New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

store-bought bench

Posts

store-bought bench

#1

store-bought bench

Joe Shelton

I'm seriously considering buying a workbench, and would appreciate any insights into these particular benches: the Sjoberg Elite series that's about 8 feet long; the Hammer and Hofmann large Premium, and the Diefenbach. Those three are available at approximately the same price, and all three look good in photos on the web.

Finally, the Lie-Nielsen appears to be terrific, even though it's a good bit more expensive than the first three.

Lastly, for those of you who realize that I should build my own bench, I acknowledge your precept, but I don't need another big project. I just need a bench, so be gentle here...

Thanks

Joe

Re: store-bought bench

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

it's a personal thing

Jack Guzman from Maine

Joe,

I'm not real familiar with those other brands you mentioned but Lie Nielsens bench is well built and well thought out. It is the closest to what I would build myself. You need to think about your needs in a bench. Pick whichever bench is closest to your ideal. ---Jack

Re: store-bought bench

#3

Weight

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

If more than one of the benches looks like it's close to what you'd build if you could, I'd suggest buying the heavier/heaviest bench. In the past, some of the Sjobergs were kind of light, for instance; and you want a bench that will resist the force you apply when planing or pounding.

Re: store-bought bench

#4

Test drive

Bob Hackett

If it`s at all possible test drive one or all of these before you buy.

Sometimes a company will ask a prior customer near you if it`s alright to have you contact them and either ask their opinion or actually see and test the product out.

I would suggest asking about this when you contact someone at the company.

Re: store-bought bench

#5

Re: store-bought bench

johnny

Hello- I don't get into the forums much anymore, but I saw this and feel the need to warn you. I bought a Diefenbach bench about 12 years ago- the "Ultimate American". I would never recommend it, it is a total piece of crap. A majority of the glue joints have failed, including one of the top joints, so now there is a crack big enough to put a dime in. Most of the joints were filled with this pink filler stuff because they were so gappy. Not a flat or square reference surface or angle anywhere on it. The vise hardware is ok. I did not know better when I bought it. After I figured out what a junker it was, I wrote the company, and they did not respond. I should put put together a Photobucket album of what a turd it is.

Re: store-bought bench

#6

Re: store-bought bench

steve mackay

I thought about it when I was "setting-up" my shop. While I DID wind up building my own my concern with off-the-shelf was expandability and adaptability. When you're looking make sure to consider any alterations you may want to make for specific projects in the future. Does the bench allow for, lets say, more & more dog holes, sides and edges that will hold clamps, more storage, space to mount another vise, mountings for an auxiluary lamp, etc, etc. For my work the answer was always "no". Just saying . . . before spending a good chunk of $ think about all the things you aint thought up yet. Or WILL think up.

Re: store-bought bench

#7

thanks, everyone

Joe Shelton

I appreciate your remarks. If I make a decision, I'll let you all know how it goes.

Joe

Re: store-bought bench

#8

Re: thanks, everyone

Peter Evans

A thought ... if you buy a top of suitable size, is there a local cabinet shop who might build you a sold base? The cost might work out ok. Even a kitchen joinery shop could put together a base economically. You then have the chance to point to a bench in the Christopher Schwarz book, and indicate the base design you want.

Re: store-bought bench

#9

Build Your Own

Barry

I built my own bench from Carlisle Lynch plans 35+ years ago. I bought the plans and vise hardware from Woodcraft. Woodcraft still has workbench plans that are very similar. It is a big project, but it is a very satisfying one. You have complete control over quality issues. You can choose whatever wood species you prefer. You can make changes like adjusting the bench height so that the bench fits you perfectly. Buy a bench if you must, but my vote is to build your own. You won't be sorry. Mine is still going strong after 35+ years. It's the most useful tool in my shop.

Re: store-bought bench

#10

Re: thanks, everyone

Ron in Kokomo

Don't mean to be a smart a--, BUT ... it is really hard to answer the question without knowing what kind of work you want to do on it??

The older I get, the fonder I become of the Roubo style

Re: store-bought bench

#11

Amen and Amen

Ron in Kokomo

Re: store-bought bench

#12

Ron, that's probably a good point...

Joe Shelton

I may not know enough yet to answer it well. Mainly, I want to stop working in plywood, finger-jointed door and window casings and drywall. I'm thoroughly saturated with home renovation, and want to see some solid wood, cut some dovetails, fit some joints tightly and do that quietly while my tailed apprentices catch up on their rest.

And one of these days, I want to post, as you did long ago, about having just filed a saw rip, with no set, and how it was a 'razor'.

Joe

Re: store-bought bench

#13

Re: store-bought bench *LINK*

Roy Anderson

O.K., some crazy thoughts here:

If you don't know what kind of woodworking you want to do yet, buy the cheapest one and figure on throwing it away in a few years.

I drill holes in mine as I find needs for them, so my home made bench is from southern yellow pine (cheap). Some day I'm going to build one that suits my needs better, but my needs keep changing, so I keep modifying the little bugger I've already got.

Heavier is better. Rigid is better. Flat, level and square is better.

Benches are made for tearing up. They are a holding tool, not a piece of furniture. If you spill indelible, incomprehensible stuff all over it or accidentally run a cross cut saw across it a couple of (dozen) times, you've got to be able to live with that. So probably, the Lie Nielsen model is out, unless you've got way more money or calmness than me.

And one last thought. Making your own bench is a good starter project. You'll learn a lot. The link below is to, not my ideal bench, but a good enough and fast bench that you can whip out with basic tools.


Bob and Dave's good and fast bench