New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

Posts

Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#1

Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

wilbur

I know that for a dovetailed drawer, one technique is to place the groove for the bottom so that it sits between the pins of the drawer front. That way, the groove is hidden on the sides by the tail boards, and the drawer front hides the grooves due to the half blind dovetail joint.

But if I want to make a dovetailed box, with through dovetails on the corners, the groove in the tail board will be visible when looking it on end, since we don't have the equivalent of a drawer front.

Are there any ways of dealing with this without making a stopped groove in the tail board?

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#2

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

Dean J from MN

Miter the DTs to hide the groove.

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#3

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

Dean J from MN

I should have been a bit more clear -- just miter the DTs which house the groove. You could do full blind/mitred but that isn't what you were asking...

-Dean

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#4

Stephen Shepherd

The English...

Stephen Shepherd

would make a small molding with a groove in the center to accept the feather edge of the drawer bottom panel. Looks like a U with the inside edge round over and the outside edge left square. They are mitered to fit inside the box and are glued in place. The panel floats free.

Stephen

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#5

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

How about planing up a bit of scrap from one of the box sides, matching color and end grain and gluing it in before assembly to stop the groove?

Or, adding immense amounts of work, planing a groove all the way around all sides of the box at that height and inlaying some contrasting wood?

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#6

or...

David Miller from Iowa

Not sure how you are making the groove. If you are using a combination plane such as a Stanley 45 I applaud you. You can just drop it in away from the edge and finish before you get to the edge. Then you clean up the ends between each stroke with a small mortise chisel. Depending upon the quality and hardness of the wood, I might be inclined to used electricity on this and you can do the same thing - put a small blade in the table saw and finish with just with a little hand chisel work on the ends. Lay out the dovetails and do the groove before you cut them to help prevent chipping. I would even cut the groove before you saw the box sides to length - easier to handle the stock. If you have some extra stock make 6 or 8 box sides - some will be better than others and if you make 8 the last 4 will be better than the first 4.

Kind of like when I just tiled my kitchen backsplash last weekend - the first 3 feet wasn't too great, the middle 6 feet was OK, and the last 3 feet looked almost professional.

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#7

OT - remodeling

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"Kind of like when I just tiled my kitchen backsplash last weekend - the first 3 feet wasn't too great, the middle 6 feet was OK, and the last 3 feet looked almost professional."

I will eventually learn to do those first three feet where they're less, instead of more, visible.

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#8

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The easiest way is to glue the box together leaving the gaps. Then if the groove is say 1/4 x1/4, plane a small rod 1/4 x1/4 x 4 and cut off little pieces to glue in the gaps. They are hardly noticeable to someone not looking for them.

If you want to go to a bit of trouble, you can make the groove just above the bottom half pin, and plan a rather shallow groove in the tail board, like 1/8 deep in a 1/2 board. Then make a crossgrain rabbet at the end of the tail board 1/8 deep, so that the tails will be only 3/8 deep and you can then plough the 1/8 groove without it showing.

In 18th century American work, the bottom of a dovetailed box is generally nailed on. Sometimes the bottom is a little larger than the box and the edge is moulded, sometimes the bottom is the same size as the box and a moulding is applied. I have never seen a stopped groove for a box bottom in traditional work. It is just too much work compared to the benefit it gives.

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#9

Re: OT - remodeling

ThomD

Sometimes hard to do, if you start with full tiles in the prime locations and work toward the less visible ones. In other words, cut yourself some slack, you are doing it the correct way.

Some of you may remember a few questions I asked this summer when doing some bathroom work for my parents. I am generally competent, but I also go a long way between jobs, and in this case had never tiled a bathtub surround. Anyway, when I got to the corners, I wasn't sure whether to grout, or caulk. I figured I could grout now, and if the unheated during winter cottage enviro, left me with cracks, I could caulk later. So I grouted and was reasonable happy with the results, but had a few reservations. Anyway all the way home, all the rest stops, all the restaurants, even yesterday in the Library, I have been looking at corners. So far I haven't seen a better job in these public places. Sure some of them are not all that great, but actually some of them are pretty fancy these days. What's out there doesn't really measure up to close scrutiny, sure somewhere there is a master at work, but I'm not bumping into his efforts.

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#10

Re: The English...

ThomD

Basically a frame and panel?

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#11

Stephen Shepherd

Re: The English...

Stephen Shepherd

Yes, it is basically a frame and panel bottom. I have also seen drawers with very thin sides where this was done as well as a half round molding mitered at the corners, glued in place on the inside of the drawer near the bottom edge. The bottom is put in place and a square molding, sometimes a little wider [flush with the bottom so it is also where the drawer glides on the runner] is glued in place. Nails as well on occasion.

Stephen

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#12

Re: OT - remodeling

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"What's out there doesn't really measure up to close scrutiny..."

I am not fond of sheetrock taping, but I'm not bad at it. Every once in a while, we'll go to an open house at a new house, and I always have to control my sneering muscles, because, even in high dollar houses, I could do better taping than I see.

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#13

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

Sean FitzGerald

try cogged dove tails described on jeff gorman's great site. they can be found in the projects section.

i used cogged d.t.'s on a mid-cent modern bookcase last year. the cogged d.t.'s were easy to make and good looking.

the bookcase has five d.t.boxes stacked inside a framework.

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#14

Re: The English...

Adam Cherubini

What I see for all sorts of boxes including writing boxes, small chests, etc is precisely what Warren said. Bottoms (and tops) were nailed on. Hard to find a piece that's not like this. On writing boxes the end grain is uncovered.

Adam

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#15

Thanks for all the ideas

wilbur

I can see I have a lot of new things to try.

Some clarifications and questions:

I'm using a Record 044 for the grooves. In fact, the box I'm making is to hold the Record 044, its extra rods, and its cutters. I'll have to try making stopped grooves with it, although the length of the plane relative to the length of the sides of the box will make that hard.

Stephen, with the English frame and panel method that you describe, is that similar to making drawer slips?

I really appreciate all the information on traditional practices. Stylistically, I'm not wedded to that look for this box, but it's always good to know how they did things back then. Overall, I'm leaning towards just plugging the holes.

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#16

Moses Yoder

Re: OT - remodeling

Moses Yoder

My cousin was a master at drywall taping in his day. You would never be able to see where his joints were. All the best contractors in his area used him. Today he has a bad back because of it, and absolutely nothing to show for his efforts other than a washed out body. So what good did it do?

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#17

Moses Yoder

Re: Stopped grooves

Moses Yoder

In my opinion a combination plane with it's long skate is the last thing in the world to use for a stopped groove in a short board. And the problem I always run into with stopped grooves especially with soft wood is the little bit of wood I am trying to leave at the end of the groove always wants to break out when the groove is almost completly trimmed, at the last possible second. It would make sense to me to use the drawer slips in your box and you could easily groove those with your plane. You could assemble the box without glue after it is dovetailed and glue the slips in place then dissassemble it and glue it together with the bottom caught in the slips so you would not need to slide it in after assembling the box. The slips could be mitered at the corners for a neat look and they certainly wouldn't interfere with the plane storage.

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#18

Re: The English...

bugbear

would make a small molding with a groove in the center to accept the feather edge of the drawer bottom panel. Looks like a U with the inside edge round over and the outside edge left square. They are mitered to fit inside the box and are glued in place.

Well, the English (or British) would only do this if the sides were thin. The technique is normally used for drawers, not boxes, and the "small mouldings" are called "drawer slips".

http://blog.woodworking-magazine.com/blog/About+Drawer+Slips.aspx

(and he's American!)

BugBear

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#19

drawer slips

Adam Cherubini

I think that blog is incorrect.

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#20

Re: drawer slips

bugbear

I think that blog is incorrect.

Well, most of it seems fairly uncontroversial, and it's quite a large post.

Could you be a little more ... specific about what you think is right/wrong?

BugBear

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#21

Stephen Shepherd

Yes, Wilbur...

Stephen Shepherd

Just like drawer slips. They appear on the drawers of old painted pine pieces made out here by cabinetmakers from England in the 1860's. The technique is also used in fine boxes but the slip goes all the way around and is mitered at the corners. Seen one box with a false bottom that was very deceptive and put on in this manner.

Stephen

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#22

Re: OT - remodeling

ThomD

Quite by surprise I have learned a lot from sheetrock work, and become pretty good at it. So I hear you. What gets me is that high end houses use it at all. I would do plaster exclusively except the stores around here don't sell it. I got excited a few years back when a local big box had some plastering stuff in stock, I thought they had finally seen the light. Sadly it turned out to be oversupply from some stuff they had brought in for a low rent apartment building. I guess landlords know something the builders of high end homes don't.

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#23

Re: drawer slips *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Well, then (not that I agree that Chris's article is incorrect, but I haven't read it in detail), how about our own Richard Jones (Sgian D___) in a post/thread here in January?

Pam


Richard Jones on drawer slips

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#24

Re: OT - remodeling

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I'm sorry about your brother's back, but I presume he got paid for the work; so at a minimum, he probably made a living for n years. Aside from that, very little of what any of us do will survive long term; but that's no reason for not doing it, especially if one takes enough care to master a technique. Exercising the mastery is usually enough for the master.

Pam

Re: Grooves for the bottom of a dovetailed box

#25

Re: OT - remodeling

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I've been wondering about plastering instead of drywall, especially what with all the corrosion problems with the Chinese stuff. Four or five years ago I attended the west coast Kezuro-kai in Oakland, CA and stumbled on a plasterer demonstration. Gorgeous jobs they showed, sold me a few trowels; so I'd be some of the supplies are available from Hida.

Pam