We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I pulled out my oil stones yesterday after an 8 year break, and compared the speed and edge I got with my King water stones. I used a Norton medium India and a Dan's "surgical" black followed with a leather strop.
I was surprised to obtain better edges with the oil stones. I should add that I was sharpening A-2 Lie-Nielsen chisels.
Here is my question: how can a medium India (around 250 grit) work right before a surgical black? If I tried that leap with water stones, things would not be too sharp.
I was told in a class on Japanese tools once that different steels respond differently to different stones. Maybe the A2 doesn't respond well to King stones. I know that L-N sells a combo Norton 1000/8000 grit stone, which sounds roughly analogous to what you're talking about, and it handles pretty well, I'm told.
I've also bounced between different sharpening media from time to time (oil stones, different brands of water stones, diamond paste) and discovered that for whatever reason, I got better results than I used to. I can't account for this phenomenon... Maybe it's just that when you go back to the other way, you're no longer locked into old habits with regard to how you used to use them?
Or, after 8 years, maybe it's just a better strop?
I can't really offer any productive conversation here, just a more drawn out "hmmmm.... that's interesting"
Perhaps you have been looking at some grit comparison charts. I think many charts have been made by people who lack real world experience. You can trust your own judgement here, Les.
I think you might do a little better with an intermediate stone or two. Like Washita or soft Arkansas. There are enough around that you might borrow one and if not they are not too expensive.
Les, my feeling is that the fine India is a lot closer to the medium India than to the black Arkansas. If you have one, you should try it and see if you can notice a difference. One factor in how well a person can sharpen is how well he can judge the results from different techniques. My hunch is that the Washita would do a slightly better job for you.
Perhaps you have been looking at some grit comparison charts. I think many charts have been made by people who lack real world experience.
No. The charts are of particle size. There's more to a sharpening abrasive than particle size. That doesn't make the charts wrong, nor yet the people who made them.
In particular, this very well known chart of particle sizes has a link to a different chart, one of cutting speed versus edge quality.
It is true that different steels sharpen better on different stones. And probably also true that there is a bias within systems, so that Japanese tools work better with their stones and western also, at least relatively. There are plausible sounding explanations for this, relating to scratch marks etc...
I also think there may be a shampoo effect in there. As in a brand of shampoo (and there are similar experiences with other products) may be one's favorite, and then a new one is tried, and it is the best ever, and so on for one's life time. That may have to do with residues, or something. The experience though is a bit like cycling through sharpening systems, and groups of tools throughout a lifetime. Though in the case of sharpening, it can in addition to concrete causes also be attention, since so much of it is application, and it is easier to stick with the latest new thing for some people.
The thing I like about water stones is their softness. It is easy to flatten a water stone and when you do so you have exposed an entirely new surface with no wear on it. An oil stone is so hard that it is difficult to flatten and the surface seems to dull rapidly from use and stops cutting well. I have the same issue with diamond stones; they seem to cut rapidly at first but that sharpness is soon worn off and they cut very slowly.
I had seen Mr. Bottorff's website before. There is nothing there that suggests he has any great experience with Natural stones. He says "The original Washita and Arkansas stones were quarried stones, but now many stones sold by these names are reconstructed." These reconstructed stones were on the market for a short time around 1990; I never heard of anyone buying one. The grit comparison chart you reference would be seen as ludicrous to anyone with real experience using Washita , Queer Creek, and 800 grit Japanese stones. And I doubt the sharpness/speed chart is based on real world experience or experiments. Les' information is based on real experience.
"I pulled out my oil stones yesterday after an 8 year break, and compared the speed and edge I got with my King water stones. I used a Norton medium India and a Dan's "surgical" black followed with a leather strop.
I was surprised to obtain better edges with the oil stones."
I'm not surprised. Overall, you can get a finer edge when ending with a strop than with a King 8000 grit waterstone. And this is coming from someone who really likes waterstones.
There are finer waterstones out there that are as good a leather strop, maybe a hair better.
I have started using oil stones on the suggestion of Larry Williams. I have been pretty pleased wit their performance over my diamond plate stones. So far the trick that has been working for me is to quickly flatten the stone with my diamond stone, when ever it starts to get slow in sharpening.
Surely in the case of the 800 grit japanese stone, the particle size is not a matter of experience, "real world" or otherwise. It's well defined by the JIS standard.
Measuring the particle sizes of natural stones is more difficult, of course.
IIRC Leonard Lee has an electron micrograph of both 8000 grit waterstones and an Arkansas stone in his sharpening book.
How well the various particles actually sharpen is another thing entirely.
All that glitters isn't gold. I'm more worried about geometry than polish. Oilstones assure the first, and give enough of the latter. Best of both worlds if you ask me. Wondering when it's time to flatten a waterstone just doesn't suit my personality.
I did a major sharpening session last night. What helps me maintain a flat surface on a waterstone is to listen to music as I sharpen. When a song ends, I grab my diamond plate and run it over the surface of a waterstone. It takes seconds, and the waterstone remains very flat.
Of course, this isn't for everyone, but it works quite well, and it really doesn't take me very long to flatten a waterstone with this method. I have a video on my blog of myself flattening a fairly dished waterstone at the link below. This took me about 30 seconds, and that was for a deeply dished waterstone. I usually don't let it get out of whack that much.
"What helps me maintain a flat surface on a waterstone is to listen to music as I sharpen. When a song ends..."
Does this work for fans of the Grateful Dead, or Ravi Shankar, too (I could go on: the Butterfield Blues Band song, "East/West;" "The End," by the Doors; quite a few jazz pieces)? Or does it require bands playing songs that would fit radio standards (3-4 minutes)?
I'm impressed by your flattening regimen, Wilbur. It raises two questions for me:
1. Would this work with any flat diamond stone of appropriate coarseness? Or is there some particular characteristic or set of characteristics of the Atoma stone that makes it superior for this purpose?
2. Would it work on oilstones, too? I've got quite a stable of oilstones, gathered over the years. I hear all the arguments about the speed of waterstones, but I like my oilstones. They can, at varying rates, none of them as fast as waterstones, get out of flat. A fast, efficient way to flatten them would be worthwhile.
I'm just glad that I'm not listening to Bruckner symphonies while sharpening.
The nice thing about the Atoma diamond stones is that there are small grooves in the surface which give the waterstone grit a place to go as you flatten it. It also makes it easy to rinse off the grit. But you could use any other diamond stone for this purpose. Having tried the DMT stone for this purpose, the Atoma is a heck of a lot nicer.
As Dean said, you can flatten oilstones with diamond stones. In Larry William's DVD on sharpening profiled tools, he dresses his oilstones with a diamond stone as well.
Maybe 20-25 years ago my brother, a chef, gave me his Norton Tri-Stone gizmo, the big one with 11.5" long stones on a triangular mount that rotated through an oil bath. It included a coarse and medium Crystolon (whatever that is) and a fine India. As a chef, he sharpened his own knives until he got high enough in the food chain to have his employer sharpen them. So he gave me the Norton.
Well, the stones weren't just dished, they were badly worn on the edges, more than 1/16", so they were convex from side to side, but concave from end to end. They were virtually useless to me because they weren't flat.
I tried everything to flatten them - my garage floor, a concrete block, a brick. Nothing worked. This was in the days before the oldtools list or even rec.ww. So I didn't know about using wet or dry sandpaper or glass with diamond paste or any other abrasive powder.
Out of desperation I grabbed an old POS AlOx stone that was crappy enough that it wore badly trying to sharpen anything. That friability turned out to be the key. Within a good half hour I had the coarse Norton dead flat. By the end of the night, all three stones were flat on both sides.
Well, you can certainly cut time and get better results with ceramic stones or a diamond hone.
One cheap "ultra sharp" diamond hone and a shapton professional 1 micron stone is faster than four oil stones, flatness takes about as much effort and there is no need to remove the swarf from the shaptons if you don't want to.
They will also cut everything there is, including HSS. Total cost, if you shop around? About $120. If you have an HTA or a reasonably large hard black, it will approach that.
So, why try something new? Because it's faster, the resulting edge is sharper, and it doesn't matter what steel you choose.
Of course, if you find one or the other almost free, there's really nothing wrong with any type of stone, as long as the final step can cut whatever you're sharpening.