New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

Posts

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#26

Re: OT - remodeling - Plaster

ThomD

There is a book out, as doubtless you know, on natural plaster. I also have the Heino Engle book, the long one, signed if you will, and it has Japanese plaster recipes in it. I did get a Japanese trowel also. I don't know that there is any terrible problem in getting plaster, or possibly making up some natural plasters. What seems to be very regional building supply wise is the availability of skim coat plaster systems, and the kind of double paper wall board that goes with them. One can skim over drywall with a combo of durabond and light finishing premix. I like to add some latex binder also. There are those jobs in life that just need to be done in the normal industrial way. And sadly the stuff for that is not found around here.

We recently got Lowes to supplement the other 3 big box stores we have Every time another one comes in I hope they will have the skim coat in their lineup. No such luck.

Southern Cali is a big area for skimcoat, and so apparently is the Northeast. Skimcoat is great for home reno types because it is faster, more fun, and there isn't any sanding. It is like hand planing vs, drywall been like all that crappy bad stuff people do to wood in the name of expediency, except plaster wise it is more expedient, other than on the skilled worker level.

Toronto has a huge Italian community, that must be full of ardent plasterers, one would think. I keep expecting to trip over some little store with plastering supplies, and I think I did, SW of Englington and Victoria Park. But no sooner found than they moved or something. Still chasing the motherload.

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#27

Re: OT - Jousting with imortality

ThomD

It's one of those thing to hope for immortality through work. But there are lots of very repetitive things in life that leave no mark. They are still necessary, like dusting and preparing food.

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#28

Re: OT - remodeling - Plaster

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

So your preference would be to go the wallboard/skim coat route rather than lathe/plater route?

BTW, how about all those Japanese style houses in upper middle CA (Palo Alto and north)?

Pam

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#29

Re: OT - remodeling - Plaster

ThomD

just in a tract house setting. If I was making some kind of reproduction Japanese effect I would have to read up on that. I have spent a lot of time in older housing with lath walls, and they seem better than drywall, harder, and the plaster is deeper. But the work involved to do that is not justified in many settings. I'd just be guessing, but take some place like Harrelsons, his shop I would guess was drywalled,, but his bath house, should get some traditional treatment. Some walls use a twig lath, and some use the machined strapping. Then there is wallboard. There are also all kinds of alternatives like cob or bales that might be plastered. I am guessing the more primitive the surfaces the more plaster they suck up. Many of these materials off-gas which is another thing.

For the most part, the only skim coat i have done is over drywall where there were too many joints meat and over ceilings where I was renovating those horrible textured ceilings. One of the ceilings I didn't even have to paint. Years later it doesn't look unfinished. Funny thing, when you end up with an actual nice wall today's paints will degrade it, because they are designed to cover up for the roughness of drywall, which is in the form of bad workmanship, but mostly in the form of the unevenness and the different texture between paper and plaster. I was being dragged around this historic site, and we entered a doctor's house. I was really struck by the quality of the walls. They were burnished plaster, and had a top coat of some shinny paint. Normally I like semi gloss walls, like the rest of modernity, but this really looked like quality and was an effect that would not be touched in most million + dollar homes (non-bubble pricing).

I did come up with my own technique for doing cornices that even got Byron Fergusen's attention on a builder's forum he moderated. So I am just an amateur at this stuff, living in a relatively crummy and unfinished home, but I like to throw around the plaster when the chance presents itself. I have learned a lot about boat work from my plaster experience, which I appreciate.

Haven't been to california, except the northernmost reaches.

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#30

Living with lath and plaster

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Our 1895 house used wood lath and three-coat plaster. I have to say, as a long-range maintenance finish, it's kind of a pain. The keys eventually fail, and it's doggoned hard to repair, especially smoothly. And cutting holes in it, as we had to do for electrical box installation when rewiring the house, is a huge pain, very hard to do well.

Also, it's essentially, like concrete, a form of stone surrogate, with all the heat transmission of stone. Our uninsulated house is colder than a well-digger's toes in winter - you can feel the heat leaving your body on the wall side of a room as you stand there. Whether it would be improved if we could figure out how to insulate without removing the walls I don't know.

As we refurbish the house (four rooms down, including the hard ones [kitchen and bathrooms], five to go), we're using drywall, and skimcoating it with regular joint compound (alternating between the official finish coat and just regular premix mud - still deciding). I do like the slight irregularities in the old plaster walls, and a good unsanded skimcoat replicates these very well. Just enough irregularity to have some interest, not so much that it looks like a tract house.

As a side benefit, because the lath-and-plaster walls are fairly thick, we're able to get 1/2" plywood up to provide shear to the walls (which had almost no shear bracing - not a good thing in earthquake country) and cover that with 1/2" plywood without having to build out jambs, in those cases where we manage to leave windows/doors in place.

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#31

Re: Living with lath and plaster

ThomD

I agree with that for the most part. It's hard to say about relative durability. Most drywall fails to some extent in the first year. I remember reading an ode to drywall in Harpers, and the guy mentioned the old house he had bought and how it had 7 or 9 layers of drywall in some of the rooms. Not sure why, but it doesn't speak well of something. :)

I think with proper insulation and while ensuring there were no bridges in the walls, there could be some advantage to heavy walls. They have the thermal mass. I have a theory currently though that works in the opposite direction and suggest that low thermal mass can be good. I still cover the windows up here with plastic, since nothing is as warm to the touch as plastic where windows are concerned. Maybe what we need is a lath wall with radiant heat built into it!!

I am a quality snob about finishes, and accept with plaster that both rough and smooth can be good. But one thing I like about real plaster is that it can be finished right off the trowel by polishing with the sole of the trowel. This is like planing where the surface of the blade, at some tangency becomes the surface of the planed board. Snobish in the sense that I don't hold with the idea that tool marks are the best one can do. But in plaster there is a whole range of tooling that has been developed.

By the way, if you like using joint compound for your plaster (not my complete favorite) The fastest way to apply it is with a paint roller. You need a sturdy set-up, and 3/8' nap roller. just roll it down and work it out with a trowel, way the easiest way on ceilings. This can do a great job, but if you want some visual interest this application can be knocked down to various degrees of flatness that leave interesting texture like one gets with a marble with natural pockets, though just at the surface.

Another "plaster" you can experiment with is durabond 90 and the premix finish coat. That will have body like joint compound but spread smoother like finishing compound, while having some of the adhesion and hardness of the DB90. I sometimes add acrylibond if adhesion is in doubt.

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#32

I'd advise against skimming...

John in NM

Still tends to crack at the drywall joints, and with gypsum plaster you can't use paper tape. Paper tape tends to keep the joint from cracking, though it's no more durable than fiber in the long run, just more aesthetically pleasing.

Cost comparison on drywall with a gypsum veneer coat vs wire lath (also known as bloodwire :D) and a good three coat plaster is 2x-3x, labor time is probably about the same, but cost is again roughly 1.5x-2x as skilled plasterers (if you can find them) make significantly more than drywallers. If you're doing your own work, that is of course not a consideration.

You can also use a lime plaster over drywall, but it doesn't stick anywhere near as well as gypsum, and you can't skim gypsum over the lime. Lime sucks the water right out of the gypsum and it won't stick.

One huge advantage to plastered walls (sans drywall) is that they breath a lot better than drywalled walls. Gypsum plaster breaths ok, better than drywall, but lime is just amazing.

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#33

Re: I'd advise against skimming...

ThomD

One thing I try to keep in balance in doing my work at home is I want to do the work efficiently, but I also keep in mind that I live here. So while a pro team doing veneer plaster might not feel like taking an extra day at a job to do an extra coat it doesn't mater a lot to me. The fact I am not using blueboard, has always meant that I was free to do embedded tape if I wanted to. And I normally do in durabond. I don't know if that would work with blueboard. I think most amateurs will get back any efficiency they loose in adding steps like this, and in my case at the end to avoid sanding, by just ensuring each step is completed in full and the job progresses in non-overlapping steps.

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#34

Re: I'd advise against skimming...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

You guys seem to know a lot about plastering and joint compounds. I'll have to mull and check things out with the local guys. One thing of interest is that when I searched on "durabond 90," Google returned Home Depot Canada, so they seem to have it. No such luck for the US.

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#35

It's just 90 minute hot mud....

John in NM

Comes in a bag, mix with water, sets well and doesn't shrink the way that awful bucket mud does. So you'd tape the seams normally using a good dry mix mud and then use veneer plaster over it all. I prefer 45 minute muds, but I'll take 90 over 20 minute any day. We were also trying to avoid sanding, but to tell the truth I don't think we saved any time. If I were to do it over, I'd go with conventional drywall/tape or wirelath and plaster, I'm just not satisfied with veneer, kinda the worst of both really.

We also mix vermiculite into plaster, it improves the properties and makes it lighter. Works especially well with lime plasters which don't set hard and fast like gypsum does, but get used outside due to being weather resistant. I was lucky to find a supplier in Albuquerque, I don't think they're all that common.

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#36

Re: I'd advise against skimming...

ThomD

http://www.usg.com/sheetrock-durabond-setting-type-joint-compound.html

USG is sorta the US Fruit of the drywall biz. They have their own Gypsum mines in Nova Scotia.

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#37

Coming in late but what the hell ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Wilbur

For a storage box, a nailed on bottom is probably the go. Still, there are more fun ways to do things if you are so inclined.

As mentioned earlier, use slips if the sides are too thin to be grooved (I would groove anything from 1/2" up). You can use them all the way around and they will be strong enough.

I have pictures from this drawer, which used slips on three sides ..




mitred slip ...



If you would rather use a stopped groove, then look to this pictorial for some ideas. You basically need a router plane ...

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/AStoppedGrooveinaDovetailedBox.html


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#38

Re: Coming in late but what the hell ...

Sgian Dubh

Derek, I know we discussed this away back in about January this year, but I have to say I've never seen anyone use drawer slips on the back face of a drawer front as you have done (and one or two other recent example from this year). That observation applies to all the antiques I've renovated over the years as well as in contemporary examples of drawer making.

To me it seems a cock-eyed over embellishment that only adds to the difficulty of executing the job, and adds nothing useful to the overall utility of the drawer. Instead of making a simple tenon at the front end of the slip to fit into the groove on the back face of the drawer front, with your method, you've got an extra bit of wood floating about aimlessly on the drawer front's rear face-- and it's mitred at the corners too which just makes the job even more tricky.

I can't think where Christopher Schwartz got the slip pattern for the blog he created on this technique. It may be an American reference he's read for I really can't ever think of an instance where I've read any British based writer promote this oddball 'back face of the drawer front slip' idea. To be honest, in my opinion, it's a piece of nonsense as there's more than enough meat in an 18- 20 mm (3/4") thick drawer front to carry a groove deep enough for a drawer bottom of any material, solid wood or man-made board. Slainte.

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#39

Re: Coming in late but what the hell ...

David Charlesworth

I'll second that.

Not sure, but has anyone mentioned that a small stopped groove could easily be made with a scratch stock?

David Charlesworth

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#40

Re: Coming in late but what the hell ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Richard

I essentially agree with you, and did so when this was discussed at the time of the original build. The focus here is adding a bottom to a box, and my intent here is simply to show that slips could be used to hold the bottom. For reference, while not the traditional way, the drawer in question has proved very sturdy so far (11 months of heavy use).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#41

Context is everything

Bob Hackett

Just so the moment doesn`t slip by and is missed,I find it very interesting how a technique can less than optimum in one context(slip vs grooved drawer front) and yet be exactly what is called for in another(slips on all 4 sides for a box).

Context and an open mind is what makes the difference.