Re: Trying plane
Warren in Lancaster, PA
Larry, I am on my way out the door for a trip to Vermont. There are too many questions for me to answer right now, but I will get back at a later time.
Warren
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: Trying plane
Warren in Lancaster, PA
Larry, I am on my way out the door for a trip to Vermont. There are too many questions for me to answer right now, but I will get back at a later time.
Warren
Chipbreaker Distances
Steve Elliott
"They both agree that optimum effectiveness requires the cap iron being set at .004" (the thickness of a dollar bill) or less."
Actually I've found that .004" is about the closest you can set a chipbreaker and still get a good surface on the wood. I've gone to .003" successfully with a very thin shaving but less than that leaves a fuzzy surface on the wood.
Professor Kato used a distance of .008" in his study and achieved a better surface on the wood than with .004". That was using a secondary bevel on the chipbreaker of 80 degrees, and the problem with the closer setting was causing deformation below the cut line. Although he doesn't mention the species of wood he's planing I think it must be softwood because of his choice of a 40 degree bed angle.
For difficult hardwoods I've had better results using a high cutting angle of about 60 degrees and no chipbreaker. By "difficult hardwood" I'm referring to very hard, brittle wood with rowed grain. These woods deform less that softer woods so they don't tend to lose surface clarity due to the greater cutting force from the higher cutting angle.
As for cambered edges, I like to have the center portion of my smoothing plane blades be dead straight so that I can take a very thin shaving that is still almost full width. At each corner I grind the edge back by about .008" over 1/8". This means that using a 2-1/4" blade I can still take a 2" wide shaving that is less than .001 thick. When I set the chipbreaker at .004" the blade edge at the corners drops back behind the chipbreaker, but that part of the blade won't be cutting anyway.
For softer woods with difficult grain I believe there may be an advantage to using a closely-set chipbreaker instead of a high cutting angle. These are the woods that lose clarity (that look of depth) when planed with a high angle blade. If a chipbreaker can reduce tearout and still leave that look of depth on the wood surface that would be a clear advantage. To test this I've thought of building a double-iron plane bedded at 40 degrees, but to date I haven't done any systematic testing on softwoods.
your web site
Larry Williams
Steve,
I really appreciate the effort you've put into your web site. I've read most of it multiple times but it's so rich in quality information I feel like I need to digest it about one paragraph at a time. So many things compete for my attention every day I haven't been able to invest the time your site deserves. I have referred a lot of people to your site knowing what they're looking for is most likely there.
I hope you keep the site on line, the information is pretty valuable.
Thanks for all your good work.
Thanks, Larry
Steve Elliott
Sometimes I have trouble myself finding what I'm looking for on my site.
My goal has been to understand how to make planes work well. Often the results haven't been what I expected and usually they're not so clearcut as to be universivally persuasive. But it's been a lot of fun to do and each testing method has given me a new perspective on what's actually happening in that tiny space where the cutting edge meets the wood.
Just this week I've tuned a top iron to have a microbevel at 80 degrees that's only .006" wide. By marking the edge with a red felt marker and doing some planing I can tell that the shaving is being deflected by the microbevel itself, not any part of the primary bevel. Using a cutting angle of 47-1/2 degrees that means the microbevel is leaning forward pretty far. The resulting shavings were tightly rippled but they didn't clog up the throat. Now I want to try the plane out on some difficult timbers and see what sort of surface it gives.
Again, thanks for your good words about my site.
Re: Chipbreaker Distances
ThomD
One of the first planes I made back in the early 80s took a 3 tens shaving in pine. It wasn't a very sophisticated effort. The polish was high. It was a Japanese modeled plane at 35 degrees with a 30 degree bevel on the blade. It didn't have a sublade. I always wonder what good a sublade would do with such soft shavings. And it would be very difficult to set even the Japanese blades that fine. In the real world would they not have sanded or scraped, so they wanted something that would remove wood fast, but wouldn't leave deep rips. While these days we are chasing really small shaving thicknesses, and refined surfaces there is little real world demand for.
A few more notes
Warren in Lancaster, PA
Placement of the cap iron is an art. If one were to say "put the cap iron .XXX inches from the edge" someone could easily find a situation where this specific distance caused trouble. It is like driving a standard transmission. Use only 1st gear and it won't go very fast; use only 5th gear and it will stall. I suppose a fellow could make a chart of when to use what gear, but it will not make him a good driver.
Re: Trying plane
Warren in Lancaster, PA
David, it sounds from your post as though you are thinking of a smoothing plane rather than a trying plane. I use a trying plane on the face of a board to remove irregularities left by the jack plane and to make the surface flat and true. For this office it needs to be able to take both light shavings and heavy shavings . A "tight mouth" would restrict the efficiency of the operation. I do not know what you mean by "a properly made single-iron plane", but I would not want to use any but a wooden plane for trying. A light plane is less tiring and allows quicker movement.
Re: Trying plane
David Weaver
Warren - appropriately made would, to me (for a trying plane), imply a 50 degree single iron with a mouth several multiples of a smoother mouth, but one that would still be measured in a couple of hundredths. I don't know the last time I used a trying plane for a thicker shaving than that.
My double iron planes all have mouths agape, and the chipbreaker cannot be set where it needs to be to break chips on them because their irons are radiused.
The exception is the smoother, but I haven't yet found a plane with a double iron that will match a good single iron infill with a properly made mouth when the going gets rough or the wood very hard. I've never felt tired after using an infill smoother.
I'm not debating whether or not a chipbreaker will work when it is properly set - in my experience, it does. I'm debating whether or not it's the best way to solve the problem of difficult wood, or if it's just the cheapest way to do it. I think the latter.
Re: Trying plane
ThomD
"whether or not it's the best way to solve the problem of difficult wood"
That's a whole cultural perception. In some cultures difficult would is the stuff you throw in the garbage. In others it is the stuff most revered. Same kind of thing with the mouth set. At least from a practical perspective it isn't a mater of not needing a bigger shaving than x, for the same effort a bigger shaving is the objective, up to a point.