New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

OT - brazing fireplace andiron...

Posts

OT - brazing fireplace andiron...

#1

OT - brazing fireplace andiron...

John Aniano in Central NJ

Yes, I know this is a woodworking site, but, since I burn my woodworkign project offcuts in the fireplace, I thought I'd ask here...

My wife and I own a pair of early 19th century andirons that we regularly use in our Rumford fireplace. I had the iron portion in the back (on which the logs rest) renewed a few years ago and they now work great. However, the front legs are brass castings and one of the legs has broken with a clean break.

My question - I'd like to braze the leg back together. I own a MAPP gas torch as well as a plumber's acetylene torch, both torches without added oxygen. Am I barking up the wrong tree to use either torch to braze this back together? The leg is ~3/8" diameter, and I can disconnect the leg casting from the entire andiron during the brazing operation.

Also, what brazing rods and fluxing agent should I try to get for this kind of repair? Color of the final repair doesn't matter since after one fire, the legs will again be black.

Thanks in advance,

John

Re: OT - brazing fireplace andiron...

#2

Re: OT - brazing fireplace andiron...

Bob Hackett

I would bring it to a weld shop and have them TIG weld it.

Sounds like the leg was getting enough heat to make it brittle and that`s why it broke.Welding fuses or actually melts the metal together.Brazing uses a filler metal that melts at a lower temp than the parent metal and bonds the pieces together.

My thinking is that if that leg is getting enough heat to make it crystalize and break then you may be approaching the melting temp of the braze,usually a red heat.

Talk to the welder and see what he says,the best opinions come from eyes on evaluation.

Re: OT - brazing fireplace andiron...

#3

Second the TIG...

John in NM

Its just the brass casting that is broken? Not where the brass is attached to the steel?

The trouble with trying to braze brass or bronze is that the rod and the body melt at similar temperatures. Metals that have good thermal conductivity - basically everything but steel - don't braze or weld well because the whole thing sucks up heat to the point of melting before you can get the rod to flow. That's somewhat of an exaggeration, but it's what it seems like the first time you try it. A skilled welder might be able to do it with a gas torch, but I never learned, not in the modern day of TIG equipment.

You could try silver soldering it with a high temp silver solder (also called hard solder). Its another kind of brazing at a lower temperature. But I'm not sure it would withstand the fireplace heat all that well, so my first choice would still be finding a guy with a TIG.

Re: OT - brazing fireplace andiron...

#4

craigd

Re: OT - brazing fireplace andiron...

craigd

If the broken part is brass, it can't be arc welded - the zinc in the brass boils and creates a mess. Another problem is the parts are going to be really dirty and TIG doesn't like that (you don't use a flux with TIG) or TIG brazing with Silicon Bronze might work. "Hard" silver melts around 1200�F, which might be iffy in a fireplace. Brass welding with O/A might be your best option, but, as John noted, you need a light touch (you'll probably need O2 to get enough heat).

Re: OT - brazing fireplace andiron...

#5

no on the tig weld

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

If the andirons are early 19th centry it is very likely that they are red brass which traditionaly is 85-3-5 or 85% copper, 5% lead, 5% zink, and 5% tin. It is notoriously difficult to tig weld.

I would suggest silver solder which is actually brazing and I would also insert a silicon bronze or stainless pin in the joint.

Robin

Re: OT - brazing fireplace andiron...

#6

That's good info...

John in NM

I usually silver solder brass, from the info in this thread I probably won't try tig on it.

The pin is a really good idea, you must have done this before :D