We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I'm posting this here cause I'm a hand tool guy....
Howdy - Getting ready for Christmas and have a few questions....
My wife noticed a tea caddy in an antique shop the other day and it seemed like it might be a nice small project to try my hand at veneer work, both making my own and applying it.
Just a simple box, pine substrate, veneered with some walnut I have around the shop. I have a question that I'm hoping to get some help with...
I'm not sure I have the time to learn about hide glue for this project, so I wondered if I can just use yellow glue to apply the veneer? The largest surface of the box is about 5 x 11 inches, so I don't think that the difference in expansion and contraction rates betweeen the veneer and substrate will matter all that much so the glue wouldn't have to have any forgiveness to movement. The veneer itself will be about /16th inch thick.
What do you think? will this work? what am I missing?
Yellow glue works fine for clamped applications. You put a towel over the veneer to provide even clamping pressure, then a panel over the towel, then cauls over the panel to apply clamping pressure. Yellow glue takes some time to dry when veneering, especially in a vacuum press, I would leave it clamped at least 4 hours and then allow to dry overnight before any further smoothing or cutting on it.
I once worked in a shop where we used paper backed veneer in a vacuum bag with yellow glue. We did have some bubbling problems with it, I suspect because the paper doesn't breath well compared to wood. I've also tried the iron method where you roll glue on both sides, let it dry an hour or so, then iron it together. It actually works quite well, though it wasn't foolproof.
The dye used to color "yellow glue" can squeeze through the pores and discolor the face surface.......According to Jeff Headley of the Mack Headley and Sons shop in Winchester and reported at a recent club program he gave to us. Well, actually the glue squeezes through, carrying the dye with it.
This shop exclusively uses white glue for veneering. They are into their 5 th generation of building period furniture so I presumed the advice was reliable. I veneered a mahogany crotch in their shop and loads of white glue came through the pores. But it had no effect on color, staining or finishing.
First off, the use of hide glue is actually easier than what you are proposing, just get the granules, put them in say a baby food jar, o smaller. Cover with water twice as high as glue, pour off excess water following day, heat (possibly in a baby food bottle warmer, or just stand the glue in boiling water). With the glue prepared, you apply it to both surfaces and press out with a veneer hammer, which is the narrowest thing you can press down hard on the surface with while moving it back and forth. I made a very serviceable hammer out of wood and a strip of brass. You can reactivate the glue with an iron, or you can even start all over. If glue squeezes up through the veneer it acts as a lubricant, and sands off without gumming up paper.
Generally for a one off-this requires less gear than a press set-up, and delivers better results in the sense that it works great and if anything goes wrong over the next 100 years or so, it is easily repaired.
I have used other methods, from vac to clamps. I use either epoxy in certain structural applications, or white glue. Yellow glue obviously works for lots of things, but in fine woodworking I prefer white glue. Though titebond is good and is yellowish. Colour isn't a precise descriptor. Don't know about this press glue, sounds interesting. Yellow glue is sorta a hack glue. It is thickened to provide better grab for casual users, or as a viscosity sidestep from PL Premium in certain types of construction. I don't use "hack" as an insult, just trying to imply coarser uses that have their place in knowing hands . Of course lots of people use it, but in general it is best avoided for fine work. This vennering job would be a perfect example of a job less suited to yellow glu, it is thicker glue which means greater difficulty getting it worked out to the point of wood to wood contact, and it has less open time. Neither good features with veneering, but if you get it in there and make it work, obviously it will be OK colour aside.
finishing is an interesting question. If you had pores that filled with yellow or white glue, and they were sizeable, that would seem like a bad deal for secondary bonding to a finish.
ThomD, thanks for the input. When I said Yellow Glue, I was, in fact, referring ot Titebond II.
Regarding white glue? I've never used anything other than the TII. Is the white glue that you;re referring to the same as the Elmer's plain white glue?
I will re-think the hide glue - I'm sure can fashion a veneer hamer, it's the contro of it's temperature that worries me. The basement is at a [retty steady 60 degrees this time of year without options to warm it up, so I worried about keeping the glue at a good working temp without spending money on a glue pot.
What about the toothing plane? is it necessary to score the substrate?
2) There's a good chance if you are doing something even slightly complicated that you'll have to fix something. With hide glue, you can always reverse it and fix something easily.
3) No glue has the strength and quick set up that hot hide has. It's just better for veneer and easier to do because it grabs the wood and holds it down without cauls and clamps. PVA is watery and it can cause the veneer to curl. Hot hide will too, but you can "balance" it by applying glue to both surfaces of the veneer.
The temperature issue you mention has been overstated. It's not false. You can ruin the glue by overheating it. But it's pretty hard to do. I have prepared glue on open cook fires, hearths, microwave ovens etc etc. My advice is to find a cast iron glue pot. Failing that, find a way to create a heat sink (water jacket etc). Choose a container with a high thermal mass. This will give you longer to react to changes in temp. When the glue looks like it's overheating, simply add cold water.
Likewise, the smell of hide glue has been overstated. It doesn't really small bad. Some people may be sensitive to it. It certainly doesn't smell as much as your average dog in my opinion.
It always helps to roughen the surface prior to gluing. I only use hide glue, but keying gluing surfaces is always a good idea.
You can use a rasp or old saw blade and drag it along the surface to carefully tooth or key the surfaces if you don't have a toothing plane. I have made scrapers blades for cabinet scrapers that are toothed to do the same process.
I don't doubts that hide glue is better than PVA for any number of reasons as several folks have attested, but, from my extensive firsthand experience, there is no reason you can't use yellow glue for this little veneer job. To me, the biggest reason not to use PVA is the open time of the glue, but for small jobs like this, I've found it suitable and convenient.
"First off, the use of hide glue is actually easier than what you are proposing, just get the granules, put them in say a baby food jar, o smaller. Cover with water twice as high as glue, pour off excess water following day , heat (possibly in a baby food bottle warmer, or just stand the glue in boiling water). "
Thanks Thom! I've tried hide glue a couple of times in the last week but hated it because it was way too watery. Can you guess which step above I must have missed?
Back on topic... I've done many veneering projects with a vacuum bag using yellow glue. I like to thin the yellow glue with a bit of water so it has more open time and rolls out thinner. Something like 4 parts glue to 1 part water or even less. Then use a small 2" disposable paint roller from the hardware store to roll it out on both the veneer and substrate and put it into the bag-o-suck. No toothing required. Comes out great for me.
recommend yellow glue for veneering (albeit he uses his own veneer which is thicker than store-bought stuff)? At least that's the way I remember it.
I've used yellow glue (following Krenov's advice) to veneer about a dozen humidors and boxes, and never had a problem. IME, as long as there aren't any gaping holes in the veneer, and as long as the surfaces are well-scraped or sanded, the glue that seeped through the veneer doesn't show under finish.
Exactly the Elmer's white glue is very good. I buy it by the gallon and when it gets about half used up the daughters get to swarm it for craft projects. Titebond 0 is excellent glue, as is probably the II, though I use it only for exterior work, and am currently using the Elmer version. I only get super fussy when it comes to joinery and guitars.
"Likewise, the smell of hide glue has been overstated. It doesn't really small bad."
I could see family members objecting if one didn't have a shop. But as a user of lots of epoxy (nice smell) I worry more about whether the stinking stuff is killing me, I know for sure the hide glue isn't and other than that the smell doesn't bother me.
I think the only bad thing about hide for the small shop guy is the extra time it takes if you sorta only have a few minutes here and there, and the wastage. when you really get into hide glue you need to have several varieties around if you do different work, and you need to buy it by the 50 lb bag so you can get familiar with the batch. It can become a bit much. But I prefer to make the effort and do a good job. Or I guess that is what is going through my mind when I am not using white glue.
"I use ordinary yellow or white glue for veneering", He says in The Impractical Cabinetmaker. So he was half right. Or all right if he was using Elmer's white, and Titebond 0.
Thanks Paul! What you are finding with your yellow glue could be solved by just buying the Elmer's white glue, which has no more "stuff" in it than is required, and more open time, yet it will do a rubbed joint, and doesn't seize before it gets tight.
To summarize what I just read so far, yellow glue is probably fine, though the color will ruin your piece, the pros use white glue, and the author of the Arts and Mysteries column is worried that you'll almost certainly ruin even your small, simple piece if you don't use hide glue, which is reportedly easy to make. (It's easy to make, but there's a surprisingly big conversation to have about hide glue. I say, learn one thing at a time.)
IMHO this is the real downfall of the internet, and of message boards and forums in particular. You're gluing two pieces of wood together. It's a really wide butt joint. On any other job, you'd be able to jump in, git 'er done, and be drinking a beer while you're doing it.
I think by now I'd be glued to the can with the latest PWW for a few hours before I could even think of doing any work.
For larger veneering jobs, or for ongoing shop processes, I think the kind of adhesive you use would be worth considering. For something small and simple, the depth and breadth of the back and forth you've kicked off in here is more than enough to half-convince anyone that they're probably doing it wrong, that any approach they take could be problematic, and in all seriousness, they should just put it off until later.
You're gluing one piece of wood onto another piece of wood. You can do this, I promise.
My early attempts at veneering were with yellow glue, using waxed plywood as a caul to clamp the surface flat. It came out fine, and I even book-matched the grain around a corner. No problem. I tried using hide glue later, it wasn't too hard, but it didn't really call to me. I listened to Paul Schurch once, said he uses all kinds of different glues... including gorilla glue, microwaved to the consistency of water. I never woulda tried using Gorilla Glue with veneer. But for him, it works. I've also talked to people who use contact cement. (No way, no thank you.)
The moral of the story is, you can do it. And while all of the voices in here have their own opinions, all have been successful in their attempts, or they wouldn't have the opinions that they do. Given that, I'd say you can use pretty much whatever glue you want to, and whatever method of work makes sense. Take your time, think it out. Make up a test-piece and do a dry run if it makes you more comfortable. I think you'll learn more by experimenting at the bench, than you will by trying to carry a forum's worth of advice to the bench with you.
Go have fun. Come back and tell us about it later.
I have used yellow glue for small veneer jobs for years and never a problem. If seepage is a concern (and the wood is darker) you can tint the glue accordingly.
That said, Old Brown Glue is handy if you don't want to mess with hide. And for larger veneer or laminations I am a fan of Unibond 800....but that's a different matter entirely.