New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Veneer with Yellow Glue?

Posts

Re: Veneer with Yellow Glue?

#26

Moses Yoder

Re: Fell into the bear trap, I think.

Moses Yoder

Well I kind of hesitate to say this for fear of waking up irate caul girls, but some of the things that have been said here I think are from hypothetical theorys and not actual experience. I know from actual experience that yellow glue will work just fine because I actually used it. However, this was with 3/32" thick shop sawn veneer, and also used with paper backed veneer and worked fine. I suppose if you had an open grained wood like mahogany and poured the glue on you probably would get some squeezing through the pores. I use a small foam roller to apply glue and have never had any squeeze through the pores, and thus never once thought about all the bad things that could happen from using yellow glue for veneer. I have seen the bad things that happened from contact cement and don't recommend trying it.

Re: Veneer with Yellow Glue?

#27

Thank you for saying this

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Re: Veneer with Yellow Glue?

#28

My definition of the trap

James Watriss

I wasn't so much referring to the glue he was using, as I was the hazards of consulting the forums on such matters.

I think that the project proposed by the OP is, and should be very simple.

I felt like the responses he received, and the resulting discussions, were disproportional to the simplicity of what he's trying to do. And while all of the arguments presented have merit, I think the issues being bandied around are more than need be taken into account for the simple purpose of gluing less than half a square foot of veneer down.

Proper technique will have way, way more impact than choice of adhesive. And even proper technique isn't that hard to figure out.

Re: Veneer with Yellow Glue?

#29

Yes, opining about glue......

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

....can lead to sticky situations. ;-)

Re: Veneer with Yellow Glue?

#30

Re: Fell into the bear trap, I think.

ThomD

"but some of the things that have been said here I think are from hypothetical theorys and not actual experience."

I think sometimes it's the reverse. If a person asks a question where the baseline issue is soluble from 300 approaches, a person with experience will have tried say 200 and have a lot of reasons why something is better from one avenue than another. An illustrative example would be dovetails. there are a lot of ways of doing them, some are better than others. I spent over 20 years in a house where the heaviest used drawer, no slides, was a pine kitchen drawer that held our second tier silverware and kitchen stuff. This drawer was held together with nails, and was made of pine. I think it got dumpstered when the bond trader who moved in did a renovation, but had that not been the case it probably would still be in use. That probably is a 100 year drawer, but you only know, not at the point when you take the clamps off for the first time, but after a lifetime of use, or when you do a lot of repairs.

Re: Veneer with Yellow Glue?

#31

Re: Fell into the bear trap, I think.

ThomD

First off, take something like brown glue, one of the advantages has nothing to do with gittin her done. It has to do with repairability. One would hope that will never be an issue in one's own lifetime, so it is like planting trees and paying it forward. I have only ever repaired one joint I made with hide glue (Lee Valley had a brown glue also, and there is Weldwood). On that particular piece the M+T s were all hide glue, but the top was probably white glue, not hide anyway. While any idiot can glue two pieces of wood together, doesn't mean there aren't better or worse ways to go about it. The choices one makes add value or not to one's pieces. I think we live in a throwaway society, even where nice stuff is concerned. But there are people who are expressly making stuff as family heirlooms, they should probably give some thought to their glues.

I started to use Titebond (or hide glue) on guitar bridges because these application are actually pretty stressed, many otherwise good wood glues will actually fail; nobody wants to have to deal with the warranty issues on a lot of failed projects, and even possibly liability. So i used what everyone else did whatever my preference might otherwise have been. That is one example, but creep can also ruin tabletops. I haven't fully figured that one out yet. But it is an example where not all glues are created equal. Given the low cost of glues like Titebond, why wouldn't I also use it in other situations where plastic creep was a problem. Say bent laminations, I actually have something I prefer even more. But glues are differently formulated and not all are the same.

Re: Veneer with Yellow Glue?

#32

THAT

James Watriss

...was truly horrible. ;)

Re: Veneer with Yellow Glue?

#33

Re: My definition of the trap

ThomD

On your main point, I think it would really help if people asked specific questions. Most of the threads that take off on a tear suffer from overly broad questions. Somtimes the OP doesn't know what he is asking, but often the opening question is just lazy. For instance to the beginner the question what glue, may be that he simply doesn't know the name of any single glue he could use, but he may not want to admit that, so the question is open. To the expert, it is a contest between any one of 20 glues he uses in very specific situations.

Second, who says the point is answering some dude's question. I mainly want to find out what others think, and sum up what I think. That is where the value is for me. That is how we all learn, not just one guy.

Third, you are the guy taking this thread off on an even further tangent, not only is it all about glue, now it is all about the foibles of the internet.

Re: Veneer with Yellow Glue?

#34

Old Brown Glue IS hide glue. I bet you know that.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Veneer with Yellow Glue?

#35

Throw away furniture

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Last year at the Williamsburg conference a man was telling a friend about a technique that he used that was a lot easier than what was done in the 18th century. I can't remember just what he was doing, but I told him that he was making stuff no one would want to repair and it might as well be called throwaway furniture.

That night I was annoyed at myself for being too hard on the guy, but at the first break the following day he sought me out. He said "I want to thank you for what you said to me yesterday. I thought about this all evening. When I repair furniture I often complain about how it was put together, and here I am doing the same thing."

Veneer is really vulnerable to damage. It is not reasonable to expect that a veneered piece will go a long period without damage from dropping or bumping or spilling, chipping or cracking, or something. You can glue it any way you want, but it might be easy to say it is not worth trying to repair it.

Re: Veneer with Yellow Glue?

#36

Re: Throw away furniture

ThomD

I don't really believe that about veneer. I don't personally use the stuff a lot. It pops up on stuff like guitars, and it does get used a lot by me on boats, though that isn't what we are talking about. The fact is though, that the majority of great furniture of all time, well ok, a lot, Is veneered. A lot of upper class furniture was veneered. This may be one of those differences between what woodworkers think is good furniture, and everyone else. I went to our local museum in Toronto, and all the western furniture there, stuff like Ruhlman was veneered. What is more, today, we probably have the technology to veneer stuff that will last a long time, or we soon will. Stabilized wood veneer is marine grade, it comes down to the glue, in certain situation there might be a UV problem. Prior to modern tech, it came down a lot to environment, and that whole central heating thing. With luck dry central heating will some day be replaced with something a little more comfortable for the furniture. My dad has a piano of very good quality, and over time, the majority of the veneer has rippled.

Re: Veneer with Yellow Glue?

#37

Re: Throw away furniture

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I am not saying veneered stuff is throwaway; I am saying it is vulnerable. I think most of the stuff you see in museums has been touched up and that the restoration was straightforward because it was glued with hide glue. Use another glue and the restorers would rather not touch it. You can use a last forever glue if you want, but make sure you don't drop it or bump it etc.

Re: Veneer with Yellow Glue?

#38

Re: Throw away furniture

ThomD

I agree with you about hide glue and veneer. That is what I first used it for. It's also fun. While we are at it, it should also be french polished. That kind of furniture at it's best can cost house money, so one hopes it gets taken care of.

Permanent glues are fine, it's the half measures that let you down. Also, super glues like epoxies are fully repairable in the first place. The vinyl like glues are the bad ones, they have creep and can't be reglued.

Re: Veneer with Yellow Glue?

#39

Its both I think...

John in NM

On the one hand, what works for one person may not work for another - take the yellow glue in vacuum bag, the one time I tried it with paper backed veneer it didn't work well, and Moses has no problem doing it. I've no doubt that both experiences are accurate and repeatable, we're just missing some of the illuminating details that would explain the discrepancy.

On the other hand, there is just so much inaccurate book wisdom crap floating around and getting repeated without thought or trial that its enough to make one despair of successfully sorting through it to find a bit of wisdom. I find WC to be less deep in it than most other forums though, which is why I like it here. I tend to have a short memory for examples of this, as I usually don't pay a whole lot of attention to them. Wait... just thought of a doozy... any kind of building code discussion, especially electrical, while valuable on the whole will be rife with examples of mis-informed idiocy that can never be supported with an actual chapter and section citation.

Re: Veneer with Yellow Glue?

#40

Yes, and....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Yep, it's good stuff. Handier than glue pots but has a shelf life issue, so no magic bullet.

T.

Re: Veneer with Yellow Glue?

#41

Re: Throw away furniture

Adam Cherubini

The conservators in Philly are beginning to restore modern furniture assembled with PVA. This is a big big problem. First, it's hard to restore. There are couple issues in there- releasing glue that is still holding and regluing surfaces that have failed.

Second, the glue isn't lasting as long as people think. 50 years may be the lifespan for a PVA glued joint under stress (stress could come from use as in a chair, or the stress caused by wood movement).

My feeling is that the chief success of 18th c was it's "repairability". And FYI- it's rare that anything you see in a museum hasn't been warmed over, refinished, repaired etc. It LOOKS like an original finish, so that may lead one to believe the piece has never been repaired. In Philly, the shiny pieces are those that were restored some time ago. The dull shoddy pieces are those that have recently undergone restoration. We're done with shiny.

For James, woodworkers generally lack the experience to know what glues are best. One needs a 50+ year look back. Almost none of us have that. So we talk about the glue that worked last year. If that's good enough for folks, great. Otherwise, I agree with Warren, we're making furniture that will end up damaged beyond repair and our grandchildren will push it out to the curb. Someone will drive by and say "wow, look how nicely that guy dovetailed those drawers. Too bad he used the wrong glue and relied on biscuits."

Adam

Re: Veneer with Yellow Glue?

#42

Using the right adhesive

Bob Hackett

The turning community is coming face to face with this very problem in a big way.

Now that turned wood objects are being included in many museum collections and many of these same objects were made by artists who are no longer living, museums are having more than a little difficulty with work that has been assembled with CA glue.These pieces are literally falling apart as the glue evaporates!

Sure you can glue them back together every 20-30 years but who wants to pay several thousand dollars for art you have to constantly maintain?

I know of at least one local craftsman(?) who was relying on CA glue to hold furniture together.His reputation is now in jeopardy and he`s in a panic.

Somehow "I told you so" doesn`t quite cover it .

Re: Veneer with Yellow Glue?

#43

Re: Using the right adhesive

ThomD

Tell me more about ca! A lot of people are using it for guitars, though guitars aren't all that long lived for the most part.

The only thing I would caution about modern glues is that there is a learning cycle. Those of us in the wooden boat community were certainly pleased to see the harm that came to plastic boats, as they blistered etc... Made our boats seem a lot better in comparison. But just as people were learning how bad these plastic boats were, they were also creating a whole new range of products of far greater longevity. And every few years there are new products that become available. At the cheap end of the spectrum, I am interested to hear about these nano tech latex paints. So while the old stuff is better, hard to know how long that will last for.

Re: Veneer with Yellow Glue?

#44

CA failures

Bob Hackett

Ask around at some of the museums where things like assembled pieces and especially segmented pieces from the early age or art turning are in collections.

Albert at the Turning Center in Philadelphia would probably be a good source to tap too.

I know at least 2 internationally known turners/wood artists who have given up CA for other adhesives with longer lives,like West System epoxy for example.

Apparently over time CA just disappears and things start coming apart.

Re: Veneer with Yellow Glue?

#45

Re: CA failures

ThomD

You can never go wrong with WEST, for the most part. So these were folks who did the basic lamination with CA. Though the evaporation would affect just about any use. Thanks.

Re: Veneer with Yellow Glue?

#46

Re: Throw away furniture

James Watriss

Adam, you make a very good point. And it's good to read all of it.

My original intent was to simply say that if it was a learning piece, that yellow glue would work just fine. I think it's more important to just go to the bench and learn something than to get lost in a rabbit hole in here.

Re: Veneer with Yellow Glue?

#47

Re: Throw away furniture

Adam Cherubini

I agree James. I never feel qualified to offer specific advice. So often we hear things like "I wish I'd done it this way when i started woodworking. I'd have so much more experience now". On the other hand, you want to be encouraging and encourage exploration.

On this issue, I think guys should just bite the bullet and get involved with hide glue. I think most of these sort of rabbit holes, and you're right, they are rabbit holes, are fairly rewarding in and of themselves. So I don't think there are too many people kicking themselves for messing about with planes when a few hundred bucks buys a decent lunchbox planer.

But you're right, everybody is trying to help and the guy with the question can easily leave more uncertain than he came.

Re: Veneer with Yellow Glue?

#48

Re: Throw away furniture

ThomD

Well Boo Hoo, maybe we need a government warning or something.

We live in a woodworking world were very little, presumably verging on none of it, has actual practical limits. It's all just funning around. The idea that people are worried about too much information doesn't really stand up. Not based on the dozens of magazine, hundreds of books, videos, schools etc... It's a virtual world.

Re: Veneer with Yellow Glue?

#49

glue for veneering

Al R.

Thanks for the discussion folks. These questions always generate a lot of discourse and I've found that there's always a couple of gems of information that pop up as a result.

To shed more light on the situation, I asked the question because I was trying to guage how many new things I would have to learn to pull this off before christmas. Based on what I learned here, I'll leave hide glue for another day (sorry Adam). I have my hands full cutting my own veneer, learning to work with thin stock, and a much higher level of finishing than I've tried before. If there's a remote chance that I can pull out the bottle of titebond, glue and clamp and be done, then I'm gonna go for it.

I've done so many things "wrong" according to some of the experts that I shouldn't be allowed to own a chisel - I'll try anything once.

If I actually find some shop time to pull this off, I'll post back with the results.

Thanks again for all the information.

Al