrett

You might try looking through Lindsay's catalog.


Lindsay's

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#7

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Agree, but..........

Jesper, Denmark

The original question was whether gravity separation could reduce the water content.

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#9

Couldn't possibly work...

John in NM

Sounds more scientific than filtering through old bread, but it's not going to work.:D

Is the methanol the problem or any dissolved water? If you want "pure" ethanol, you can either buy it from a lab supplier or make it as Stephen describes. Can't be that hard to find the stuff, it has many applications outside of finishing.

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#10

Re: Couldn't possibly work...

ThomD

Actually the original question, I supposed not properly stated by me, was can I separate out the nasties like methanol etc... water I can live with. I do realize that water is a problem, but to my surprise the one bottle of 190 proof I got in Nashville was absolutely fine. And it lasted for years in a nalgene lab bottle without ever getting gummy or milky. That is actuall two bottles, the one containing the alcohol, and the one containing the mix. That is all contrary to the general suggestion of what one would encounter. The Mix of potable alcohol, an shellac was just yummy. French polishing felt like cooking rather than using "chemicals".

And since I am not drinking the stuff some residual methanol or other stuff is not ideal but not dangerous, at least not in comparison to having to use the fully poisoned stuff.

Though I didn't want to get into the legalities, it is a combination of unavailable, and or expensive as far as getting pure ethanol is concerned in Ontario. I heard another guitarmaker got a license, but that is the usual point where I tune out.

By the way. I read something recently about a new product out there that is a premade shellac and is stable and does not go bad. Apaprently it is pretty good stuff. I forget the details. That would be an option if it didn't seem too unwholesome, On could just add some extra flake.

Anyway, thanks for all the help!

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#11

Re: Couldn't possibly work...

ThomD

This is the original material that got me thinking:

"Get a very long piece of pipe, I'd guess at least 3/4" inside diameter and 6 to 8 feet long. Put a small valve on one end. At the bare minimum , perhaps it'll work with a chunk of garden hose and a nozzle, the twist kind working better. Set pipe upright, nice and vertical, valve down, or just hang hose from open end. Fill with the denatured alcohol. Wait. Ethanol molecules are heavier than methanol so they will settle to the bottom. However there may be other additives that are heavier than ethanol so they will settle underneath the ethanol. Settling will take time, leave the pipe completely undisturbed for at least a week. Then, very carefully and slowly from the valve at the bottom, drain off 1/4 of the tube, discard. That would have stuff that's heavier than the ethanol and not in solution with the ethanol. Drain off the next 1/2 of the tube, save. The remaining 1/4 of the tube would contain methanol and things lighter than ethanol that are not in solution with it, discard.

The amount you saved, for the chemistry I remember, will be a more concentrated form of ethanol than what you started with, with less of the toxins. In No Way Whatsoever Is It To Be Considered SAFE, it's merely safer. If it worked at all, you've thrown away about 40% of the ethanol but that was the part most likely to have most of the methanol and other toxins. The 50% you've saved will still have stuff that was in solution in the ethanol, small amount of methanol, some other stuff. It's a crappy separation method, but... It's cheap, easy to do..."

---------------

"So, we go in reverse, long tube. There are limits, if i tried to use a tube of only 1/64" inside diameter it wouldn't matter if it went a half mile straight up, I wouldn't expect to see significant separation within a year, not enough molecular motion in not enough directions. About 3/4" dia by 6 ft looks right, enough cross-sectional area for meaningful separation with, important thing, enough length to get distinct "zones" to form. The 1/4-1/2-1/4 scheme selects a zone that the methanol should be practically out of while also rejecting any other additives that are heavier or lighter than ethanol. While it is possible that certain additives could be strongly enough bound to the ethanol to not separate, I would think that would interfere with the desired industrial properties of the ethanol thus they wouldn't be allowed. Additives whose molecules had the same approximate mass as ethanol would however remain, but methanol is the main concern.

Then the only remaining ingredient, is time. If it works at all, and I don't see why it won't work at least somewhat, a week of being left alone should yield measurable separation, hopefully a good deal. Granted a year would likely be better than a week, but as this is an, umm, "immediate need," a week would achieve the basic objective of reducing the methanol within a timeframe that should be acceptable.

Hmm, thought of an improvement. Funnel. At the top have a funnel or similar enlargement attached to the pipe or hose, fill so the funnel will have liquid in it too, the methanol will rise into the funnel where the larger surface area will yield greater evaporation than the pipe/hose alone would, further reducing the methanol concentration."

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#12

Re: Denatured alcohol ...

John Aniano in Central NJ...

Tom,

Have you any friends in New Jersey who can buy this for you? I buy Everclear grain alcohol for French polish and I simply get it at my local liquor store. Not especially cheap, but I go through a bottle, maybe once every two years, so cost is not a major issue.

A bow making friend of mine in Washington state also swears by Everclear as the best product for French polish. He convinced me and others years ago to go this route. He investigated alcohol products a while back and came up with this: denatured alcohol can be denatured by any one or a mixture of "contaminants" that prevent the stuff from being taken internally. They can include methanol, but not exclusively methanol. Maybe acetone and maybe other hydrocarbons. He thinks that these other potential contaminants, which can vary with whatever "stuff" the supplier has on hand at the time to add to make the denatured product, is the true cause of problems with French polish. By sticking with Everclear, his polish was reproducible and consistent in application. FWIW, many of the violin makers I know also use Everclear for making varnish.

My WA friend gets around his state's restrictions on buying the stuff by getting some sort of special permit. He is limited to how many bottles he can get in within some time period set by the permit. Of course, as a fellow bow maker, he is running a business and this may be the key to getting the special permit. Individuals may not be so lucky (unless you live in New Jersey!). If you are interested, I can ask him the details, but I'm sure they will be specific to WA state.

Over and out,

John

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#13

Re: The simple answer is...

ThomD

Water isn't my main concern, but it is a concern. My main objective is to purify the ethanol from methanol. If I can get the methanol out by stratification, that would be worthwhile. But to make that work I need a relatively pure source of denatured alcohol. The 190 proof potable alcohol works very nicely for French polishing. I just can't get it.

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#14

Re: Denatured alcohol ...

ThomD

Thanks John. I tried the 190 proof stuff while in Tennessee, and was very impressed. That is what gave me wood for this whole subject. After using the potable stuff, I can't take seriously any of the alternatives.

There probably is some process for getting the 190 proof stuff in Ontario Canada. I know one classical guitar guy who used to have that kind of permit, though it was expensive, like using sipping whiskey for your base, but expense doesn't rule it out for me. I use so little, I could bear paying the alcohol taxes, but I think that even if you want to pay for the 190 stuff you can't get it? Anyone know from an Otario basis? I heard you need a permit. I prefer not to ask permission for stuff I can MacGyver on my own though.

I realize that there are other possible barriers to using a methanol alcohol base. That there are other impurities. I am just going on the possibility that so long as I am willing to start with denatured alcohol, that there is a pure source of it out there. I mean I can't drink it, right? So until I can verify the supply, I am trying to verify what kind of luck I would have separating out the methanol by stratification.

I came across some info that in New Zealand denatured alcohol is actually pure ethanol. They have kept the adverse labeling, but have not kept the poison.

Another thing would be whether they sell an everclear product in Quebec. I get there often enough that I could handle all my needs. Quebec is very grown up about alcohol. They have neither the over-regulation we have in Ontario (I am actually OK with that), or the falling down drunk culture that one gets in some freer locals. Anyone know about Quebec?

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#15

Stephen Shepherd

One caveat

Stephen Shepherd

They do sell a version of Everclear that is 150 proof and is not suitable for french polish or as a shellac thinner because it contains too much water. I have just recently experimented with the 150 proof and it made a muddy mess. Make sure that it is labeled 190 proof for the pure stuff.

Stephen

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#16

Re: One caveat

joel moskowitz

as far as I know the 190 proof everclear is off the market.

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#17

Bottom line...

John in NM

Denatured alcohol is 95% ethanol and 5% methanol or other similar poisonous chemical. The 5% is what is meant by "denatured", ie rendered different in an essential property, in this case potability. There is no easy way to undo this, if there were all the winos would have figured it out. I'm afraid the hocus pocus you've been told is pure bunk, little better than the filtering through stale bread that the bums used to think worked until a few of them went blind.

You can buy it, or you can make it out of legal spirits by the method Stephen described. Those are the two options for obtaining 95% pure ethanol.

I am a bit skeptical that the methanol could have much of a detrimental effect from a scientific point of view, but a process like french polishing is at least half un-scientific, so if pure ethanol is a help then you should continue in your effort to find it. I'm equally amazed that lab grade alcohol should be hard to obtain, even in Canada, but then I haven't tried even here. Its not as if it were a machine gun or something, its just a matter of taxation.

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#18

Re: Bottom line...

Joel moskowitz

I have to disagree the most common DNA on the market is %50 methanol. I have done a lot of research on alcohol in the past year and our conclusions surprised us.

I do agree that if you cannot get lab grade material, and or outside the us following Stephen shepherds advice might be the best way to go.

Click here for more info

http://www.toolsforworkingwood.com/Merchant/merchant.mvc?Screen=NEXT&StoreCode=toolstore&nextpage=/extra/blogpage.html&BlogID=239

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#19

Stephen Shepherd

Re: One caveat

Stephen Shepherd

Maybe where you live Joel, but in many states it is still legal. While I cannot buy it in Nevada, it is available in Utah and Wyoming.

Stephen

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#20

What?  There's something you can't buy in Nevada?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Kind of ruins my stereotypes....

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#21

Re: One caveat

ThomD

Based on the label, that isn't the stuff I bought in Tennessee. But I bought something just as good, or maybe the small bottles are just different.

Wiki has some info on Availability:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Everclear_%28alcohol%29

Does not say whether it is available in Quebec. It is available in Alberta, but I haven't been out there in a long while.

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#22

Re: One caveat

Joel moskowitz

It's always been illegal in NYC but my national rep said it was discontinued nationwide. More research on the web during this blizzard while I am sick like dog confirms that happily you are right. Btw how much is a quart?

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#23

Stephen Shepherd

Re: One caveat

Stephen Shepherd

The largest size I can buy is a pint bottle for about $8.00 in Wyoming. Only in half pint bottles in Utah about $4.50.

Stephen

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#24

Interesting

John in NM

I had no idea it could be that much... must be cheaper than ethanol. :D

Re: Denatured alcohol stratification

#25

Re: Denatured alcohol ...

Frank D. in Montreal

Last time I checked (a few years ago) the most potent white ethanol you could get here was 180 proof (90%). I can check again next time I go, but it might not be for another week or two (I'm runnng on holiday reserves for now).