New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

comparing water stones and oil stones

Posts

Re: comparing water stones and oil stones

#26

Re: Your stone flattening technique

David Weaver

I've been an atoma pusher ever since alex gilmore sold one to me when I was buying one of his fabulous natural stones. They are great for general use and flattening water stones.

However, schtoo (everyone knows schtoo, right?) reminded me one day that the atoma stones are electroplated strip steel attached to a milled aluminum surface with an adhesive that will probably not tolerate solvents over or oils over the long term unless you seal the edges. The blessing of the adhered strip steel is it allows you to replace the diamond matrix without throwing out the whole stone, but it might be a curse where solvents are involved.

If you look at an atoma, you'll see what I'm talking about. If you seal the joint between the top and the milled aluminum with epoxy, I think they'd work well. That's too much work when a DMT is cheaper. I use a DMT bench stone (because it's easier to hold with oily hands than a DMT duo sharp and about the same price) on my oilstones. It works well.

Oilstones also don't release their matrix as fast as waterstones, so the swarf isn't as much of an issue. As wilbur mentions, the diamonds are arranged much more orderly and with set space between them on the atoma (they're in little rows instead of a random coating like the DMTs appear to be), and they are far nicer to use on waterstones, despite not being a great choice for oil stones unless you want to do some gluing.

(I don't know if any other diamond hones that are flat other than the atoma and DMT. I've never seen EZ laps guarantee (they may also be very flat), and the ultra-sharp diamond hones that are available from time to time for about $45 are not quite as flat as those two, though they're probably flat enough). The ultra-sharps look to be a copy of another japanese branded hone that says not to use it with stones, so not worth mentioning.

Re: comparing water stones and oil stones

#27

that one kinda slipped out, but

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I had the opportunity to edit and decided not to :D